I ordered a pepperoni pizza, mozzarella sticks and Cole slaw. The cole slaw was very nice, creamy and tangy, with nice flavor. The mozzarella sticks were lighter than typical and that was nice. The pizza crust was droopy but still managed to have some crispness to it. It was also nice and light. The pizza had decent flavor overall. On a scale from 0-10 I would rate this 7.7.

Great food! We got a large Italian and a small BLT.The large was definitely large. Too much to finish 😩😍 but it was definitely great food!! You definitely get your moneys worth.I personally did wish It was a bit cooler in there, but otherwise a great experience!

Pizza looks good. Lots of options!

One of our local favorites for quality pizza and pasta at a reasonable price!

Great spot even better employees. Food was amazing, pizza thin and crispy and ready in a couple minutes. My new go to for slices

Service not fas.t food is good. Clean place.Friendly

Last night we Decided to order from here, because we Got a great discount with Uber eats. After we placed our online order I immediately called The restaurant because we needed to correct a wrong order. Guy was nice on the phone, said he would take care of it ( wanted fried chicken instead of grilled) Order came on-time, nice delivery driver too. Unfortunately we got grilled chicken and the rest of the food was just okay. This was our first experience withAmerican Pie. We won’t rush back anytime soon

Pizza was tasty not greasy and crust was very good. Would recommend

Always courteous and willing to correct any issue! The food is consistently delicious and the portions are plentiful! The gluten free crust is a great option to have!

When it first opened I wasnt a total fan, but after trying it again, I really have to say that the pizza is very good. Good service..

Great pizza. Very fresh ingredients. Delicious!!

So good.Crust. Sauce. Wings. On point.Best pizza that Ive had in the area and some of the best Ive had in the state. Wings so crispy.Why did I have to discover right before I started dieting 😂

This place is good. Better than pizza chef. Better than scales

Best pizza I’ve ever had in this town, I stopped at cvs and saw the signs across the street and went over and has a slice of their veggie pizza. It was delicious and loaded with toppings and afterwards I noticed their expansive ice cream menu I had their salted caramel truffle and their ice cream was amazing also! Highly recommend.

Yall need a menu online. If that is put up then I would give 5 stars

I was shocked to see some negative reviews. Ive been here many times. So far nothing but good food and service. Excellent hand breaded chicken tenders. By far the best pizza in town (if you know anything about pizza). Tons of options on the menu. This is good food for a very fair price. The medium pizza is $7.50! My daughter and I are both stuffed and there is still a piece left. Cost me $10 for that pizza and a big ice cream from my daughter! I strongly recommend giving this place to try if you are in the area. Quality food with a fair price!

Is the best place in Massachusetts I drive every day all over Massachusetts and try different places for food but this place is the best and the owner exelent some times I drive all the way from Providence just for there Chicken wings and pizza and my family always ask me if I go near there to bring wings for them

This was first time eating here and it was very good and good portions too. Haddock dinner,meatball sub,and chicken broccoli ziti! Also they got icecream parlor with grapenut flavor!!! Sooo excited !!! We will be back definitely!!

My whole family absolutely loved this place. Pizza was fabulous and the salad I got was so good. Usually grilled chicken at the other places around town can be very dry but this chicken was flavorful, seasoned, and tender. Boyfriend said his burger was better than five guys!

Excellent food and service! My favorite place to go! I order here regularly and always had an amazing experience. 👍

Decided to try the new pizza place is town. I dont leave one star reviews often but this one stood out for me. Sorry to say if your gonna try to compete with A&D and Pizza chef you gotta bring your A game and this place was a flop. A very greasy flop. Because thats what my $20 pizza was. Ive never had pizza so greasy and underdone. Also when ordering for takeout the staff didnt give me a wait time or price and hung up on me. If your gonna open a pizza place train your staff and make good food or your not going to make it.

Good food nice decor excellent service and Ice cream

First time, been driving by while working, soo I wanted to try them out.. I was the only one there at the time, knew what I wanted, so the service was quick n friendly. Ordered a large hamburg, mushroom n onion, pizza. Crust was on the thin side, not enough sauce, couldve added more hamburg. The taste was good n hit the spot.. Price was moderate.. Would give it a 3.5 star, overall..

Got a case of diarrhea after eating there, possible food poisoning. They had to give me a replacement of chicken versus veal after waiting over a 1/2 hour for a ziti w/veal dinner,the chicken tasted recooked and had a couple of hard chunks of batter mixed in the meal. I chose not to go back there, rather than complain to eatery and possibly get the same poor meal free.

Ive lived in Mass for 7 years, originally from NY. Its hard to find authentic NY style pizza here. If you like the pizza from A&D and Pizza Chef, then American Pie isnt for you. However, if you love actual, good, NY style pizza, then American Pie is the closest Ive found around! Ive only ordered pizza so I cant comment on any other menu items, but the pizza has always been great!

I was super duper hungry and I couldnt believe how delicious yeah pies and a spaghetti clean courteous people to clean place wonderful experience

This review is simply for, who I thought is, the owner. You know when you walk into a place and you just need to pee cause every restaurant/gas station won’t let you? Well, I walked in and said “I’m sorry, I just really need to use the bathroom. Would you mind?” His immediate reaction was “No need to be sorry, it’s right over there.” JUST FOR THAT HUMBLE, POLITE, AND WONDERFUL MAN - I GIVE YOU 5 STARS! Thank you cause I would’ve peed my pants. I don’t live near the area, but I will be back to try your food, and even if it isn’t up my alley, your stars will remain because you are a kind human being. THANK YOU! ♥️

Very clean very nice place as well as a nice place to grab a bite to eat, employees are very respectful except for the cook I heard today yelling at the server cuz he did not listen to the order and got it wrong but the rest of the staff are courteous food was good until today when they decided to put my roast beef in the microwave you never put meat or anything really in that thing I dont like it and will always know! Dont know if I will return do to the fact that I wasted my money cuz I just got ride of the sandwich

Great good! Friendly staff.

Tried for the first time tonight and we absolutely have a new go-to pizza place in town! The staff are incredibly friendly, even though I was the jerk who ordered near closing time. The pizza was delicious- thin crust, but sturdy, not a greasy mess by any means! Can’t wait to try more menu items!

I got the turkey and bacon sub excellent

I will give three stars because I understand that this location just recently opened so I will give them the benefit of the doubt.The food is decent. Portions are extremely small. Ordered the zesty lime shrimp and avocado salad, $12 and some change for it and it looks like a side salad. Also ordered the firecracker chicken wrap, it is drenched with hot sauce.The chicken, bacon, ranch white pizza is bomb.com though. I’d recommend that.

I’m almost positive that the negative reviews on here are from competitors and those related to competitors, because my husband and I tried this place tonight and DANG! By FAR the best pizza in town. Pizza is big and delicious and not super greasy like other reviews stated. Hot, fully cooked and AMAZING. I can’t even describe the taste, idk if it’s the sauce or what but it’s like taking a bite out of nostalgia. It’s so good! My only gripe would be I wish the onion rings were shoe string - but the thicker ones are just as good! I also appreciate the side of Alfredo dipping sauce - you guys are great - we will DEFINITELY be back again. I hope everyone tries this joint, you won’t be disappointed!

The pizza here is great! New York Style crust, this is not greek style at all, which is why there are bad reviews. Ive also had some of the sandwiches, and they are superb, extremely flavorful.The service could use work, but it is very obvious that is because they have only been open for 2 weeks. The staff are extremely friendly, but they do not have great systems in place yet. All the service problems will be solved once they have had a chance to iron out their procedures.

Chicken/bacon/ ranch wrap was very good!

Best Pizzaits so hard to find pizza this good . Been 3 times in 3 weeks, will continue. Staff was helpful and friendly.

Great tasting pizza. Very nice owner and staff.

Best pizza ever!!! There pepperoni pizza is amazing!! Highly recommend

Really like the food best pie in town wings are the best

Every time we order, SOMETHING is always wrong. Either they deliver the wrong food, or simply mess the entire order up. Not to mention being on the phone for almost 10 minutes just telling someone we want 2 items. We have definitely gone elsewhere for pizza and food

This is the only pizza I like in Millbury. Pizza Chef and A and D can’t compare. The other food I got to was amazing too. Buffalo wings and mozzarella. Pretty cheap to.

This home made lasagna is TASTY AF! Always satisfied with the friendly service and delicious food! My new go-to pizza spot in Millbury for sure.

I loved the thin crust. It was not greasy at all and loaded with vegetables. The pizza was much better than most pizza take out in this location.

Great pizza, great people and good prices. Best pizza in Millbury!

Had great experience here. Food was ready when promised. Team at front very friendly Pizza was Delicious!

Best pizza around! Staff is always super friendly and courteous.

A newer pizza shop. The interior theme is route 66/ classic Americana. Come grab a slice and check it out!

Definitely some of the best Pizza in Millbury. It’s nice to have Italian pizza and not whatever style a and d and pizza chef serve. Thank you American Pie!!

Some of the most fresh chicken I have every got from any pizza place every. It was in their teriyaki pilaf bowl, which also the teriyaki flavor was amazing tasting and fresh onions, peppers and mushrooms in it also. Will most definitely order there again, if not a few times a week.

Items missing and wrong and the food was horrendous. The chicken brocoli alfredo pasta was sent as a pizza and tasted like curdled milk. The chicken fingers and chicken wings were saturated with grease all the way threw and were obviously soggy not crispy. The spicy curly fries were the only thing we ate from a $80 order

Taste similar to NY pizza. Very good, crust is thin as well.Pizza Chef & A&D pizza can’t compare at all.

Living in Sutton, this is the best tasting option for pizza delivery that we have available to us and they travel pretty far for us.

Very clean and excellent

Pizza was burnt, crispy chicken tenders where soggy and mushy, onion rings soggy and a few the batter wasn’t even cooked my sons hotdog was so over cooked it looked like a thicker slim Jim. NEVER ordering from there again

Pizza was soggy. Called at 1030am for a noon delivery. Arrived after 1pm. Chicken wings were burnt and wet, cold, and soggy. Almost $40 for 2 medium pizzas and a small order of wings. We threw away EVERYTHING! It was inedible.

My first time here and I was happy. I will definitely come back again.

Real good place, much cheaper than the other places in town. I prefer thin crust pizza anyways but Id bring my buisness to a new place than the Chef or A&D thats been around for years.

Better than anything else around also doesnt take them 2 hours to deliver your food...corner/douglas/village..

Our first time ordering and the service and food were great. We loved the thin crust on the pizza and the jalapeño poppers were so good.

Food wasn’t that good. They messed up the order.

Pizza & calzones are very good, delivery can be slow at times

Ordered a pizza Friday night. The kid that took our order over the phone was clueless. People inside were confused and backed up. Worst pizza I have eaten ever. Boxed pizza from the grocery store tastes better. This place will not last long.

Fantastic pizza! Have tried all the pizza places in Millbury and this is by far my favorite. Also the owner is very kind!

Great pizza.

By far the best spot in millbury

Qas fantastic. Great pizza and prices

NEVER RECEIVED MY FOOD. Ordered 2 pizzas delivery, waited two hours before calling and the food wasn’t even made yet. They are clearly unorganized as she said she has “no idea what’s going on”. No apology or care they just canceled my order. Save your time and go to A&D or pizza chef.

Ok, pizza is unbelievable!!!

Ordered ftonight. Pizza was tasteless, very greasy and undercooked. Very disappointing.

Ordered Chicken Alfredo Pizza and got a terrible buffalo chicken pizza Hot sauce and a few pieces of chicken under tasteless cheese Cheeseburger sub missing requested ketchup and contained one small overcooked patty cut in half Fries, onion rings and mozzarella sticks generic frozen kind Gave them several chances to come through but always disappointed Will not repeat

I have to say I love the other pizza shops in town, but this is my new favorite place to get pizza. The pizza is HUGE, extremely tasty 😋 and is the cheapest place around. The people are also very friendly. There is also a pretty large selection of baked sweets and a good size menu.

Quick Service. Great subs including eggplant sub. They also have baklava like many Italian and/or Greek eateries in Massachusetts.