Unique flavors at this stall in the Garage Food Hall. I tried the Gorgonzola Candied Pecan based on other reviews - the gingersnap lemon curd wasnt there when I went otherwise that would have been my pick. The Gorgonzola ice cream had a deep and rich dairy flavor, while the candied pecans gave a touch of sweetness and spice - very decadent but not too sweet.I gave 4-stars because I couldnt get a cone that day. Im not entirely sure why but it was crossed off the board.Id go back again to try something else (hopefully they have cones) but wouldnt make it a regular stop because of the parking situation - I dont want to pay to park to just get an ice cream cone.

Definitely a must try place! Unusual flavours and very delicious. We tried Ginger lemon curd and Gorgonzola candied pecan, was just heavenly. I am already planning to grab some more later this week. Located inside Garage, a corner shop, definitely super crowded on weekends. They have around 8 flavours and of course cones, waffles reasonably priced. I wish they provide to-go boxes or lids for the icecream cups, will be much easier to just grab and go. Keep up the work team lick! 😁👍🏼Another visit, A pint of toffee wee mac, just delicious and couldn’t resist from buying gingersnap lemon curd again.👌🏼

Ice cream is mostly unusual flavors. Flavors include sweet corn, Old Fashioned. And, actually, the novelty flavors, to me, taste better than their versions of more standard flavors. Also significantly sweeter than most ice creams, with slightly below average creaminess.Again - in coming to the Garage food hall, prices are higher than youd expect elsewhere, parking will add significantly to your food bill, the cash register will attempt to strong-arm a tip (color me skeptical that it reaches the nonowner performing the task of scooping ice cream into a dish) and you can get ice cream thats as good or better within walking distance... These factors make this a tough sell for anyone but a hotel-occupying tourist.

Waiting for her to open upon her request. She then waited on a couple that walked up even though we were waiting. Rude! I will take my business where customer service is important! Update. The owners contacted me about this review. If you want people to contact you instead of leaving a review because of small business. Why dont you provide your information?

The vegan chocolate marshmallow was SO YUMMY. My dairy sensitive kid LOVED it. She’s normally picky with non dairy flavored milks, but she had nothing to complain about. My other child chose vanilla and it was the best vanilla we’ve had. Such yummy flavors with smooth textures.

Delicious awesome ice cream flavors!! I have been looking for an ice cream place with interesting flavors like I used to get at a place called Blank Slate in Ann Arbor. The owner was super nice and let us try everything. The lemon curd ginger snap was fantastic and the malted milk jam was awesome too. Will come back!

Always a wonderful choice. Very inviting aesthetic and workers. Some of my favorite ice cream Indiana has to offer. Unique flavors that aren’t over the top

Love the unique “gourmet” flavors. My favorite is the lemon curd gingersnap, it’s insanely good. They let you try the flavors and there’s so many unique ones to choose from!

I visited this ice cream spot not too long ago. I ordered a scoop of blueberry corn cookie (I think) flavored ice cream in a waffle cone. It was okay, but I wasnt too impressed with it. Also I feel like it wasnt worth the high price. Id rather save my money and get a dollar vanilla cone from McDonalds.

This is the place for expertly crafted unique flavors. I had a scoop of Cedar and Whiskey recently and it was well done...not overpowering in any way but a hint of both flavors. So so good👌. Ive had unique flavors at other places and they taste odd but not here.... They know how to blend unique flavors well!

I really like their gorgonzola candied pecan ice cream. It’s my favourite. I brought my mom for a treat for her birthday and the service was really bad. Unfortunately, it’s not the first time I’ve experienced that. It takes away from the experience. It makes me not want to go there again.

This place has some quirky flavors but they dont miss! If you want to try something new then check them out. The blue cheese ice cream was amazing! They do also have a couple more tame flavors if youre not adventurous.

The cedar whiskey was very, very good. The gorgonzola candied pecan was life changing! I would give them 10 stars if that was possible.

Ordered the strawberry cheesecake milkshake it was good but tasted more cheesecake than strawberry but I liked the consistency of the shake, wasnt a long wait great service

Some of the best ice cream Ive had in years, and my family ran Jiffy Treats in Bloomington. The gorgonzola ice cream and whiskey sour flavors were amaizing.

My favorite ice cream in Indiana! Im on a mission to try all their flavors. Three of my favorites are salted carmel sage, lemon curd gingersnap, and rosewater pistachio brittle. Trying their Fall seasonal flavors now!

This is the best ice cream on the planet. If you disagree, I will fight you.

Cherry amaretto... So delicious!!! Waffle cones made while you watch is something special, too!

Very good!!All natural, and not to sweet. It was refreshing and well balanced! Cant wait to go back

They have great ice cream! The location is a little odd. They make small batches right there in the shop. The more unique thing about their ice cream is that they make flavors others dont. Whos ever heard of shagbark hickory syrup and bacon flavored ice cream? They make it! They also have more ordinary flavors like ordinary ice cream makers. They must not sell much in the shop because they only have four flavors available at a time which you can get in a cone or cup only. Did I mention that their ice cream is really good? It is!

Lick ice cream has innovative flavors!

Great ice cream and price

Great flavor combinations, excellent ice cream!

It cost me $18 for two chocolate shakes that were good, but the size not so good.

Such great ice cream made with great organic ingredients. The quality of the cream used in the ice cream must be great because it is velvety and buttery in texture. Flavors are creative and intense. Almond horchata flavor tastes better than most horchata drinks you get in coffee shops. The coffee and chocolate was also crazy good. Friendly owner who was the most helpful. We were in town from KY visiting the museum and zoo and we were happy we took the time to find this ice cream gem.

Best vegan Ive cream Ive had!!! Sliced chocolate marshmallow for the win!!!

Lick has delicious ice cream and the most unique flavors I have seen. Its located inside the Circle City Industrial Compex, room C11 (enter by the CICC gear sign off Brookside.)

This place is a hidden gem! Absolutely the best ice cream I’ve ever had in my life. So far my favorite is a tie between rosewater pistachio brittle, which is a perfect blend of fresh & salty, and balsamic dark chocolate, which tastes like a tangy chocolate cheesecake. Every time I’ve been in, service has been personal, helpful, and friendly. The $18 flight of 4 half-pints is definitely the way to go - there are way too many unique and delicious flavors to narrow it down. One more reason to love the food scene in Indy.

Amazing homemade ice cream!

Hard to find but worth looking. There were 4 fun flavors in the case but they had pints and 1/2 pints of many flavors. My kids enjoyed kid sized scoops (which as a parent I appreciate a place that has a smaller size) of cranberry shortbread. They both gobbled it up even if it was a bit tart. I had the gingersnaps lemon curd which was fantastic and my kids ate half of (not cool!). My mother had the smores which was delicious! The ice cream itself isnt super creamy, but the flavor makes up for it. The price is reasonable for what you get. The owner was there and interacted with my kids (her 4 yo son stopped in for a short bit too) and she was very informative. Great experience!

Interesting flavor combinations.Lots of interesting choices, the workers are friendly and get the job done quick!

What a delight! Such unique flavors and a great service experience.I consideref it totally worth it and would recommend. I got blueberry corn cookie to eat there and brown butter cookie for later...

Great and interesting flavors.

Amazing ice cream! So many flavor options, including vegan! Such a nice atmosphere and friendly staff!

Best icecream in Indianapolis. Better than Brics, better than wyleipalooza.

This placed saved the day for us the day my son and I were standing outside our favorite frozen yogurt shop reading store has closed sign on front door. I found Lick Ice Cream by doing a search and boy am I glad that I did! It truly was the best ice cream Ive ever had. Well most definitely be going back. Thank you guys

They have some of the most unique flavors Ive ever seen. Their location is a bit difficult to get to, but its worth navigating the industrial complex.

Tough to find but they said theyre getting ready to move. Excellent ice cream with non-traditional flavors. Kids loved their Smores and Chocolate Cherry Amaretto while the wife and I enjoyed Cedar & Whiskey and their Gorgonzola Candied Pecan. Very welcoming and accommodating to the kids also!

This place has a lot of unique flavors Ive never seen before, like candied pecan gorgonzola, milk chocolate goat cheese, sweet corn, rosewater pistachio brittle, and berries and champagne. The sweet corn and the berries and champagne were awesome. I also enjoyed their regular flavors too, such as the coffee chocolate chip. Its hard to find since it only has a small sign thats visible from the street and once you enter the building, its located down a hallway. Its very affordable, so Ill definitely be back.

So yummy!!! The bacon brittle ice cream is the best flavor I’ve ever had!!! Support local always!!! :)

My new favorite sweet treat stop! You must try their homemade waffle cones.

A delicious hole-in-the-wall ice cream place. I had the Smores. The impression I got from the customer service i witnessed was that they care more about selling good ice cream than upcharging/making money!

A tiny place, within the CCIC building. Great hand crafted ice cream and a nice owner. My friend who was visiting really liked the Gorgonzola Candied Pecan flavor.

Try the cedar whiskey!

Not expecting to taste anything better til heaven.

I had a sample of their gingerbread lemon flavor and it was absolutely delicious! Hope to visit their shop in person this summer.

Amazing small batch ice cream. So glad we finally went - blueberry sweet corn cookie & gorgonzola pecan. The hardest choice - which one.

What a delicious sweet, chocolatey treat surprise ending for a First Friday Art outing for my son..next time Ill get my own cup!!

Awesome owners, unique fresh ingredients, definitely worth coming back!

The best ice cream in town. Shop local, people. You wont be disappointed. I always go for their 4 for $18 half-pint deal, because they have so many amazing flavors! For this batch, I went for the following ridiculously awesome and unique choices- Cedar and Whiskey, Rosewater Pistachio Brittle, Gingersnap Lemon Curd, and Strawberry Mint. Cmon, why would you go anywhere else?! Unless you need to do some sort of quick drive thru DQ type deal, this is the definitely the decision you should make for your Indy ice cream needs.

Great small batch ice cream. Hard to find location, but worth the hunt.

AWSOME I loved it IT was good no hairs in the ice cream

Hard to find not sure if it was worth the walk

Best ice cream in town

I love this place

Amazing Ice Cream!

Nice Lick Ice Cream

Amazing Ice Cream