Great bagels! Great people! Get them early though. Theyre mouth wateringly hot and soft early in the morning. By mid day, theyre still good, but just bagels. The next day theyre rocks.

Place could have been cleaner, wrap was very small, but not bad

Been going for many years and always my go to spot for picking up fresh bagels. Ive long since moved away from NY but always make it a point to go here, last time even left room in my suitcase to fly home a dozen to FL

Bagels always fresh with a large variety. Their seasoned cream cheese is a wonderful

Horrible bagels butter tastes like lard

I love their food but they never pick up the phone. It’s almost as if they don’t pick up on purpose. I’ve called to place orders every time I want something from here and they almost never pick up. Then when you drive there, you can hear their phone ring and they blatantly ignore it. 3 stars for that reason only

Bagels are amazing. Everything fresh. Service is quick and staff friendly. Place gets very busy, but thats cause they are good

Love this place I’ve been coming here for years but y’all gotta work on the coffee it’s watery otherwise good staff good bagels

Good bagel but i ordered 2breakfast sandwiches and i was last to get them. A little slow.

Good breakfast bagels!

Used to be my favorite place growing up but its gone downhill which is a shame because its fairly close to home. I figured Id give it another chance after being disappointed about a year ago.Both of my orders were wrong and I caught them making the one wrong and had them correct it and they still gave me the wrong order somehow, Id be fine with it but paid double what I normally would since I was supposed to get a sandwich and got a very bland doughy generic tasting sesame bagel. There are better places around, Pats Supermarket even has better bagels.The store is mostly ran by kids now with no leadership. I dont blame the young staff because they dont really know better, management/ownership should be aware and more involved to make this place great again.

Please do something about dozen flies ; they were landing, in the dessert & bagel display. Also no hot chocolate . I was there at 10am

Stuff-a-bagel has some of the best bagels around. With great variety with their French Toast Bagel being to die for. Their staff is extremely helpful with speedy severice. Its a great local place that I cant recommend enough to any bagel fan.

Fast service but on occasions bagels not bake enough.

My new hot spot...use to go to this new deli up the street across from the church on main street, but they keep switching owners. This place has a lot to offer as far as menus goes and all the staff, super friendly and service is quick.. not to mention the food is always tasty and however you order it is exactly how you get It!, hot food is hot ! Cold food is cold....

Great bagels, staff is very quick and good at keeping the line moving.

I love bagels from Stuff-A-Bagel in East Islip. I only get to visit every couple of years but make it a priority to stop there at least once when we go to Long Island for a visit.It doesnt matter if we fly or drive we always pick up a dozen when we head back home to Missouri.Theyve got at least a dozen varieties of bagels and all the fixens. Plus theyve got lots of other great food.

They stop serving hot food.. like bacon and eggs an hour before they close because they cleaned the grill already. Missed out on 5 orders. I will never return there again. Staff was very unfriendly.

Meh

Staff is friendly, but the prices are too high for the quality of food served. $5 for an egg sandwich that barely has any egg on it or meat, youre basically paying for a bagel only. Not impressed... used to be a lot better.

Waited 15 minutes for a few bagles.... when I got home and opened my bagle there wasnt even a teaspoon full of cream cheese on it..... what a joke. Should have went and got my money back.

Yummy

Good bagels but they need some vegan options. I have a dairy allergy and it would be great if they could carry a vegan cream sheese or at least some non dairy creamers. In todays day and age with good allergies it amazing they dont have either.

I dont know what happened to this place. It used to be the best bagel place in town now its down right bad the last three times Ive been there it was less then mediocore and this last time I basically paid 4 dollars for a bagel with nothing on it, I asked for veggie cream cheese but I was hard pressed to find any at all. VERY VERY DISAPPOINTED!

This is the go-to place for the best Brooklyn style bagels around. Forget bagelboss with thier horrible rude staff. Always a pleasant experience even when busy.

This place is always so fast and their egg everything bagels are so delicious. Its my only breakfast spot when im down in East Islip visiting friends. The scallion cream cheese is always my go-to!

Bagels very blonde, not a great variety. It was an ok experience.

Prices are too high for the quality of food served.

Best bagels Ive ever had if you like warm & soft this is the place

I have ordered a number of egg sandwiches from stuff a bagel in east Islip since the new ownership and have not once been satisfied with the outcome. My husband and I ordered two sandwiches on Saturday morning, one was bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel and the other egg whites bacon and cheese on a wheat bagel with ketchup. It was by far the messiest, greasiest meal ever and both of us didnt even finish them. The egg were all chopped up and fell off the bagel, ketchup everywhere and the bagel was greasy to the touch. Unfortunately, this is not the first time this has happened, but I keep returning assuming it will get better, but since it doesnt we will NOT be returning customers in the future. Disappointing since Stuff a bagel always had such a good reputation!

Service is great foods good a little pricey

Stuff a bagel is always great. Staffed well for such a small bagel store.

Great tasting bagels good service

Best bagels in town. Always fresh and delicious!

They have great promotions!

Not the same at all

Although everyone is friendly and the service is always fairly quick, i feel like the food is hit or miss, especially egg sandwiches. However the line is always long so this may only be my opinion.

The best bagel store around

Amazing i love bagels i love stuff a bagel ! the workers are great i love this place.

I JUST NOTICED HOW STINGY THEY ARE WITH THE CREAM CHEESE AND WHEN I MENTIONED IT THEY GAVE ME A SMALLER BAGEL THAT WAS HARD . THEY OVERCHARGE YOU ANYWAY... Time to go to another bagel store...WHAT A RIP OFF....MANAGEMENT DONT CARE AS LONG AS THEY GETTING OUR MONEY...FLIES ARE IN THIS PLACE. BUGS ARE ON THE COUNTERS...DISGUSTING

I like this place because its close to my house. The food isnt bad but they lack consistency with their pricing, one day you pay $6 for something and another day they are charging you $8 for the same exact thing.

Stopped in for the first time today and what a disappointment. Ordered a plain bagel with scallion cream cheese and nova. The cream cheese was so thinly spread that you could not tell you had any. The scallions and nova were nonexistent. This is not how you “ stuff a Bagel”.

Great food great service

Always fresh great friendly service

They use frozen not fresh made bagels, and the help they hired recently just is beyond sub par. Was my go to place seeing they are around the corner from me But no longer I’m done with them. AVOID AT ALL COSTS!

On occasions bagels not cook enough

Love coming here.

Amazing high notch food and very nice people

Good bagel place, but not the best

Need to clean that place, fresh paint or something.

Great food and staff

Amazing Bagels & Friendly Staff!!!

Great bagels

Food is good, problem is some staff dont pay attention to requests, crispy bacon, or ketchup on wrong sandwiches, $5+ for a bacon egg and cheese slightly pricey.

Ordered over medium eggs for my sandwich and got sunny side up eggs and a mouth full of nasty burnt grill scrapings..oh and the cheese wasnt even melted either !!!!

Nice people, but the food is less than mediocre

Great bagel selection

Best fresh bagels

Best bagels around!!

Great egg sandwich

Good choice

Great bagel!!

Better places around

Best Bagels

Trash

Nice

Delicious and special