I must say that I had the most pleasant and wonderful experience at the Coin Shop. I had some things that I was interested in getting evaluated and sell. I met with Anthony and I cant say enough about how much time he took to review what I had taken, explained the reason for the value of some of my items and also the coins I had taken in. I have dealt with other coin and jewelry shops and Anthony is the most honest one I have ever dealt with. I highly recommend the Coin Shop to anyone looking for an honest place to take your items. I most definitely will go back again.

Anthony met with us for an hour and gave us a very good review of the coins that we had. We feel that he gave us an honest amount in return for the coins that we brought to him. Great to do business with!! We will definitely refer friends and family! We will return to him when we have more to have reviewed.

Ive been to The Coin Shop twice to have some gold tested. Absolutely professional and helpful. Cannot recommend them enough. Although I have not made any purchases I wouldnt buy from anyone else. Its family business that treats you like family. No BS. Just honest truth.

Anthony was wonderful to work with. An absolutely pleasant experience. He took the time to explain what he was doing throughout the appraisal process and was very friendly with conversation outside of our appraisal. He coupled his appraisals with secondary samples of similar items to back up his estimations. There was absolutely no pressure or stress at any point in our experience with Anthony. We will most certainly recommend The Coin Shop whole-heartedly and without hesitation.

Anthony was really amazing just very good care of us was very helpful and very very very honest I have never met a broker that was so honest before. I will definitely be going back there I don’t think I’ll ever shop at another coin shop. You can’t get honesty with brokers like that. Thank you Anthony for all your help today look forward to seeing you soon.My nephew is very happy with what he got today and my son will be very happy with collecting started for him

The store owner, Anthony, always pays the highest prices for silver and gold in the area. Super nice guy who will explain the intricacies of the market and whatever you might be buying or selling. This guy is a straight shooter, and I highly recommend this shop to buy or sell precious metals. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Tony was honest and helpful. This is definitely the best place in Fort Myers to buy/sell gold.

I am very impressive at the knowledgable service I received. I am a new customer and I loved that the offer on my gold was done by calculating in real time gold prices! The experience was not only painless, but I received a great deal and purchased a pair of earrings at a great price! I highly recommend The Coin Shop for all of your silver, gold and coin needs.

Great experience. Very knowledgeable owner. Thank You for the great service and free coin holder.

The coin shop was recommended to me by a friend of mine. So I went in with some scrap gold not expecting to get much. I was pleasantly surprised that the price of gold has gone up. Its a beautiful store. Very clean and they had lots of things to choose from. Like silver coins to gold necklaces. I will definitely go back.

The price of gold is the price of gold anywhere you go. But if you appreciate dealing with someone who is straight forward and honest then The Coin Shop is for you my friends.Im new to the coin game and had an issue with some gold pandas that three different shops couldnt figure out and didnt want to deal with. Tony went way out of his way to have them tested for me and kept me informed during the entire process. It felt like that cousin/friend who always has your back. Thank you for the awesome experience!

Been there several times and very professional and honest. Have recommend many friends and family members to see Anthony which he explains everything in detail. Highly recommend if u have any gold, silver or coins Anthony will tell u the full value of the items.

Super up front and honest! I sold gold here and was provided a great value. I was very happy with the service and atmosphere. Highly recommend!!

Honest, efficient and knowledgeable. Found the shop last month and plan to visit weekly. Sold several coins last week for a fair price. Relaxing atmosphere and a great place to spend some time. 50 year collector/stacker.

Anthony at The Coin Shop was very knowledgeable and friendly - he gave us a very thorough assessment of our family coin collection and great advice for its caretakers! The store is very well laid out with so many nice collectible coins and great jewelry. Definitely will visit again!

Enjoyed coming into your store, I was treated very well and was paid a very good price for my coins. Will probably be back to do more business when I am in the area. Thank you so much.

Tony is very knowledgeable and welcoming. My son and I have recently started coin collecting and he has been a great guide. Highly recommend!

Outstanding customer service, great prices and good selection. Will be back

Anthony at The Coin Shop came highly recommended by our estate attorney. He was fair honest and thorough with his assessment. We were very pleased with our payout.

This is by far the best coin/jewelry shop i’ve ever encountered. I’ve already been here a few times & every time it’s a great experience. When you walk in you are greeted with a warm smile & friendly hello from Anthony, his wife, & daughter. Anthony always gives me fair prices every single time whether I’m buying or selling. Now that I’ve found this place I’ll never go to the other over priced shops ever again.

Great shop nice selection of coins and jewelry. Tony was very fair and fun to deal with. He offered me more for my items then the other shop. Highly recommend weather you are buying or selling.

I never leave reviews but had to take the time to tell all about my experience with the coin shop.Anthony Knows his stuff. He took the necessary time to research my entire coin collection showing me and telling me what he would pay and sell my coins for. He even took the time to show me detailed listings of what my coins would bring at auction. I was very comfortable selling my collection and did not feel like I was getting low balled or ripped off like I felt when dealing with other shops in town. Highly recommend!

Very friendly nice safe secure atmosphere. A true mom and pop shop. Owner and his wife greeted me with a big hello and welcome to the coin shop. I was very impressed and happy with the amount I was paid for my gold and diamond jewelry.

I shopped around they paid me the most in cash not a check like other shops. Will be back nice selection of coins. Anthony was very upfront and honest showed me all the numbers.

Tony is awesome very knowledgeable always has unique items and is the go to place in SWFL in a very safe clean location!

It was a pleasure speaking with Anthony this morning! I Appreciate his honesty & education on coins & currency...Thank You Anthony, lll see you again soon

Very friendly,knowledgeable and helpful especially since I had never sold jewelry before. Process was easy and safe environment

Manager was very helpful and easy to deal with. I purchased several coins and got a great price. I would definitely return.

Best shop in town. They pay the most and very friendly. Happy with what I was paid. Will definitely be back.

I had a great experience here. Anthony was very Knowledgeable and answered all the questions I had. I’ll be definitely coming back here again for more coins!!

Just ordered another chain. I love this shop Tony is good people always treats me right. Best jewelry and prices. I dont have to drive to Miami to get my links anymore.

Very knowledgeable and great deals. Very honest and helpful. Will definitely be coming back any time I need any type of jewelry.

Great prices and great service will definitely be back. Thank you Tony.

This guy is really good very nice and honest prices,made me deal very comfortable.

Great honest customer service. Large variety of items. Very knowledgeable. Great store to shop.

Great all-round experience. It was a pleasure to deal with owner Anthony. He is knowledgeable and above all, you get a fair deal. Looking forward to deal with him again.Dr. Axel

Awesome very professional best coin shop I ever been to.

Great customer service, wide variety, great deals. Good shop all around

Great shop! Pays the most. Very satisfied.

Great place with fair trades. Nice selection of beautiful antiques and sports memorabilia. My new favorite shop!

Very nice owner, I would highly recommend him.

Fantastic selection of coins and jewelry. Great service and great overall experience. Well done!

Very nice guy had great prices and taught me the history of the coins he had and I had.TIP:Buy his silver and gold he has the best price of all the coin shops and pawn shops out there

It is a beautiful new shop! It has a great collection of coins and a very knowledgeable and professional owner.

Awesome will go back sometime when ready to get more coins or rounds I like to support the local shops

Great service, learned a lot and best coin shop in town!

My favorite shop. Tony is the best.

Dont sell your jewelry anywhere else!!!!! This store is so welcoming and beautifully lit. Honest, friendly and down to earth owner gave me top dollar for my jewelry.

Excellent honest service, highly recommended!!!

Really great service!