Great ice cream and shakes. The extreme milkshakes are $13. They are delicious and fun!

Wow!! The extreme milkshakes are the real deal. Theyre also $13 apiece, and more calories than you need in an entire day, so youll probably want to split one.We got the smores extreme shake and it was awesome. Honestly, though, the toppings are fun, and its a great treat, but next time we go Im getting a regular shake. The actual milkshake was the best part. Delicious!

The ice cream presentation was seriously beautiful, but the strawberry cheesecake rolled ice cream was gross. I ate part of it and tossed it. I was very disappointed. The restaurant was also pretty dirty. I wont be back.

Super overpriced and they don’t even taste good. The cheesecake was horrible and my shake barely had any flavor. The cookies were dry, cookie dough tasted good but the shake tasted like fake chocolate syrup. Definitely won’t be returning. $26 for these little shakes is ridiculous. They aren’t that “special”.

The extreme shakes are very unique and look great for pictures, but I was disturbed by how filthy the place was.I took a picture of the sticky looking, crumb covered counter that peoples desserts are prepared on... that cheesecake slice they plopped there was part of my order.Youd think with their prices that they would be a bit more sanitary and professional. They do not care about their image, so it makes me wonder if they care about food safety.If they present themselves like that to the public, how horrifying is it behind the counter?I wouldve taken more pictures but I didnt want people to think I was taking pictures of them. Literally every table was sticky and covered in crumbs.There were many teenage workers behind the counter. Many of them were standing around when I walked in. At least 1 of them could have cared enough to clean.I personally will not come back to this place. I can pay less for higher quality elsewhere.

The extreme shakes have extravagant, artistic, and tasty toppings, but the milkshakes themselves were bland and very underwhelming - not at all worth $13. The rolled ice cream tasted great, but it was either cold and hard, making it difficult to eat, or runny/melted. There was no in between. This is a cool place to visit once, but we would not go back.

Absolutely love Extreme Creamery! Love the decorations they always have out, the ice cream is amazing, and someones always waiting to serve you.

We got the buckeye and pumpkin rolled icecream and it was the best ice cream we have ever ate before!! Absoutely phenomenal flavor and the workers were very nice.

It was so good!!! We got strawberry cheesecake milkshake, oreo milkshake and kids bowl of cotton candy ice cream. Everyone loved there cold treat. Quality, flavor and size all great!!! Look out because we will be going frequently!!!

Brought my daughter here for her birthday and she Loved the extreme shake. She got the birthday cake and it was so cute lol her bestfriend got the strawberry cheesecake.

Rolled ice cream and extreme shakes are their main attractions. Delicious doesnt even begin to describe it. We stopped by to try it out and stayed to watch Cars on the TV. Excellent rolled ice cream, I wish I would have watched how they do it, but it was a bit crowded.

I had never heard of rolled ice-cream before, and I have never really been a huge ice cream fan but Extreme Creamery has the best rolled ice-cream! It’s AMAZING! It’s like nothing you have ever tasted before. If you are looking for a new and unique ice-cream experience you will love this place. So many different flavors and combinations. Just watching the “freezing and rolling” process is a fun and interesting experience in itself. They also have very popular and gigantic shakes perfect for any celebration. The owner is also an awesome guy and we should all be happy to support our local businesses! I definitely recommend everyone checking them out :-)

I got the cookies and cream extreme shake. It was GREAT! Didnt know there was a place like this near me. Can also get regular milkshakes, but why would you?!? 😁

The aesthetic of the milkshakes are cute. However; we ended up getting three different extreme milkshakes. One stawbee milkshake, one peanut butter chocky, and a birthday cake. The birthday cake was disgusting. Another couple in the creamery bought theirs, took one drink and tossed it in the trash. Its 50/50 itll be good.

Even though we had to wait 2 hours, it was well worth the wait. We got know, talk to & chill with some awesome people. We met & ate our deserts with Maddie & Zoe. The deserts were AMAZINGLY crafted. We also got to discuss future business with the owner who was really cool. We WILL be back AGAIN.

The best ice cream place weve ever gone to. Their extreme milkshakes are amazing!!

Very well decorated and beautiful looking but overall taste of the milkshake wasnt all that good best was the toppings not worth the price tbh

This place is awesome! Love the crazy shakes and the rolled ice cream! Will go back often!

Really nice place and staff. There was a little bit of a wait but it was worth it. Will definitely be back soon

I went here during the pandemic and purchased the extreme oreo shake. Presentation was on point from all pictures you can find online. Everything on top of the shake was really good, but the shake itself was pretty average. Still tasted good though. Also some of the tables werent very clean. Would probably go here again.

Great place to get ice cream

Great local place that serves not only the current fancy rolled ice cream craze but also the traditional hand dipped favorites in cones or cups or as a yummy sundae. If you are willing to spend a little more they have some pretty great looking extreme shakes that could easily be shared with a loved one! ❤️

Got the peanut butter lovers rolled ice cream and it was superb! The rest of the menu looked pretty damn good too, we will definitely be back! Just make sure to get there promptly when they open, ot didnt take but maybe 20 minutes and the line was already to the door

Delicious ice cream and helpful employees. This is not a quick ice cream place unless youre wanting a scoop of normal icecream. They pour the cream on the chillers right in front of you and you get to watch as it all comes together right in front of your eyes. Such a cool experience and delicious as well! Will definitely go back.

Awesome place to get shakes.

But of an issue seen my order go to another person explained it was mine and worker told me this was the other customers. Once customer walked away I explained everyone else had gotten their orders and mine was before theirs. Everyone in my party was done without me getting mine at all. Asked again about my order. Was told it was made and given. I explained yes to someone else. They finally made my order. It was good but I did ask to speak with manager. Never came out

Very unique presentation. Great ice cream concept! I really enjoyed watching my order get made. Eating it was even better.

We waited about an hour but it was so good, would definitely come back again

Got the ice cream rolled waffle bowls they do make the ice cream by hand there it takes a little longer to wait for it but its well worth it very rich very creamy very flavorful and theyre not kidding when they say extreme when it comes to the shakes as you can see in the pictures there was a long wait however it is a new place in the area and it was well worth the wait I would most certainly go back if I was traveling in the area again staff was great and theyve tried their darndest to get people in and out as quick as possible.

It was amazing and the upmost delicious...

Four stars because the artistic creativity is super cool and unique. The ice cream flavor is not special. The look of the Extreme Shakes is awesome. This is probably one of the best places to take an ice cream loving kid for a unique birthday treat.

Everyone was nice. Service fast. Even helped make my son laugh and smile to keep a tantrum from happening 10/10

I’m not typically one to leave bad reviews or complain buuuutttt…….My family of 6 was beyond excited to try this place. The extreme shakes look delicious. And the toppings were pretty good. Everything else was horrible. Customer service…horrible. Cleanliness…disgusting. Milkshake…absolutely disgusting and the milk may have even been spoiled. It was a combination of milk with cottage cheese at the bottom.We waited more than 20 minutes while 10 “workers” stood around and tried to get out of doing any work at all. No big deal, I realize customer service is a thing of the past so I wouldn’t really complain about that if it weren’t for everything else that happened. While my wife’s death shake sat after being made, a multitude of flies were landing in it. I asked if it was part of my order so she could get to it before the flies are it all to which I received a snotty answer, eye roll and then was talked about amongst the workers for even asking. Then we finally got our milkshakes. Impressive looking yes. And the whip cream, and other toppings were pretty good. Then we started drinking our $13 milkshake and quickly realized it tasted terrible. After taking the lid off to examine the situation, I realized it was pretty much milk. I then pulled the straw out to see what was thick at the bottom and realized it was some kind of cottage cheese looking stuff. I’m assuming this was spoiled milk based on the original taste and texture. I wouldn’t recommend this place to my worst enemy. Again, I don’t do negative reviews. But this was more than justified.

Very busy but the staff handled it well, ice cream was wonderful

Really fun treat place. They are taking all the proper safety precautions. We really enjoyed our crazy shakes and rolled ice cream. We look forward to visiting again.

This place makes Sundays are out of this world look like something aliens would make but they are awesome

Totally worth the hour n a half wait! The lollipops werent as tasty but the milkshakes are delicious!!! My cheesecake WAS SOOOO GOOD. Well be back!

The size and price of their extreme milkshakes were good, but we were all four surprised they didnt have as much taste as you would think. Rolling the toppings on the outside of the cup is a neat idea but makes them messy. It was busy there, and there were way more people inside than could have been safe for anyone at high risk for covid with as small as the building is.

Wow . Really really good. Was very suprised

Great service, great product, great experience... Highly recommended 🥰

Great treats, nice staff, it was pretty bussy but we got our orders fast. Recommend to anyone with a sweat tooth.

This One The Best Place Ive Ever Tried.

So yummy. Thanks!

We got a large chocolate shake extra thick. $ 6.00 the shake needed more chocolate and it was the size of a medium any where else🤨.

1st time, great experience and awesome Smores Shake

My girlfriend and I were there Saturday while on vacation, the pics on their website were too die for, I ordered the death by chocolate extreme milkshake, all the store bought items on top were good, the chocolate milkshake though was horrid, mostly milk. Ill never waste money there again

Always up to par. Very busy place and handles it well. Well go back again!

People love this place. I prefer my home creations. At least they are local and give back. The lines are always long plan to wait.

Amazing. Well worth the drive. Shakes are reasonably priced as well.

This is the Best Place Ive ever Had

Awesome we love this place

Love this place. Employees are nice and treats are amazing.

Amazing, I can feel it in my blood sugas lol

Fast service and everyone is required to wear masks. All of the employees were wearing masks and were cleaning everything off. Great service and friendly atmosphere, highly recommended l!!❤

Saw this and had to try it!. I think the concept is amazing however the place was really dirty when we went. We got strawberry cheesecake extreme milkshake and death by chocolate milkshake. Presentation I give a 10! Flavor of strawberry milkshake was mostly just like milk. However the chocolate one was really good. The staff was not sociable at all. Overall good experience just needs some better management!

Drove over an hour with amazing anticipation for the extreme shakes. The pictures on Facebook and the presentation made it a must have. My family and I got extreme shakes and one of us got just two scoops of butter pecan ice cream. The presentation on the shakes were a 10/10 but the actual flavor of the shakes were lacking. It tasted a bit flavorless with the heavy cream used in the shakes. I had anticipated a super strong flavor of peanut butter in the peanut butter extreme shake but it wasn’t up to par. Although it wasn’t the best shake I have ever had, it wasn’t the worst either. My family had a similar experience in terms of flavor. The shakes had the best presentation I had ever seen. The butter pecan ice cream was delicious though. Overall decent experience.

The staff was awesome, there was only two working. The ice cream was amazing.

I drove 56 minutes away from my home to get to this place! They did not disappoint! I ordered a strawberry cheesecake extreme milkshake. My son ordered the Cinnamon roll Extreme milkshake. Delicious and totally worth the $12 bucks. If you do not plan on eating there you better bring a bib because these sweet heavenly babies are very very messy!! I only gave 4 stars because the floors were messy and sticky and the workers werent very friendly.

The ice cream is definitely good but that cheesecake they put with the strawberry cheesecake is nasty. It taste like store bought cheesecake. I still would recommend this place though

I would love to share a full review however, I did not have to use the toilet during my visit so I am unable to factor the facilities into this. It makes this very difficult because most of the time 2 to 3 stars of my reviews are based on the bathrooms. I take into account not only the cleanliness and general presentation of the restroom, but also the smaller things such as readiness of ample amounts of toilet paper should I need it in some sort of taco Tuesday type scenario. Extra merit is awarded to facilities that offer a hands free hand cleaning system and the quality of the soap dispensed. Food was ok. Not bad at all. You pay for the presentation of the shakes and not the quality of ingredients so if you want something to snapchat this is right up your alley.

Went out of our way to come here because we heard good reviews. Highly recommend to come here if you like ice cream of any type

Wed heard so much about the Extreme Creamery that we decided to chk it out for ourselves. So we drove 40 mins just to go. And it was sooooo worth it!!! Wow!Cant even begin to describe the crazy, custom ice cream treats /deserts / meals (not sure what to call them!) but lets just say they included every decadent ingredient you could think of and they were AWESOME!!! If you love 🍨, you got put Extreme Creamery on your bucket list! It was on ours and now still is. Well be back to do it over and over again!!!

Really enjoyed this place.! They have milkshakes, waffle cones & bowl shaped waffle cones. Also they have these really well made Extreme milkshakes. I had a regular 20oz blueberry/chocolate chip milkshake. It was delicious and the price was $5.50. Well worth it. Great staff, chill environment and good service. Great place to go if your im the mood for something sweet.!

Great ice cream and very creative

At this niche establishment, the toppings were good and plentiful however the substance and taste of the shake itself was very disappointing considering it was a $12 milkshake. On a crazy hot 91 degree day, the expectation and beautiful presentation of the shake was building me up to think the taste was going to be out of this world. This Strawberry Cheesecake Milkshake tasted like plain milk with a slight hint of strawberry and not creamy at all. In the end a total let down. I ended up throwing it out leaving it half full and my kids did the same with theirs. You can fare way better at Sonic for a fraction of the cost.

Wait was long but that was expected. I got the rolled ice cream which was good. Did not try one of their fancy milk shakes. People were working like crazy to get orders out. Need more tables out side. Or just chairs. Or maybe bring your own chair. The wait for me was about 45 mins. In the sun.

It was nice place and the ice cream was good. Just be prepared for really sweet and rich desert.

Definitely worth the trip!!

Visual 5 stars, taste 3 stars. Honestly nothing special. And the only thing extreme about this place is the cost. $12

I went to this place today, It opened at 2, I got there at 3:30, it was filthy already. It was so dirty I didnt feel comfortable sitting down on the inside, so I went outside and it was dirty as well. The milkshake was very cute. My daughter took a sip, took a pic, then we threw our stuff away. I wasted $29 simply because I couldnt imagine how clean the equipment and counter tops were if the floors and tables were that gross. The bathroom was nasty as well.

Good ice cream my first of the rolled ice cream. Not really worth a 45 min drive to get but good was not disappointed.

Its an experience. Dont go here for a quality ice cream, its pretty bad in my opinion. Just a really really big crazy dessert. Im glad I had the experience but wont be going back...

Line took a while to get through due to limited capacity inside the building, but the staff brought out lemonade. The extreme milkshakes were fantastic! Definitely worth the wait! Yum!

This place is super awesome!!! I cant wait to go back! Good place for people with a sweete tooth

Not worth the time you waste inside not worth the money for what youre getting over hyped is all it is you can do the same thing at home for half the price and half the time

Really 2.5 stars. Looks good but thats about it. Drove 45 minutes to wait an hour and a half for store bought cake on top of Deans ice cream in my shake. They sell that at Drug Mart. Not worth the wait.

Rolled ice cream was awesome! Will definitely be back! Only complaint was they were very busy with only two workers making multiple orders. Maybe be a little more prepared staff wise. Overall it was a great first experience with rolled ice cream!!😋😋

OMG you guys this place is EXTREME!!! The extreme milkshakes are incredible! Get there about 15 minutes before they open and get in line then or expect to wait upwards of an hour, but totally worth the wait. They are extremely popular. We drove an hour and 40 minutes to try them out and will be making the drive again!

Its definitely extreme

Definitely worth a try and a 25 min wait. The toppings were amazing. Cant go wrong with chocolate.

Expect a 20min + wait after you order. .

We visited Extreme Creamery for the first time on the hot 4th of July weekend. They were extremely busy and it took quite a while to get our order filled. Since we just had dinner, we opted for rolled ice cream rather than the extreme shakes. Ive had rolled ice cream at other places and enjoyed it. This was superior to other places that I have tried. Worth the wait! We will return; but not on a holiday weekend!

Very busy. Wasnt really impressed with the taste. The milkshake with piece of cake and candy is impressive.. but taste wasnt there..especially for the money

Great ice cream

Great deals on delicious ice cream!

The ice cream is amazing, the service was fantastic, and an overall great experience. I would definitely come again.

Amazing staff, DELICIOUS icecream & milkshakes!☺ Definitely will be back, this was my first time going I came clear from Coshocton, Ohio

Had to wait 2 hours to get in the store and then another 25 minutes to get two shakes. Then when I got my shake, it tasted like spoiled milk and couldn’t drink it. Definitely not worth the time or money spent. Won’t be going back.

Wonderful ice cream. Love it

Definitely creamy. Really good ice cream just not my favorite. Service was good and quick, friendly staff.

Very busy which is understandable but they need a little more organization waited 30 minutes after placing my order got a extreme strawberry cheesecake milkshake and it was terrible taste just like milk wasn’t thick at all very thin cheesecake was dry as if it had been sitting out the workers didn’t change their gloves as I watched them work while waiting for my order once I received my order my cup was sticky on the outside due to the workers sticky gloves

Fantastic Ice Cream. Over the top Shakes and very good rolled ice cream. Owner is a really good guy. Good service and a good product.

Definitely will be back.

Really cool and unique experience. Kinda pricey, but worth it.

First time there. Shakes were amazing and service was fast and pleasant. On the down side in the days of covid cleaning seemed subpar. Also, for 5 shakes to cost $60, extreme or not we probably will not be back for a very long time if ever. It was worth the experience but thats about it.

Newer places like this need to make sure that they are prepared well for the basics! It is a very simple setting without much seating. But the worst part is that it isnt very clear where or how you order. You have a male employee standing behind the counter not saying anything and just looking at you. You assume that this is where you order and maybe he nor the manager, who is standing right there, cant talk. It is expensive and the next craving we get for ice cream we have many other choices that have to be better.

Yes the extreme shakes are instagram worthy.... however the actually taste of the shake itself was not worth the hr+ wait

A very long wait for ice cream that was bland. They do have a lot of variety and some unique creations.

Best ice cream around.

Their ice cream is amazing! If you havent tired it, you must! Worth the drive!