We stumbled across this adorable shop while strolling through Princeton. My kids were so excited about all the cookie options. The cookies are so yummy and this place is now on our must-stop-in list when in Princeton.

Cookies are always delicious!! I also love that they take feedback seriously and if you weren’t happy with something (very, very rare), they’ll make it right. I highly recommend this place.

Cookie we’re crispy on the outside and chewy in the inside they have all types of milk for everyone’s needs, a little pricey but it was worth it, I will definitely be back when I’m around

Very cute place with very good cookies.

A hidden gem in Princeton! Milk and Cookies is a small bakery on Chambers Street that serves amazing cookies, milkshakes, and ice cream sandwiches. They offer gluten-free, vegan, or both! Their prices are very cheap considering on how good their desserts are. They also offer online delivery for their cookies, which me and my friends often use. Their assortment of desserts and drinks is just astounding, and Im very surprised that not a lot of people actually go there (from my experience). The staff there are very kind, and take time to get your order right, and please you. Thanks Milk and Cookies!

I have been searching for a great peanut free cookie place for years! This place is great and has delicious cookies. I especially love the lavender cookies.

I got the cookie shake. I’m still shaken up by the experience. I’ve been staring into space at a red light three blocks from the shop contemplating what’s happened and felt I needed to share. I didn’t believe in a God until today. Some say nothing is as good or bad as it seems, nothing is perfect. Well I just drank perfection. I held perfection in my hands. The perfect ratio of cookie crumbles mixed into the milkshake. The customization - you’re the captain of your ship. Want chocolate ice cream with a chocolate chip cookie? Do it. Vanilla with snickerdoodle? It’s yours cowboy. The straw’s width is thoughtfully thicc.Maybe you’re just browsing your options. Maybe you aren’t particularly hungry. Don’t let this opportunity slip away. Nothing should get in the way of your happiness. Believe in yourself. Let go of your inhibitions. Start anew. Get this shake. Fall in love.

Such a cute little location with the best cookies in town.

Cute shop located just off the Nassau strip near Princeton. They offer cookies that are vegan and gluten-free. Oatmeal chip cookies were yummy and had a great texture without being too sweet.

Cutest cookie shop ever, it has a fairytale vibe. It is an amazingly cute tiny shop to take pictures, hang out and have delicious cookies. The tea latte and hot cocoa were very yummy. I would definitely recommend it if you are in the area. (I only wish they would serve the cookies in a plate and not on napkins)

“Amazing delicious cookies, I totally recommend coming here” says Lucas

Wow - cookies tasted as good as a cookie can - soft & moist ... The staff (maybe she was the owner) was amazingly nice ... definitely worth a try. Its the 3rd from the right, but the door is on the side

First time costumer today, was not disappointed.Most importantly the cookies were delicious, the customer service was nothing short of terrific, and it was all affordable. I was awarded a cookie simply for being inconvenienced by a wait of 10 minutes, a very minor wait in honesty. My favorite thing to note was that they used ice coffee cubes in the iced mocha, now I get to wait for them to melt and have a little more.Definitely going to order again in the future

Kiara, who works there was very kind, and I really appreciated her helping me with my pick up and a cookie choice. The place smells awesome!

Pretty good cookies

My husband and I are new residents in Princeton and we were delighted to be within walking distance of this cute little cookie shoppe. We have enjoyed their cookies. But on a cool day, we decided to try the hot chocolate. I ordered two while my husband waited in the car. The cups were covered and upon tasting them in the car they were hot, rich, and delicious and covered in a yummy dollop of whipped cream. On another cool day, my husband again waited in the car while I ordered two hot chocolates. This time they were handed to me without lids, which I asked for. When I returned to our car we sipped them. They were just luke warm, but we continued on our way. We decided to try one more time, thinking this was just a fluke. This time, they had lids, but I decided to taste them before I left the shoppe. They were both less than luke warm. Needless to say, I was very disappointed and just requested a refund, which was given to me. I can only assume that the staff needs more training.

Simply delicious 😋 cookies and the friendliest staff!

Delicious cookies 🍪 Great customer service 👏.

Great customer service! Uplifting vibes! Space to sit chat or do work...and awesome cookies!!

Cute shop and good cookies. Great for a quick treat!

HORRIBLE! I came here and the cookies was hard and it taste like stale bread.

I love the snicker doodles here

I just loooooooooove this place!!!! Really the best cookies in town. The cookies are amazing and it is an unbeatable atmosphere. The cookie I like most is the heavenly chocolate, and it’s nice they have vegan and gluten free options, too! Just around the corner from Nassau street and the location couldn’t be better. The staff is always so kind!! The hot cider is great, too! I love this place! I recommend to anybody!!!

We have visited here two times. Today we visited and when it was hot outside the inside of the store was not comfortably cool. I would not want to sit inside to get work done. It is a very small lobby area to sit, maybe 3 small tables total. There are no public bathrooms.The concept of the store is great but the execution struggles. Both times I have gone into the store and bought cookies. At least half the cookies werent fresh. Today, over half of our order was stale or hard. Of course it wasnt convenient to go back to the store or ask for a refund but there is a good chance we would not go back because of our two experiences being similiar. I will however say that when the cookies are fresh, they are very tasty. But good luck knowing which ones are fresh when you order.

Love the s’mores cookie it’s my favorite! Always warm and delicious

Absolutely delicious cookies - soft and chewy, and packed with flavor. My friend had me taste her vegan/gluten free one and it was unexpectedly incredible! My favorite cookies; wish I lived closer! 110% would reccomend!!

They have vegan options! Delicious. The person working the cookie counter was very very nice.

Amazing vegan cookies :)

Cookies are amazing, especially the toffee and chocolate chip! Milk was nice and cold! First time ordering from them, definitely will order again, thanks!!!

The cookies were hard, the ice cream had frost burn and the brownies. I cannot even describe them but they were the last thing I would ever want near my mouth. I was not satisfied with this order and I am writing this in hopes that there will be better service for the next person.

- Love the style of this place- Wasn’t a fan of the selections, nothing special stood out. It was your basic “make at home cookies”- Staff was helpful, but just standing there waiting on me to decide.

I came across Milk & Cookies on DoorDash app. My mom and I are always in search of a good snack. So we decided to place a order and give Milk & Cookies a try...I am happy to report that my mom and I both are extremely satisfied with our cookies. The cookies were fresh, soft and delicious. The boxing they came in soooo cute and presentable.My mom is a tough cookie when it comes to her goodies but these have passed the test and we will be happy to place another order and another order.

Cute shop right around the corner from the main street. Crowd at 3p was mostly high schoolers stopping in for snacks.We were in town visiting family and tried cookies, 3 different kinds, that tasted stale on a Friday, hot chocolate was weak.

A great place to recharge and refresh with an iced tea after a day in Princeton. Since its not on a main drag, its far more relaxing than other similar joints in town.

Delicious cookies, fun flavors and they do great party platters.

Showed up 10 minutes before closing just wanting a simple cookie to go. Was told the register is closed. Then why pretend to be open till 11...

Being gluten free really limits your dessert options but these cookies are the BEST gluten free I’ve ever had and there’s a lot of variety. The owner is so friendly and actually gluten free herself so she really understands how to make delicious gluten free cookies! I often buy regular cookies for friends and family and they also rave about them. The shop is super cute and I love how they support other local businesses by serving Grover’s Mill coffee.

I ordered from milk & cookies last night. They never delivered my cookies. I called and they said they would contact the driver to see what happened. Never heard anything back. I ordered 30$ worth. Don’t order from here! They stole my money!!

I really like how they use coffee ice cubes in their iced coffee.

Cute spot!!! However they did not sell any cookies with nuts.First time there and last ;-(

OH GOSH I LOVE THIS PLACE!!! I come here for a warm cookie unless 3 times a week!

Sweet cookies, sweet employees. What a cute little shop! I love stopping in for some freshly brewed Rooibos Chai iced tea and a cookie or two. Everything has been delicious and flavorful so far. The ladies behind the counter are delightful and I leave feeling good inside and out. Bonus that there are no plastic straws in the store, which we know are so harmful once disposed. Adorable red and pink striped paper straws are available, or they even have reusable glass straws for sale at the counter. 👍👍

You can never go wrong with warm cookies I personally like this place more than (insombia cookies) the chocolate chip cookie is my all time favorite!

It is exactly what it says, and they have gluten free ones too

Really like this place, my family orders cookies all the time. Recently it takes about an hour, it took 3 hours and 15 minutes tonight. The cookies are always broken and often wrong.

Love this place! super delicious and perfect for any night

The cookies are out of this world! Great variety and incredible taste.

Very cute, nice people, tasty cookies.

Gluten free options and everything is yum!

The Cooke’s are rock hard and taste bitter and nasty.

Such delicious cookies! A must visit if you’re in the area!

The cookies were warm and delicious and the delivery lady was super nice.

The best coffee/mocha cookie ever... The glaze made it.

Nice cookies, friendly staff, and love the fresh milk and ice cream from halo farms, just wish the cookies were softer and melty. Sometimes it feels like theyve been sitting out for awhile.

Nice employee and the best cookies

Incredibly nice staff and delicious cookies!

They have a couple different types of vegan cookies! :)

Great cookies and decent coffee

Cookie

Awesome cookies, vibes, and drinks.

Just a cookie. Nothing special at all.

So yummy

Cute shop

Eh

Very friendly

I DEFINITELY want to go back their customer service was EXCEPTIONAL! They didnt have the cookies I wanted so I was given the cookies that I did settle on trying. It was so refreshing being that most of the service I had at restaurants was unprofessional and just flat out rude at times 💜