Pick Your Pie nailed it! I actually purchased their Pumpkin Cheesecake in Fairview Hospitals cafeteria. I love that its perfectly portioned and has no additives. This cheesecake was smooth, rich without being cloying and balanced with spice. The whipped cream was light and the graham cracker crumbs were buttery and crisp. Well done PYP!

Such a new, creative take on pie! Honestly could sit here all day and eat these delicious treats. I cant just recommend one item because theyre all phenomenal

Extremely disappointing!!!If you are looking for a slice of a yummy traditional pie this is NOT the place to go to!!!! What you get its more like a portion of pudding in a cup with graham crackers, if I wanted to eat that I could easily mix that at home 😳I think their web page should have more accurate information about this place to save someone a trip and money!!!

Wow! Bought four different types of Pies in a cup. They all taste delicious and pies have different graham cracker depending on flavor. My favorite was chocolate cream and coconut pie was divine.

Ive used Pick Your Pie for several parties, and I take 5 or 6 dozen pie flights into work every year for Christmas. The pies are delicious, and really easy to transport, which makes my life easier.

Delicious pies, great service and what a concept!We are considering a pie bar at our wedding, and now that weve had a taste, Im convinced!#coconutcream

Amazing place! Service was amazing! The workers were super friendly! I love this place!

You can create your own pie and it tastes amazing. Several types of fillings and crusts along with a plethora of toppings make this store a must in the Cleveland scene!!!

Great service and so polite I suggest that you go and check them out all homemade fillings and toppings including the whip cream

Their concept is great, but the stuff is a little rich. Thats okay - just get less of it.

This was my first time at this place and i had high hopes. I ordered a pie here and was told it would take 10 minutes to make at 5pm. It took 35 minutes for me to get my pie and it wasnt because it took long to make its because the workers were on their phones the one guy was on facetime and the other siting down behind the register and when they werent doing that they were sitting around cracking jokes and talking instead of helping us. They were increadbly rude to us and I even overheard them making fun of a different customer whom had just left.

Actually found these guys via Dave Ramseys radio. Sounds like a great idea!

Its not even pie. What a waste of time and money, its literally a cup of pudding mixed with cookie crumbs. You could make this stuff at home, very bad place dont recommend this place to anyone. And if I could I would put no stars but you at least have to put one star in your review.

Literally just a wad of cream cheese and graham cracker dust. Not pie. Yuck