Very polite and helpful staff! Decent size store. Lots of sweets and cakes, many ice cream flavors. The Key Lime Pie ice cream was delicious! We bought all kinds of local made sweets for our friends. They also have an amazing collection of clothes and accessories for sale! Our experience shopping was great, we ended up buying everything we need in this store.

No lie, my entire party agreed this was the best piece of Key Lime Pie we tried in Key West! It was such a happy moment. I don’t think I even had time to take a picture of it because we ate it so fast. Delish- just the right amount of sour/tangy lime and not overboard, and a good crust and whipped cream, it was marvelous. The shop itself is very cute as well, they actually sell a lot of Kermits Key Lime shop products from down the road which I found interesting. I enjoyed how they had a lot of Ernest Hemingway pictures up on the walls- the hero of Key West! They also have ice cream and coffee for those other cravings you may have. Highly recommend the KLP!

The slice of Key Lime pie was good however the girl behind the counter made us feel like we were invading her sanctuary. You could tell she truly hated her job. Zero personality, no greeting, no offer to assist, and just frowns all around.The shop itself was poorly stock with Pies, just slices of 5.00 🥧. I would have thought there would have been different types or flavors of the famous Pies but non were in appearance. Go elsewhere of want to feel like your business is appreciated.

The key lime pie was FANTASTIC!!! I have to tell you, the flavor was out of this world. My friends loved it and it looked so beautiful! Want to visit again!

Key lime pie is delicious! Friendly service. hit or miss on friendliness. Guy was friendly but on another day girl was not very personable. But then again most of our experiences here at key west have not been very friendly

Possibly the rudest shop in Key West! The girl working here was beyond rude & than EXPECTED a tip. My 6 year old niece dropped her key lime pie & was clearly sad. We had just bought numerous food items for all the other kids with us. Instead of replacing her slice of pie she made us buy another one.Attitude all around.Bring your business somewhere else, to someone who will appreciate it.

Its ok, but tastes VERY familiar....like Edwards. Staff was very friendly, but the Key Lime Pie was meh. Nothing fancy.

The shop was cute and pie was good but as a few others said, girl behind counter was very unfriendly. She did not smile once and snapped at my husband about how many forks he needed.. We found most businesses in area to be very friendly and welcoming. This shop might want to consider nicer counter help.

The woman helping was not very friendly. Luckily, we are from Philly where people are not friendly either. They had a lot of key lime products and the pie was pretty good. I will be going back to try the ice cream tomorrow.

Amazing store, nice product!Very recommend!

Wasnt the best key lime pie especially 4.99 a slice definitely not worth it!

Simply really good key lime pie. Grabbed a whole pie. YUMMY!!

I’ve been recommended to try this place by a colleague from work in Phoenix. WOW!!! You can sample here almost everything, they do have them - so nice! I liked so much the ambiance of this store and the girls at the counter were so welcoming and cute. They have a huge diversity of key lime delicatessens- Key lime cookies, candies, cakes, coolers, chocolates, ice creams and more. The Kermit’s pie and pie on the stick is a must to try - so delicious, LOVE it! Will go again for sure when be back to Paradise. Would definitely recommend this place to everyone who’s visiting Florida keys.Cheers!

Excellent key lime pie! I wish we had bought two. Will definitely see them again next time in Key West!

This wasn’t on our plan but noticed it while walking on the street. I wanted to try key lime pie in key west and accidentally stumbled on this place which had best key lime pie. I have never had key lime pie before so I cannot compare but it was delicious. Small cozy place which has few chairs outside. We sat outside eating our pie and drinking tea. Our son had ice cream. We saw few chickens running around which reminded me of my childhood back in India where chickens were just part of life in villages.

Kind folks with sweet treats

The key lime pie was not flavorful at all. We had much better pie at other locations in the Keys. The lady working the shop was not at all friendly. She didnt smile or speak.

The girl was super nice. Love it.

Quest for the perfect Key Lime takes me Southernmost Key Lime Shop. I actually got it to go. Simple packaging. Larger than average amount of whipped cream. Smooth texture and a great blend of sweet and tart. Crust was decent, not chewy and good flavor. The more I contemplate the better I think it was.

They do have GF key lime pie!!! Finally a place that does ;)

Good keylime pie. A small $5 slice as per usual.

Their key lime pie is creamy and well balanced. My familys favorite.

Nice little local shop. The key lime pie was was really good and we also had a chocolate shake which was also good. The Proprietor is very nice and the shop is cute with a lot of key lime themed things to purchase. We will stopping back by before we leave to pick up some more pies to go.

Wow... key lime pie from this place is the best Ever! If you’re in the area you need to stop here. A bonus are key lime pie candies. I was so happy to find them after we got them as a treat from the local escape room.

This was a great stop to catch some AC, grab a cold drink, and enjoy a bevy of key lime flavored and related treats.

The best Pie in my Life!!! IT is very delicios Pie!!! Great Service!!!

Pricy, but very good!

THE most delicious key lime pie ive ever had in my life. Im not a fan of key lime pies, i dont usually order them as desert. But since i was here in key west, i decided to give it a shot and it was the best decision of the day. It was amazing. Every taste bud was happy. Very easy going atmosphere, really nice to eat the key lime pie on the porch looking at the interesting people.

Great pies and service. Was able to sit and enjoy our pies inside in the shade.

No bake key lime pie is something, Next time will try the classic one.

Such a great place to dine at! Customer service was real great along with the place being very tidy and neat. Tried the key lime pie and it was just wonderful! Had some other desserts also and they were all great!

The pie was ok but they had too many non local prepackaged items for sale.

My first key lime pie so far, so different from the cheeze cake but it looks the same. Yummy . Hope we will stop by tomorrow

Not much to say except come here if you want the best key lime pie in the country. The food taste great and the costumer service is out of this world. The food is prepared in house and is quick and fresh. I will be stoping by here again next time I’m in the area.

Awful tasting pie. Grainy and disgusting. The coconut Pattys even more disgusting. Recommend keep on walking

This Key lime shop is just greatt! Customer service is amazing and the key lime pie is exquisite along with the sweets and coffee that I’ve tried during the time I was there. Something else I really liked about this place is that everything was fresh and the place was clean and quiet.

Great key lime pie.

Wonderful key lime pie.

Good key lime pie

If you didn’t drink their coffee and eat the best key lime pie in the US please read this and go there!! The fresh bean coffee is delicious and the key lime pie is heavenly. Greetings from The Netherlands.

Great pie.

Yum. At first, I thought the pie slice was too small, but its so rich that its the perfect size. Leaves you wanting just a bit more but not so much that you actually go get another slice... until the next day.

Beside the delicious Key Lime Pie, they have a large variety of all kind of yummy Key Lime stuffs: candies,ice cream, chocolates, dressings, taffies, biscuits etc. If you want to bring your loved ones some really nice souvenirs from Key West, this will be the place to get them. Did I mention that the girls beside the counter are super helpful and knowledgeable?

Nice piece of pie. No complaints

Great key lime pie!

Small slice size but not too small considering how sweet it is. Other interesting lime products as well.

Fantastic key lime pie in a cute shop. Dont get the chocolate dipped, get the real key lime pie.

Visiting once again for amazing key lime pie❤️

The pie is very rich and very delicious. The staff is wonderful as well

Was not my favorite place very expensive for the quality of the food

Yummy key lime pie. My kids and I approve.

Key lime pie crust was a bit grainy and the lime was delicious

The Best Cake in my Life!!! Super customer Service!!!YOU are The Best!!!

A must do if you are in Key West!

Not worth it. They just sell Kermits pies.

Yum;!!!!!

Visited in December 2019. As the name suggests, it sells key lime pie and related goods, iced coffee, and so on. I had a very satisfying and interesting experience of enjoying a key lime pie in Key West at a key lime shop. I was satisfied with the essential taste.

I think Lime pie is moderately sweet and sour, and tastes good, but you have to take a small bite. This is a must-eat when you come to Key West.

Breakfasts and snacksGo and choose something sweet and different

Totally disappointing.Very unpleasant home of the waitress. She did not smile at us once. She was dry and brittle.I have never tasted such a bad lemon pie! It was a lemon or sugar pie?Much too sweet ..... and the taste of lemon was almost absent.And no table to eat ...In summary Home as bland as the pie.To avoid.

Super Key Lime Pie. Definitely try if you are in Key West.Personally, Im not so into cake in the heat, but a key lime pie is a great refreshment.Greetings from Switzerland