I enlisted G&H to cater my 40th birthday event at my home. Everything was top notch!! Once I filled out the event builder on their website, Paola got back to me the next day and offered to put together a menu. She was able to put together a menu that included stationary yet socially polite appetizers, buffet dinner and socially polite desserts. Paola was very accommodating with the minor adjustments I had to make due to a food allergy. Aside from the food being well presented and tasting delicious- the most amazing part of the experience was the catering staff!! Known as “The A Team,” Astrid, Michael, Craig and were courteous, attentive and efficient in their service. It truly added to the success of the event and I look forward to working with them in future!! Thank you!

Despite the obscure and nondescriptive name of this delicious and wonderful deli, this store is worth going out of your way to visit! At least three counter displays of various chicken dishes, tuna, mozzarella, coleslaw, and vegan and vegetarian choices as well. Helpful staff. From the street this could be a plant store selling seeds, or a place that sells soups - who knows. They could rename it Garelick and Herb Delicatessen. Im so glad when I visited my father in the Rye New York area from San Diego, that he took me by this place twice, and it provided us scrumptious wondrous lunches and dinners!

The food is delicious! We ordered from their Thanksgiving menu and thoroughly enjoyed our meal! We would definitely order again.

Great food, with a very friendly staff.

Ordered lunch from here via Seamless today. There were pieces of plastic in my sandwich. Not sure if they sliced the deli meat and got some of the wrapper in there or what. Fast forward 3 hours and I am on bathroom break #4 with the sweats and shakes. Pretty sure I am going to pass on them from here on out.

Best around

Surely a place worth stopping by, the food is awesome and fresh, the prices are fair and it is regularly clean there. Keep up the good work.

Garelick & Herbs is a wonderful place. The food is varied and consistently delicious. The staff is helpful, friendly, and efficient. I have not had an event catered by them, but visiting the store for coffee or lunch is always at pleasant experience.

Great selection fresh salads nice sandwiches

Kind of hard to find, but not a bad little deli to grab a snack. I would rate this place higher if the food were more consistent. Overall just OK.

Cute place, lots to look at, but dont wait for service. Cafe seating, but order and pick up before you sit down. Help congregates behind counter and eventually looks up to help. A little frustrating, but the coffee is good.

Update as of 4/26/2018: just bought a delicious iced tea but moldy piece of crumb cake at G&H. So unfortunately lowering my rating and recommendation from 5 stars due to this unfortunate transaction._____________________Really enjoyed the takeout catering for our pool party. Tasty sandwiches, pasta salad, tossed salad, etc. Convenient, flexible, a little pricy, but our favorite of the nearby options.

Funky Little Deli type place the food is amazing though its not cheap but everything Ive had from this place has been excellent

Upscale place with easy parking. Not easy to spot when driving by on Post Road.

Expensive, Bad service, but decent food

Best salad bar

Probably best sandwich place in Greenwich avenue.

Thanksgiving menu List all available food for thanksgiving.

Really gross. Just ordered soup and there were inedible chunks of uncooked turkey skin all throughout. Horrible. Had to throw it away.

Excellent food, great customer service & a very homely & welcoming enviornment. Stop by & give the food a try, youll be back !!!

Excellent food outstanding service

Best yogurt and granola ever!

Great gourmet food

A must stop in

You pay to dollars for quality.

Pricey