user
Gourmet Bake Shop Inc
775 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States
Appearance
Gourmet Bake Shop Inc
Comments
Mi
Review β„–1

I love this bakery. I will pick up blackout cakes from here when I need. Its always fresh, delicious, fudge, chocolatey filled. My favorite. You can never go wrong with anything here. All their cakes are awesome, as well as their pastries and cookies! So amazing. I highly recommend them. Also the prices are amazing here, epically for the quality. I am always a satisfied customer!! Oh yeah and I ordered a birthday cake for my God son. It came out awesome πŸ‘Œ

Ma
Review β„–2

As usual, doesnt disappoint. I have been ordering special occasion cakes here for 20 years, always to rave reviews from my guests. Highly recommend

ja
Review β„–3

Great bakery, huge selection of delights, all fresh, great young staff helpful and professional.πŸ‘β€

Ca
Review β„–4

Old school bakery. Quality pastries reasonably priced and best cheese danish and linzer tarts.

Pe
Review β„–5

Really good bakery with unbelievable low prices. The only downside is that it’s really bad for my diet. Highly recommend.

El
Review β„–6

The absolute best bakery I know. I’d sell my kidney to have their apple turnovers for life... too bad they always go out so fast! I also appreciate the small, home-like feeling to this bakery. It’s not like some crowded, over commercialized one. Service is also great, they are so kind.

Su
Review β„–7

Always love what I order. Fresh and delicious. Staff lovely, friendly and helpful. Parking easy and accessible.

Su
Review β„–8

Gourmet for sure! Best place for your baked necessities. Nice selection of cakes. :)

He
Review β„–9

A cute little bakery with great coffee and cakes! Must visit when in the area

Cr
Review β„–10

Fairly priced and always delicious. They constantly rotate new and seasonal treats to tempt you. Beware the credit card fee for purchases under $10.

Th
Review β„–11

Been going there for years.Bread and cakes are always fresh.Nice staff.Joe the owner is a very nice guy, too.

Da
Review β„–12

Cozy little place decent section of bake goods. I stop in for a treat all the time, price is good cakes are always tasty.

Ca
Review β„–13

Wonderful staff. Delicious cakes, cookies and pastries.πŸŽ‚πŸͺπŸ₯

Ru
Review β„–14

I usually go there for the apple turnovers, they are full of apples unlike some other places. Its a nice cozy place to go and meet up with friends. Theres a self serve station for coffee for a morning or mid morning break or afternoon.

Ma
Review β„–15

Great little neighborhood bakery. Highly recommended!!

Yv
Review β„–16

Very friendly staff. Fresh cakes and breads all the time. Large variety of baked goods.

Mi
Review β„–17

Its a great bakery which we have been patronizing for 25 years. We will miss their Easter Lamb cake. We hope you come back to us after this crisis. Thanks to and your staff for being so kind.

Be
Review β„–18

Best napoleon cake anywhere!

P
Review β„–19

Everything here is just like a grandmother would bake. Im impressed with the flavor of the pastries and the variety of baked goods. One thing I really love are the cheesecakes that are sold by the slice. The Italian cheesecake is one of my favorite. There is an apple ring that usually calls my name but it is sometimes hard to find because it is popular and gets scooped up pretty quickly. Everyone there is helpful so dont hesitate 2 ask questions!

An
Review β„–20

Good prices

He
Review β„–21

Excellent tasty pastries and average pricing for what you get ....best cheese cake ever..

Jo
Review β„–22

Great selection of cakes nice staff

Ra
Review β„–23

One of the neighborhoods hidden gems. Good prices and good baked goods. The staff is very knowledgeable.

Ba
Review β„–24

My father went in to buy a cake and a brought home a jelly doughnut for me.It was absolutely delicious. It was covered with sugar, soft, fresh and filled with raspberry jelly. Better then dunkin donuts. I Wouldve posted a picture but I gobbled it up.

To
Review β„–25

Bery Guood store

Ma
Review β„–26

Awesome bakery 🧁 shop. Quality and prices speak for themselves.

Na
Review β„–27

Bake shops staff is friendly and the store has multiple cakes for any occasion, regular and sugarless cookies and specials for every holidays. You can come in for a cup of coffee and some just baked pastry. Available samples can help you make up your mind and choose the right sweets. Excellent fresh baked seeded rye bread is always on my shopping list.

Je
Review β„–28

Cannollis made while you wait so always fresh. Bright. Clean. Helpful staff. Good coffee. Nice place to sit with a friend and shoot the breeze.

Ka
Review β„–29

I visited here to buy a birthday cake for my daughter, I liked they had classic cakes which were great for a young child with a simple palate. I went for the Oreo cookie cake, hoping it was amazing. It ended up dry, tough and cookies were stale. I won’t go back.

An
Review β„–30

This bakery has very reasonable pricing comparing to other nearby bakeries. I always get cakes made on order with the design I have in mind, and Joe always does it so perfect. Never had any issues with any of my cakes.

N.
Review β„–31

Bought cupcakes for my niece and nephew. I buy cupcakes for them from pretty much all of the local bakeries on a whim when I visit them a on my way home from work. These had to be the toughest cupcakes I’ve ever purchased. The red velvet one was okay. The regular chocolate and vanilla frosting were pretty horrendous. Will not be back considering the proximity to other places.

An
Review β„–32

I recently had a custom cake from this bakery and it was fabulous inside and out.

Ca
Review β„–33

My husband brings home this Mongol bread?? Probably misspelled it but its like..bread,cake biscotti? All in 1? Love it! Service is always nice.β™‘β™‘β™‘My hubbys barber is in same complex..thats how we found it years ago.

R
Review β„–34

Apple turn overs are the best

Ch
Review β„–35

Simple, unpretentious, affordable, excellent. What more can I say. Everything is fresh with that homemade taste and quality. I just love everything

cr
Review β„–36

Superb birthday cake for a little cutie

Cl
Review β„–37

I like that their bakery goods are not too sweet. Their cakes and danishes are amazing, but my favorite is always their pies & tarts! Fruit tarts, pumpkin pie, coconut pie are all phenomenal!!

S
Review β„–38

Love that place good prices and good quality

S
Review β„–39

This place is delicious and the staff is friendly and helpful. I will continue to go here when I need a cake for an occasion, or even just a cup of coffee. (Much better than nearby Buttercooky in Floral Park where I found a hair in my cake and was refused a refund!!)

D
Review β„–40

Put in order 5 days go for Thanksgiving and it was incomplete and they said what do you want us to do about it, talk about good customer service. I have 60 people over for the holiday and have half a order and scrambling thanks for nothing. If I could give 0 stars I would to the rude people you have working there.

An
Review β„–41

Love their cakes! Not to sweet or plain...Best of all they are not breaking the bank ;)

Ro
Review β„–42

Great cakes for a great price!

Ke
Review β„–43

Great little neighborhood bakery!!

Pa
Review β„–44

OK, but could use a little better selection of morning/breakfast items. I thought the selection of crumb cake and coffee cakes was a bit limited. Didnt see any donuts (???). How does a bakery NOT have freshly baked donuts for the morning crowds?

r
Review β„–45

Great neighborhood bakery. delicious baked goods, cakes, breads, cookies, desserts. great atmosphere

To
Review β„–46

The staff is rude and will ignore you if you aren’t a regular customer.

Al
Review β„–47

Amazing. Nothing else like it around. Great pastries, iced coffee, regular coffee.... And hands down best jelly donuts ever!

an
Review β„–48

Excellent bakery. Probably the best in the area

Co
Review β„–49

The pastries here are absolutely delicious. We go out of our way to get them there

M
Review β„–50

Good berry good bekery exselente fast food 😁

Ma
Review β„–51

Didnt feel welcomed here & the babka I bought was stale. That was the first and last time theyll get my business.

Sa
Review β„–52

Our favorite in the area. Better than Marthas bakery and Iavarrone Brothers. Delicious pastries, homemade taste, buttercream cakes, including special holidays like Rosh Hashanah. Great service. We are customers for 8 yrs.

Ma
Review β„–53

Great being at my cousins amazing bakery...so many Italian goodies 😊

Ro
Review β„–54

Been going there for years and they have the best cookies and cakes, and the bread Id outstanding.

Ba
Review β„–55

Fresh pastry and friendly staff. Jelly Donuts off the hook

Ma
Review β„–56

I always come here for cakes for all of my occasions. Their cakes taste the best!

Ky
Review β„–57

Great place for very affordable high quality cookies and pastries. I always stop by a few times when Im back in town.

St
Review β„–58

Best

ju
Review β„–59

First off, I used the Yelp $10 for $15 deal and the girl who helped me was really nice and helpful as I putzed around on my phone looking for the code I needed.As for the store, its clean and has a lot of reasonably priced delicious looking desserts.We seriously struggled to get to $15 as we ordered whoopie pies, cookies, a red velvet cupcake, a slice of rainbow cake.Most of these wonderful desserts are in the $2.00 to $2.50 range.There were many others I wanted to try. They had lobster tails, elephant ears, and Oreo cheesecake.Many of the cakes looked great and were very reasonably priced.As good as buttercooky bakery is down the road this place is much more affordable and almost as/equally delicious.The whoopie pie was not dry despite being really thick. It was really good. The rainbow sprinkled cookie which didnt get a picture, was melt in your mouth good. Everything here was moist, tasty, and made me want to come back again.Loved how friendly they were accepting the Yelp deal. I often dislike using groupons and other deals for fear of attitude or poor service at places. Everyone working here was so nice and helpful.

Ni
Review β„–60

We have never been disappointed when visiting this bakery. Ive tried many around the area and this location is our favorite!!!!!

Ma
Review β„–61

Great custom order cakes (along with standard bakery fare) all at very fair price. We normally get stuff for parties from here.

Ch
Review β„–62

What can I say GREAT BAKERY

Sy
Review β„–63

Yummy, fresh backed bread and cookies, cake and courtios staff

Ke
Review β„–64

They sell some good cookies.

Da
Review β„–65

Delicious pastries and cakes, fresh cannolis are great.

Le
Review β„–66

Best crumb based cake.

Na
Review β„–67

Love Kakes, and everything to this bakery...

Jo
Review β„–68

Good Coffee and Danish treats

Jo
Review β„–69

Excellent selection and quality.

Ho
Review β„–70

Pleasantly surprised . Very good

Ma
Review β„–71

DELICIOUS FRIENDLY GREAT BAKERY

Av
Review β„–72

Great cakes great service

Mi
Review β„–73

Love their chocolate mousse

K
Review β„–74

Yum best lemon drop cookies

it
Review β„–75

Amazing bake shop!

Ma
Review β„–76

Nice assortment of fresh pastries

Ba
Review β„–77

Very nice place & nice staff

LI
Review β„–78

Nice customer service

Bh
Review β„–79

Ok

Ch
Review β„–80

Great bakery

Ha
Review β„–81

Weight watchers dream

To
Review β„–82

Great cakes

ka
Review β„–83

Nice

Ra
Review β„–84

Very good in general

Ba
Review β„–85

Its ok

Jo
Review β„–86

Great donuts

Pe
Review β„–87

Excellent

Information
52 Photos
87 Comments
4.5 Rating
  • Address:775 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States
  • Site:http://gourmetbakeshop.com/
  • Phone:+1 516-354-3930
Categories
  • Coffee shop
  • Bakery
Working hours
  • Monday:7AM–6PM
  • Tuesday:7AM–3PM
  • Wednesday:7AM–6PM
  • Thursday:7AM–6PM
  • Friday:7AM–4PM
  • Saturday:Closed
  • Sunday:7AM–6PM
Service options
  • In-store pickup:Yes
  • Dine-in:No
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance:Yes
Dining options
  • Breakfast:Yes
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Payments
  • Checks:Yes
  • Debit cards:Yes
  • NFC mobile payments:Yes
Similar organizations
  • CJ
    CJE Cafe1985 Marcus Ave, New Hyde Park, NY 11042, United States
  • Starbucks653 Hillside Avenue, New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States
  • MIKE CONVENIENCE804 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States
  • Starbucks1596 Union Tpke, New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States