I’m so happy that I can get bagel sandwiches again! I am not sure when it happened, but the Bagley is now operating with a fuller menu, including coffee as well!From what I could see all orders are done at a walk up window with no customers inside right now. You place your order and walk a few paces down to wait at another window. They have dedicated parking spots out front for those who decide to order online and pick up.All of these options to order are fantastic because I love the bagels and specifically the sandwiches they have on offer. At a great price you get a delicious bite with So many slices of cheese on it… it’s just a blessing in a circle shaped sammy.

Bagels and cream cheese were decent with a lot of option for both. However, the woman who rang me up was fairly inconsiderate. Felt like her man objective, through her condescending comments, was to inform me of how upset I made her for ordering bagels. I always want to support local business and will likely be back but the customer service was concerning. I have never felt compelled to write a negative review but here I am. Take it or leave it

Located a bit off the beaten path on a narrow one way street in Bellingham’s aged and noticeably PC downtown area, thought we’d discovered a hidden gem of a bagel shop when Bagelry crossed our path. And not a shop that simply sells bagels as a sideline. Eew! But a true bagel shop where they make, boil, bake, and sell BAGELS. And indeed, Bagelry is that by all appearances. But their product is not the slightly crusty, shiny, chewy boiled NY style bagels we’re used to. These were heavily crusted, as in “Yes, child, you can break a tooth” crust. Somewhat like a loaf of good, thumpable, crusty Italian bread, but there wasn’t enough of a crumb, that soft yummy inside, to offset the hard crusty exterior. Not our preference. There was too much crust that was proportionally far too thick for the product it encased. And once toasted it became that much harder. Seriously, you could break concrete with it! [Deduct 1 star.] And the flavor? It was okay, possibly even slightly good, but not great — and you shouldn’t have to convince or talk yourself into saying it’s good. It either is or it isn’t. [Hence the “okay.” Deduct 2nd star.] But if you like meandering through narrow downtowns and around and up and down on clustered side streets & smirking or raising your fist to all the “We the Pee-oppa-leez” propaganda posted on virtually every wall, and seeing the local uber enlightened and equally indoctrinated citizenry waiting patiently outside on the sidewalk for their very own hard, crusty bagels, this may be the place for you…. Us? We came, we saw, we tried, and like Johnny Mathis of old, next time we’ll walk on by. But check out what’s 2 doors down…

It was really good. Service was fast, options were extensive, prices were reasonable. Id go back again - tons of variety so theres always something new to try. A good choice for fresh bagels/sandwiches!

The bagels are good but why have an online preferring option if it’s slower than any other option…. Should just not offer it….

I am disappointed in this place. This is the first and last time I am coming here. Coffee drive-thru spots with bagel items and making bagel sandwiches at home is better than this place.I received lackluster bagel and bagel sandwiches. The bagels were dry and did not taste fresh. I paid $12 and ordered online for curbside pickup.When I arrived, there were no spots available. I called, and they told me they only start making the bagel sandwich when I arrive and let them know I am here for pickup. WHAT IS THE POINT OF HAVING CURBSIDE PICKUP WHEN YOU START MAKING IT AFTER I ARRIVE AND TELL YOU I ORDERED FOR PICKUP?!!! The system they have in place is totally dysfunctional and lead to bad customer experience.I waited 20 minutes more....AFTER the time that it was supposed to be available for pickup!

For starters Ive never given a place less then 3 stars. Quite literally the worst bagels Ive ever had. I can get better quality bagels out of a frozen food section in a Grocery store. Their everything bagels had almost no topping on them. I asked for a bagel and cream cheese spread on it and they didnt even bother to heat it up or toast it. Their coffee was tasteless. I wish there was a way to give negative stars but thats not an option. Not sure how this place is still in business.

Good Walk up window experience. Still awesome bagels. They were very busy, and everyone was being respectful of social distancing.

Dont get me wrong, I love their bagels but the service is horrible. My wife online ordered, we were sent a link to click when we arrived. Clicked the link put in the info about the car and waited, and waited, and waited. After 10 minutes a spot opened up by the front so I moved there. Clicked the link again, nothing. Called the number on the curbside sign which told me helpful info about their online menu but then hung up on me. Waited 10 more minutes then gave up,got in the line for the window that was now 10 people deep. By the time I got to the window I had been there for almost a half hour. Let the cashier know I had been waiting that long and was met with a shrug. No sorry you had to wait so long, no apology, nothing. If you cant fulfill orders via for curbside pick up maybe you shouldnt offer it.

Truly has to be the best bagels in the world!! They are so FRESH and delicious with an excellent selection. Toppings are limited right now but the bagels ar so good that you dont want to overtake their flavor with too much stuff anyway! Currently they are doing take out only with a walk-up order window and separate pick-up window. There are a couple of reserved parking spaces for a quick pick up when ordering ahead. Also limited hours. Very organized.BAGEL PERFECTION!

I came by for a toasted bagel with egg on my lunch break and there timing for there service was horrible! I waited over 15min and saw only 2 small orders ahead of me. I looked inside and it was plenty staffed but looked like a lot of them were standing around just talking and a line quickly built behind me. I was definitely not happy about the service especially for my first time visiting this place. The bagel was ok.

Open early! Fresh delicious bagel sandwiches!

Best bagels in town. Freshly baked everyday and really delicious.

I’m not sure what the hype is about this place. I’ve only had bad experiences with their bagels. It almost seems like they don’t boil their bagels before putting them in the oven or something.I’ve resorted to making my own bagels at home since moving here. If you like a good quality New York style bagel I can show you some recipes, but this place is not it.

Ive been going to The Bagelry since I was a kid. Hands down, best bagels Ive ever had! If youre looking for something a little more filling, you cant go wrong with a sandwich! (Load it up, you wont regret it) There is always a variety of soups, salads and other baked goods as well.

I’m a big fan of the Bagelry whenever I’m in Bellingham! I often bring their bagels for trainings I’m holding, and they’re always a big hit! If I’m lucky enough to have some time before a meeting, I like to come here myself and enjoy a bagel and a latte. They make a great latte and the ambiance of the restaurant is cool with all the bustle of patrons and yummy smells.I’ve only ever tried the garlic bagel with Italian cream cheese. It’s just so so so so so good.....However, I’ve been meaning to branch out and give the others a try!The Bagelry is doing it right, that’s for sure!

A lot of restrictions, but dang they are good bagels...

Still as good as the 90’s. Way to keep consistency going owners. Possibly the only west coast sourdough bagel that actually has the taste of sourdough. Love this place always.

Great beer. nice spot to spend the afternoon

When I order a toasted bagel with cream cheese I expect it to be at least warm. Plus the jalapeno bagel tasted plain. Plus not able to pay with cash is a pain for people like me who hate to use plastic.

Bagels are good and food comes out relatively fast, but I dont recommend ordering drinks there, I ordered an iced mocha and a caramel latte and it took 20 minutes to get the drinks out

There is a reason theres a line on weekends and your bagel order takes a long time - these bagels are fabulous. The cream cheeses are out of this world (esp the feta garlic dill cream cheese) and they have such a perfect salt bagel!

Dese guys really. Really. Make good bagels. For a “recovering New Yorker”. These make the grade, with less attitude.

Todays order did not go well. First I ordered the sandwich this morning online at 8:15am. I arrived 10:00am they texted me to tell when it ready. I get in lined and then was told they are short staff and it would take another 15 minutes. OK no problem I have patience.Will I waited 20 minutes no bagel, nothing like Im sorry Ill figure out whereas your order.Now here is a funny part.. I go up and ask whats happening with my order. Thats when I saw some one pulling it out of the cooler.Oh and I paid extras lox est. didnt get that either.I know we have bad days and I really like this place best bagels in town but all I got was a sorry. And I got a text at 11:07 that my order was ready for pick up.

Not accepting cash is a really stupid idea

Finally found a real New York style bagel in the northwest. Fresh bagels in a variety of flavors including my Everything favorite. Nice cream cheese and other deli addons available. Better yet, you get a free bakers dozen after buying 6. Sandwiches and desert items are really nice!

One of my favorite places in Bellingham. We live in Ferndale now but still love stopping by on the weekends!

Actually i haven’t eaten my bagel yet, but i gotta say this place is legit. been going here for years and they’re some of my fav bagels in all of washington.

The online ordering is easy to use but calling in your order is the way to go if its your first time getting bagels from this local shop. Both the man who took my order and the blue haired girl who gave me the bagels were super helpful and friendly! They even have vegan cream cheese but I didnt see any gluten free bagels :/ maybe one day

Great vegan option bagel and cream cheese is why I give a 5 star

There isnt a better bagel in town. They are so fresh and warm when I pick them up. Ordering online and curbside pickup is a breeze!

The veggie peanut soup is so delicious!

I spend each morning at the Bagelry while visiting Bellingham. The salt bagel with peanut butter is my go to combo. The bagels come out fresh and they are now offering vegan cream cheese. Check this place out! Affordable, fresh, and worth the wait if there’s a line.

Fresh sesame bagels with Feta garlic dill cream cheese

Kinda slow? I missed breakfast by minutes so I was bummed

Bagelry is located in the downtown area of Bellingham. It is a cute restaurant that serves a variety of bagel flavors with different spreads. They also had bagel sandwiches. Everything seemed to be fresh. The place was clean. You will need to pay a parking meter out front to park.

Best selection of bagels in town. Perfect destination for a quick and yummy breakfast...or lunch.The staff is also friendly and welcoming.

Wonderful little place serves good Bangles. You can get toasted or cold, cut or uncut. A little crowded but besides that its a nice little store. Only serves Bagles and some drinks like juice and coffee. Has good seating and is right near the buss station.

Hands down the best bagels I have ever eaten (and I have tried so many other bagels after moving away!). My favorites are rosemary and sesame. Give some of their cream cheese flavors a try too. Treat yourself to a black bottom cupcake. Buy a dozen and store them in the freezer to keep them fresh. Delicious!

My everything bagel was more like a piece of wonder bread with a few poppy seeds sprinkled on top than any bagel I’d pay $6 for.

Pretty good breakfast bagel

Honestly the best bagels in town. I drive far to get them over other bagels.

Brought back so many memories. Cant wait to go in and eat.

First off, the customer service is terrible. Second, the food has gotten progressively worse over the past few years. I was going to eat here today but but looking at the reviews I wont be to a long time. Thank you bagelry for making you a place I wont eat at for a long time.

This is a gem that I quickly fell in love with. Service and people were very kind! They offer delicious flavors of bagels, cream cheeses, bagel sandwiches, pastries, and pasta salads. All made from scratch. Healthy and gluten free options available as well.

Vegan Italian on garlic begal because!

I cant wait till its back open to the public. It was one of those places you tell your friends, and show off to your relatives. Not a bad bagel, product or staff member in the entire place.Amazing is not a good enough word for this place!!!

Bagels are really good however the customer service and speed sucks. Ordered over the phone and got there 15 mins later and watched her start on my bagel as I got there. The lady said they were busy but had 2 people outside and had been open for 15 mins. Really need to work on customer service.

Bialy is soooooo good

Loved the bagel sandwich. Jalapeno bagels are the best!

This place stinks. Forgot to give coffee twice, then the bagel order was wrong and they didn’t include either item correctly. The bagel we did get was stale and hard.

Best bagels west of New York!

They raised their prices about 40% after COVID. Their bagels are good but not that good.

Still open through COVID with an outside order andcollect system. This place is popular with locals. Service is slow, be prepared for a wait

Building on other comments... you must order bagels 24 hours in advance.

This place is swesome!! Spacious AND cozy!! Very nice folks😊

Great bagels, better than New York in my opinion when compared side by side. Bellingham friendly. Love the small town vibe.

Fresh everything BAGEL ! Is the way to go! Gosh I’ve never tasted a bagel so flipping delicious. Crunchy from the outside and soft and hot from the inside. They make them in house and the best is you can call them and they can get you a pretty good ETA on the freshest batch! Which I love !!!!Oh gosh I’m craving some right now !!

Great place to get bagels. Made fresh and steamy or get them toasted. Lots of homemade cream cheese and sandwich options. Pro tip, on the other side of the counter is a spot for to go bagel and cream cheese orders. Perfect for a morning grab and go. You need to eat these bagels fresh though because they get stale fast.

Ordered an everything bagel….is this a joke???

Doesnt accept cash. Shouldnt have to use my credit card for a 3 dollar purchase.

The food is always top notch, even on covid-world they manage to deliver, literally. They also have a walk-up window but I suggest you order on-line for curbside pick-up, or call your order in, as the walk-up can get very crowded. Both in regular times and in covid times the service can be a little lacking, but that is because they are SO busy there is confusion and it is far between. The staff are always happy, peppy, and polite, and when there is confusion they are happy to help sort it out and never act like it is a bother or the customers fault. I highly recommend. 5 stars because there is no 6th.

The only New York style bagels Ive found west of the Mississippi! So happy theyve begun making sourdough bagels again!!

I was very excited to try this place. Ordered an everything bagel and a coffee.I was given coffee in a cup where the lid didnt fit so it was spilling all over the place. Also no card board sleeves (extra burn) and they were out of everything bagels, which was not mentioned until 10 minutes after you ordered the bagel. Several others in line were also told after the fact they had to change their order.As an aside was looking for non dairy cream cheese, which I heard they had, but their signage was awful, and it wasnt clear at all. Was literally walking away from the restaurant but thought I would double check, and they did have it, just didnt advertise it? Also their google page still says they are closed, so something is clearly amiss with management.Will try to visit in a few months perhaps and see if things have improved.Ok, round 2! Went again today and their signage was better, the menu was clear. The staff was kind and actually knew what was out of stock. But once more they were out of everything bagels! The non everything bagel I received was cold (you don’t toast bagels?) and the cream cheese was so scarce it was non existent. Never again.

I always love this place. Nice and chewy bagels, fast service, consistent.

Love the Bagelry. There’s always an abundance of seating here and plenty of vegan options. They always have a special on a vegan spread of the week, and once it was this beautiful buttery cinnamon walnut spread.All of their bagels are vegan and delicious!They also usually have some vegan baked goods or desserts to choose from, like cupcakes, fudge, cookies, muffins, etc. I’m never disappointed coming in here.Super affordable pricing too!

Very tasty bagels and nice staff!

Absolutely, positively the best bagel Ive found in the state. Thanks lots for bringing the sourdough bagel back!

Fresh, amazing bagels. I always stop in for a dozen or two when Im in Bellingham. They have something like 15 flavors of bagels. Chewy crust and soft interior. They also make excellent sandwiches. Good prices and great bagels.

Having grown up in Bellingham many of my most fond childhood memories are from getting bagels with my family.Since COVID shut things down they offered a bagel supscription which I was VERY excited about. They have been brilliant since! Their communication is top notch and the bagels arrive on my porch still warm from being made that morning.Today there was a mix up and my order was short 4 bagels. I shot Terra an email and within 30 minutes they delivered the remaining bagels to my house. This kind of customer support is so difficult to find these days. 5 stars for a wonderful local business! Thank you all for the work you do!

As far as food.. the quality cant be better or more original. The price on the other hand is typical for this type of shop. Trendy crowd, extremely high prices, super small portions. Seriously, you would have more of a meal if you went to the store and purchased everything individually. There really is no experience to be had here... Theres nothing extraordinary about this place. But it is very good food. Oh, people bring their dogs to this place... If your okay with that and you have money to burn this place is perfect for you. Ill go back.

Bagels are pretty good here. Coffee was definitely just okay. The lines are pretty long and they arent great about getting the lines down quickly. The place is a pretty cute place to eat.

It was my first time here and the staff was very kind and helpful. The bagels were delicious too! I had the garlic bagel with onion cream cheese I think. Definitely recommend!

Great bagels. Service was easy and fast.

Best lunch in Bellingham! Unbelievably delicious bagels and sandwiches. I have been going here my whole life and will never stop!!

Quick, friendly staff at all hours. Great fresh food. I love the veggie sandwich on a garlic bagel! Try their black bottom cupcake, or,any other of the great treats offered!

I enjoy coming to the Bagelry, they have lots of options for different flavored bagels. Thing is, oftentimes the bagels are hard, or seem less fresh. I always ask which bagel is the freshest and oftentimes they say their last bagels came out a while ago. I enjoy their coffee, its cheap compared to other coffee places. The vegan cream cheese is so yummy and I really like the garlic bagel, especially when its actually fresh.

Fast service with fantastic food. A little on the pricey side but Ive never left disappointed. The new addition of card payment is great. And it always smells wonderful.

Fix your website to alert customers that the Bagelry Does Not Take Cash. Its a waste if peoples time otherwise.

The Bagelry is that rarest of downtown eatery experiences: truly authentic local food with a dedication to quality and excellent customer service. Even when its jam-packed, as it sometimes is, employees are genuinely nice, take time to make sure your order is right, and bring your food to you with a smile when its ready. I dream of their toasted salt bagel with lox and schmear.

Always get great bagels, I really like that they opened up the other side of the store for those whom are wanting just bagels, its quick trip in and out. The weekends are not the best time to go if your in a hurry and downtown parking is always full. I usually go during the week days in the morning. They can have a slow, slow staff and I have been forgotten a couple of times. But as far as the food very good food.

One of the many fitting gems on the beloved Railroad Ave. Charming little locale to grab an affordable bite or coffee with some Old Town charm. Is there a wow factor, not really - but everything they do is done well. Friendly service, tasty food, antique-y environment. High recommendation.

The bagel sandwiches are so yummy! especially with added sprouts! They also have a rotation of monthly cream cheese and bagel. Love to see what their options are!

My family has been coming here for at least 15 years and its been perfect the whole time. Great bagels and fantastic eggs. Coffee and hot cocoa are amazing and lots of space to spread out and work

Bellingham at its finest.

A fun and enjoyable place to grab some breakfast without having to break the bank to do it. Their bagels are of great quality and they even offer simple accommodating fare such as eggs. A great place to stop off for a quick bite!

Love the bagels. Dont be in a hurry when you visit though. Some days its like a regular place of business. Other days you feel like you might as well settle in and get to know the people waiting in line with you.

Dissappointing

The best bagels!!!! Garlic is my fave! Super nice staff and they take credit cards now.

One of the best bagel shops around. Good food and friendly service. A fun, everyone welcome vibe.

The staff here are phenomenal. They kept their cool despite an unexpected shut down of the ovens and delivered wonderful service. The hot chocolate is some of the best Ive ever tasted!

Im from the East Coast, so Im super picky about my bagels. These bagels are legit. I had the Rosemary salt with scallion cream cheese. OMG!I really am disappointed that we cant get this quality of bagel in Seattle. Whats up with that? However, I will make the trip up North just for these bagels. Keep it up! And maybe branch out to King County?

Tasty, hot, fresh bagels in large varieties. Super good breakfast and lunch choices. Very friendly and efficient staff.

Best bagels EVER!

Best bagel place ever and speedy toasting; get there early for a larger variety of flavors.

Really like their bagels, but there is no place in town that works so hard to ignore customers so consistently.

Had breakfast here the other day and it was good food. But i was very impressed with the customer service. thanks to Olivia who helped us! She was great and we were quite complicated. Great staff.

Excellent options for everyone. Bagels are fair priced too. Side note all the bagels are Vegan and they always have a regular and flavored Vegan cream cheese.

I love this place there bagels are the best you cant compare to other i wish there were more places they make the bagels each morning you can even bring you dog in there my dad dose not like bagels but he likes these bagels they sell shirt as well and they make homade treats to.

Amazing homemade bagels. Friendly and quick service. Prices are reasonable. Great place for lunch or to take a dozen bagels home!Warning: cash only but they have an ATM.