Excellent service, great flavors. 10/10

Me and my family have been getting ice cream 🍦 here for years we love the smooth taste 😊

Excellent staff! And the ice cream of course is delicious. They have every kind of ice cream you could possibly imagine. Five stars

This place has been a staple in West Babylon for along as I remember . Ice cream is very good. I bought an ice cream cake and it was also good. Service is great. Highly recommend.

Listennnnn!!! OLD FASHIONED ICE CREAM has been my favorite place since I was a school aged child visiting my aunt and uncle in Wyndanch. We stopped there after each visit as tradition. Now I have moved out of state... but you better believe my children now know Old Fashioned and all it meant for me and our family. We visit the store every single time we are in town. They ask for it by name. Now if I could just figure out how to transport some of that deliciousness down to Baltimore.

5 stars for ice cream, don’t get me wrong. Incredible flavors, absolutely delicious. However they had a weird policy where I couldn’t get a double scoop on a sugar cone so I had to order two scoops in cups with a sugar cone on the side and then assemble the quickly melting ice cream in my car? I’m a spoiled brat for this I know, but what’s it take for a guy to get his double scoop on a sugar cone around here…

Excellent choices of ice cream and reasonably priced! Every flavor I have tried is excellent!

A long Island treasure. The icecream is delicious.

This place reminded me of the ice cream shop when I was a child. It brought back so many memories that I was able to share with my daughter. The cherry vanilla ice cream is to die for! My daughter thoroughly enjoyed the mango ice cream! Well worth the trip!!

I love this place! My favorite ice cream spot

Absolutely delicious ice cream and great staff. Hot fudge is a little sweet and could use a little more bitterness for perfection. I cant wait to come back!

Really like this place ice cream very good, many different varieties. I have order special cakes & pies, always good & ready when they say.

Been going here since I was pregnant. My son is now 13y-o. The🍦is delicious. Id like a Baileys flavor please😩

I absolutely love this place. The staff is very friendly. The ice cream is delicious. They enforce social distancing which is sadly a must these days.Please visit them if you’re in the area.

The best so far on the island

The ice cream here is nothing like Ive ever had before! Its so creamy and smooth and delicious!

Everyone in this place is just amazing. All staff is sweet and welcoming and helpful, made me and my family welcomed moving here.

One of long island’s best kept ice cream secrets. Literally the only place I’ve ever seen with grape nut!

Real ice creams made from scratch on premise . As are some of the toppings . Delicious creamy treat .

Suuuuuper good.

Absolutely DELICIOUS & Affordable!!!I Recommend You Try This Icecream Parlor At Least Once In Your Life Yo!!!I Had SOFT SERVE STRAWBERRY ICECREAM YES SOFT SERVE...they had banana soft serve but I didnt try that one !!!My Children LOVED Their Chocolate & Vanilla...So Smooth and Rich In Flavor !!!

Love this place. Great ice cream, and great service.

Flavorful and not overly sweet. Great variety of flavors. I got Rocky Road (would have like more marshmallow and nuts...Im old school R&R fan...but the chocolate was good) and I topped it with soft serve banana...great!!! Dont judge the size of my cone, it is smaller by my request. Highly recommend a visit. I will be back to try other flavors. The young man who served me was very friendly, excellent service. Small parking lot and street parking.

Everything is Good for ice cream lovers

Soft service cream is creamy and thick. They have malts, milkshakes, ice cream cakes, ice cream pies, hard scoop ice cream, soda and much more. We love it there. We been getting our ice cream treats for over 10 years from this place.

Reese’s pieces pie was a hit for my wife’s birthday. This place is a hidden gem and love supporting a local place like this.

This place has some of the best ice cream Ive ever had. Theyre friendly too and the service is always great!

Let me just tell you, this is a GO TO if your in the area. I came here bi-weekly for like 5 years straight. I grew up on 18th street and I could WALK here all the time. It was hard moving with this place 😅

It was absolutely delicious. I really liked the soft serve vanilla with hot caramel. Their ice Cream reminds me of when I was a kid.

All of your favorite ice cream and one spot 😈🥰🖤🖤🍧🍨🍦

Great ice cream

Fresh ice cream

Friendly service, great ice cream!

We have been checking out the home made ice cream places on the island and this place does not disappoint! Good quality, excellent flavor ice cream. The owners are very friendly as are the employees. We will definitely be going back for more. Highly recommend.

Large variety of flavors. Excellent ice cream.

Wow this place is old school and AMAZING! Hands down the best ice cream Ive ever had. Staff was very helpful and informative as well. Great ice cream spot.

The last 5 times I went here the milkshakes were the consistency of water. Everything else is really good though

Really nice people .order is taken well made.

My family and I stumbled upon this place a few years ago and fell in love. I usually don’t write reviews but I feel incredibly compelled to recommend this spot. If you want good ice cream, you have to try. Their grape-nut ice cream is unbeatable. highly recommend.

I really like this place. The ice cream is homemade and I’ve gotten ice cream cakes for my kids birthdays the past three years. They are very nice and affordable!

Best soft serve strawberry 🍓 ice cream. Excellent service. Good social distancing & PPE protocols

So fresh, and the waffle cone was one of the best Ive had. Definitely worth the drive.

I took my daughter and we both loved it,they have so many flavors you to go there often to try them all.

Great place for ice cream!!

Nice place, good ice cream but they are VERY expensive as compared to most other ice cream establishments

Very nice employees at this place and delicious creamy ice cream:)

Best ice cream around

Store was very busy and ice cream was average.

Best ice cream in the area! My family comes here to get ice cream almost everyday! Staff is always the nicest and there’s always a great rotation of soft serve flavors!

Great customer service and a neighborhood feel. Delicious homemade ice cream

Best ice cream I visit al the way from Queens NY to get ot

Delicious and fresh ice cream. So many varieties to satisfy everyone in my bunch.

Always 5 stars

Yummy yum yum!!! Love going to OFIC!!! Always get the grape nut and Im never disappointed

Not bad ok

Have gone a few times when visiting relatives in the area. Prices for a cone are $2 less than the Carvel in Kings Park near my house. Had the soft serve black raspberry last week, it was incredible. Staff is super nice as well.

Awesome ice cream and soft serve ice cream as well. Its awesome to support your local family owned.

My fiance and I had the pistachio soft serve ice cream with peanuts on top!!!!! This ice cream is ridiculously good and the peanuts are always fresh and roasted well!!! What a glorious treat!!! And the service there is always spot on!

It was definitely worth every pound I just gained.Whenever I am in the area, this is my go to happy place.

Amazing maple walnut hard ice cream, its worth coming all the way here !!

One of the best Ice Cream shops I have encountered. Their employees are really nice and cool.

Absolutely The Best Ice Cream!!! The Young People Behind The Counter Were Very Pleasant!...Definitely Will Be Returning ☺☺☺

Best ice cream around definitely make it in and try anything 😋

Nice old school spot

Is it possible to add more stars?! These guys are just FANTASTIC service-wise, and the ice cream (you can buy scoops in a million sizes, with whatever toppings you want!) is the best on Long Island!! Do yourself and your family a favor - hit them up ASAP!!!!

I almost wish I never went...its ruined store bought ice cream for me. I ordered the cookies and cream.... so creamy, good amount of big cookie pieces. So so good!

This place has the BEST ice cream in Suffolk County. Their fresh soft serve banana, strawberry and pistachio ice creams are delicious. The workers are very courteous. They have awesome hours.

Favorite ice cream place in Long island. Honestly the best!

So good! Love the big portions when you order a small. They offer you samples of the ice cream and comes with a cone. Lots of flavors and friendly service.

The dole whip is incredible! Got the mango flavor today. The place was clean, the people are incredibly friendly, and the ice cream is awesome.

Awesome Ice cream joint.

Great tasting ice cream

Always very nice and quick to help you. Their ice cream is also very great. I specifically go there just for their strawberry soft serve ice cream!

The best in town for ice cream. Very nice staff. Always a wonderful experience.

Do yourself a favor & head on down to this amazing mom & pop ice cream parlor. They have a good variety of flavors at an affordable price, much better than any franchise you could purchase from. They also make ice cream cakes for your partying needs! The cherry vanilla ice cream flavor must be what God snacks on. Definitely worth a visit!Disclaimer: No, I was not paid by anyone to say these things. Actually, Im the one who paid.....for their delicious ice cream!

Excellent ice cream with an old fashion touch !

Take me back to my youthful days The ice cream was good and the prices are fair. So there is nothing bad about this place.

Been going here for 13 years, ice cream is fantastic

Ill start with the positives. Great people and great service. Always professional and courteous. Great hours and literally 5 minutes from my house. Now the bad. If you love ice cream, you cant go there. Spend the extra 15 minutes and go to Friendlys. My ice cream is soup by the time I get home. 5 minutes away. They suggest you bring a cooler. What a joke. I love ice cream, not cold pistachio soup. You cant even recognize it as ice cream after a 5 minute drive? Get new freezers.

I really liked their ice cream and Customer service

Great place and reasonable prices much better than Carvel.

We have been going here for a long long tIme the best!

Beautiful best icecream in new York

Lemon Pepper wings for me

Great ice cream, very fresh and not overly dense

I grew up on Long Island and always pay this great place a visit when I come back!!

Most delicious ice cream ever

Pretty good ice cream and sundae selection at good prices. Try the butter pecan with peanut butter drizzle! But place looks a bit run down and is understaffed, so the line on a busy night is out the door.

One of the best ice cream parlors on Long Island, with soft and old fashioned ice cream and both are delicious with a lot of flavor choices.

Always changing flavors of ice cream which is a great idea...

😃

This is the first time I came here. I tried the Oreo Vanilla Ice Cream and the Oreo Chocolate Ice Cream and the Cake Batter Ice Cream and it was was just tasty. The people are very friendly and are here to help. And I would most definitely come back here again.

Love you guys and your ice cream To the ice cream lovers you must come here!

Most, if not all, made on premises. Friendly staff. Offer taste of special daily flavor(s)..

I only buy ice cream from here. As the ice cream is rich, flavorful, and a homemade style. They always have various flavors, and trying new types of ice cream.

Amazing icecream Im on love, So recomend worth going friendly staff .

Great ice cream and Italian iced, everything is made on premises and they have very friendly staff. Highly recommended!

This place nails it!! Super clean, old school, one of the last places to keep the ice cream at the correct temperature, dont think that I didnt notice or was aware of that! :)

Been going there since I was a kid. The ice cream is wonderfully nostalgic

Great place awesome staffOne of the best and fresh ice cream Ive had