The Deli of Italy is one of my favorite spots to get a quick bite. The subs here are the bomb! They use quality A+ ingredients that are imported directly from Italy. I normally order the Qubano or F22 Raptor sub. They have such a unique and flavorful taste that I can’t get enough of. It definitely reminds me of the sub shops in NYC. Overall, I highly recommend checking this place out!

While visiting the Stauffers factory store, we asked for a good local deli as we are new to the area, she recommended Deli of Italy, stating the meats were imported from Italy. I didnt confirm that at the Deli of Italy, but can say that was the best Italian Sub/ Hoagie Ive ever had. Delicious! House dressing was lick your fingers tasty. Meats delicious.

Nice spot huge sub come hungry

If youre looking for a real taste of Italian food this is the place to go. Good Italian food is very hard to find in this County. They make all of their food fresh they slice all of their meats for their subs fresh. The staff is very very friendly. I highly suggest this restaurant

This is the place for absolutely delicious and fresh deli sandwiches

Sad, so sad. Over $16 a sub. More bread than meat. Heavy on the lettuce. What a joke. You’ll get more on your sub from subway for less. One and done. Never again...🦀

The pastrami sandwich is amazing! The service is quick and friendly. The food is always made to order and never takes too long. Thank you!

Great place to grab a SUB I would skip the sides though nothing to write home about. But seriously awesome fresh deli sandwiches. highly recommended.

Best chicken Caesar salad ever. I also love their passion fruit juice. Join the email club for deals.

Absolutely lovely staff. I went a few months ago and things were sub par. They have done a total 360! Food is amazing again. Staff is friendlier than ever! Definitely a must go place!!!!

Great food, friendly service, and an all round wonderful experience. They have the best meatball subs that I’ve ever tasted. I tried a couple other subs too and everything tastes great! Every time I go there I’m always impressed.

I couldn’t comment on the quality of meat because I barley got any! They lay the meat flat on the bread- and give once slice of each meat (for a total of 2 slices) no seasonings added to my sandwich-very basic- maybe Because I used Groupon- I’m just used to eating at Jersey Mikes- either way, WON’T be eating here again.

Great food! Awesome vegetarian options, too! if youre looking for quality food at a great price, look no further... you found it!

Awesome subs with top quality ingredients. Highly recommended.

The sandwiches are great. Well balanced flavors, good bread, they dont fall apart. They have great mozzarella also. Wished they served higher end bottled sodas. Five star sandwich deserves a better drink then a fountain soda. Just my opinion.

My husband and I stopped in on the way home. What a wonderful surprise! The food was absolutely delicious and service was fast. We will definitely come again.

Only place in York to get a gluten free sub and NOT GET SICK. My gluten eating family loves their selections as well.

Been there twice so far and both times it was a great experience. They even have the godfather sub challenge that is tough but win or lose you still win since their subs are amazing.

Everything is delicious, great quality, and looks exactly like the pictures. Also, there’s always great customer service. 😁

The staff greeted us, was very friendly, our food came extremely quickly. The Qubano was definitely one of the best Ive ever had. I will be going back for sure.

My hoagie was really good. Good roll, good meats.

Okay as far as food. Their food is actually really good. I would give them 5 stars. Now the reason I only am giving one star and most likely never eating there again. They now use blue gloves to keep their hands clean, not to keep the food clean. I actually saw one of the employees walk into the bathroom come back out not change their gloves and start cutting turkey in a tray. So thats disgusting!!! No doubt if they are that open about it. I am guessing it happens a lot. My favorite thing to eat.. turkey sub 🤢🤢🤢

Best subs in York. Friendly people. Good service. Highly recommend

Their antipasto salad used to be amazing and consistent!!! Over the past few months every time I’ve ordered I’ve gotten different ingredients. Once it was spinach (YUCK!) this time it was iceberg. It used to be mixed greens (YUM!). They keep changing the toppings as well sometimes you get olives, banana peppers, sweet peppers, tomatoes ect in various combinations never knowing what will actually be on it. The only thing consistent is the onion. I also think the amount of meat has decreased.

Very fresh everything was bloody delicious and I would highly recommend it to everyone big portions and good flavors

Wife and I both had the Chef Salad with Ranch dressing, just amazing with wonderful freshness and taste. Outstanding experience..!!! Very clean establishment including the restrooms; this place is a keeper...

Best subs in York. Worth the very little extra you pay for quality ingredients and first class preparation and service. Good food and a smile; who can ask for more?

Been here a few months ago and everyone was very friendly and helpful.

It has good sandwiches. Not over the top but still good.

Best grilled chicken caesar salad in town!! Both of my picky kids LOVE this salad! Its the easiest way for me to greens in them. Its the dressing, its so good!! They are always friendly and accommodating! Last year when I couldnt find mortadella locally for a party they sold me some from their stock. We also love the antipasto salad. My kids, of course, love the canollis. Excellent quality and service every time!!!

My new favorite! My food was so good! I got the spicy Italian hoagie. The man at the counter was very nice as well. For being busy, my hoagie was still made in less than 5 minutes. The meats are amazing! The dressing really topped it all off. The whole thing is paired together very well. Definitely worth a try if you are thinking about it.

I love the owner. He always goes out of his way for his customers.

Their subs are actually amazing 11/10 so effing good

Mama Mia is the best sub, bar none. Great place and food.

Best cold subs in the county. The commitment to quality is very evident by the ingredients they use.

Always great subs. Also have gluten free rolls for subs for anyone with allergies.

Had the Italian sub and a peice of cake vary good

Ive been a regular customer of theirs since 2007. Theyre Italian hoagies are amazing. Fresh meats and cheeses made into Perfect, mouthwatering combinations. I still go in there and cant decide which one to pick. Theyre all so good! The quality has only gone up and its a friendly, clean atmosphere. If youre looking for somewhere new, start here! Ps if you like hot sauce ask for their homemade sauce 🤤

One of the best subs Ive ever had. Did not disappoint

Best gluten free bread I have ever had! So soft, no rough texture like.most other gf breads. Thank you for great food!

Great food. Great service.

The. Feel was like being back in the Bronx or Jersey. The just do it right old world style.

Great food, great service, friendly people and atmosphere and they make their own teas!!

Quality ingredients. Nice folks. Silencer sauce.

Great food and pastries and very inexpensive

The best subs start with the best bread and this has the best sub rolls in the county

Best Italian subs in Lancaster and York county

Nice cozy place to stop for a bite to eat. Great italian meats and fresh homemade menu items.

Amazing food, good prices!!

We were driving between Maryland and New York and stopped by for lunch. While I dislike delis and the types of flavors were very predictable (pretty common for areas that are further from major cities), I was pleasantly surprised by the homemade drink offering, quality ingredients and the vast portion size -- one Il Diablo sandwich fed me and my guest. Even though I dislike these types of sandwiches and subs, they do a good job doing what they do; while I wouldnt go out of my way to visit, I wouldnt be against stopping here again if we had another road trip.

Great subs in what I would classify as an authentic style... Very fresh ingredients and quick service!

Food was ok I had the bacon double cheddar (which had no bacon, weird) wife had the meatball sandwich. The cheesteak was mediocore and the meatballs were frozen. They were out of most of the side items only had potato salad and chips. The cups didnt have lids that fit and multiple drinks options were out. Service was friendly and pretty standard on speed. Would have given 2 stars but the deli meat sandwich options looked like they could be good. Overall if your looking for a lunch meat sandwich give it a try but cheeseteak or meatballs go somewhere else.

Great local business, friendly service and fantastic food.

Not your average sandwich shop. This place has flavors so bold that they literally smack your tastebuds.

Best imported italian lunch meat 10/10

Il Diablo with made in house Ghost Pepper sauce was delicious. Burnt my face off. Loved it, getting another tomorrow.

Love it there, second review, love you guys !

Great sandwiches!

New Yorker is delicious

Antipasto salad was great ! And the service was great too

Great sandwiches. Some of the menu was not available though.

Messed up a lasagna beyond recognition. And although at the time they advertised sliced lunch meat to go, they wouldnt do it.Never went back.

Good fun, fun lunch date with my gf!

I dont always write reviews, but when I do, Its either because I hate it, or I love it....this falls under the love category. That cuban sandwich, the Cubano....wowza. This is NOT an authentic Cuban sandwich, but one that is influenced by it...er, or, more like a sandwich that is made to honor a classic, authentic Cuban sandwich. Man O Man O Man, its good.

Hits the spot everytime! Def the hidden gem of York.

Best subs in town

Best damn sammiches in York. Period.

This place is amazing. Like better than panera.

Everything is delicious, try the just one.

Love their subs!

Food was average. Smaller portions. Nothing horrible, but not amazing either.

Fell in love from day one

Italian Rose salad was delish!

Best hoagies in central PA

Best sandwich in york

Excellent, quick, food is top quality. Friendly too!!!

Yummy, good hot sauce

Good chicken wraps

Wonderful food

14 bucks for a 12 inch sub.

Dee-double-fresh-&-delicious!!!

Great sub shop

Their food is like a meal at the Italian grandmas house!

Best deli in York!

Liked it.

Awesome!

This place sucks

The food is to die for!!! 💀☠