Very tasty chocolates and truffles! Quality ingredients and fair prices, I would visit again for sure. Only advice I would give is maybe invest some money into the dusty exterior of the place, I honestly couldnt tell if it was operational. Oh, has great parking right out front for those driving in.

It appears that chocolate is a very difficult commodity to deliver in perfect condition every time. Ive learned to appreciate fresh & flavorful and, after sampling the offerings from every provider I know of within 50 miles; there is only one provider that doesnt put its product over tin foil and under Saran wrap (bad sign, unless you like slow moving, aged/stale product)...never seen that at Criterion Chocolate. Always fresh, always delicious...and it melts!!! Did you ever notice that the crappier chocolate barely melts in your hand. This is not a plug for M&Ms; its an observation that additives effect taste (sorry Hershey & Nestle)...Criterion product still melts!! Buy your chocolate there...there is only one #1!!

Support local businesses.Granddaughters love their chocolate and taffy.

Wonderful quality, helpful staff. My familys favorite place to buy chocolates. Our first visit there was like discovering a hidden jewel in our own backyard!

Great place to stop by to pick up chocolate for any occasion! They make themed candy as well for Easter, Mothers Day, or any holiday. I will definetly be stopping by again.

I love Criterion Chocolates. The candy and chocolate are delicious and always a pleasure place to visit and buy gifts.

Friendly owners and employees. Very clean. Nice variety of chocolates and best taffy in NJ.

Great dark chocolate raisin clusters, non-pariels, DC covered cherries and marshmallows. The best saltwater taffy. Reasonable prices. Friendly service. Loyal customers.

A friend mentioned Criterion Chocolates to me as she used to live in NJ, and still has relatives there. I ordered a pound of dark chocolate nonpariels for her and some dark chocolate turtles as well. When they arrived, she offered me a taste, and I loved em. Ill be ordering more for my own enjoyment.The ordering process is a bit old fashioned ... nothing on line. Gotta make a phone call, talk to people, and then wait a while before getting the chocolate. Kind of nice ... Oh, they wont ship the chocolates during the hot months, especially to California where were located.

Good selection and excellent chocolate

Best haystacks and chocolate turtles I have ever had! Very sweet ladies helped us and answered our questions. Would recommend to anyone.

Great chocolate & great people that run the company

Great chocolate and friendly staff. My only problem is they dont make peanut butter cups! About average price for good chocolate. I visit each valentines day for choc. covered strawberries.

Best tasting chocolate ever had..will highly recommend

Theirs was BEST ! Most flavor to taffy. Remember as a kid.

Great chocolate & great people that run the company

Especially after holidays with special candy dealsThe best

Wont go anywhere else

Delicious. You get what you pay for....high quality!

Just DELICIOUS

Chocolate-covered Oreo cookies is there anything else to say this place been there ever since I can remember my name

Try the dark chocolate. Awesome!

Best candy never stale friendly staff

The best selection of chocolates & salt water taffy

Chocolate is awesome...a little pricey but its made fresh on premises. I go there all the time. Love Criterion

Me and my daughter favorite place to get chocolate

Amazing chocolate 😍👌❤️. Its a must to come and try this chocolate.

Need nice chocolates, especially sugar free ones? This is the place

I love there chocolate turtles with peacans

Great small shop to pick up some treats

Best saltwater Taffy- always fresh

Awesome store, I go when ever I am in NJ

Smells sooooo good in here.

Its chocolate at its best

Great people and GREAT chocolate!!!

Good selection of chocolate

Great homemade chocolates

Candy fine

Inside smells musty.

Yum