Randy is the absolute best, he is great to do business with, extremely helpful and does amazing work and he is extremely honest and trustworthy! If you have a classic car or hotrod, take it here, you wont regret it. I have had him do work on my 68 Mustang and currently have him doing a lot of work on my 69 Z/28 and have a lot more planned down the line for sure! Attached are some before and after pictures of the Z/28, he installed new headers, correct valve covers, power steering, new ignition system, etc. The list goes on and on. I honestly trust him more than I trust myself when it comes to doing my own work.

Randy does a great job with my antique cars. His shop is well organized and I like his attention to detail. He knows his stuff!

I have been working on Hot Rods for over 50 years, the electrical problem I had was driving me crazy. The problem was that I was buy inferior electrical parts. Randy found the problem and fixed the electrical problems.Randy was a very pleasant person to deal with and the work he did was very reasonably priced.

1st time using LI Muscle and boy am I glad I found this place. Randy and Rob were great. Straight shooters - gave me options at every decision point and provided no pressure. You can tell these guys truly love what they do. This beautiful Camaro needed some TLC under the hood and Randy and his team took care of everything! Cant wait to get over the break in period of my new Blueprint 350 Crate motor making 403 HP! Randy kept me within my budget and went the extra mile to do things right! Will definitely be back.

Being new to the muscle car hobby and all I can say is I’m glad I found my shop on the first try. Randy’s expertise, knowledge and attention to every detail helped bring my dream car back to life. His dedication to his business and customers lives up to the 5 star reviews and hype. Highly recommend and can’t wait for the next project.

Where do I start with Randy & and his Crew?? I had been giving it a lot of thought of having a engine built..So I went to Long Island Muscle car...Where I met Randy & the crew!! I decided to let them do the build.. And what a Custom build it was!!He keep me in the loop from start to finish with up dates & pictures.His knowledge is unreal..The end result was phenomenal!! I was very impressed..Long Island Muscle Car Garage is Stuck with me and All my Cars for life!!Thank You so much

Can’t speak enough good about this shop! Randy is a stand up guy. If your looking for quality work I highly recommend considering this shop.

Best muscle car shop on Long Island, great service and the owner Randy, is extremely knowledgeable about all things muscle car.

Beyond Amazing!!! Let me start off by saying I usually only write reviews when I have had a negative experience….Not this time! Over the years I went from mechanic to mechanic dealing with half fast work. My days of jumping are over, Randy does fantastic work. All of the work that Randy did was clean and it was done the right way. Randy provided me with step by step updates and photos, which made me very happy and excited. I literally turned to my father hours after I dropped off my 1981 Camaro and showed him progress pictures, my father replied “This guy doesn’t fool around”. He doesn’t! Randy is extremely knowledgable he gave me great advice and pointed me in the right direct, my car has never felt better! From this point on Muscle Car Garage will be the only shop that does work on my car! P.S. You know I’m serious because I literally drove over an hour from Brooklyn to have Muscle Car work on my vehicle.

Finally someone who know how to fix it right the fist time.. great service and very fair on price

Randy is a great guy and amazing mechanic I trust him with all my classic car needs