Five course dinner for $24.99 each .A great deal in these tough economic times. Food always tastes great. Ive been coming to Peter pan throughout the pandemic and have always been warmly greeted by the owner. Highly recommend..
We love Peter Pan diner. The food and service is always great and it comes with a smile. It is not inexpensive but it worth the money every once in a while. The only issue is the parking lot is very tight.
Petter Pan Diner was a much more than pleasant surprise. First off that they were open for inside dining was great. Next, the interior was immaculate the decor warm & welcoming & the staff very friendly & top of their game in serving. Now the food? Oh man the food! Both my wife & I had burger deluxe platters. I got mine with sauteed onions added to the burger...YUM. Everything was cooked to perfection, the burger just right aaaand juicy. The sweet potato fries, the onion rings crispy on the outside & delicious on the inside! Even the Cole Slaw & pickle were super fresh & delicious. My wife ordered a slice of Lemon Meringue & I ordered the Chocolate Cream pie. We both were over the moon how fantastic these.two desserts were! When we left we were both thoroughly full & very happy! This diner really delivered two completely wonderful, lip smacking good meals. Go visit them!
YUM! I love a great diner. The burger was simple and delicious, cooked perfectly. I love jazzing up the side of fries and making them ✨disco✨ with melted mozzarella and gravy, and it was great! The onion rings are great too. Ive heard the sweet potato fries are amazing, so Ill have to get those next time. Plus, the free Famous Amos cookies at the front of the diner are a nice added touch. Excited to come back!
The food is good reasonably priced and the staff was very courteous environment is very comfortable
Sharon is literally one of the best waitresses I’ve ever had and I’m so excited when she is my server. She is excellent and so is this diner. Great food and great service.
Love the place. Always feel as if something can be better but stull a place I love going back to
The food is very good, there is a wait of 15 -20 min . The down side the menu has no pictures :(
Love this place!! And they sing happy birthday!!
The place is roomy lots of room to breathe. And after u stuff yourself u dont feel crumby because it is quality food go there and enjoy
Best omelet ever! Waitress and hostess were courteous!I wont go to IHOP anymore!
They deliver, always on time. Tonight their driver broke down and they were an hour late. They credited our entire order. Great customer service .
Solid diner! Fantastic service! Well above average Patty Melt! All our food was inhaled! Highly recommended! Enjoy!
Havent been to Peter pan for over 25 years and it was even better than I remember. Great service!! Cant wait to go back.
Always good eatz here. Been coming here since I was a kid and they never disappoint😋
Service was great and the food was even better. The prices were very affordable when compared to other diners in the area.
Just wanted a quick chicken finger meal. They actually serve that frozen gelatin looking chicken you gave to your toddler. Yuk
Where’s the cease and desist? All jokes aside, really good breakfast food! I can’t explain how some diner food tastes better than others they just do. Best black and white cookie here!
Place was clean.. We were seated immediately. Service was quick and waitress was friendly. Food was okay. Pancakes a little over cooked. Home fries undercooked. Eggs were good! Orange juice was delicious, tasted fresh squeezed. I probably wont come here again.
The food was good but could have been a little bit better.
The food was good.The first time my dish came out they got my order wrong and the second time they brought it out, there was a bug on the plate. The manager remade my dish and didn’t charge me. However I did lose my appetite from waiting for my meal to be made right.
The chicken tenders were not so good. I think from now on I’ll just order grilled cheese. The good chicken tenders are located at either Dave & Busters or Applebee’s
The food was excellent and the atmosphere was great,I especially liked the booth and the art work on the wall.Thank you.
Food is excellent! Service is awesome! Its a great place to go for Breakfast, Lunch, AND Dinner. Five course dinner is a GREAT deal!!!!
Best diner on L.I. so far.... food is amazing and workers are great
It was really good but the prices were alittle bit expensive
Always solid food and expansive menu. Quick service on takeout and waitstaff is always attentive.
Awesome Cookies. Waitress was very nice. Good food.
Great food, fantastic service and amazing atmosphere. Old times neon diner.
Nice place. Great ambiance. Food was good
Food taste is good. Food service is good. They deliver. Ordered the gyro platter. Over $15, and I get THREE slices of gyro meat. Sorry, not worth it.
Always good. Sometimes great. Other times not. Yet the hometown, feel, service and nostalgia is so feel good its always worth a visit. Enjoy. You will.
The waitresses are very friendly. The food is fantastic there portions are oversized I had a grill chicken wrap with chopped tomatoes and chopped lettuce she gave me a dill dressing that was so delicious plus I had onion rings pickle & coleslaw. My mom had a burger and onion rings and a pickle and coleslaw I only can eat half of my grill chicken wrap. My mother only ate half a burger I definitely recommend this place definitely get your moneys worth mother order piece of cheesecake after dinner the slice was so huge sorry I forgot to take a picture of that next time its my favorite Diner.
I come here often, has typical diner food selection and always good!
Great diner. Great food. Service is exceptional
Skirt steak with Shrimp Scampi was delicious! Best lemon soup.
As always very friendly and pleasant ambiance and food delicious. Im a customer since 1985
My favorite diner ! The breakfast is perfect every time
Really good and really fast service
Very good customer service the service the food was excellent a generous portion.
I always ask them to make the fries or onion rings extra crispy and they never do I guess well take out they dont pay much attention
Good food friendly service good value.
After waiting for 15 min to get served we asked a nearby server who would check on us. He said “it isn’t me” and then came back saying he would be waiting on us (Mario?). He took our order and came back a bit later with our food.My meal was incorrect. I ordered the grilled cheese loaded with turkey club. He brought me the club. My husband corrected him. He brought back just a grilled cheese and said “I heard turkey club”.The food was mediocre. The service was horrible. Came here and was told this place was an incredible local diner. I wouldn’t chose to come back here.
Never a bad meal at the Peter Pan Diner! They have an outstanding menu and great specials. The staff are super friendly as well.
This place always serves a nice portion. They have plastic up between the booths so they are permitted to seat in all of the booths.. plus the place Is quiet.
Food and service is always good. Prices are a bit high.
Not bad. Soup and a buger
One of my all time favs bit extremely disappointed last time I went. Covid has to taken them down, I hope they get back to where they were. Food not good service not good still rate this ad one of my favs I know they will rise back to where they need and deserve to be
Nice diner.... clean, nice workers... food was great...just wanted sh they served gluten free bread...
Open on Easter which sucks but breakfast was awesome. My family dines in regularly. Never any issues. Farmers omelet is a must try.
Friendly accommodating staff. All social distancing measures in place and practiced. So far same ole Peter Pan... Burgers are fantastic!
Very clean. Great food and service was excellent.
18 people In party one terrific waitress.
Great diner. Quality food and service is outstanding. Really friendly and quick. The place is a perfect diner experience. Support local
Food was good, friendly service.
Nice and clean good food . Not bad with price.
If I could leave zero stars I would. The only reason I decided to come to this place is because the website said they had grits. Well, there are no grits on the menu. False advertising.
Old school customer service, like its supposed to be! Great food, atmosphere and service. Nick, youre the best.
Good service friendly waitresses and the food was good not regular diner food its good
This is the quintessential diner experience. You have your regualers, the commraderie, awesome servers with great attitudes, and a well planned diner menu. They serve great food, and I have never had a bad experience. I definitely recommend Peter Pan Diner.
Great Greek salad with chicken just ask for little more dressing
Had a small family reunion there. The help was excellent, food was delicious, we usually have a family reunion there every year.
Amazing food, big portions, great service, nice prices over all. great place for the family, first dates friends, and long time loves. I will always come here❤❤❤
Our waitress Kristin is AWSOME!!! Very attentive, not leaving us wanting for anything!! Real nice person!!!!!!!
Great food, considerate staff, love it!
Good dinner when for breakfast clean Good service prices fare all-around good place
Love NY diners! Great Food!
Really nice service and staff, foods ok. Good breakfast food and good coffee though.
Its a nice place to take your family the people are friendly and nice
Great service n food
Good dinner when for breakfast place clean waitters attentive food good.
I like it but feels like the cost for going out at local places like diners has gone up more than national chains.Typically good service and never had food that wasnt at least good.
I dined here for years with my husband in the 1990’s when we lived in Bayshore. I recently dined here with my son and BFF. The waitress was awesome. We had dinner, dessert, and coffee. She never rushed us. We laughed and she helped us remember the outing by taking pictures with our iPhones. This diner has been here for many years. They never disappoint. Always a nice outing.
Best pancakes in town. Fresh and homemade flavor. I had with cranberry and almond Delicious!
Very good and very nice people working there.
Good eats. Excellent service. Friendly atmosphere. Going back.
The service was excellent, friendly atmosphere and big portions enough for 2 people!
Friendly atmosphere, good food and reasonable prices.
This service was excellent and fast! The food was quick and delicious. Very clean! I suggest going here!
Good food and great help
Chicken parm was great as always. The chicken quesadilla on the other hand...used to be my dine in pick or to go choice for after. Not sure what happened this last visit but the ball was definitely dropped. And hard. Id easily revisit next time I’m local though.
Good food good service