Knowledgeable staff on ingredients and allergens. Plenty of delicious sounding choices, were looking forward to trying our selections. Tasting not currently allowed, looking forward to its return.

We were visiting the area and walked into The Olive Mill.......what an amazing store, with great hospitality!We purchased some chapstick and Tuscan Herb Infused Oil, simply delicious!

A pleasant shopping experience. The store layout makes finding things needed simple. Very friendly staff. I will definitely shop here again.

Great selection and quality. Customer service is also excellent. My go to place for olive oil. Try the blood orange olive oil in chocolate brownie recipe for a really great twist on brownies!

Friendly, helpful employees. I like how they are quick to open up another register when lines start to get long. Food staples like milk, butter, eggs etc. are always a good deal. Good store to pickup a dozen or so items rather than visit a larger supermarket further away.

Wish we could bring in our bottles for refill. The Tea Tree in Batavia allows it.

Love the Olive Mill, Deb and Lori are so knowledgeable and I have enjoyed all the selections they recommended. Big fan of the butter olive oil, rosemary, tuscan herb olive and tuscan herb balsamic, lemon olive oil and strawberry balsamic. Also the popcorn is amazing. Highly recommend the Olive Mill.

One of my best friends and I were l strolling around Geneva late in the afternoon and just happened to come across this place. My friend absolutely *adores* good olive oil - I suspect shed even put it on ice cream if she found the right kind - so we popped in to have a look.It turned out to be a great little shop. The Olive Mill is warm and inviting, even homey. Shopping there feels very much like being in a beautiful and familiar kitchen.I enjoy some olive oils, but Im not really a huge fan of it. Yet even I thought it smelled wonderful in there. The extremely friendly and helpful gentleman behind the counter described each oil and gave us samples of whatever we wanted to try. My friend, of course, was in olive oil heaven, but even I thought they all tasted *wonderfully* good.This was several months ago and we havent made it back since then, but its still starred on my Maps list under places to go! I highly recommend everyone do the same - then make sure to go!

The incredible oils, basalmics, and seasonings help make some incredible meals! Curbside pickup is available too!

Excellent olive oil and balsamic vinegars with tons of flavors and choices. Excellent staff that is friendly and knowledgeable.

A great selection of gourmet EVOO and balsamic vinegar. The staff is VERY helpful and will steer you through all of the choices. Great quality.

Obsessed with olive oil from here!! Such a huge selection to choose from. Won’t disappoint

Great place for oils and vinegar. Great selection and good prices. Never knew how good balsamic vinegar was until I tasted it here, then bought a lot of it.

Very nice place with knowledgeable sales staff. Great variety of balsamic vinegars and olive oil. We will return for more.

Great place to pick up a quick gift that will be used. The traditional balsamic is my favorite.

Good place for flavor infused olive oil. Convenient location just was of 3rd St downtown Geneva

Helpful staff. Cute boutique. Great for finding gifts

Excellent and tasty olive oil and balsamic selections.

Great olive oil and outstanding balsamic!

Large selection of olive oil, balsamic vinegar, and more.

Love this place!

Wonderful oils

Love it!!

We are satisfied with the price and quality