Absolutely LOVED Wild West Pizza. It was the first restaurant recommended to us by our hotel, and although we dont normally go out for pizza, we decided to try it. We werent disappointed and even went back again before leaving town. Everything we ordered was delicious. We tried a few different pizzas, cheese bread, Mac and cheese, and wings.
Pizza was delicious!! Side salad was fresh. Visiting from another state. Looking for late night food we luckily stumbled across this place. Ordered to-go pizza over the phone. Staff was friendly, quoted us 30 min, only took 20. Couldnt be more pleased with the results, it was as good as pizza from my hometown. We ordered the Doc Holiday (veggie pizza) and added Pepperoni yum. Bar looked busy and fun on a Saturday night. Would have stayed but was just too tired from a busy day rafting, and some sight seeing in Yellowstone.
Amazing food, amazing service, ridiculously friendly, and a cool vibe. We went here three nights of our six night stay 😂😂. Its that good and that much fun. Pizza is a must, as is the Mac and cheese. Pictured is the bread sticks with pepperoni...so good! It does get crazy busy though, so be prepared for a wait if youre there on a weekend or at dinner time
After a day of driving and site seeing, my wife and I decided that we wanted a nice warm meal especially after being rained on. The pizza was great, we opted to eat in the bar area (on a Friday night!) And we had a blast! There was live music, the staff was quite friendly, give great advise and very attentive! Thank you for the wonderful experience and amazing food!
This is a pizza place plus a game parlor near the West Entrance of the Yellowstone National Park. The place is lit up and is pretty happening. We ordered the Chicken Parmesan Sandwich and the hot wings. The wings were really hot and tasty but the chicken sandwich was pretty ordinary. We ordered a no meat lasagne but it was loaded with meat and had to throw it away. The only good point is this place is open till 11 PM which works out in favor of those returning late from the park.
Cant say enough about how friendly the staff is here. The prices for pies are incredibly reasonable given that these things come fully fully loaded; highly recommend the 16 because youre always going to want more - or left overs for the next day. Beer is reasonably priced compared to some of the other places around Yellowstone, and quite a great selection too. In the evening, the saloon/bar portion turns into a club they say, as the chairs get removed but we didnt stay long enough to find out. Theres dining hall adjacent to the bar space thats very family friendly!
Yummy!!!! Took about 45 to be done but West Yellowstone was packed so thats actually pretty great timing. Hostess could use an attitude upgrade hence 4 of 5 stars. Rolled her eyes dead in my face cause I asked for parmesan to go with my TO GO food. Long haired brunetre who worked 10/9/21 at night if ya care to know btw. Other than that TY for giving us a great meal our first night hereAlso they say delivery BUT when you call they dont deliver until 5
Pretty awesome pizza place with hot sandwiches, salads, and world renowned Mac and cheese as well. Their garlic bread was super tasty and their Mac and cheese is glorious.Their pizzas are really good as well and they have some super interesting specials as well. They serve beer from one of the local breweries that is also top notch.There are a lot of neat pictures and artifacts on the wall giving it a very western feel. Definitely worth a visit with the family. If you are Sana kids there is also a bar side that caters to adults only.
If Quick service and delicious Pizza is what you are craving, then wild west is the place. The 8” pizza was perfect for one person and the cheesy breadsticks were great. The spaghetti could have been better. I will definitely recommend this place in west Yellowstone as it was perfect for families, friends or couples.
Ordered to deliver to our hotel. Looked at all the reviews and I was really excited for the service and food. Food came to the door was still hot and the delivery girl was really friendly. Opened the food and tasted the food, it was like others reviews said. Chicken wings are the best and spicy. Will come back here for dinner and try out pizzas tomorrow 😋.
Great food, would have given 5 stars if not for the rude server in the bar (6/8 dinner). Yummy Mac and cheese, we added bacon and chicken. Delish pizza - crispy crust, yummy toppings- we ordered the Calamity Jane and one with Canadian bacon and pineapple (known as a Hawaiian where we come from). Mountain Margarita with huckleberry was good.The service - woman server in the turquoise shirt, with tattoos and a pierced nose - RUDE. We are always friendly and try to be non-demanding. When I asked how the Mountain Margarita was, she rolled her eyes and said great, in a snippy tone. When we ordered a Hawaiian pizza, she slapped her note pad down on the table with a big exasperated huff, rolled her eyes yet again and snapped at us that she didnt know what that was. She continued to interact with us in a nasty tone for no reason, my husband was looking at me like what the heck. No idea what we did to set her off, but we almost left at that point. She seemed to not like us from the moment we walked in. The other two women servers were very nice, one with dark hair and a baseball hat, the other tall with glasses. We didnt see the other one again. Thank goodness.Even though it was packed, it didnt take that long to get our food. Sit in the bar if you dont have kids, there wasnt a line.
Their pizza, and drinks are amazing. I ordered the huck mule and sitting bill pizza it was delicious.Wonderful customer service and they are open later than other places in town. Highly recommend it!
Came here twice in our week stay at Yellowstone because it was so good. Food was far better than average pizza-bar settings. The service on the bar side was awesome! Everyone was working together to run food and drinks. Super friendly a cool staff, even though they were unbelievably busy.We didnt sit on the dining room side but I imagine it was just as pleasant.
The main reason I dont mind driving nearly 6 hours from Mountain Home to West Yellowstone is because of this restaurant. Ive yet to find another around here that can compete with their calzones, wings, and (world renowned) baked mac n cheese!! The bar is large with separated dining room. The walls are riddled with pictures of locals and regulars that makes this place feel like it will cater to all. Typically short staffed but the food always comes out hot and delicious!
The Diablo wings were unique in a good way. The seasoning is a dry rub that gets baked onto it and the wings are cooked just right to where theyre tender. Worth trying if youre in the area.Cheesy bread was pretty much what youd expect from a local pizza parlor.The pizza was okay. We ordered half a pepperoni pizza which was very greasy but otherwise pretty good. Unfortunately the other half of the pizza we ordered the Calamity Jane. It wasnt terrible but it also wasnt good enough to finish.The place was very busy when we arrived but we were seated almost immediately. Its a decent option if youre in the area but outside the wings its a pretty ordinary local pizza place.
I typically never leave bad reviews, but we just had the absolute worst experience here. The only star was for the food which was good. The waitress did not take our drink order and just brought us water. She acted like she was upset that we even came in. She was expressly unprofessional and dressed like it too. The calzone we got had huge chunks or handfuls of spinach and when we told her this she said she could give us the 10% off discount after she argued that it was our fault because we ordered feta and Gouda cheese in it and was very rude about it. The rest of the food was really good, but I would never go back there because of the terrible service we received. It was not even busy she just was a horrible server. We came on Nov 6 2021 at 2:30. She was the only server so I hope management can take care of this.
First, the hostess that seated us needs to work on her smile. Unfriendly, cold and more interested in playing on her phone than helping her co-workers. The waiter that took our order was friendly and trying his best to take care of everyone. Our taco pizza was delicious and loaded with toppings. I liked the crust.Those of you from out of town need to chill out and realize most people are working extra long hours, trying to please you. Leave your Im special attitude in the city. I saw a man lay into one of the employees because he wasnt immediately waited on for a take out order.We would order pizza here again.
We visited in mid October, so it was between seasons. The food was really good. We ordered 2 large pizza, which was way more (like we ate half) than we needed for 5 people. Our friends hit sandwiches. They gave us mixed reviews. One was really good. He didnt like the meatball sandwich though. She did really like the Moose Drool beer.The service was good enough, but certainly not very friendly or welcoming. Also felt that the pizza, while good, was really expensive.
The high point reviews didnt disappoint in the least. The atmosphere was fitting for the Wild West. The mens restroom was represented with a pistol. And the womens was with a holster. Some adult humor here that I found cute. The pizzas we ordered were just amazing in flavor and texture. Kudos to the chefs. Service was very friendly and everyone seem to be enjoying their time spent.
Service was amazing!! 🙌🏻 Which is hard to find anymore...in my opinion. And the food was delicious! We had several servers making sure we had everything we needed. (But not hovering 😁) I definitely recommend this place!
I really feel that I couldnt give them a 5 star. The waiter lost or order and we waited quite a long time. The pizza (the Cecilian) was delicious. The other food items looked really good. Family friendly and the pizza is quick if your order gets put in.
Best pizza I have ever had! Will definitely visit again in the future. Wait times for tables are pretty long but well worth the wait!
AMAZING pizza! We stopped in here after a long day in Yellowstone. About a 30 minute wait for two and we were able to walk around West Yellowstone while we waited for our table (they text when your table is ready and you are able to see where youre party is at in the waiting queue from the link they send you - I love when restaurants do this!) We ordered the Geronimo and it was worth the wait! Definitely recommend stopping here!
The crust was more of a pan style, not thin. It was perfect for me. It was very very good. The gluten free crust was the best though. Usually like a cracker and bland, this place has a great gluten free recipe for pizza crust!
This is, without a doubt, the best pizza I have ever had! It is definitely homemade with pride.Our wait time was about an hour and a half, but it is well worth the wait and the price.Dont go here if youre looking for a health food joint!
The food is really good. The service could be friendlier. We would come back for the pizza.
Great calzone with lots of cheese and they Italian sausage sandwich was amazing. Kids spaghetti was great for kids.
Delicious pizza! Tons of ingredients, great tasting crust. We compared photos of the other pizza places and Wild West pizza looked the best and it was the best. $2 Rainer Beers. What else can you ask for. Service was alright. Waiter took forever to take our order, check on us and bring the check. All the while there were 3-4 other employees milling around wiping tables that could have checked in for our waiter, removed our plates or asked if we needed anything.If the pizza wasn’t 5 star I would give Wild West 2 stars. Also it’s not the cheapest pizza you’ll ever find.
This is a great place to eat some warm food and drink a few beers after a day spent in yellowstone. Also the staff was really cool.
Beer and Service is great. Pizza is really good with tons of options. The town is a bit on the silly side and full of park goers who couldnt find a better place to stay. If you get caught in this place I highly recommend this pizza. Beer, pizza and good service with a little casino inside. Great way to end a long day in the park.
Our group thoroughly enjoying our dining experience. We dined at lunch time, and the restaurant was packed. We received great service. The food was excellent and we were stuffed by the time we left. I highly recommend visiting them if youre in the Yellowstone area.
Im not really a pizza person, but their pizzas are terrific. I had a slice of the sour kraut one that a buddy of mine ordered and it was fantastic. Kraut?! Whodathunk? The service was good...even during the reality of folks not wanting to work in the service industry any longer, theyve seemed to have found enough staff to manage the Yellowstone crowds. It has a Montana bar vibe which is what we needed for our last night in West Yellowstone.
Nice place... stopped in for drinks after dinner...... friendly atmosphere.... friendly people...... decent prices on the drinks...... would definitely come here again.
Pizza is great!!!! I eat pizza all over the US and really enjoyed this place. plus I placed an online order and the driver was on time and very courteous!!! pizza is loaded with toppings and cooked to perfection!!! really a must stop! a++++ keep it up
The service was very minimal. We each got the chicken parmesan and it was swimming in a pool of liquid along with very dry chicken. The sauce was barely seasoned. Its like they attempted to season it with spice but it was horrible. The best part was the garlic bread and even that wasnt that good. It looks good in the picture though.
If you are looking to sink your teeth into a delicious pizza, with a variety of western themed pies to pick from, then this location will not disappoint you!Follow that with a selection of beverages, including your choice of beers to help clear your palate and satisfy your belly. Yummy!
Friendly service, and good food. We got the Butch Cassidy pizza (12) and it was perfect for two people. Ive never had baked beans on a pizza, but it definitely worked here. It was very good! Besides a bunch of pizzas (including a build your own option), they also have some Italian style dishes (spaghetti, chicken Parm, lasagna), wings, and several different hot sandwiches. The other person we were with got the Branded Cowboy and they said they really enjoyed it. (They also had great beers on tap.)They offer Take Out & Delivery (even better) so after a long day at the park, you can call in your order and have it ready by the time youre back at your lodging.
Great food, pizza is awesome. Drinks great. Fun atmosphere.
Great pizza options, we got the Calamity Jane which was just outstanding, and a larger build your own. Taking leftovers home. Just right after a day of adventures in yellstone.I highly recommend this place also has a bar side if youre wanting to get a drink and shoot some pool.Family friendly restaurant.
Been there many times over the past 15 years. Always the best pizza around. My favorite is the Blazing Saddle pizza with no mushrooms! Amy says her taco pizza is the best shes ever had too.
Really good Pizza! If you have kids, and want dinner during peak season, expect to wait over an hour, even if you want take out. If you are fortunate and don’t have kids, you can sit in the bar area right away! O and it is a Steelers BAR! As a western PA boy, absolutely loved it.
The waiter/hostess/ do everything guy was awesome. The food was great, way better another local restaurant in this area. I would highly recommend. We had chicken parmesan, the sitting bull pizza and a pepperoni and salami pizza... all were amazing!
The negative: Being seated the hosted just tossed the menus on the table and kept walking. Did even turn back to say anything. My wife and I were like, uhhhh, I guess this is where were sitting....The positive: The pizza was really good. The bottom was cooked and the cheese was good and stretchy. This is one of the better places of West Yellowstone.
Didn’t try any food but came here for drinks a couple times. They have good pitcher specials on draft beer and the service was good. Nice stop after a long day in the park.
30 minute wait time but from there it was great. The pizza fresh made and fantastic. The Waiter was awesome and did a great job. The place was slammed but they got it done.
Really nice service here, that was the first thing that impressed me coming into this dark, cool and welcoming pizzeria and bar. Prices were reasonable, beer was great. Unfortunately, the pasta that came with the chicken parmasean was way overcooked. And the salad was pretty average. The pizza was quite good. We enjoyed it, and would order it again. So, I would go back, but stick to pizza and drinks. Maybe the appetizers are better? And, as I said, the service was first rate!
We are visiting Yellowstone and absolutely loved Wild West Pizza in West Yellowstone. Besides having great pizza at a REASONABLE price, they are very family orientated. A young man named Chris was seating customers, bringing them water as they sat down and bussing dishes. I thought this was a remarkable young man to be so willing to gain experience and develop work ethics. I think more young people should take his example.
Delicious pizza.Long wait times, but its a popular place.Appetizer came out after the pizza.Beers were slow to come as well.Id probably get your pizza to go here.
Its OK, but prepare to wait on your drink if you arent a local... ...
Fun enjoyable times at this pizzeria in West Yellowstone! Friendly cheerful service with a smile. The kitchen was slightly backed up during the busiest moments of dinner service, and there was a significant wait time between the pizzas and lasagna dishes. Oh well. All the food was nicely prepared, and was delicious all in all! Yummy!!!
Very good place too eat employees Very friendly
Place was very busy when we entered...when 14 of us entered. There was exactly one server available for a room that held about 50. Service was, naturally enough, slow but our server kept us informed on where we were at in the process at all times. The food was good, almost as good as the service.
Bartenders and waiters/waitresses are awesome. Thank you guys.
The place was packed and the service team - including the amazing bartender who had started 2 hours before we arrived - were outstanding. If your entire party ow over 21 you can sit on the saloon side and it’s first come first served. We sat down and immediately got water, beers and menus. Pizza and drinks were on point. Great West Yellowstone find.
I was honestly shocked to see so many 5 star reviews. The pizza I got did not live up to the hype, although I am used to east coast pizza. Chicken parm was basic and came with a bag of chips, which seemed kind of weird. The staff were great though.
Amazing garlic bread and pizza. The staff was also AWESOME, quick-never had a empty drink!! Huckleberry press was a great drink!! Definitely be back!
This is some of the best pizza Ive ever had. Service is prompt and the servers are friendly, and you cant beat the quality of food. Mac & Cheese with bacon is unreal, calzones are HUGE. We always stop here no matter what when we come to Yellowstone.
*Taken during Pandemic* after a long drive from the Grand Teton mountains my wife and I were very hungry and pizza felt right. The atmosphere was just like it would feel anywhere else trying to deal with the pandemic but our waitress was giving positive vibes. Once were got our food, the Geronimo pizza, and the Lasagna, everything just hit the spot. Come here if pizza and beer is what you are yearning for. 🙌😊
We placed an online order at this place two times during our stay at Yellowstone. Food was above average. In terms of customer service, they are so poor. I felt they don’t know what does customer experience and satisfaction mean. It was so ridiculous that they just have one line for everything and I had to wait 45 minutes to pick up my food even though its an online order and I received the order completion message. Management doesnt seem to know the definition of business.
Good pizza, great service! Our waiter James was super nice and friendly😊Wait can be a bit long but is definitely worth it. Nice atmosphere, definitely recommend.
Absolutely fantastic thinner-crust pizza. Pepperoni personal 8” was perfect, pepperoni curled up the edges and was nicely crisped. The pizza overall had a great crunch but not too hard as to hurt your gums. My mom got something odd with feta and pineapple, not for me, but she said it’s the best pizza she’s had in YEARS. The order of bread sticks was a rectangularly-cut 8” pizza base with cheese. The dipping sauce was the same pizza sauce as on the pizzas with (maybe) extra red pepper powder mixed in. Worth a try.
The bartenders were amazing as well as the food. We planned on having one drink and dinner then moving on but stayed for a few before we headed out for the night. Highly recommend
Used to be good. Disappointed in the gluten-free crust. Burnt to a scrip and topping were dried and barely there. Not going back.
Delicious Pizza - crust and toppings excellent. Plenty of gooey delicious cheese. Wonderful beer selection. Great staff
A bit pricey for the portions and service is pretty laid back. But overall pretty tasty.
If I could give zero stars I would. Our waiter was drunk and several times was aggressively begging me to leave a tip. When he had to ID me, he asked for it three times before confirming I was of age to drink. But service aside, the food was terrible. The noodles were overdone and tasted soapy and the chicken parmesan was freezer burnt. Two people in my group had to throw up after leaving the restaurant. I would seriously avoid this place. Ive never had this kind of dining experience in my life.
We loved our dinner here! The hostess helped us find a bar table to avoid a pretty long wait. Our bartenders were so friendly and helpful. The pizza was definitely tasty. Overall a really great experience!
Passed through while camping, amazing food and large selection.Staff was busy, but they still gave us plenty of attention, would order pizza for pickup, but theyre a few states away.If youre hungry, eat here and youll get good portioning and flavor.
Friendly waitress, but too few servers. Every customer who’d been seated was looking around impatiently for someone to take their order or bring the check; every prospective customer was waiting at the host stand unaware that there was no host! And the food was so-so. They need to up their game. Friendliness of waitress is why it’s two stars instead of one.
Pizza was great. Mac & Cheese with bacon, chicken and spinach was the best ever! Will definitely come here again!
This dive and is easily within a 15 minute walk from just about any hotel in West Yellowstone. If you want to sit in the dining room there will be a wait. However, the bar area is always open to anyone over 21.For drinks they serve a lot of local craft beer (try the Old Faithful Ale or Grinder). Also the Pizza is pretty fantastic!
Friendly family atmosphere! Excellent food and service! Dine in, take out, or have it delivered! I love the Mac and cheese!
Coming to WY a few times each year, we were excited to have yummy Wild West Pizza, its been a family fun favorite. This time after ordering & waiting, we noticed groups that came after us, including a large party with about 5 pizzas, had their food already. I had to go find our waiter. We were told ours was coming and they do a rotation. What kind of rotation is that? After almost an hour, I took a drink of water & it was the last straw. I tasted a weird taste on the lip of the glass. At first, I thought it was soda, but it was some other horrible taste. 1st time weve ever walked out of a restaurant!
Very friendly, efficient servers. Excellent pizza with awesome crust. I highly recommend this place!
We ordered delivery two nights in a row. We choose make your own pizza and we had pizza margarita with extra cheese. It was great. We had the leftovers next day for lunch since is the park is very hard to get food because of the long lines.
Taste like an East Coat pizza sauce is good