I spoke with Jeff, the owner, and his responses to my questions were the most genuine responses I’ve come across. He also impressed me with taking the time to fully respond my questions with kindness, patience, and humor without an expectation in return. That made me feel comfortable and it is a good start to building trust. I recommend Jeff and his store!

As I am new to numismatics, coin collecting and investing in precious metals, I look to local businesses for guidance and help. I cant thank the owner, Jeff, of Specialty Rarities in Bellmore, NY for taking the time to answer my questions and educating me on numismatics. Fair and honest pricing without the expectation of making a large investment up front was what I was looking for. And I found it with Specialty Rarities. I look forward to working with Jeff again in the future.

First, thank you Jeff. Our experience at Specialty Rarities was excellent. My father had saved a bunch of silver coins over the years and it came to a point where they were just taking up space and he was unsure of the value or how to sell them. My neighbor recommended that we give Jeff a call and make an appointment which we did. Walking through the door we didnt know what to expect, since this was all new to us, but what we got was great service from a caring individual who took the time to go through all of the coins, explain what he was looking for and the the values and then we were made a very fair offer that pleased my father immensely. Jeff even told a few coin stories that were fun and educational. So, if youre unsure of the value of the coins that you have then you should meet Jeff. Hell take the time to educate you so you can make a decision that best suits you.

Jeff and Francine are very knowledgeable. They helped us go through tons of stuff left by my father in law separating what is valuable and not. Jeff explained piece by piece one at time so we understood why. His prices were fare and just an all around good guy. I recommended him to my family and friends.

Friendly knowledgeable service. Good rate for silver buy back

RARE FIND ... my first experience here was authentic, educational, and insightful. After Jeff spoke with me for over an hour about my coins and a related item, his patience, deep knowledge, & integrity became more and more prevalent. A fair and good price for my items was settled, and Jeff went out of his way to assist me with a dilemma. While only a first experience here, I will most certainly be back for any coin-related needs in the future. Great to see people still out there with integrity like Jeff.

This place is the best! They had a great selection, a great shop, and great customer service. I would definitely recommend this place whether you are buying or selling. Very honest and fair. My overall experience was perfect, and I will be back!

I really didnt know to expect all people seem nice on the surface, but when I was selling my collection. I wanted my kids to keep something from their grandfather. Jeff took the time and really seemed to care about what I was keeping for them from my Dad. Jeff is a good guy!

Very nice people to deal with. Nice on the phone and even nicer in person and beat other prices. too! all great!

Excellent thank you

Were very nice and explained everything about every coin I had. Would go back again!

Took the time to answer my questions and explained everything to me. I am glad I went there!