Ive had two cars repaired by 5 star. Both black and they came out perfectly. Prices were very reasonable

Dear Miss Goldberg ..... I am sure you’ve made a mistake by rating my company which has no affiliation to any lot in Babylon. We are located in Port Washington and are associated with Port Washington Police and not Amityville. Please rectify your review and rate the correct company as my company is 5 Star Auto Center and not “Five” Star .... thank you

My car was towed by this company when I was in a collision last month. They were contacted by the Amityville Police which means they are obligated to charge specific rates determined by the town. They relocated my car to their lot in babylon and after agreeing that there would be no additional charges decided to charge outside of the town rates as well as charge for services that they never did to my car since it was totaled at the time of the accident. When I approached the owner he lied to me, made up excuses and acted unprofessional. I had to get the town clerk of amityville involved. After much stress and time the town clerk made them adjust the bill. The company continued to try and hold my car hostage and ask for cash even after the town clerk was involved. I proceded to get the police involved. This was an incredibly terrible situation that caused me unnecessary stress when I was already having to deal with the aftermath of an accident. All in all, this company is untrustworthy, unprofessional and downright scary to work with. If you are ever in an accident I would highly suggest making sure this business does not get involved.

The owner is kind