user
Bayshore Bagels Deli
222 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States
Appearance
Bayshore Bagels Deli

Comments
Ha
Review №1

Best bagel. This guy knows how to make a bagel. Every bagel, EVERY time, cooked perfectly, mixed perfectly. I employ other bagel store owners to take a ride, & experience what a real bagel should taste like!Customer for life.

Ju
Review №2

Great place!! The owner always remembers my order and is a very friendly & hard-working guy! The iced coffee is great as well!! Love this place!!!!

Sh
Review №3

Ive known Bill for quite a long time and his sandwiches are amazing. I call or walk in and he already knows what I want without telling him. I wish he would get a bigger shop though even one with tables so you can eat in.

Ru
Review №4

Food is always good never had a bad experience

Ma
Review №5

Run down shopping center. Bagel deli small. Has plastic shield to protect you. Food was just ok.

Ri
Review №6

Ive been coming here off and on for over a decade and Ive never been disappointed. The bagels are always fresh and their veggie cream cheese is my personal gold standard, which I judge all other veggie cream cheeses against. The owner is friendly and kind and works very hard. I love this place and I go every chance I get with my awkward sleep schedule and after moving about 10 miles further away. Its worth the trip for the level of service and the quality of their bagels and cream cheese.

Un
Review №7

The owner is a great guy! Works hard and has an INCREDIBLE memory!After 2 visits he already knew my order and its impressive how quick he can recall mine as well as the orders of a whole line of customers.They also have the best bacon sandwiches in the area too. Must try!!!

Vi
Review №8

Great egg sandwich

jo
Review №9

Breakfast sandwiches are good

Ed
Review №10

Great Breakfast meals and good prices.

Wa
Review №11

Great egg sandwiches. Very friendly and funny owner too!

Review №12

I love the owner of this place. He’s hilarious and trying to do everything almost by himself. And also has good food.

Jo
Review №13

Bagels are always made perfectly. Spreads are always fresh. Been going here for about 2years. Owner is very nice.

Ja
Review №14

Small with very limited Bagel selection

la
Review №15

The food is always delicious!

Jo
Review №16

Probably one of my favorite bagel shops. Great staff. Short wait time

Ch
Review №17

Best breakfast in bay shore in my opinion. Bagels are always fresh and always great service! Seems like the owner is there every day cranking out quality sandwiches! lol. Deff recommend

An
Review №18

Good quick in and out early morning bagel shop. counter person is always alert and ready to serve

La
Review №19

My parents live down the street and every time I visit I make sure to stop in and pick up a dozen of they delicious egg bagels and vegetable cream cheese. Very cozy place

Ed
Review №20

Chicken salad on sesamee bagle was spot on

Oi
Review №21

Bagels are always delicious. Spreads and salads are fresh.

Je
Review №22

Bagels are great and so are egg sandwiches.

Sk
Review №23

Excellent bagel shop. Their bagels are hot and fresh every day. At least as good as bagel boss.

Ci
Review №24

I love this place!! The register guy, who I assume is the owner is pretty cool and funny. The prices are cheap and the breakfast sandwiches are good!!

Ca
Review №25

Owner was a bit grouchy early morning. Food good

Ro
Review №26

This place is the best, not just the bagels but the Billy burgers are outstanding! Its rare to find a place with awesome food and great service.

To
Review №27

Great place, Bill is a great funny guy, if dont want to wait just give him a call.food is always hot and delicious.

Ja
Review №28

Ok....cute but small place, his first mistake there is one person working on a Sunday before noon....whom I believe to be the owner.Not the worst but for sure not the best! My total came to $8.25 for an egg everything bagel w/cream cheese, a chocolate milk & a Qz cup of veggie cream cheese. Which to me is too high for a bagel that seemed was made yesterday.It was my first time, I was highly disappointed and will try someplace else next time

Ry
Review №29

Great spot for breakfast and lunch Bill the owner is a great guy friendly funny what more could you ask for

Ma
Review №30

Good

Mi
Review №31

After standing there for over 5 minutes without being acknowledged got skipped over. Thanked them and walked out. Will never be back.

BE
Review №32

Great bagels with some unique flavors, like blueberry. The fresh squeezed o.j. is delicious.

Mu
Review №33

The Bagels Are HARD...The Man Was Sweating Wiping His Brow/Forehead !!!He Used The SAME Glove Over and Over To Grab The Bagels After Each Customer !!!HOW DOES A BAGEL SHOP ON LONG ISLAND HAVE BURNT BAGELS 🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️

Ca
Review №34

Perfect bagel shop. Slightly brusque but not unfriendly service, eggs done right, great spreads, and fair prices.

Ke
Review №35

Bill the bbn owner is quick to serve and quite pprecise.Aways fresh always good

Ge
Review №36

Quick service. Reasonable prices. Limited menu.

Je
Review №37

The worst would give no stars if I could. Not sanitary at all. They dont change gloves or a the utensils they use to cook with and prepare your food. The staff are so unprofessional.

Je
Review №38

Asked for extra bacon on my sandwich and got 4 pieces all together literally....how many do u get if u dont ask for extra????? One for each half of ur sandwich??? LOLThis place is not for me...sorry

Ca
Review №39

Food is great, and at good and reasonable prices . I would definitely recommend.

da
Review №40

Food is great, busy but fast service.

•N
Review №41

I love this place because they make bagels so fast,and they also make the bagels nice, warm,and fluffy

Br
Review №42

Good food great price

Li
Review №43

Poor customer service. I order 4 toasted bagels/ sausage but one of them was burn and I told the Spanish tall lady not to give me that burn bagel and she act like not hearing me and still give me the burn bagel so I asked her to change it and she give me a actitud. Shes always moody.

Ma
Review №44

Breakfast was great staff pleasant

T
Review №45

Dont come here.I went here the other day, bought two bagels and later discovered that BOTH bagels had ARM HAIR on them...Always check your food before you leave.Go around the corner to Graces deli their bagels are so much better...and are hairless.

an
Review №46

This my spot. Order the playa platter. They got u. My guy bill killing the bagel game.

Le
Review №47

Awesome bagels very reasonable love it

Th
Review №48

Good bagels, excellent breakfast sandwiches.

Ke
Review №49

Cheap sandwiches i love their hungrymans

Fa
Review №50

Great place to get bagels ;)

Ra
Review №51

Best bagels. Period.

Cr
Review №52

Fast, delicious bagels and coffee.

an
Review №53

Love their blt sandwich

Vi
Review №54

The bagels are always great

De
Review №55

Good for quick bite

DI
Review №56

Perfect breakfast spot

Ke
Review №57

Just completely trash

Da
Review №58

Awesome bagels!

K
Review №59

Best BLT in town!!!

Fe
Review №60

Ok food

mi
Review №61

Great

no
Review №62

Good

Fr
Review №63

Good bagels

De
Review №64

It was excellent,

Information
7 Photos
64 Comments
4.2 Rating
  • Address:222 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States
  • Phone:+1 631-647-4626
Categories
  • Bagel shop
Working hours
  • Monday:6AM–2PM
  • Tuesday:6AM–2PM
  • Wednesday:6AM–2PM
  • Thursday:6AM–2PM
  • Friday:6AM–2PM
  • Saturday:6AM–2PM
  • Sunday:6AM–2PM
Service options
  • Delivery:No
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance:Yes
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Similar organizations
  • Bagel Boss East555 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States
  • Sunrise Bagel2054 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States