user
Criterion Chocolates Inc
125 Lewis St, Eatontown, NJ 07724, United States
Appearance
Criterion Chocolates Inc
Comments
Sp
Review №1

Very tasty chocolates and truffles! Quality ingredients and fair prices, I would visit again for sure. Only advice I would give is maybe invest some money into the dusty exterior of the place, I honestly couldnt tell if it was operational. Oh, has great parking right out front for those driving in.

Ri
Review №2

It appears that chocolate is a very difficult commodity to deliver in perfect condition every time. Ive learned to appreciate fresh & flavorful and, after sampling the offerings from every provider I know of within 50 miles; there is only one provider that doesnt put its product over tin foil and under Saran wrap (bad sign, unless you like slow moving, aged/stale product)...never seen that at Criterion Chocolate. Always fresh, always delicious...and it melts!!! Did you ever notice that the crappier chocolate barely melts in your hand. This is not a plug for M&Ms; its an observation that additives effect taste (sorry Hershey & Nestle)...Criterion product still melts!! Buy your chocolate there...there is only one #1!!

Mi
Review №3

Support local businesses.Granddaughters love their chocolate and taffy.

Ro
Review №4

Wonderful quality, helpful staff. My familys favorite place to buy chocolates. Our first visit there was like discovering a hidden jewel in our own backyard!

Bl
Review №5

Great place to stop by to pick up chocolate for any occasion! They make themed candy as well for Easter, Mothers Day, or any holiday. I will definetly be stopping by again.

Su
Review №6

I love Criterion Chocolates. The candy and chocolate are delicious and always a pleasure place to visit and buy gifts.

Di
Review №7

Friendly owners and employees. Very clean. Nice variety of chocolates and best taffy in NJ.

St
Review №8

Great dark chocolate raisin clusters, non-pariels, DC covered cherries and marshmallows. The best saltwater taffy. Reasonable prices. Friendly service. Loyal customers.

Sh
Review №9

A friend mentioned Criterion Chocolates to me as she used to live in NJ, and still has relatives there. I ordered a pound of dark chocolate nonpariels for her and some dark chocolate turtles as well. When they arrived, she offered me a taste, and I loved em. Ill be ordering more for my own enjoyment.The ordering process is a bit old fashioned ... nothing on line. Gotta make a phone call, talk to people, and then wait a while before getting the chocolate. Kind of nice ... Oh, they wont ship the chocolates during the hot months, especially to California where were located.

Fr
Review №10

Good selection and excellent chocolate

Da
Review №11

Best haystacks and chocolate turtles I have ever had! Very sweet ladies helped us and answered our questions. Would recommend to anyone.

Ka
Review №12

Great chocolate & great people that run the company

C
Review №13

Great chocolate and friendly staff. My only problem is they dont make peanut butter cups! About average price for good chocolate. I visit each valentines day for choc. covered strawberries.

Vi
Review №14

Best tasting chocolate ever had..will highly recommend

ma
Review №15

Theirs was BEST ! Most flavor to taffy. Remember as a kid.

Ro
Review №16

Great chocolate & great people that run the company

Gl
Review №17

Especially after holidays with special candy dealsThe best

To
Review №18

Wont go anywhere else

Pa
Review №19

Delicious. You get what you pay for....high quality!

Ma
Review №20

Just DELICIOUS

Ro
Review №21

Chocolate-covered Oreo cookies is there anything else to say this place been there ever since I can remember my name

Ja
Review №22

Try the dark chocolate. Awesome!

Pa
Review №23

Best candy never stale friendly staff

jo
Review №24

The best selection of chocolates & salt water taffy

Ti
Review №25

Chocolate is awesome...a little pricey but its made fresh on premises. I go there all the time. Love Criterion

Qa
Review №26

Me and my daughter favorite place to get chocolate

Al
Review №27

Amazing chocolate 😍👌❤️. Its a must to come and try this chocolate.

Ke
Review №28

Need nice chocolates, especially sugar free ones? This is the place

al
Review №29

I love there chocolate turtles with peacans

Bi
Review №30

Great small shop to pick up some treats

Da
Review №31

Best saltwater Taffy- always fresh

Jo
Review №32

Awesome store, I go when ever I am in NJ

Je
Review №33

Smells sooooo good in here.

Ja
Review №34

Its chocolate at its best

Ja
Review №35

Great people and GREAT chocolate!!!

Fr
Review №36

Good selection of chocolate

Br
Review №37

Great homemade chocolates

St
Review №38

Candy fine

De
Review №39

Inside smells musty.

Co
Review №40

Yum

Information
13 Photos
40 Comments
4.6 Rating
  • Address:125 Lewis St, Eatontown, NJ 07724, United States
  • Site:http://criterionchocolates.com/
  • Phone:+1 732-542-7847
Categories
  • Chocolate shop
  • Candy store
Working hours
  • Monday:10AM–5:30PM
  • Tuesday:10AM–5:30PM
  • Wednesday:10AM–5:30PM
  • Thursday:Closed
  • Friday:10AM–5:30PM
  • Saturday:10AM–5:30PM
  • Sunday:10AM–5:30PM
Service options
  • In-store pickup:Yes
  • Takeout:Yes
  • Delivery:No
Highlights
  • Fast service:Yes
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Similar organizations