The comic tour rolled into this awesome comic store in Oneonta NY!! They have tons and tons of sweet back issues!! Gary is a really cool guy who is very knowledgeable about comics! You need anything Gary is your GO TO guy!! A must stop!! Enjoy! 👍👍

Awesome store. Great selection and very nice owner.

It took me hours to comb through all the cool stuff I found at Secret Comix Cave. If your reading this and want to go somewhere to stroke your nostalgic nerves this place has alot more than a typical comic book store....it has figurines referencing games and movies, new and old and cool stuff just stacked everywhere.

Best comic book store in the area. Gary is amazing and always willing to help out a customer and point you in the right direction. My wife and I, and especially the kids, love going to see Gary and pick out our favorite comics. The selection is second to none. I highly recommend!!

Polite employees, and an amusing little alarm dog.

A must stop place if your in Oneonta and love comics!

This is a great comic store. I tried to come here once a few weeks ago and showed up on the one off-day, but finally made it last week. Gary is a super friendly and knowledgeable guy. Theres a great balance of newer trades/graphic novels and a real good back issue selection, and Gary can order anything else youre looking for. Theres also a great selection of toys and novels, and some game stuff as well. Definitely will make sure to stop by anytime Im in the region!

We were vacationing nearby, and I love checking out shops when traveling and was so impressed by this one I had to write a review. What an excellent, friendly, and meticulously organized store. I know that the outside may look industrial (I think that is where the name comes from) but inside every bit of space was used well without feeling over-packed or dirty. Super well-organized and helpful owner, and a really impressed wide range of new books get ordered and put out on the shelf every week from what I can see. I feel like this shop really invests in not just fulfilling pull lists, but also keeping available all sorts of things across a range of publishers to browse and try. It had also been a long time since I had seen a 5 for $1 box (including free used bags and boards) and it was not just the usual stuff you see in those, there were some real surprises in there. I bet this is the kind of shop that helps build audiences for books that arent the top of the list. They also have really sensible and clear policies in place for safe shopping during the pandemic. I am glad I went and it brought me back to the days I would travel a lot for work, seek out shops whenever I could, and sometimes find a real gem that I wish was my local. Highly recommended..

This is the most amazing store to get your comic fix. The owner is personable, friendly, and enjoyable to shop from. The store is set up in a pleasing and fun manner, and there are always fun events. If you are looking to get comic books, get your child into reading in a fun manner or looking for a fun time in the area I recommend you stop in immidietly.

Gary is so friendly and very knowledgeable! If he doesnt have what youre looking for, he will order it! SO many comics!!!

Fantastic shop. Huge selection that is so well organized! Very knowledgeable staff. Great covid safety measures

Excellent comic book store that also carries a good collection of graphic novels, regular novels, books for the young ones (and coloring books), and toys. Also, Gary the owner is awesome and can get you anything you want if they dont have it in shop.

By far best comic shop in the area. I found tons of older comics I was looking. He carries a ton of current runs, as well as orders the newest trades. I get my entire pull list here. No need to go anywhere else. Lots of figures, statues and pops as well.

Great comics

Great place to visit and build your collection! Gary is one swell guy and definitely knows his stuff and very informative. Not many comic stores around anymore, but this is one above the rest. Thanks Gary!

Gary is awesome. Makes you feel a home. Love this place.

Vey friendly and knowledgeable proprietor. Visited from Ohio while on vacation. Vast assortment of comic books and graphic novels! We had a nice visit!

Great store, knowledgable staff and large inventory.

This is a hidden gem and I cant wait to do business here again! The owner is very friendly, helpful, and carries a wide variety of new and old comics.

Great selection. Super nice owner. One if the best shops I have visited

Place is great. Glad to see an actual comic shop again. Great staff!

Best comic shop in area! Gary is super knowledgeable and very friendly. Awesome deals every week and events at least monthly!

Great shop! Gary and Dexter are very welcoming and will help you find the right comic for you!

Best Selection of new and old comics. Gary and Dexter are very welcoming, and are eager to help you with whatever you are looking for.Ive been to comic stores all over NY State and various places up and down the east coast. None of them are as good as Secret Comix Cave. Gary goes above and beyond when it comes to sales, events, and overall presentation of comics.Comics are neatly organized by date, and then by letter. Every comic purchased comes bagged and boarded with no additional cost. There is a crazy amount of Manga and TP, and hardcovers, Gary also takes the time to pull full runs and then bundle them so you dont have to scour the long boxes for every issue. An awesome selection of Funko Pops, and action figures. If you are looking for your one stop shop for all things comics. This is the place!

Lots to look at and an adorable yappy dog ❤️

A well stocked and clean store. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable.

Selection of comics are awesome! Owner is super helpful.

Gary is a real expert with a great personality.

Best comic shop Ive been to Gary is the best

Best comic shop in Oneonta. Has everything you want, and then some

Great place, with a friendly atmosphere.

So many comics!!