The service was good and relatively quick. The egg sandwiches my wife and I devoured were really good and we even took some lunch sandwiches to go and our kids absolutely loved them. The Commack Bomb my son couldnt stop raving about. Yes, the place was a bit pricey but isnt everything nowadays.

The service was friendly, efficient, and welcoming. The bagels were only so so. For Long Island, they need to step up the bagel game here. The cream cheese was really good (we had both the scallion and the lox cream cheeses), but the bagels were a bit anemic, small and kind of dry. Less chewy than the bagels I associate with NY metro good bagels. Looked like they had some decent deli options for lunch time.

Medium Iced coffee (or just ice?) is 4.07 bewareTwo stars only because it was decent coffee

Just happen to place this store and stopped in for a bagel and butter and a small coffee. $5.96????. Are you kidding??? The bagel was good but common now. I been to plenty of other places where they have specials with large coffees for much less.

It may look like your average bagel joint, but Bagels On The Main is anything but!I wandered in with family on a beautiful beach day and was immediately greeted by the friendly staff and the incredible aroma of fresh grub. The shop was filling up quickly, and despite the volume of orders, we were able to snag some delicious bagels for the beach in no time!We ordered Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon and an everything bagel with cream cheese along with some aesthetically pleasing half and half lemonade drinks. The bagels were crisp, flavorful, and made with love. Everything worked together beautifully; I was especially impressed by the packaging and care invested into each order. By the end of the meal we were planning our next visit. We found our new spot!P.S For all of the influencers out there. This is the perfect spot for affordable, delicious, and photo-worthy EVERYTHING!

They have a banana fosters cream cheese that is amazing and so much more to choose from

This place used to be good, when Nicki was running the place. Now with two or three people behind the counter, it takes 5 mins to get a bagel with cream cheese when the place is even moderately busy. More often than not the bagels are overdone. It’s a pity, the place used to be great, the egg sandwiches are still good, but order in a face or you’ll be waiting

Food is decent, though their Cold Brew is very good. However, they have consistently gotten my order wrong multiple times and busyness of the day. There are better delis nearby to get what you want.

Great service and one of the best Reubens Ive had on long island

A little pricey for sandwiches, but the are very tasty

Wow this guy David is the best. He treated me like a god. I walked in my order was handled by him one to one. He even threw a few sides on the house. Definitely coming back here everyday.

All good except for the line. The online order customers were getting quite nasty to the rest of us and it seemed no one knew how to handle it.

Fast service! Smelled like fresh hot bagels. Delish...

Very expensive. poor and lacking service.

Great authentic New York bagels!

Not opened at 5am all the time unreliable

Really good bagel store

They messed up pickup orders unprofessional stuff

The food is good, when your order is right. Seems like the counter people listen to half of your order and then just rush it out of the kitchen without checking. Theres also a counter person who likes to pull knives on customers in the parking lot after having to remake said wrong order. Its a shame, I ate here nearly every day.

Nice place

By far the best bagels I have ever had, as well as some of the freshest cream cheeses! Love living close to this place!

Wow fire spot, and great customer service.

Best bagels in Long Island, by far!!!

I dont know, Ive given this place so many tries, I want to like it, but the customer service is sub par and the bagels are only okay. Their other stuff is great (bakery items, drinks etc), but with so many other bagel places around, Im done giving this one shots

Have been going regularly since the new owner took over. Great bagels. Staff is super friendly especially Saison - aka Nicky. Fresh foods. Bagels are not doughy and have a nice crunch to the skin. Best neighborhood bagel shop in and around Huntington village.

Excellent bagels and speedy service. Mediocre coffee, but thats not why I go there.

My favorite deli in the area. Not the best Ive ever had, but still very good. Prices are reasonable, extensive menu. The staff is very nice and accommodating as well. Im not sure if the phone number works though?

This is the most incredible place for lunch. Its a hidden gem of a place to eat in Huntington. Much more than a bagel place the food here is incredibly delicious beyond what you could even imagine. And their prices are so reasonable. Youd pay a lot more at those other restaurants in town and the food is even better than many of them. Besides the food the staff is so friendly I cant wait to see them again. This place is like eating at home with friends without anyone doing the cooking:) I cant rave enough. You have to check this place out. You wont be sorry. I may be sorry because it will get even busier when I go there. Enjoy!

Nice Staff good location. Easy to see right off of Main Street in Huntington. Plenty of parking. Self serve coffee which always helps with moving the line faster. Small store but nice. We will definitely be going back.

Where do I start. The staff is great, food amazing. I stop there whenever I am in the area. Had a Jose Quesadilla. It had sausage, peppers, eggs, home fries and a few other things. It was the best breakfast sandwich I ever had. Be careful the pastries are to die for.

This place is always busy, but the service is fast. I usually get a toasted everything bagel scooped out with bacon, egg, cheese and spinach... its so good! Crispy bacon & generous spinach. I havent tried the lunch items yet. Also, the pastries are buy 3 get one free :)

Best bagel shop in town! Clean, large variety of bagels and pastries (behind glass or wrapped), great salads and sandwiches, great prices, AND a great staff! Highly recommend.

Great bagel store as well as sandwich shop. Always clean and helpful. Salads are homemade and always good. Great egg sandwich’s too.

Complete turn around for this location! What once was old and dreary now is new, energetic, and all around fantastic! Definitely my go to place in Huntington for bagels, sandwiches, pastries and the employees could not be more friendly and attentive. Thank you for saving this location and providing such great service!

Just went to try this place because it was on my normal route and wanted to give them a try. I was not disappointed great food great staff so many great treats amazing bagels and strong delicious coffee.

I went there for the first time today. I was pleasantly surprised. There was a largevariety of food there. All looked fresh and appetizing. I will go back!

The bagels we got were fresh from the oven good.

Great food. Fresh. Clean atmosphere. Friendly staff and great coffee

Excellent food service very fast nice and clean.

Unfortunately, after my last two visits, it is clear that this place takes their customers for granted. Today, when they were not too busy, and I was the first in line, I stood there for at least five minutes while the seven or so employees congregated behind the counter chit chatting, three walked by behind the counter and gave me eye contact without helping me. When I asked if someone could take my order, a male behind the counter said they are busy. So I left and will not return. Poor management.

Fresh bagels. Typical bagel breakfast options, done well. Friendly place, friendly people. A bit hectic during peak hours.

Fresh hot breakfast place. great bagels. great service.

I moved away from the island a while ago but whenever i come back to visit family i always make a pit stop here to grab a dozen bagels. They even have fun rainbow ones for kids.

Outstanding!

Good service. My bagel was good and the coffee was strong.

First time i ever came here and i had the best egg sandwich ever

This place is so good I had 3 bagels in 1 sitting

Best bagels in Huntington, try an Everything with Tuna Salad and Tomato.

Good bagels, but my egg sandwich was just ok (missed on some of the details)

Solid. Long lines on weekends but moves fast

Clean, quick service and decent quality bagels.

Great bagels, great service, great deli meats

Good food, slow service

Great Customer service !! Shout out to my girls Nikki, Lauren, Heather, Love Ya! ❤

They have good bagels, but they messed up my order. I asked for everything and they gave me plain.

Bagels were A+++

Great food & really nice staff!

Was hoping for a change, but this place is still slow, very slow, and overpriced. I would avoid.

Excellent. Friendly and very good food.

Best begels in town,mmmm good

Not open as postedNot @ 5amCompletely dark inside

So cheap and also upper class 5 stars.

The bagel was passable, but tough as leather.

Nothing special about this bagel or service. Very busy nonetheless.

Best bagel shop in the Huntington area

Great bagels!

Great bagels, polite staff

Best bagels in town

Very friendly staff, short wait times.

Overpriced $6 for a coffee and bagel is ridiculous

Great bagels

Excellent

Good bagels

Ok

Excellent