Yummy ice cream with a good variety of flavors. My granddaughter said the banana ice cream had the most banana flavor ever lol. Nice people, clean place inside and out...we enjoyed ours outside at one of their many tables.

This charming ice cream shop was a new find for me, and Im glad to have discovered it! Portions are generous and the ice cream sweet and creamy. I especially appreciated that the flavors are bold. Hope to be back!

Cash-only ice cream parlour with a splendid assortment of flavours. Good portions. Great value for your money. I highly recommend their pistachio.

TodayI had the pleasure of visiting this ice cream parlor with my family. The staff was very friendly and attentive. A good selection of flavors and toppings. As you walk in you are in a country rustic setting which is very clean and roomy. The owners were very nice and made you feel like family not customers.

We each ordered a waffle cone with three scoops (Medium), we should have ordered a small, the portion was huge! I had the cookie monster, oreo and peanut butter. We both sat on the tailgate in the parking lot and had to eat it fast. We got ice cream everywhere but it was worth it.I also got to watch someone hand bake and roll the cones behind the register while we were being rung up. This is why the place smells so good right when you walk in.I enjoy this place more so than the more popular ice cream businesses in the area. Usually at those joints you feel rushed and anxious because their menu is absolutely enormous and overwhelming. This place feels like an old country store and the interior of the building has a beautiful historical post and beam theme. Definitely worth the trip!

Yo..I had a banana split sundae this thing came in a bowl 3 different types of ice cream my choice 3 different toppings my choice a mountain of whipped cream ...BOY it took me a 20 minutes to eat this monster .No lie try it!!!!!!

I go there all the time it’s close to my house and I love how smooth and delicious the coffee ice cream is. However they only accept cash which is a pain and today I was informed I could only taste one flavor ice cream even though I was buying already. That is ridiculous, so you want me to buy a flavor I’ve never tasted and waste my money if I hate it, hmmmm.

So well furbished inside, their ice cream is delicious and filling, quick service

I have gone to Whittmore Ice Cream a couple times since they reopened and I have really enjoyed my experiences. Good selection of tasty choices, and I love their waffles cones— they’re a delicious flavor and consistency. Very friendly service, too.

Great family running the ice cream shop, pop in and enjoy some in the nostalgia of an old fashion ice shop with a quaint country charm feel to it.

I think its new owners. Ice cream is much better and actually frozen now. Amazing and worth another visit.

Ice cream not that good, chocolate chips tasted like baking chips. No taste. Ice cream was gritty. Maybe I got a couple of bad scoops.

Great place. Gina is one of most pleasant people I have ever met.

First visit since the new owners took over. They have some new flavors.The barnyard brawl might be my new favorite

Great ice cream, many fun flavors, cheerful staff.

Great icecream reasonably priced

Professional and friendly service. Great ice cream!!!

Non dairy is delicious!!! Service was fabulous!

We stopped in for ice cream, they have been in business for quite a few years and the ice cream was always very good. Today, they hardly had any flavors to choose from and the ice cream containers didnt have much ice cream left in them. I couldnt believe on a hot Summer day they didnt have any napkins. The guy said the truck hadnt come in with the supplies. If they knew the day before they were out or low on napkins why didnt they stop at a grocery store before opening the store today to buy some. The ice cream drips in the hot sun!They had no inside seating anymore only picnic tables most in the sun and two small tables on the porch. They used to make waffle cones, the cone my ice cream was in was stale. The guy that got us our ice cream didnt say anything about the place closing but they sure were out if a lot of things. I will choose a different ice cream place next time I want ice cream out.

The service was terrible they don’t ask if you want the ice cream that you pay for in cup or cones and just assume what they think you want and call it a day

Worst ice cream place ive ever been to. Its worth the 5 minute drive up rt 67 to richs farm

Outstanding homemade ice cream, one of the top three ice cream places in the state, in my opinion. A little out of the way, in Seymour, but well worth looking for. You wont be disappointed

Lots of parking. Good variety. Friendly service. They do not do soft ice cream which my wife likes.

Very nice, old building. Nice selection and portions. Very pleasant!

Great ice cream!

Very expensive ice cream, to me its just not worth $12.00 for 3 ice cream cones.. disappointing when you go for out for an ice cream cone and it costs that much!!! Never again!!!

Great ice cream for a great value. You can taste the homemade in every bite.

Great icecream, great sundaes, everythings delicious..its worth the trip!

Great, vintage, handmade ice cream made on site, PLEASE bring your family here

Hubby and I walked in and walked right back out because they only accept cash. We did not have cash on us, so we didnt get any ice cream, so if you decide to visit, have cash on you.

Wonderful homemade waffle cones and bowls. Homemade unique ice cream flavor concoctions. Great old timey decor. The dance studio upstairs sounds like theres 100 horses galloping around but as a local it doesnt seem to bother anyone because the ice cream is that great!

Fantastic icecream. The valleys best

The ice cream is good. No signs saying cash only. I would rather just get regular ice cream though, or go up to Rich farm.

This ice cream place is awesome. the Flavors that they have in this place are everything! the taste ummm yummy!! They are really friendly :) ONLY CASH!!!

Love their ice cream, many flavors, lots of toppings, staff is friendly and welcoming. Open seasonally. Theres tables inside and outside to sit​ while enjoying​ your ice cream. Great family place or date night stop.

Went there today. The girl behind the counter was not wearing gloves to get the ice out of the containers and I ordered a pint of ice cream and there were no pint containers so I order a quart size and there were no lids to go with the containersPlus I ask for a ice cream and I do not think she knows how to make one.

Checked googled to see if they were opened yet this year and it said yes open until 9. So tried to surprise my son after school today but then got there to them being closed! Please update so people know! I know it changes seasonally but please keep your customers in the loop thank you.

Really good ice cream in an old style location. I believe the location was an old tavern or general store at one point. It has a lot of old character, and the Ice cream is fresh and delicious.

Good one to have a nice icecream

I enjoyed the variety of ice cream flavors. The service is excellent.

When I had my first experience of Whitmore ice cream back in 2005. It was truly the best ice cream I ever had cause the people who owned it. Truly took the time to make the perfect ice cream in my opinion and the old owners took time out to talk to their customers. But they since sold the place to these people who only care for money. I mean they cut corners...barely cut their grass the people behind the counter are pieces of trash who I personally cant stand and believe me I did put my personal differences aside so I could take my 6 year old out to try some home made ice cream but I just couldnt. It taste like I dont know Im not going to say manure cause its ice cream but you can tell its a different owner. So ill just say its ok. But thanks for reading and may you and your family enjoy your lives

Cozy ice cream parlor located in what was once an 18th century tavern. Beutiful exposed beams. Best place to go if the lines are too long at Rich Farm. Cash only!

Awesome ice cream more people should visit this place.

Its cash only but so worth the trip to the ATM. Their Graham Slam ice cream is unbelievable.

The worse ice cream I had in my life. Myself, fiance and the kids did not enjoy their choices either. We all had something different and could not finish it cause it had a weird taste. It was almost like old and stale ice cream that had been sitting for a while. Will not go back.___Update: A year after I posted this review I received insulting text messages from two different numbers telling me that I suck at reviewing and to delete this review. Not sure what to make of this but my review was based on experience and nothing else so it remains as is.

Ice cream made on the premises and it is extra creamy. I just had a cone of their Irish cream ice cream and it was rich and delicious.

Not always in stock with flavors. always try for the yogurt black raw w choc chip I think it is but havent had it much lately

A full variety of flavors. Cash only, just hard ice cream.

Always patient when my shy soft spoken kids are not loud enough when placing their orders. Quick service.

They have some great ice cream here. Would have been 5 stars if they were not out of coffee ice cream the other night, lol

AMAZING! They always have Cookie Monster! They are so nice too!

Delicious ice cream a lot of flavors and great price.

I ordered the pistachio and it was so rich and delicious! Friendly staff ! Highly recommend!

Very friendly & great ice cream... & only a couple blocks away from home!!

Wonderful ice cream, great service and quaint old fashion charm .

Service Poor no details or signs for Ice cream scrapped the bottom of the bucket for small cup of chocolate chip no smile no thank you no anything will not come back & will put the word out Ill stick to Rich Farms Im all about giving places chances unfortunately it was a great let down I have no clue if color diversity plays apart, but Im all set.

Great ice cream and toppings. Awesome service

Great Ice cream, Family friendly environment. Cant wait for 2017 plans.

Great service good ice cream

Nice atmosphere, great ice cream. Cash only.

Great ice cream, waffle cones, and milkshakes. Cash only, but totally worth it.

Very good ice cream iand excellent service

Nice atmosphere, great variety of icecream and toppings, polite employees.

Just try it and you will love it too..

Worst variety of ice cream. No soft serve scream at an ice cream store is very strange to me.

The best ice cream you can find in the area. FYI: Cash only.

Great selection, nice place and great service!

This place made my day! Best ever!

Nice ice cream place

The Birthday cake was really delicious !

Does not accept credit cards. Cash only

Great place for a family, amazing flavors, friendly employees

The best ice cream in the town and the pumpkin ice cream is hear :)

Great ice cream

Good place

Great scoop shop!

Great ice cream.

Excellent

Yummy and waffle bowls!

Amazing ice cream!

Good stuff

Very good

Good ice cream

Love the ice cream

Very good

Best Ice Cream ever!

Excellent

Yummy

Family place