Looks like a bar from outside but glad we stopped here. Great food overall. Staff were funny and service was alright. Will stop by here again if in the area and wanting some Italian food

Came here for lunch and had a great experience! There was a very long line, but the staff quickly took orders and was able to get food out in a very short period of time. I ordered a small pizza with Italian sausage and it tasted great, loved the way their pizza was seasoned. This is definitely my favorite spot to come for lunch!

We ordered Italian-style pizza, 4th Street Bourbon pizza, and Greek pizza (shown in the pictures in that order). The price was fair for three medium-sized pizzas and 3 drinks. The pizzas were really tasty, the thin crust was so crispy and yummy. Each pizza was completely delicious, highly recommend this place!

Upon arrival I was super excited to try out the food. The ambience was catchy with memorabilia of Kentucky horses, sports, actors, and artist. Hence the reason I’d agree with a 1 star review for this place. The FOOD on the complete other hand was like something out of a kids plastic easy bake oven. Grease piled on top like it was some sort of dressing for the pizza, dough that was RAW, and a staff that couldn’t have cared less. I had gotten up from my table, returned in line with the customers who were ordering to address my issue quietly. The male at the counter said he would have no issue putting my pizza back in the oven to finish cooking it. After about 10 more minutes of waiting for him to come take the pizza from the table my girlfriend had to get up and take it to him. He says no words and takes the pizza. No more than 30 seconds later my pizza was returned as if it was MICROWAVED warm🤮🤮🤮 DONT WASTE THE TIME! DOMINOS IS BETTER and that’s just pathetic.

Terrible service. Got to store my food was taken by the driver. Had to wait for replacement order. Order the spaghetti marinara got home meat was in my spaghetti. I’m vegetarian that’s not what’s up. Called up was told by one of the workers that I could get a pizza in replacement for my meal. The next day I try to get the pizza they say “no I have to bring the other food back”. I was never told that, lol terrible service. First time eating there and probably the last

Was in town for the day. Stopped here for lunch and it was really good. If I happen back this way I would stop to eat again and would recommend anyone else to stop in as well.

Great food, very fast turnaround time. I will continue to enjoy Sicilian Pizza & Pasta Downtown. Baked pasta dishes are quite good!

I am in Louisville about once a month anymore for business, and no matter where I stay, I am about 1 mile round trip from this pizza place, and I will walk there during a 105 degree heat index and back, just to have one of their 4th street chicken bourbon pizzas!!! There is nothing better around the city!!! Go there, walk there, just get there!!! It is well worth it and amazing. Sicilian, you have a customer for life in me every time I am in town!!! Btw’s, the crust (which I am not a fan of crust), is THE BEST!!! I eat it gone without sauce!!!

Best pizza in Louisville. Get the fried chicken pizza

Im so frustrated. These guys ruined my pizza and when i called back they blame me. Never ever will i call them again. Its nothing like it used to be BEST TO PASS ON THESE GUYS

Pizza was good.... but when a customer calls and ask for an item not to be in a salad, its probably because they are allergic and then im told were not modifying any food but then when I get my order, its missing half of the toppings in the salad. i will never order from here again. this shows me that money is more important then a customers health.

Below a one star and thats only cause it was cooked but cold when I got it. And paid 35.00

Amazing. Good taste. Fresh ingredients. Good place. Nice staff. Well come back.

Great pizza friendly staff - will definitely be back!

The employees are very professional, and respectful. The food is great

I was disappointed usually the baked chicken zitti is delicious but this time it was really off, not much flavor and the noodles were not cooked enough. So sad this was one of my favorite spots.

WOW! This place is seriously good. We had the famous bourbon wings (fantastic flavour), the little sicilies (absolutely no need for red sauce with these) that are bursting with Italian spices on top of pizza dough, wrapped around your choice of a ton of toppings. Then I finished it off with a 10 inch calzone. The crust was filled with Italian flavours and was perfectly cook so it was crispy outside and tender inside. The service was great and they were super friendly. If you like seriously good Italian style food, you have to eat here.

Ordered the pepperoni and breadsticks. Was pretty darn good. Definitely one of the top pizza places Ive visited. Would definitely order again if I lived closer

The pizza was ok. Not the best Ive ever tasted but it was edible. Asked for extra sauce on pizza and didnt look or taste like they put any on it at all.

I understand downtown has been going through a lot so I am giving them an extra star. The young employees they have now are rude and have no customer service skills. The pizza still tasted good. I suggest you just get it to go the atmosphere is just not there anymore. I used to think they have the best.

Had the Stromboli, fantastic flavor, fresh dough, large portion stuffed with meat and cheese. Would highly recommend.

We had a group of 50 that wanted to visit Sicilian Pizza on a Friday afternoon. I spoke with the owner, Joe, the day before and he assured me that they could accommodate our group. At 12:45pm on a Friday, we visited the restaurant and were greeted with reserved seating, a pile of pizzas and great customer service. The staff was very polite and we walked away full and happy. This is a great establishment with unique pizzas and a great atmosphere. We will visit again when we return to Louisville.

Great pizza at a good price. The employees were nice and the restaurant was clean . I loved the decor.

I am eating here now and they all have positive attitudes and are patient this is one restaurant I would recommend for a family so crongrats I give you all a thumbs up

So good, i ordered the Greek pizza add sauce and pepperoni and a Sicilian salad. Both were delicious. The staff were really nice as well!

Had the calzone and Hawaiian pizza. Both were really good. They were short staffed but wait was still ok. Would recommend for quick pizza!

Absolutely the most phenomenal pizza in all of Louisville! This place is above and beyond any other pizza joint in the area.. (In comparison to other pizza places of its level they are reasonably priced) - As for the spaghetti, it was very much like a true marinara, and much less like a sauce. If you prefer a thicker marinara and less watery then this would be for you. The tomatoes give a bit of a sweet flavor to the baked spaghetti. Also, you must try a brownie!! They are delicious and have a wonderfully soft texture.

Service was not that great. Ordered wings and pizza. Both were dry and disappointing. Pizza had no sauce, paper thin, and you could just peel the cheese and toppings right off the so called crust, as well as thrown together and cut carelessly. Wings had no sauce and were dry tasting. For a supposed Sicilian based food place, and coming from a fellow Sicilian, this a shame and disappointing. Would not recommend.

This is one of THE BEST pizzas Ive EVER had! And Ive had pizza in downtown Rome! I special ordered thin crust with oil & garlic instead of pizza sauce. They said 1 hr for delivery and showed up 30 minutes later! AMAZING pizza and service!!

Im a truck driverThey delivered the pizza to me At the location I was at .My daughter loves her chicken alfredo said the best shes ever had and this pizza is definitely one of the top three Ive hadThis place is great all yall truck drivers give it a try great food great delivery all around five star experience

Just got a sub from here. It was beautiful and delicious. Must visit.

It was good nice walk there. Beautiful day. Food was delicious. Nice evening walk back to the car. Good day on forth street.

Absolutely horrible. Undercooked, way to many toppings. The only thing good was the salad

The Hot Brown pizza is the most amazing thing ever!!! I diverted my trip by two hours just to pass through Louisville and get this deliciousness. Highly recommended!

Delicious! A must go!

Dined in-store. Staff was exceptional & friendly. Local clientele were also on hand to sing their (the staff) praises. My son is a GM for a major pizzeria & even he was charmed by the ambiance of the restaurant. Will definitely return.

I love Sicilian baked spaghetti. They never disappoint and it’s super convenient being down town.

Service was awesome! The pizza we ordered was exactly what I’d been craving after a long day of travel! I will definitely stop back by if traveling through the area!

I dont know why I ordered from this place, but it was pretty good. The sauce was good it tasted a little sweet.

So I am not a pasta fan. This restaurant was walking distance from my hotel and smelt amazing. I loved the calzone I got! Their food is fresh and full of flavor. Its a neat little cafe type setting. I will be eating here again my next trip back.

This place was awesome! Great food and atmosphere! I would definitely recommend this place to anyone who comes to Louisville!

Loved he atmosphere, the food was good and at a good price. The house creamy balsamic dressing was really good. Just wish the crust was a little crisper on the 12 inch pizza.

If you want to be left on hold for 30 mins and they answer the phone saying hold, an just leave you there an when you call back they just ignore your phone call, then go too this place. I’m a business owner an was trying to make an order of atleast 400 dollars pizzas an give them some business but looks like I’ll just call papa John’s and get it from them. Thanks for the rude hold an ignoring my phone call.

So far, the best pizza that Ive had in downtown Louisville.

I love their pizza and the location is great. However, I did not like the wings. They were fake breaded frozen wings that they just heat up and threw some sauce on. I expected better for the price.Really disappointing.👎🏻

After arriving to my hotel after a long flight, I ordered a “4th Street Bourbon Pizza” for delivery. Estimate was an hour, but it arrived a bit earlier. It was greasier than I’d prefer, but the flavor was great. About five days later, I walked to the location on 4th Street and ordered a Chicken Parmesan sandwich. I was the only customer, but within the next 30 minutes several large groups came in. They received their food before I did, and after waiting about 45 minutes for my sandwich I politely asked the server if there was some problem. She replied that they had to remake it, but it would be up soon. Sure enough, a few minutes later my sandwich arrived, along with an apology for the wait and a refund (which I hadn’t asked for). The sandwich was toasty and delicious, and I’d recommend it to anyone. The garlic butter breadstick-like bun really made the sandwich excellent.

First time having this pizza and I gotta say its pretty good. The crust is nice and soft plus flavorful. Definitely a place Id go again.

This Personal pizza was massive and delicious. Nice place.

Pizza was good But fooled me on the BLT. Full of bacon bitsAnd salad leaves!!!Please dont mess up the BLT like that. I spend too much money to be played like that. There was NO cheese on it.

I stopped in after the Diana Ross concert to get a bite to eat. The pizza w/chicken & bourbon glaze was delicious!! Great customer service & atmosphere. In the words of the Terminator, Ill be back!!

Open late, great service, tough finding a good eating place after 10pm in this town. Ordered the special (see photo) very nice and not miserly with the toppings. Thanks guys.

Very impressed. The pizza was very good. I also commend the staff for their warm service and politeness. My delivery person David was awesome, called 30 seconds out for heads up, and was also very courteous when he arrived. We will order again soon!

Best pizza Ive had in awhile. Traveling from out of town and it was by my hotel. It was pretty busy, constant traffic. But it was fast and delicious.

Very good food in fair price.

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza to take back to my hotel. It was a great pizza to enjoy last minute.

Food taste like cardboard. 2 hours after we ordered we got our food. It was wrong and they refused to fix it. If I could leave 0 stars I would!

Pasta and salad were great. Dr pepper was flat tho...But who cares. Haha

Sits at #4 out of 35 pizza reveiews in Lousiville. A fantastic, oven baked pizza.

First time dining here. Staff was very friendly and the food was delicious! Here’s a personal half bacon and half pepperoni. Prices are reasonable.

I got a thin crust pizza with an oil and garlic sauce instead of pizza sauce and it was literally the best pizza I have ever had!

I ordered my pizza over 2hrs ago, and still hasnt arrived, as Im sharing this review. I DO NOT recommend this establishment for delivery EVER!!! Still waiting, tried to call multiple times, but line is busy. Im from out of town and wanted to support a local establishment, but I wont EVER call this place again when Im back in town....UNREAL!!!

I have to say this is the best Pizza I have had since I have moved to the Southern States. I thought about going home because this is a must and the price is super fair! LG gourmet pizza, LG Greek Salad, and 2 sodas, the delivery driver was on point!, Great service 💯 all the way around! The front of the house took my call within 2 rings and gave a personal favorite recommendation that was the bomb! The best experience in pizza from order, to door, to table we have had yet! The end🤗🤗🤗D.S.K.

My sister and I came down from Central Illinois. We loved it!! We will be back.

Love their pizza and calzones. My parents were visiting the other night and had their first taste. They were duly impressed!

Like every where else in the post-covid world, they need more help, but the food (spaghetti bowl) was excellent!!!

Very good pizza at a reasonable price.

Website and hotel said open until midnight. Walked in at 11:30 and were told to leave because they decided to close at 11. Despite the door open and people eating. Careful.

Service was nice and fast. Got a meatball sub, it was as good as it can get. Their brownies are pretty good too.

Great food and great service.Highly recommend

Never actually had the food at this restaurant. Hours are incorrect. Attempted to place an order Saturday night---posted opened to 2:00am. When we attempted to place an order at 11:50, an employee that could benefit from Customer Service Training stated the owner is not wasting $500.00 a POP to keep changing the hours. He cleaned up already...going home...with this person being the voice of the restaurant.....you would do better to post correct hours.

New Years eve in Louisville and we passed by to try this place. Very good Hot Brown pizza and spaggetti w/meatballs!

SO GOOD. Fast and friendly delivery to local hotels and food is insane!!! Was NOT expecting it to be this good... We got baked ziti, a cheese pizza, and a calzone! Highly, highly recommend! Amazing!!!!!

The pizza was good but theyre disrespectfully small...

Good local pizza place. Ordered take out and it was ready when I got there. Chicken Alfredo pizza was excellent.

Unique specialty pizzas that you have to try out. Food was cooked well and fast for take out. Pasta dishes are delicious too. Hours are convenient for late nite people.

The guy who works there is awesome and so nice. Always make sure he speaks to me and not just hi and have a good day, he makes the effort to try and have a conversation. Food is awesome i never been disappointed

The chicken alfrado is aweeeesome sauce. My husband had a calzone from there and he its was awsome.

Excellent customer service. This is one of my favorite pizza joints. Believe me youll always be satisfied.

Yummy for your tummy😁😁💯🔥

Delicious wings, pizza and Stromboli. Friendly service. A++

Really good food I placed a order by phone was done really quick nice portion Ill be back

Everything is served on a dirty paper plate with plastic ware. I got pasta with a salad and the lettuce in the salad was obviously old and unwashed. Then the pasta was even worse. The chicken tasted freezer burnt and then just heated in the pizza oven with some pre made pasta. 10/10 would never recommend spending your money here.

It is very annoying when the hours posted are wrong or a restaurant just decides on their hours on the fly. Google makes it very easy to update hours. Called at 10:30pm and website states midnight.

Simple, pizzeria. Staff was great, and its clear that a lot of locals go there. Had the calzones. Terrific!

This place is FIRE!!! Cool delivery guy also. Will not disappoint you.

I order from them several times a month and even have my Job ordering from them. We love them. Food is always great and Hot.

This is a very good pizza place, it was a fair price and is made per order no cold pizza ore hard crost. The peperony slice were on point and they have a good pasta selection. The desert may not vary as much but there ok and is covid time sow I can understand why not getting a lot of them. True enjoy the food will come back again

Terrible terrible delivery service takes forever and when it arrives it’s always cold. Pizza is good!

Great food, cool environment, good service, awesome location! Cant say enough good things about this place!

Terrible experience. Ordered for pickup and was told it had to be delivery b/c pickup ended 1 min ago. Had to order an extra item to avoid delivery fee. It took them over 1hr to deliver a stromboli 1 block away. I ended up with an inedible, barely warm, soggy mess. And since it was after midnight at that point, I was out of options.Skip this place and go fast food if you need a late night meal. (White Castle and Taco Bell are nearby and much better)

One of the best in Louisville. Love the build your own calzone. Great house salad.

Amazing food. Great pizza and subs! If you come during lunch, there maybe a wait. Id recommend you order ahead.

Attempted to order delivery and my total went from $35 to $56 with a required tip, driver tip, service fee, delivery fee and tax. $21 in extra fees?? I understand times are tough but understand this is unacceptable and borderline scamming. What is the $7.07 required tip for when you automatically selected a $5.32 tip for the driver. Then the delivery fee and service fee...just because you have the ability to do something like this it doesnt mean you should.

Nice place; lots of options and a super friendly staff! We were here on a weekend that there werent many places open and everything was an hour plus wait. We waited about 45 minutes for our pizza and a calzone but this was worth the wait. Yum!!! The 4th Street Bourbon BBQ pizza was spot on🍕😋

Excellent. Had the chicken parm and had to find it under all the cheese. Definitely recommend.

Awesome pizza and pasta. Amazing people and customer service.

Smashing! Great Food and Excellent Customer Service. Ill definitely make it a point to come back again. Highly recommended.

Nice little spot. Great flavor!

Best calzone in the United States! Im not kidding, I ordered it today it was delivered timely and it was amazing!

Definitely competing with Blaze for the best gluten-free pizza Ive had! they will accommodate for celiac disease needs!