Authentic New york thin crust pizza!Taste as fresh as it looks.Our new favorite spot!Came in with my family of 7 ( 5 kiddos)And we were treated like family!Waitress and all staff was very kind.Even better the food was the best !We were in the mood for boneless wings but since they were out we opted for buffalo drenched chicken tenders.They did not disappointment.We also had some fries that were served topped with garlic and parm- so yummy!Pizza arrived super fast ( all 3!)Food was reasonably priced and worth every penny.We will definitely be back.
This is snowbird heaven.BIG (and authentic) New York style thin-crust pizza, by the slice or the pie. Nice enough and clean enough inside, but you can also carry out. Staff are generally polite enough and relatively efficient. Prices are pretty reasonable for the Melbourne area. As a bonus, you can even catch a beer and watch your football game there in the dining room.You transplants from New York? Go here. The rest of you, too.
This cute little Italian pizza joint was a gem that im glad we found! For what it was they hit all the marks. Good atmosphere, friendly servers, amazing food and prompt service.When we first arrived around 5P.M. there was only one person dining in and for the entire first half of our meal there was nobody else in the restaurant by the end of our meal around 615 or so the place was packed.Something I love to see when I go out to eat is servers who work together, this place delivered that, if one got to busy and saw we needed help they would come over and top off our drinks instead of waiting for our designated server to get around to us. Because of this our drinks were never empty for long, and our table was always cleared from clutter.We ordered a large variety of things to eat and were rewarded with one of my favorite things an Italian restaurant has to offer; generous portions. We mistakenly expected small portions and got more food than we could handle. Our order wasTortellini alla Italiana with Pasta E Fagioli,Gnocchi and spinach Alfredo with garlic Knotts and a 24 in cheese pizza with extra cheese and half pepperoni.Pasta e Fagioli - gentle flavor. Great balance, pleasant salty flavor from the pork.Garlic Knotts - not a highlight, good garlic flavor. Soft dough, airy interior. Still overall not bad, nice with a marinara (creamy flavor not to acidic) felt more like a roll than a knott.Tortellini alla Italiana - Tortellini had a nice bite to it, the sauce was creamy with a bold cheesyness boastong a light ham flavor. Overall Big portion.Gnocchi and Spinach Alfredo -The Gnocchi itself was light and semifirm, it had a great bite to it and it want overcooked. It came in a sauce that had a smooth spinach flavor, blends with well with the cheese sauce Another very filling big portion24 inch pizza. - its no joke, massive pizza, cheese is stringy and has a nice bite to it, good crust that isnt scratchy on the mouth, a little soggy under the crust after a couple minutes but not unpleasant. The crust is crispy, and overall a tad bit greesy. Still an excellent pizza. The server even took one of the slices back and cut it up for my daughter so we didnt have to.
We ordered the ribeye steak pizza a pepperoni pizza and calamari the pizza and the calamari was very bland no flavoring at all on any of the food decided to go with this place after seeing all the amazing reviews barely any steak on the pizza lots of onion and peppers very dissatisfied for the amount of money we spent on the order
Solid cheese pie. Big slices. Reminds me of Jersey boardwalk pizza
Im so sorry to do this but i was truly disappointed with Ny Pizza Spot.. I ordered a Margerita Pizza, I got this.. The margarita that I am used to and I am born & raised from New York, is a pizza with minimal pizza sauce with sliced tomatoes and fresh sliced mozzarella with fresh basil unfortunately this is not what I ordered and I am very upset with the margarita pizza that they are supposedly selling no where is it fresh too much sauce and that is not even mozzarella.. Truly unhappy.
We eat here often and always pick up. Usually 30 min wait time. No problem. Had a busy day so we ordered delivery. I saw the 75 min probable time. We called after 90 minutes and was told driver had just left. It’s a 6 minute drive and the driver didn’t show until 9:27…over 2 hrs. Didn’t even apologize. The staff is always friendly when we pick up. But delivery shouldn’t be available if it’s going to be 2 hours.
I used to love coming here but some time back pizza was not the same, air pockets at the crust area a couple, the cheese is not real mozzarella artificial maybe? So disappointed. Talking about 2 years back. Just missed going there.
Great pizza will definitely order when im back in Florida for vacation..!!!
Great food and great service too. This is the best pizza spot. Salads here rock!
Just got Philly cheese steak pizza and got a pepperoni with an order of calamari and the pizza had no taste at all I was surprised about all the good reviews on here it was probably the dullest tasting pizza Ive had both of them the calamari was super plain to even the breading on it definitely wouldnt recommend it especially for the price
The. Real. Deal. I’ve eaten tons of pizza in tons of states and even countries and when it comes to authentic New York style pizza it’s usually a giant miss for many places - NOT this place though, it’s definitely the real deal and an absolute knockout! The pizza is some of the best I’ve had in the south, Melbourne is lucky to have this in their back yard. GREAT PIZZA!
Moved away from NY over a decade ago, worked my way south to Melbourne, FL. Every place along the way claims they offer a NY slice but seldom live up to it. However, this slice had the size, passed the fold test (95%), got thin crust just right, and tasted good. Exactly what I was craving. But really, when someone walks in and stands there and your main guy is stuck on a call taking a massive order that just doesnt end, someone else ought to step up and at least greet, even better take the to go order. I had to be a NYer to get some service. But after that, it was smooth and quick.
Best pizza in town 👊The Buffalo chick and Mias Italian Margherita are family favorites but everything is always fantastic. We do large group orders for work also.
Excellent pizza. All the other chain type pizza shops give you the same flavor over and over. You know what it tastes like before you go pick it up or have it delivered. With new York pizza spot 😋it can be slightly different each time, but always great pizza,and its always big and loaded like new York style pizza should be.
Is it great “New Yawk” pizza? I dunno, I’m from Chicago. Is it fresh? Is the sauce tasty? Do they load it with cheese and your choice of ingredients? Is the crust really good? Yup. Undeniably so. The people who take your order are always friendly and call you by name (if you’ve ordered before) and the price is really a bargain: just had a large mushroom and onion-$15.50 out the door!It’s our twice a month pizza place and you can trust that you’ll get a good pie.
Says they deliver. But after a long hold on the phone, they say they arent doing delivery. Disappointing. Sounds like they have good pizzas. I also like seeing all of the scared, mask Nazis leaving one star reviews because their employees arent wearing masks. Makes me want to try the place out. Maybe Ill get a chance to try it in person someday and can update this review.
Really good pizza! Nice people working there. Monday and Tuesday they have a large cheer pizza (carry out only) for like $10? And its real pizza people.
Consistantly good! I love the calzones.
The only other place around here to compare it to is Brooklyn Pizza and Pasta in Rockledge. Good New York style pizza and pasta. I saw great reviews on this place so thought I would try it. I was a little disappointed in the pizza. Not really much cheese on it and it looked kind of overdone. However, the flavor was very good and the crust was not to thick, not too thin and it was crispy.I also ordered the chicken picatta. The flavor was delicious, however, the chicken looked like pounded down boiled chicken, no pan seared marks or grill marks to be found any where. Also, I might add, I ordered it to go and compared to Brooklyn Pizza and Pasta, this place was TOTALLY skimpy on the pasta on that order. It wasnt even half way up the container. At Brooklyn, they FILL the entire container with the delicious pasta and lay the grilled chicken cutlets on top.Flavor was good on everything, but presentation can make or break it! Staff was super friendly.
Amazing pizza and salads Great serviceHighly recommended
Pretty decent NY pizza was not disappointed, will def go again!
Ive never had a bad meal when Ive eaten here! I had Antipasta Salad today, excellent!
Absolutely delicious! Eating in was the right choice. The best Alfredo sauce I have ever had, and I am a big Alfredo fan. Staff is fantastic. Friendly, kind, and super helpful. We had so much food that my meal alone was enough for me to have three (3) meals out of it!!! I did order the cup of Alfredo sauce on the side extra but otherwise this all came with my meal, plus a salad. We also order garlic knots, they were Soooo good.. Fresh minced garlic on them.
The food and service is Outstanding!!! One of my parents favorite restaurants. My wife and I took them here for their 52nd Anniversary dinner. We all had the linguine Di Mare with garlic knots and a side salad. It was probably the best seafood pasta dish that I have ever enjoyed in the U.S.! Loaded with fresh seafood, aldente linguine in a white wine, garlic and olive sauce that was just amazing! My Dad said that the salad tasted like it was just harvested from the garden. The tasty garlic knots sure came in handy sopping up the broth at the end of the meal! And just before I was getting ready to ask for the check, our waitress brought us a wonderful anniversary surprise dessert! What an awesome treat for Mom and Dad! Im looking forward to returning and trying more tasty and delicious food! Highly recommend!!!
Great vegan pizza, with dairy free cheese even, best weve ever had! Found this place the day after we moved to Melbourne beach and it immediately became our pizza joint.
The best pizza I have ever had. Cooked perfectly. Went back a 2nd time and had the spaghetti and wow. A monster dish of super good pasta and the knots were good also.
Good pizza and good people. Nice little spot for a simple lunch or dinner.
Great spot for pizza, pasta, sandwiches. People who work there have always been extremely friendly! Beats the nearby chain restaurants easily!
One of the best pizza in brevard county....the closest youre going to get to New York style pizza
Just like New York pizza thin, good sauce and crispy. Ask for it crispy. 10/10 would order again..... and again...... and again.
SO DISAPPOINTED! Really very off putting here, I ordered take out and when I arrived... I was treated like I was a Martian.I had a face mask on (hello a little thing called Covid). There was not a mask on in the place. Granted I expected people eating at tables to have masks off. I didnt expect employees to be mask less. I also expected to see some sense of social distancing. I SAW NONE. We are so close to having life going back to a decent normal but we arent there yet. I would expect business owners to be wanting that.
Delicious! Good atmosphere, music, and food. Crust was good, lots of toppings, and not expensive.
Have been a local beach traveler. Decided to try this on the way back home. Delicious pizza & nice staff
GREAT FOOD try the Italian Hero, YUMMY 😋 !!!!
Excellent NY style pizza. They also serve a 24 inch pie. Many other dishes. Carry out or sit down at 7 or more tables.
I absolutely love this place and has the best gluten free pizza in Florida
We were super excited that they now offer vegan cheese so that we could have vegan pizza we dont have to make at home, however it seems the price is significantly more than a standard pie despite there only being one flavor of cheese on it. We typically get spinach and artichoke added on and take it home to add a vegan cheddar cheese and some seasoning then re-bake. It was also off putting when we ate in for the first time and the waitress didnt know what vegetables could be added to the pizza (we asked because she was taking our order before we had time to find that section of the menu), then once our pizza was out she crouched down and leaned over to talk about how she would have to try it some time while she hovered over my food (gross)Nevertheless, its at least a nice start that they offer vegan pizza !
First visit and it wont be the last. Our pizza was so good, we almost ate the whole pie. Check this place out!!
We had a little of everything and it was 100000 better than expected. The food gods sent us here on accident and we ended up coming back again!! Next time we are in town we will bring friends!!!
I have to agree with Frank in Florida in regards to not a single employee wears a mask. Seems like most Florida residents are just pretending COVID does not exist. It is people like them that are the reason we have been dealing with this pandemic for a year now.Having said that, the pizza was absolutely delicious and the staff seemed friendly despite being very busy. And I did not over pay like I have at most places.Since no one there (or anyone Florida resident) seems to care about your health and safety, I simply wear my mask, keep my distance, and tell people off when they get too close. It is worth it to get this pizza, assuming it doesnt come with an extra side of COVID.
Amazing pizza n their waitress are awesome went today n I got the chicken Parma it was good thanks to our waitress Ivy
If your homesick for great Italian and PIZZA, this is the place to go. My wife and I came for lunch after a recommendation from the aide on my bus lol. it’s in a strip mall near the Melbourne mall, cozy place employees are super friendly and the food is delicious tastes just like Nonna made it. The pizza is the best around so if your from the north this is the place to come.
The pizza was BIG and very tasty.
Favorite family place! We like their white pizza and meat pizza. Very friendly staff. Recommend all our friends and family.
Just dont plan on a time. One time order lost. On Monday and Tuesday dont ever assume it will be done when requested. Pizza is good....butLuckily Publix id next door to wait on ur order.
I was in the neighborhood and caught a slice and a soda. Good.
The Greek Salad with grilled chicken is the best around!!! Their House Italian dressing is absolutely delicious! Pair the two together, and you have the perfect combination!! Absolutely divine! Will be visiting this place again and again!!
Just ordered 1 pizza it was truly amazing !!!! for sure..the BEST pizza in PALM BAY FL!!!! Hook line and sinker.... i will definitely be ordering from you guys next time..absolutely amazing if my picky 7 yr old loves it i am so down she had about 2 slices..and the crust 2 truly truly amazing :) bravo..
It’s pains me to say this because I have a lifelong friend that owns an Italian restaurant up the street from here. They would kill me if they saw this review. NY PIZZA SPOT HAS THE BEST FOOD EVER. These guys and gals have never disappointed me or anyone that I have served their food to. This place absolutely ROCKS! I highly recommend their Square Pies. Brings me back to childhood. Everything you order will be amazing! Thank you, for always keeping it quality.
Tried several different dishes; pizza, wings, subs, salads and pasta and Ive never been disappointed. My go to pizza place.
Great pizza! The Margherita pizza is excellent.
Got their Brooklyn pizza, and it was great, loaded with all kinds of delicious meats and veggies. Would recommend to anyone with a craving for pizza.
I just ordered a to go grilled chicken caesar salad, the entire meal is amazing. The lettuce is fresh, they gave two full containers of delicious caesar salad dressing. They also give a good amount of cheese, but not too much to that it becomes unhealthy. Just enough for the flavor, with perfect crutons. The chicken has great seasoning and is cooked perfectly. It is obvious they care about their ingredients and how they prepare the food as far as presentation. The pizza is also phenomenal, the best Ive had down here since moving from New York. Id definitely recommend them to anyone, the prices are great too. They also make great baked pasta, extraordinary customer service as well. Bobby shows he really cares about his business through his staff and him personally shaking hands with all of his guests. Something you dont see much anymore.
I had to make an account just to tell you guys not to come here! I ordered a cheese pizza for my child and the amount of grease on the pizza could sink a ship! With my order I had mozzarella sticks so I was hoping they were going to be good... nope they were solid room temperature! I recommend you NOT to come here.
The food is very good. I think they forgot I was waiting there for our takeout. I waited about 20 minutes and had to ask for my food after I was told it would be a few minutes.
If you want to know what its like to eat overpriced food made by drunk dudes, check this place out. I keep giving this place another shot, but regret it every time. During several extended waits, I repeatedly observed staff slipping out to the nearby liquor store. None of the staff wear masks during the peak of a global pandemic, but this might actually be their smallest issue... They are disorganized, slow, and serve up overpriced food with small portions. Taking safety precautions for their customers with masks wont fix any of that. Considering how happy they are to rip customers off, theres no reason to expect them to care about your health and safety. 😂
So good and friendly staff!
The cheese pizza was good as was the chicken parm sub. The ravioli was horrible. Could not even eat it.
Great food. Friendly servers. Why are you against wearing masks for our protection against the Covid-19 pandemic?
The food here was good and the service was good too but none of the waiters or kitchen staff were wearing a mask. It made us feel very uncomfortable to eat inside there.
This was my favorite pasta spot but, our experience this afternoon was horrible. While eating we saw a baby roach on the wall and one under the napkin dispenser on our table. Service was poor as we waited 20 mins+ for just the check while watching our waitress on her phone most of the time. Will not return at all. All of the pizza on that glass rack has no heating lamps or any way possible to keep it out of the temperature danger zone. That can get anyone sick or worse it can be fatal to elderly or children. No one has masks on as well.
Pizza was so greasy it was un-eatable. They seem to cook with butter or something. I gave a whole pie minus 2 slices to a homeless person.
Hands down your typical white trash spot where the staff never made it past 10th grade. The food refuses to have flavor. The portions are small as all get out. I paid 3.75 for a slice a pizza that legit couldnt full up a toddler. Any positive reviews was friends or family members. Just pop in and see what Im talking about. No gloves. No masks. To call this place is Ny is a joke. At this point you might as well believe that Goodwill sells exclusive Versace!!! Unreal.
Stop right now and go get food! Outstanding customer service and phenomenal tasting food. 🤩🤩🤩 I have had just about everything on this menu and I am always fascinated by the exquisite and unique flavors. Their sauce, pizza, the chefs menu and the desserts just absolutely yum!
First time where for me the staff very friendly helpful I ordered take out the food is good yes I would definitely visit again great atmosphere I recommend this place
Im from Long island NY and Ive been to about 10 places around the area and this is by far the closest to NY pizza you can get! What makes it even better is the staff, every single one of them is super friendly the girls there greet you with smiles and ask if they can get you anything else even when you are about to leave. I looked at some of the negative reviews and Im thinking they are from locals pizza chains trying to bring their reputation down because their pizza is excellent and not greasy at all! And for that jerk saying they dont wear masks …..they do.
This is my go to pizza place! The real hidden secret here is everything else on the menu. The entree’s and pasta dishes are better than great. They taste like my Italian grandmother was helping in the kitchen. Thank you for always providing consistently great food.
Great food, large portions, and perfect service!
The waitress was awesome just like food. Loved it.❤❤❤
Every weekend I get a white pizza and a pepperoni house pies and they are always great hot and fresh
Great pizza!
Used to love this place, but it must be under new management or something because it isnt what it used to be in terms of food quality. Even worse, NO ONE is wearing masks. Hopefully they start wearing masks as Id like to come back at some point. If this doesnt change, I wont for a long time.
Good food with great service!
Ordered 2 Stromboli’s-1 with mushrooms, 1 without. Nothing in the Stromboli but pepperoni, sausage and a little cheese and the most foul, rotten tasting mushrooms ever. The dipping sauce tasted exactly like Campbell’s tomato soup directly out of the can. While we waited for our order, we noticed the folks closest to us had a pizza that looked really good, so we were hopeful. Hugely disappointed. To the women working there, pulling your mask down to your chin and speaking to guests and then packing up their leftovers with your mask down and no gloves was unbelievable to witness. It was an overall rotten experience and even worse food. We will never, ever go back and will tell anyone who may ask to just skip the place.
Dont go if youre the least bit concerned about COVID. Not one member of the staff was wearing a mask, some of the patrons were as they entered. Plenty of other places to go that care about the safety of their customer!
Great food. Awesome service
Always top service Always quality foodThis is the place I measure all others against.
Fantastic authentic Italian food at a good price! I love this place! Friendly staff, great service, wonderful food! Only reason I didnt give 5 stars is for the dining room. Dont get me wrong, its clean! Just a bit small. Overall, I definitely recommend this place!
All dishes made with 🇮🇹- loving care. Family owned. Very attentive servers. Busy place!! Also had Sunday night football games on too. ❤️💚
I ate the best margherita pizza I believe Ill ever have in my life here. Also the garlic knots were perfect, as well as the marinara dipping sauce, so glad I found this place
Linguine di mare, so delicious! Atmosphere is relaxed, and super n.y....loved this place! Definitely comming back to try a slice!
Disgusting & stale slices.
This is the closest I have eaten since I left NYC and it is AUTHENTIC.....best NY food in Florida rn!!!!!!
I don’t know what voodoo Bobby and his staff puts in their pizza but MAN was it delicious. The crust was baked to perfection in my opinion. The buffalo chicken pizza omg is amazing. This is my husband and I new and only spot for the lazy nights. AAA++ Will defiantly try other menu items as well.
Best NY style pizza around. Our food was so good. Hot and fresh. Excellent service. Large menu. New favorite place🤩