user
Bagel Boss Hicksville
432 S Oyster Bay Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, United States
Appearance
Bagel Boss Hicksville
Comments
Li
Review №1

The bagels were so very good. The kind of dense and simple bagels. The tuna was not it very bland and not the best. The cigar dessert was dry but tasty. Best dessert was the Linzer tart. Overall a good place minus these few items.

Nx
Review №2

This place is on the short list jockeying for position in the race for Goat. If this place was a WWE wrestler its finishing move would be the 24hour bagel toaster. The staff is super helpful and will always answer any questions you may have. They are known to serve up some more fluffy airy bagels rather then the crispy crunchy verity but if you prefer crispy crunchy bagels just ask for it toasted.

De
Review №3

I got a poppyseed bagel with tuna. The tuna was disgusting. It had zero flavor. I came home, added salt and pepper but it still tasted gross. The macaroni salad was gross too (tasted sweet) but the pickle was good. For almost $13, Ill try another bagel store.

Me
Review №4

Great selection of bagels and spreads. We got two cinnamon raisin bagel with strawberry cream cheese and scallion cream cheese and a everything bagel with strawberry cream cheese. Everything was great except for the part where they toasted the cream cheese with the bagels making most of the cream cheese drip and fall. All in all a great place for fresh bagels

Ga
Review №5

Good bagels. Friendly service

Ry
Review №6

The bagels seem a little better in the day time than at night, probably for obvious reasons, but its hard to beat a 24 hour bagel spot. They have all the classic bakery goods as well. The store is clean and the staff are nice. Not my favorite bagel on the Island but definitely the most convenient.

St
Review №7

What great kosher bagels! I really enjoyed the lunch I had here. And the French vanilla coffee was delicious. The line moves quickly and we were able to enjoy our food while it was hot. Outdoor dining was available as well.

Ya
Review №8

I was standing for 15 minutes, only to take someone elses order who was supposedly in the line. There was no indication where the line started

Ma
Review №9

Flavorless, bland place. just go to taco bell and get the healthier cheapest options. The bagels are oddly bland. Salads, no oopf, everything ..overpriced.

Jo
Review №10

The bagels are good albeit a little pricy. They have a great assortment of drinks and sandwiches along with some confections. If I ever need a good bagel with a drink this is my first stop I think of.

Jo
Review №11

Good bagels and pastries. Large selection of kosher foods, perfect place for lunch or a late night snack. They are open 24 hours a day which is wonderful. Closed on Jewish holidays. Really nice sitiing area with a large tv and bathrooms. Large parking lot so you can always find a spot. Overall a great bagel place plus a whole lot more.

Ja
Review №12

You want good bagels? Stop here! New York’s finest. This is what I like baby. Thick & heavy on the spread. 🥯🥯🥯

ap
Review №13

Ordered bagels to bring home with us (we live out of state) and they were made fresh and packed perfectly. We have brought bagels from other places and these where by far the best we have ever gotten! Highly recommend this place and will definitely order from them again!

CP
Review №14

$5.25 for toast with butter and a small coffee.The toast was like a wet sponge and the coffee was not good.I dont like feeling cheated when ordering a very simple breakfast. Never again.

Ha
Review №15

I get that it’s a rush but kinda slacking on the cream cheese wish I noticed sooner they’re normally overflowing

Ol
Review №16

Amazing. Fulfilled all my flagel dreams!

Ra
Review №17

Open 24 hours per day. Large selection of bagels and other food to eat. All of it is delicious. Have used them several times to cater parties and have been very satisfied with the presentation and quantity of food.

Ke
Review №18

Almost always fresh bagels in the morning, delish crisp outside and fluffy airy inside. A little expensive if you get cream cheese etc. there but just buy a few bagels and shmear them at home!

Ro
Review №19

Great bagels, always soft, fresh and delicious. Great service, fast efficient. Lots of things to go with bagels, like cream cheese plain, lox and scallion, and lots of other goodies. We used to go to other bagel places in the past, but now its our go-to place!

K
Review №20

The guy that helped me was very patient with me even though I had no idea what I wanted and was barely awake lol. He rightly asked if I wanted a coffee to go with my breakfast bagel and Im glad he did. Their French vanilla is wonderful. Overall good first experience.

Pa
Review №21

Been coming here for several years, love there bagels there the best,you wont find a better bagel anywhere else..

Je
Review №22

Yea it came with 2 tiny pickles...but does this look like a $10 sandwich to you?! ...nah I didn’t think so. ...one of my favorite places- urgggg -another one bites the dust.

Dr
Review №23

The guy behind the counter was more than helpful even though I came in extremely late at night. I had a very large order too and he was patient and didnt get frustrated even while another guest was waiting and even acknowledged him to let him know he would be right with him after me. Excellent customer service and the bagels are even better. The bakery good are good too but I didnt care for their cheese danishes.

La
Review №24

Excellent bagels and kosher food. All kosher. Had everything natal toasted with scallion cream cheese lox lettuce tomato with 1 pickle and side of potato salad.

Mi
Review №25

The person helping me kept touching his face and adjusting his pants. It also took 3 people to give me back the correct change. I notice the workers are more interested in talking to each other than waiting on customers and providing good service. I stopped going because of the lack safety/cleanliness when handling food.

An
Review №26

I ordered a pumpernickel bagel very, very lightly spread with cream cheese and salmon. I got a rye bagel with cream cheese so thick I needed to take it off and it measured a full half cup of cream cheese. The samon was so chewy. This cost me almost $14. It included potatoe salad and a pickle. The potato salad was good.

mi
Review №27

Good bagels and excellent selection includes nice pumpernickel. Many homemade salads includes excellent whitefish salad. Various cream cheese varieties. Also like that they have a large homemade soup area.big bonus that its open 24 hours. High quality and high price.

Pa
Review №28

Egg and cheese on a roll,Bagel with cream cheese,Small iced tea. $13???Did I get overcharged?

Ni
Review №29

Best bagels just wish they had a Separate line for just picking up a dozen bagels

Av
Review №30

Kosher and open 24 hours except on religious days.

Da
Review №31

Best bagels on Long Island best white fish salmon smoked salmon they have everything you need in a kosher bagel store

Ho
Review №32

Wonderful selection of bagels and salads as well as fresh baked goods. I went out there from Brooklyn just to get a dozen bagels which taste just like old time Brooklyn bagels.Great 👍

An
Review №33

Love that the place is open 24 hours !. The lox cream cheese spread is delicious, as is the selection of pastries . Very surprised they don’t serve Kedem Grape Juice though.

at
Review №34

I have had better egg salad from other places, it was bit dry and just chunk of the eggs. Flagel tasted amazing and so was customer service. Place was busy but they were working fast that no one was waiting too long. Ill go back and maybe try something else

P
Review №35

They ARE KOSHER! Not like the traitors in E Northport.

Sc
Review №36

Best bagels on long island

Yo
Review №37

Visited this place on Monday early morning. There was a line to get bagels but it didnt take that long to get the bagel. I got a dozen of bagels but pumpernickel bagel was not the one that I was looking for. The color of the bagel looked more like a whole wheat bagel to me. The whole wheat bagel was okay. I still need to try the garlic and onion bagel.Overall, it is the okay place for bagel/breakfast.

Ro
Review №38

Great clean place. Fresh

St
Review №39

Great bagels. Great service. 24/7. Favorite place ever.

Da
Review №40

Was VERY impressed with this place. Great service, very clean & food is amazing!

Da
Review №41

So great.. These bagels are delicious!

Ja
Review №42

I have been going here for years love this place but i went in today to see a sign that says they are charging customers almost 4 percent to use debit and or credit instead of cash..they are charging the customers the fee that the credit card companys charge to businesses for having the machine thats a fee that the businesses pay not customers its absolutely disgusting what they are doing this puts an extra at least 30k in the owners pocket a year!!! Will not ever come back i dont support people who do scumb bag things like this!! This place is very successful so there is no need for them to be doing this!! Its ppl like this that whats wrong w the world today ur taking advantage of others who put u there in the first place!! Karma will come!

Ma
Review №43

They have tasty bagels, but for me, not worth the long wait and getting a bagel with not the cream cheese you asked for....Disappointed.

Da
Review №44

Quick device, great food

Zl
Review №45

I come here with my gf, never change my order always get the smoked salmon cream chz and also salmon salad toasted both on everything bagel. Service is severely hit or miss depending on the person making the bagel. Portion is perfect. People need to stop complaining about the price increase and the charge on 4%. Everything is expensive now deal w it, this is not corporate owned, go help your local restaurants and pay cash if you are not satisfied with your 4% charge. Thank you for your delish food.

Sa
Review №46

Waiting for the dining area to open up in a safe manner.

Sa
Review №47

The bagels here are FRESH and taste amazing!

De
Review №48

IN A TIME WHERE SO MANY BUSINESS ARE COMPETITIVE, BAGEL BOSS KEEPS THERE CUSTOMERS IN MIND AND AT HEART, CONTINOUSLY PROVIDING FRESH PRODUCTS!

F
Review №49

Great bagels. Open 24/7, I believe. Great food. Very Good service.

Ca
Review №50

I drive way out of my way to go here for their Billys that r fresher than anyplace else

Ma
Review №51

Amazing bagels and great service. We were from out of town and the guy working was so patient and polite and the bagels were great.

Jo
Review №52

Great bagels and friendly help.

Ja
Review №53

Enjoyed my bagel so much

Ag
Review №54

Best bagels and service in long islandThe two women working night shift are the best and best workers and so polite and nice to talk too

la
Review №55

Best bagels on the island, excellent selection, always fresh and friendly staff.

De
Review №56

Food and service was awesome!!

Br
Review №57

Food is always fresh, delicious and accurately made to the customers liking. Staff is attentive, personable and go above and beyond. Best bagel place on Long Island.

Jo
Review №58

Bagel boss is amazing all their salads and food are off the charts delicious not to mention their bagels are always super fresh!

Ra
Review №59

The best bagels in Nassau County, friendly staff and good service

Y.
Review №60

Very good bagels, usually get butter on everything bagel or lox plain toasted. Come here twoce a week good price. 3% fee doesnt bother me because I know how small businesses work and we all need to help the community business and also tosurvive to make profit and save money. The problem is the person who makes the food, can be hit or miss depending on the person. Some are superb and some I have to repeat the order 3-4 times :( and some sometimes put onions and peppers on my lox idk y :( overall very good :)

LA
Review №61

Huge store with Bakery & Deli, Kosher too. So many choices & open 24 hours! Our family has been coming here since it opened in the 70s.

Mo
Review №62

Love this places! They have the best bagels Ive ever had and also have very friendly and fast service. They are also open 24/7 which is amazing.

J
Review №63

This was my first time at bagel boss. The cashier was attentive, kind and sweet but she didn’t take off her gloves when she took my money. She touched the bagels and the money with the same pair of gloves. What’s the purpose of wearing gloves? Needless to say I will not return again. Don’t handle my food with dirty gloves.

Ju
Review №64

I tried several times and I prefer the bagels and cream cheeses at several other places. Its average. The sweet snack are too sweet and lack things I had at other places.

RO
Review №65

Open 24 hour! They seem to always have fresh bagels.

Wa
Review №66

Worst bagels ever, poor service, everytime i go there theres always something missing, old tuna salad and found a hair in their cream cheese.

Mi
Review №67

Good food open 24/7 but they dont serve bacon which annoys me.

Ed
Review №68

Great fresh bagels - always!!

ak
Review №69

Best 24hr kosher bagel deliBaked salmon on a everything bagel is the best

D
Review №70

Ordered Everything bagle with scallion cream cheese and this is what i got. Drove 20mins back home and breakfast ruined. Always check before you leave.

Dw
Review №71

Love their bagels since the late 1970s. The establishment has increased in size and products. Family owned and a staple of communities. Open 7/24. Product moves fast so items are made fresh daily. Offers catering and delivery. Ample parking in and outside tables. Great place for families. Personally, I love moist large white fish and baked salmon. Price can be high but excellent product.

Gl
Review №72

Always go there for the best bagels. They are always fresh and hot. The staff is very friendly and eager to help. They have a large variety of products from salads to pastries. I always like to go very late in the evening or very early morning. The prices are very reasonable.

Bl
Review №73

Delicious, Best bagels ever 🥯

Ga
Review №74

Bagels and pastries are fresh and delicious. Lots of cream cheese spreads and salads. Would have preferred to have meat and cheese options for sandwiches.

Ke
Review №75

Bagels are good but there are plenty of good bagels on long island. The big draw here is they are open 24 hours. The prices are insane, bring cash because they charge extra for credit cards which is crazy.

Fr
Review №76

Decent tasting bagels. Honestly it didnt knock me over. A&S in west Hempstead had more flavour

LO
Review №77

No meat. Idk why they dont find a way to have meat and dairy products separate. It lets a lot of people down.

Jo
Review №78

Love the bagels here!

Ri
Review №79

Always greatThe staff friendlyThe bagels the BEST

Mi
Review №80

Great place. Bagels are tasty, friendly staff, they take your order on a fly. The only negative thing I have is a price... but its worth it.

An
Review №81

A Beautiful place! Very clean! That being said. Its all vegan. I had the vegan breakfast sausage . Disgusting! And I like veggie burgers. Love the burgers king impossible burger and Cheesecake Factory beyond burger. I will try thier burger

Cl
Review №82

Delicious toated Butter bagel 🥯

Ga
Review №83

Great bagels.

Al
Review №84

The bagels are good but they have recently decided to start charging a 4% fee for credit card purchases. I find it insulting they would comment that they value my business when credit card processing fees are one of MANY costs of doing business... While Ill probably still go there, it will only be when other bagel places are closed (huge advantage to bagel boss being 24x7x350(or so).

ju
Review №85

Waited over 10 minutes and nobody even said hi to me walked out

Ri
Review №86

Its more to us than just a bagel shop,my husband and I make it a DATE NIGHT,they are open all hours and we live so far from the store so we make it a fun ride. Also, only because their food is ABSOLUTELY worth the trip,warm bagels each time we go. Simply THE BEST.♥️♥️♥️🌹🌹🌹‼‼‼

ch
Review №87

Best place on the island for bagels, iced coffee, and a ton of other goodies. I was in and out in 5-6 min even being the 10th person in line.

Ma
Review №88

Theres a reason why there are long lines during lunch rush. Good food, nice staff. A good amount of room in the back to sit.

Ai
Review №89

Always good! Took a dozen to WV for a relocated Newyorker!

La
Review №90

Employees are great and very friendly. Food tastes great and they are open 24/7! A+++

Vi
Review №91

Great staff. Delicious food. Great selection.I didnt give them 5 stars because they are a kosher deli that doesnt serve meat. But their soy bacon tasted just like the real thing!

Sa
Review №92

I live near Manhattan and this place is 30+ miles away. I enjoy this place so much that make the attempt to visit this place once a month.Whole wheat bagel toasted with salmon salad, potato salad, and a dill pickel on the side. Just for that.

Al
Review №93

Great Service 24x7. Still miss getting chicken salad on a bagel. (They are Kosher)

Co
Review №94

Them aight, them aight

Ch
Review №95

Bagels are fresh. Salads are fresh. A full line of tasty treats and catering. An excellent stop for breakfast, lunch...anytime. Open 24 hrs.

Ka
Review №96

Great selection of bagels, sandwiches, baked goods. Staff is quick and nice. Great tasting bagels

Br
Review №97

Walked into shop, looked real clean...Then walked over to salad counter where two people were behind the counter not doing anything, they looked at me and turned away not saying anything. I walked over to the register and again 4 people stood there not saying or doing anything. Finally one young woman asked if I needed help...I asked if they have any lunch meat, at that time another employee cut into the conversation rudely, obnoxiously saying that this is a Kosher place and there is no meat served there. ROLLED his eyes turned his back to me ...I grew up around and with Jewish families and know what KOSHER means...To the OWNER of Bagel Boss,, inform your employees what KOSHER means...I will attempt again another day soon...How could you employ such an idiot...

RT
Review №98

After the reply from the nice people at bagel boss I thought I should edit my review and write something a little more coherent. Here it goes. This is my idea of coherent.I grew up near the Plainview store. They started out with a single storefront and it was busy day and night. They were smart enough to unlock the door while they made the bagels and people came in at all hours before finally going home after a long night out. No sooner did that rush end when working people would start coming in for breakfast before work. They make gigantic bagels made and cooked the right way and overstuffed with delicious tuna or chicken salad or vegetable cream cheese. Before long they needed more space and I think they took over a card store and Roman gardens restaurant. They have grown since then but they still do everything right. They serve the freshest fish, salads, baked goods, sandwiches not to mention soups, coffee and snacks. I wish they could make a bacon egg and cheese on an everything roll, but they cant and thats ok. You can order something that conforms to their traditions (many of which are quite delicious) or you may take an assorted dozen home, slice them and freeze them. They come back nice in the toaster oven, and you can do whatever you want with them!Bagel boss is family run and has been a fixture in the community for almost 50 years maybe longer Im not sure.Do not miss an authentic experience at the bagel boss....P.S. Their prices have always been reasonable especially considering the quality of the food.

Ho
Review №99

24/7 great food

Ne
Review №100

I had to throw my bagels away as soon as I got home due to poor hygiene! by the server. I have been a customer of this Bagel Boss for decades, but I think I have had enough. The older manager-type person (always wears a hat) repeatedly touches money and does not change his gloves before touching more food! I have seen him do this multiple times and when I call him out on it, he takes the bagels out of my bag, tosses them back on the shelves and grabs different ones. So disgusting.

Information
100 Photos
100 Comments
4.4 Rating
  • Address:432 S Oyster Bay Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, United States
  • Site:http://theoriginalbagelboss.com/
  • Phone:+1 516-681-1856
Categories
  • Bagel shop
Working hours
  • Monday:Open 24 hours
  • Tuesday:Open 24 hours
  • Wednesday:Open 24 hours
  • Thursday:Open 24 hours
  • Friday:Open 24 hours
  • Saturday:Open 24 hours
  • Sunday:Open 24 hours
Service options
  • Curbside pickup:Yes
  • Delivery:Yes
  • In-store pickup:Yes
  • Same-day delivery:Yes
  • Takeout:Yes
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance:Yes
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot:Yes
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Similar organizations