I have been loving Spread Cheese Co. for almost two years now ! You really cannot find a better selection of cheeses around and the store also sells all of the accompaniments and cheese board swag you could need. Once you visit Spread you will never be able to buy grocery store cheeses again.I have purchased platters, baskets, cheese by the pound, and recently I went to The Beginners Guide to Cheese class which seriously exceeded my expectations ! The amount of cheese you got to sample was impressive and you could tell that Lily, the class instructor, is a cheese expert ! So fun !Shout out to Jamie, Lindsey, Alayna, Brenden and Lily for always being so helpful !Bring your friends :)

I LOVE this place. They have such an amazing variety of incredible cheeses. Everyone that works there is really friendly and knowledgeable. You can tell they love cheese. Its a really great place.

An amazing selection of a wide variety of cheeses! The people working were very kind and so helpful, offering suggestions and helping me find what I wanted.Great place and very reasonably priced! A wide selection of local cheeses, which I really appreciated. The option to not get a paper receipt was also great. Sustainable practices with emphasis on local products, great and friendly staff, reasonably priced, and great cheeses between selection and quality.Overall, Id absolutely come here again!

I stopped in for the first time this week, and Im happy to report that I will be returning. The guy who worked there was very helpful in recommending cheeses to try, and they were delicious. Its a cute shop with various gourmet food products; I also bought some crackers and shortbread cookies, which were excellent.

Have been a couple times and just ordered a platter for Mother’s Day. We were impressed with the quality and selection, DELICIOUS. Worth every penny.

A wonderful addition to downtown Middletown, friendly people who like cheese as much as I do, and I like cheese a lot!

Great selection of cheese, meats, crackers and pickled vegetables. Owner is extremely knowledgeable on cheese and helps you make recommendations, while tasting samples. Very reasonable prices. Youve made regulars out of us!

Nice small store. The lady was helpful and kind. I will return if the snacks I purchased are delicious.

We love speead. Use their products to curate a delicious pairing with our own.

Went to Spread Cheese last week for the first time. Amazing staff and selection of cheese. The store is beautiful and feels like a country escape in the heart of Middletown. The staff has taken every precaution during these times to keep the store clean and safe and it was noticeable and appreciated. Although I was not able to taste anything right now Brendan did an amazing job at describing a few different selections I may like- and I DID!!!!!

Just recently purchased a charcuterie platter from Spread Cheese Company. I asked them to put it together for me and the results were phenomenal! The variety of cheeses, meats, crackers, olives, etc were so well combined. Everyone at my gathering all asked where we got the platter. I was very happy to recommend Spread Cheese and will continue to do so!

Adorable shop. Very interesting finds for kitchen gifts and entertaining. Love the assorted cheeses. Staff was extremely helpful! Good pricing too considering cheese and charcuterie can be very expensive. Cant wait to go back!

Amazing cheese shop with a great selection and helpful staff

This place is amazing!! They have a HUGE selection of different cheeses. Every cheese that I have tried so far has been excellent. Their staff is VERY knowledgeable and can answer any of your cheese related questions! They also have great variety of snacks that you can purchase in store (I.e.- nuts, crackers, jams, jerky- just to name a few). I highly recommend that if you are ever in Middletown that you stop by Spread!!

As a proud Dad could not be more pleased with how beautifully decorated and well stocked my daughters cheese shop is. Great selection of artisan cheeses, sausages, and related accoutrements. Destined to be very successful.

Awesome! Very knowledge about their offerings!

Excellent selection of cheese! Talked to one of the owners, Lindsey, very sweet and knowledgeable- told me that her and her sister went into this venture together. Best of luck- just what Middletown needed!

Got delicious cheese and they helped me pick what I wanted by tasting the variety. Very helpful and a great local business.

Had a beautifully made charcuterie board for my 22nd birthday! Delicious meats, cheeses, and pickles. Thank you!

Awesome selection of cheeses, gift baskets and other items for cheese platters. Very welcoming, well educated team.

Went opening day and loved it. Prices are decent and the staff is polite and helpful.