Fair and honest..superb coin supply store..they also buy scrap gold jewelry, some sterling flatware, and my old silver coins.I am impressed with prices. will be going back here without a doubt!

The kids club is awesome! Kids get something free (coins/currency) every month and something special on their birthday month. It could be roughly 50 dollars worth per year.

Best coin shop in the Indy area! The owner is always fair and helpful. When the lockdowns first happened I was put in the position of having to sell some of my collection. I wasn’t happy about it but Scott was fair with me and I didn’t feel taken advantage of. A lot of coin shops in the area can treat sellers like they are at a pawn shop but not here. They understand and try to work with you to get the best price for your precious metals. I won’t go anywhere else to buy or sell! Thanks Scott

My first time there I was a little put off. I was going through generic silver, finding bars and rounds that interested me, when the owner pulled all the bars to show to a early teen boy whose dad bought them all. It was not a huge deal, but felt pretty rude.I gave them a second chance two weeks later, and I am glad I did. Scott has fair prices for what I am after. He and his wife are super friendly. Things happen, no big deal. Hes quickly becoming my go-to.Third time in, still happy and on the path to a lifelong customer.

I took my Jesus Jesus pendent in to check and see if it was real and they took it to the back as whole pendent and returned with pieces and never apologized or offered to fix it I will never recommend there services to anyone looking to sell or buy gold . I would give a half a star if I could...

They have an excellent program for kids that has fostered my sons interest in coins.

Great people. Vast selection of coin and currency. 👍👍👍👍👍

Wonderful store for new and experienced collectors. They always spend time answering my questions, have fair prices, and carry a nice selection. I make weekly visits and am always impressed with the service.

I came in to sell some silver/gold and was given a very fair price. They were friendly and very knowledgeable. The transaction took no time at all and I was given cash in exchange. They had a clean store with a great assortment of coins and currency. I highly recommend coming here!

Great family friendly place

I brought in some old jewelry that I will not wear again, and I was very pleased with my experience (and my offer). I much prefer Gold and Coin of Fishers to a jewelry store when selling gold. Everyone was very friendly, and thank you to the guy who gave my daughter a quarter for the gumball machine! I definitely recommend Gold and Coin of Fishers!

Had an excellent experience with this shop earlier in the week. I came in to sell some silver and they gave me a fair price. I would highly recommend them!

This is the BEST coin shop to do business with! If you had a coin collection to sell or even gold or silver jewelry - this is the place to go. Think warm, friendly and knowledgeable, and this describes this family run business.

Fast, honest, friendly, and fair.

Really friendly staff and they were willing to answer questions.

Always very welcoming and I believe to be extremely fair on their prices.

I went in to sell some silver. I was treated very kindly and respectfully and was payed a fair amount. I would highly recommend this store.

Large selection of coins, stamps, tokens, and paper currency. Staff is knowledgeable and attentive! Great prices whether selling or purchasing!

Quick and easy to work with 👌🏻💯

Very nice, informative and patient. I will be back! I love the “ma and pa shop” feel.

Great price on constitutional silver and American eagles. I would recommend.

Store owner is very knowledgeable and fair and friendly, always have a good experience when stopping by.

A amazing store great prices and great if your just starting

Staff was respectful and attentive. Which was better than other coin shop experiences in the area.

Good store. I try and buy most my silver from here.

Bought several coin there, best prices in the state! I also sold them some old gold jewelry I had, checked around and they paid more than anyone quoted.

Nice guy, friendly and helpful.

You need to update your times online. I drove from Cumberland and hit traffic because of an accident. I arrived at 5:33pm and was livid when I found out you closed at 5:30. People look you up on the internet, so you need to keep it updated.

Huge selection, great prices, highly recommend.