Cute little shop, great choice of bagels, plenty of seating inside and out!

Enjoyed a delicious Early Bird sandwich with a refreshing cold latte.

I’ve been here before always have liked the place but I wasn’t too happy because I wanted banana on my bagel they didn’t have banana then I wanted a hot chocolate and they didn’t have mocha but I did still enjoy my bagel with strawberries 🍓

Food is great! Great selection of fresh made specialty bagels for both lunch and breakfast. Skip the coffee though. Is always burnt and bitter

This place is a true Idaho gem! They have a great selection of tasty bagels, and the employees were very friendly and helpful as well. I recommend this place to everyone and will certainly be making this my usual stop.

Had a keesh and it was really good! Get it on the jalepeno bagel! So good

A gem in Pocatello. The food is always amazing and service is awesome. Love this place.

Amazing food, service, and always a good experience, the only thing that would make it better is more locations

Some dadgum good bagels. Sandwiches are great. Definitely a popular joint to eat at here. My sister regularly buys bagels and spread and brings them back home, an hour and a half away.

So disappointed today. Usually they are generous with the cream cheese. Today, however, I think they just waved the knife over my bagel without really touching it.

Called twice and they picked up and hung up cuz they were busy. My triberry smears tasted like garlic from getting cut with a knife with savory leftovers.

I was there during the lunchtime rush, but the workers were polite and efficient. We didnt wait very long for our sandwiches and they tasted fabulous!

I called them at 3:30, placed my order for two bagels. Gave them my name & phone number. Told them Id be there at 3:45. I show up at 3:46 and my sandwiches were still not done. I waited another 10 minutes for one guy to finish my sandwiches & help the line of customers. I understand that it was 30 minutes before closing. But when I call ahead of time & show up, theyre still not done and I see 3 girls standing on their phones in the back. While this gentleman is running around struggling to help everyone. If youre going to hire women based off their looks, at least look for some common sense. Its incredibly frustrating having years of restaurant management experience & seeing such lack of teamwork & effort. When theres a line of customers & those girls just stood back there watching him work with their phones in their hands. All while staring with disgust at those keeping you employed. Disgusting.

Stopped here on a road trip & im so glad we did!!! the staff was so friendly and seemed to be well acquainted with the regulars there. a lot of good vegetarian items/you can make anything vegetarian. havent had a bagel sandwich this good in all my years …

One of the few local restaurants in Pocatello, there bagels are great, I recommend the California its very good, the only issues Ive had is ordering online takes longer then in person even if you preorder and that the drinks take a very long time to get dont recommend it if your in a rush. Ive also been told that there coffee can taste burnt on occasion. However there actually food is very good and a great breakfast place.

So good! Traveling through the area and wish we had one near home. Would definitely recommend 10/10.

Absolutely amazing. My wife & I just moved here from Houston, TX. This place came highly recommend to us from coworkers. We tried it and were blown away by how great this place was. We only live a mile away and will definitely be back.

Best place ever! Drive an hour just to come get a bagel every once in a while. Their captian crunch boba is absolutely amazing too!

Another great stop for breakfast. One of a kind and great sandwiches! I’d highly recommend this place to anybody passing through or even as a regular spot! We can’t get enough and the helpers are always friendly.

The food was good.. But when my wife was ordering the staff was the most disrespectful people I have ever seen in any food service I have EVER been too. I will never visit again. I was embarrassed to be in this shop and couldnt imagine what the owner would think. Or if they are even aware of how the staff acts and treats the guests.

This place was so good! was in town for the day and OMG.... these bagels are delightful! i got a sundried tomato bagel with egg and avocado on it... to die for

Such a yummy breakfast. We ordered several different kinds and each one was fresh and delish.

Happened upon this absolutely awesome bagelry by chance and so happy I stopped in! The bagel of my 3 Little Pigs sandwich was soft and very flavorful, and the staff was wonderful.

This place has it all. Goid food, good drinks and great ambiance.I always try to stoo here when Im in Pocatello. Try the Lox and cream cheese with tomato slices for a salty sweet treat!

Crowded but quick. Sandwich was a bit smaller than Anticipated, didnt quite match photo on wall. Lots to choose from

The bagels here are the best! Ive had everything on the menu and I can say its all good. They also serve gourmet coffee and specialty drinks as well as fresh squeezed orange juice. The cream cheese is homemade with lots of different flavors to choose from. This place is great and reasonably priced.

Some of the best bagels I’ve ever had. Definitely worth stopping in Pocatello just to eat here.

Good sandwiches and baked goods.

Best bagel place in Idaho BY FAR. Great variety and fun location near ISU.

Not only is it delicious, the people there are great. I had a huge order and was missing a bagel. I called and the girl on the phone rectified the issue instantly. So good and great customer service!

Long lines more of a wait than I prefer but the food n coffee was worth every min. Highly recomend it all.

The food was great. There wasnt very much seating. I would have also liked the option of a kids menu.

Amazing! My sisters and I went here for lunch, and there was a line, but it was handled well, and we got our food quickly. The food was so good, Im definitely coming back!

Best bagel breakfast sandwichs.

Nice fresh bagels (several varieties) lots of coffee drinks, fresh oj, milk, tea, nice environment, wifi and friendly staff.

Awesome food and a great atmosphere. All the food is good quality.

Pumpkin bagels are finally here! This shop has Fresh bagels! They make them throughout the day so they stay fresh. Their selection of bagels, bagel sandwiches, and breakfast sandwiches is extensive! I have tried most of the bagels and I have yet to find a complaint. If you get a sandwich with bacon- they make their bacon into circle patties, and for whatever reason, it’s bomb! I tried a latte today for the first time, and I was not disappointed at all. It was actually one of the better lattes I have ever had!

They make great bagels, cream cheese and sandwiches. The classic chowder was wonderful. The service is excellent

The spicy Italian. Not the most flattering picture but absolutely delicious. I saved half in the fridge and it was even better cold! Great employees and service. Pricey though. This cost me nearly 7 dollars. If you are in the area, pleas do stop by. They also have a nice eating area outside.

Some of the best breakfast/lunch in town! Good service from happy employees.

Wonderful food, amazing coffee, and very friendly staff! Always helpful with suggestions; highly recommend!!!

This is such a fun place to get breakfast or lunch! The environment is cozy, yet upbeat and the bagels are so good, I love them Schmeared or as a sandwich. They also have great soups, treats and drinks.It is always busy but they get everything out pretty quick and 90 % of the staff is really fun and friendly so it makes the place that much better.My favorites: The California club, BLT or the Rueben.

Long wait times, friendly staff, decent food. Small dining area. Just a small location in general.

Every time I come back home to Utah, my family and neighbors request I bring these bagels back. The staff has always been kind and the prices are great.

Loooove this place! The best bagel sandwiches ever! They have breakfast and lunch sandwiches as well as coffee and other great beverages!

Adorable little shop with nice wall art, tasty food and coffee, and a nice corner with a fireplace and couch. Good place for some road trip fuel!

Bagels are great, however go elsewhere if you want a good cup of coffee

Great food, fast service.

I really love their lunch sandwiches. Im not crazy about their breakfast sandwiches, mostly because the egg is a bit rubbery like its been pre-cooked, frozen, and then rethawed. I could be wrong. MYbe they made the egg fresh and overcooked it. Either way, this is still my current favorite place for brunch in Pocatello. The food is very fresh, light, and healthy. Its a unique and tasty breakfast/brunch place.

Loved the jalapeno cheddar bagel and cinnamon twist latte. Was busy on a Saturday morning but worth the wait in the line. Huge variety for the whole family

Good atmosphere. Fantastic bagels and bagel sandwiches. Local favorite.

Love their bagels, great place for breakfast

Their veggie bagel and hummus is great. They also make super tasty coffee as well!

Phenomenol bagels and fantastic variety. Atmosphere is coffee-central. Music and mural are on-point with their theme. Good locally-roasted coffee, and fantastic cookies, brownies and other sweets.

Awesome place fresh food loved it

Great bagels and drinks and a great custom selection

Yum. Love the bagels, smeared or sandwiched, delicious either way. Fast, friendly service. The Deja Voodoo is so tasty if youre a coffee drinker.

Love the art on the wall.

They dont really toast your bagels, just warm them up. Theyre also a bit overpriced. Otherwise, great.

The bagels are excellent. I love coming here for the food but every time I order a coffee or drink, it takes the employees an unreasonably long time to make it.

This bagel shop is amazing! Everytime I go, it smells amazing, the food is to die for, and the staff is friendly and helpful!

Employees where very helpful, Lox and Cream Cheese was excellent.

Theyve got really good bagels. You can have something sweet or savory, or a sandwich. I also really like how you can sit and eat in the couches by the fire. Pretty cool.

In my opinion, while the food was delicious, I feel it is severely overpriced. I bought 3 bagels for $36. Nothing special done to them or anything, just straight off the menu and without modifications. If you can cook a half decent amount, youre better off putting the effort into it rather than spending this kind of money.

Delicious bagel sandwiches and boba teas!

I cant believe it has taken me this long to review 5th St Bagelry and say how amazing this place is. I have been in alone, with small groups, and have done some larger orders, 3-5 dozen, for group functions and have always been extremely satisfied with the staff and the food. It is one of my favorite places, whether I just want a bagel with one of their many flavors of cream cheese or a bagel sandwich, I leave satisfied every time.

Love stopping here for lunch on our way through town.

DEEELICIOUS

Ordered two lox spread with lettuce and tomato I ended up getting too plain with lettuce tomato and capers no lox anywhere. 9 bucks each way overpriced..

Great bagel with avocado and cheese. Should have skipped the egg though.

Love everything about this place! The food, the prices, the atmosphere..excellent!

The food is amazing. Great customer service. You will always leave satisfied. There is even a nice room to sit and relax while eating. It is a very friendly environment.

A little pricey but good food

One of the only places we regularly eat at in Pocatello. The environment is cozy and relaxing, bagels are excellent, and their drinks and desserts are great too. They go above and beyond to make the customer happy here, love this place!!

Bagels as good as New York. At least what I was told by New Yorkers. Come and get one!

I rushed in close to closing time and these guys were so friendly and helpful. Very impressed with the level of customer service.The food is also always great. Im continuously impressed with the quality of the food.Highly recommended.Thanks guys!

5th street is super good! Wish they had vegan options

Great food, and comfortable environment. They have prepared and implemented great cleanliness procedures. It was a very pleasant lunch.

Great, as usual.

Great food when it’s made correctly. I go here very often and recommend this place to all my friends but I will not be any longer. I have ordered MULTIPLE times and been missing items that were supposed to be included on the bagel (sprouts, avocado, etc). I’ve even paid extra to get avocado on a bagel it wasn’t already included on and got all the way home before opening it and realizing it was not there. Check your food before you leave because it probably doesn’t have what you are expecting on it.

I always come out of there with way too much food but I cant help myself cause its all delicious!

Always great food!

Good food and atmosphere

I live in Idaho Falls and sometimes drive to Pocatello (about a 45 min drive) just to have their bagels! They are that good! Their food is a bit on the pricey side but very delicious.

I have been coming to 5th street my whole life, but there has been a noticeable shift in the last couple of years. During visit in particular, we were disappointed by the service we received. The bagels were perfectly fine, though the eggs on mine tasted bland and lacking in flavor. There was no cream or milk for the coffee, which is unfortunate as it doesn’t cost much to provide this. The service was the most disappointing. One of the best parts about 5th street is walking in and feeling welcome, like there is a great little bagel place where the community can really get together. That wasn’t anything like our experience today. We were rushed through the line as if we were parts in a factory assembly line, and it was not particularly busy. We were repeatedly asked to repeat our orders, and when we asked for extra veggies, we were told multiple times that this would cost extra and treated as if this was an inconvenience to the employees. I understand that everyone has “off days”, but it would be upsetting to think this is the new normal for a town favorite. Hoping next time is better.

I always enjoy their sugar cookies

Best bagel i’ve ever had!

I come here way too often. So delicious and the people are so nice.

Disappointing. Wanted it toasted bagel came out raw. Probly wont go back

Kind service, great begals! Thanks Fifth Street Bagelry!

Recently tried Fifth Street Bagelry for the first time and was pleasantly surprised. Coming from Salt Lake where we frequented a national bagel chain, we had pretty high standards for what a good bagel sandwich should taste like.We definitely werent disappointed. Between two sandwiches and a soup, we were happy with our order. The food was ready before we were finished paying, so no wait, and they had plenty of selection of very tasty bagels. Excited to go back and try more of their sandwiches.

Great atmosphere, friendly service, and good options. The prices are a little high, but the products are fresh, so its a balancing act. Also, its super busy in the mornings and weekends, so carve out enough time to wait in line just in case. Great experience overall, though.

This place has great food. Come in the morning get a bagel. Come in the afternoon and get a sandwich. This food so good and fresh.

Their bagels are all made in house, they are fresh and delicious! My family and I come here at least once or twice a week to get some of their bagel sandwiches and some amazing coffee! If you’re looking for a cozy, fun place to eat some great food, 5th street is the place to do it!

Love the Bagels and the boba tea. Only place I know of in Pocatello that does Boba.

Very good

Best Bagels Ever!!! I would plan to wait as they go as quick as they can, but they always have a smile on there face. They are friendly, and trust me everything is worth the wait!!

Parmesan bagel was nice and soft. I miss when they used to put more parmesan on top. The Blueberry bagel I bought must have been a day old or more because it was very stale. My 13 year old garbage disposal wouldnt even eat it :( It was 1:4 in the bin, so maybe when the bin of bagels is low, it might mean the bagels are a bit older? I assumed it was just a popular bagel that sold fast.

They have fantastic bagels! They made yummy combinations and toppings for them. Their cream cheese toppings are yummy and of course they sell fresh! Their coffee I was not so impressed. Outside of brewed they dont make very good cappuccino or flavored coffee.

Its fast, the coffee is good, and its a nice little spot to meet up. Never too busy but definitely not a hole in the wall.