Great experience. Went there to get used youth hockey gear for my 5 year old daughter. Good enough selection that we outfitted her with everything she needed. And when I say used it was barely used. Really good quality equipment at ~30% the cost of new. While we were there we were able to get a downhill ski set up that was roughly as expensive as 2 rentals! I will be going back for future hockey or skiing needs.Sales associated Troy was great as well. Help me find a few items that were a little more hidden.Their resale policy makes the low prices even better knowing you can sell it back to them later.

Staff is very knowledgeable and the best place in Ithaca for all your hockey needs! I’ve also purchased plenty of golf equipment and been very satisfied. Highly recommend!

Found what I was looking for off-season fair prices nice store great selection of products

Theres a lot of nifty finds in here and typically can be had at a reasonable price. Ive gotten many football cleats here that were gently worn. Good selection of hockey equipment too. Very friendly and helpful associates running the place as well.

They have a lot of options and the staff was attentive and personable however pretty pricey for used items.

Great store, good deals on ski gear and more!

We have always had great experiences here. Their selection of new and used equipment covers a wide spectrum of budgets and they are very helpful. We outfitted my son for snowboarding there and when we couldnt find the right length board *with* bindings they were quick to perform a binding swap so we could get exactly the gear we needed at a very affordable price. I would highly recommend Instant Replay!

Helpful proprietor and big selection.

Walked in just to take a look around and walked out with a new pair of skates four pairs of socks and a hat.

This place is the perfect example of how a good staff can build business loyalty. The main guy who has been there forever is great, and he seems to pick good people to work with. The amount of money this place has saved my family in terms of sports equipment costs is crazy! highly recommend.

Best sports store in the County!

Great place. Last time I visited was before the pandemic.

This place is great! Larry was extremely helpful and the prices were unbeatable. I literally travel from Rochester, NY to come check out their stuff. As a father of two little girls that play hockey (and goalie) this place is a life saver.

We came in for some used ice skates for our son. The staff took us directly to the skates and recommended a size. My husband easily laced and assisted our son and we found a good fit. The selection is great and the staff seem to know what they have and do not have.

Great customer service and amazing deals on overstock stuff that the big guys couldn’t sell. Got a brand new callaway 3 wood for $90 amazon still had them for $269. Can’t recommend enough.

I have baught more amazing used ski equipment here. Equipment that I couldnt afford when it was new. Primarily ski boots. Because they had so much stock on hand, I got a particular brand of rear entry ski boot, that they just dont manufacture anymore! But thanks to this store I got mine!All this and at a very reasonable price. In the day these particular name brand boots would have fetched almost $300.00 new. Mom and Dad I wish this store would have been around when I was a kid. Youll be able to equip your son and or daughter with reasonably priced used sporting gear.If saving bucks isnt your thing, Instant Replay Sports has new gear too! Tell them you know Jack and I sent you! Enjoy the savings and good for you supporting your kids in whatever their sporting endevors are! At least theyre not sitting on the coach stuffing their little faces or plopped in front of the computer. Myself I have enjoyed the sport of down hill or Alpine skiing for over 45yrs! Good luck may your kids be properly equipped and safe!

Top notch! Good selection of sporting essentials, great staff, and good prices.

Great sports equipment at wonderful deals. I have purchased ski, golf, tennis and hockey gear at deals that cannot be matched. This place is absolutely awesome!!!

Great selection of new and used sports equipment. Found a great pair of kids roller blades in like new condition for a fraction of the price at other stores.

Excellent service and incredibly quick turn-around on restringing a lot of badminton rackets. Great work!

Ron is great and really knows his stuff -- also, hes looking for what will work for you, not just the most expensive package. Lots of great deals here!

The sports store has a good mix of new and used gear. Better than other box stores that sell sporting equipment. Staff is friendly and helpful.

Great place to get new and used sporting goods. Great friendly knowledgeable staff.

Bought my snowboard with boots, a helmet and goggles, and so far happy with my budget beginner snowboarder set.

Best place in town for great deals on used gear!

Great place to find discount items new and used.

Great selection of both new and used items at great prices.

Awesome store, awesome staff, great place for sports equipment.

Nice sports equipment place

Always veryHelpful!

This place is great 👍

Every sport

Thanks!