user
Madison Street Retro Diner
2421 S Madison St, Muncie, IN 47302, United States
Appearance
Madison Street Retro Diner
Comments
Ch
Review №1

Walked in and had a seat. Leslie was our waitress. She had quite a few people come in at the same time who all sat down in her section, so things kinda got off to a slow start. She was very friendly and funny though, I might add.I ordered the Loaded Tots, which is the first picture. Tater tots smothered in chili, with cheese, sour cream and chives. This was very good! Chili is a little on the spicy side, but tolerable. I could only eat half of it before I was stuffed!The second picture is of my daughters Meatloaf dinner. The meatloaf was sitting in a layer of chili. It was served with mashed potatoes and asparagus. Watching my daughter take her first bite and seeing the reaction in her face, I knew something wasnt right. She said the meatloaf was cold on the inside and very crunchy on the outside. It did look a little overdone, however, she ate it.My girlfriend got the schnitzel sandwich, which is basically a breaded tenderloin, and French fries. She said it was amazing and had good flavor. She said it had some gristle in it but that it wasnt bad. At one point, when Leslie went to get us to-go containers, the other waitress, Jen, stopped and asked us if we needed anything.After paying and getting ready to leave, my daughter and myself wanted a hand dipped chocolate milkshake, which Jen made for us. The shakes are absolutely amazing!I give it 4 out of 5 stars, knocking off a point for the bad meatloaf. But everyone there was very friendly and talked to you as if you were family and had known you all of their lives. We will definitely be back again!

Ch
Review №2

Wonderful... Best Restaurant on the southside of Muncie Indiana... Lunch and dinners served different everyday. Great servers; clean restaurant.

Sh
Review №3

Friendly, comfortable, anytime of the day. Home cooking, decore 40s 50s 60s.

Si
Review №4

We were impressed with the food. So good. Service was awesome also.

Al
Review №5

The food isnt bad but there doesnt seem to be much consistency from the kitchen. Went in 2 different days, a day apart, got the same meal and it was cooked completely differently. First visit my over easy eggs were medium and my biscuit had been split open and grilled on the inside. Next visit my eggs were cooked correctly but the biscuit hadnt been cut and they had grilled the outside of it. Only 2 kids menu items and not a very large selection for breakfast items. Prices arent bad but would not recommend.

Ro
Review №6

Good American-style food at reasonable prices. Plenty of choices for breakfast and lunch.

Je
Review №7

Great Experience, I had the Country Fried Steak and my wife had Vegetable Soup with grilled cheese sandwich. It was excellent, Staff was friendly and very helpful. My wife got Hot Cocoa Shake and said she loved it. This was the first time we came here but it will not be our last. Hard to find a Dinner of this quality now days.

Ch
Review №8

The prices are very reasonable and the food is made well. The place always feels clean and well cared for. Though atmosphere is a little sparse, the staff is where this place really shines. They seem to really care, and want you to enjoy your visit. Eat here once and theyll make you feel like family. Definitely worth a try for a classic Americana diner experience.

Mi
Review №9

Today was our first time dining there since the remodeling and it was really nice! The new decor was much improved as well the atmosphere. The hand-painted mural on the backwall was well done and interesting.Our server was friendly and prompt as well attentive to our dining needs.I had a BLT that was great which came with a choice side besides fries. I would definitely recommend this diner!

Ka
Review №10

Great atmosphere, but would have liked soft music playing. Vegetarian skillet was delicious, but a bit greasy, and better quality of sausage patties. Would prefer regular chocolate milk instead of Nestles Quick. Other than that looks great and we are satisfied.

Ta
Review №11

Amazing restaurant with an old 50s vibe. Staff is excellent and the food is great and very well priced. I will most certainly be back again.

Ge
Review №12

Food staff friendly and good like theyve always been. Not a fan of the new decor. I feel theyve lost what made it the Retro Cafe when they got rid of the pictures of Sinatra Elvis Presley Johnny Cash James Dean Marilyn Monroe these are all the things you think of when you think of something retro. I just feel they lost their soul

Me
Review №13

I visited this place when they had the old menu. The prices were good, and the food was always good as well. They should have kept it the way it was. The prices are higher now, however, everything is cooked fresh. I havent tried it yet tho, because they were literally out of food when I went.

Ha
Review №14

Everything is awesome and great service

Bi
Review №15

They have taken away from the restaurant since the remodel. Like it better before. Put the old pictures back. And more on the menu. The wife and I both had the county fried steak. Made us have the craps a hour after eating it. Dont recommend it.

Br
Review №16

I had seen the Restaurant Impossible episode where this restaurant was featured, so I was curious to check it out when I was visiting Muncie. Both the food and service were excellent. I had one of the scrambles, and I could immediately tell that every ingredient had been freshly prepared. I look forward to a return visit the next time I am in town!

Ka
Review №17

The best place to get breakfast in town. Very layed back, comfortable, and clean restaurant. Jessica is a great waitress! They have daily homemade specials to please any pallet. Also homemade desserts 👍😁

Ty
Review №18

Really pleased to find this place and pleasantly surprised by the experience. The decor was themed to a retro diner but the food was more varied. We had pulled pork and a burger, fries, and sweet tea and really enjoyed it all. The prices are great and so was the service. I always like to find local places and hope to make my way back.

Me
Review №19

This place has a nice homey atmosphere. Since the remodel and revamped menu the food is outstanding. Customer service has improved.

Tr
Review №20

Place looked nice, was clean, staff was great. The meal was good, hot, and what I ordered. Ill be back for more.

Ro
Review №21

Food and service was great. We come to Muncie at least twice a year and before seeing this restaurant on the tv never really paid attention to it. Glad we stopped.

Mi
Review №22

I love this place and I was here before it was remodeled and it was amazing. Their food tastes so good. Try the fries they are delicious

aa
Review №23

Great dinner food, amazing customer service above and beyond most, and they hand make the shakes and regulars there are great too

Do
Review №24

Food was amazing. Staff provided great service with a smile. Nostalgic hometown diner.

Ju
Review №25

Disappointed. We spent $45 on a family of four and none of us could finish our meals because the food was not good. Chili is clearly from a can, the fries are from a box, the schnitzel is nothing more than a tenderloin. The shrimp sandwich was over cooked, the country fried steak was inedible. The “meat” was fatty, tough and zero flavor. The one thing all our meals had in common besides yuckiness was they were all cooked in the same oil. The same oil that tasted as if it hasn’t been changed in a really long time. Do not waste your time or your money.

Ru
Review №26

Very pricey and cheaper quality then Dennys. Plus side was Great customer service and food like you made it at home. They had thick ranch, thin bacon, omelettes, and spaghetti. My ham and cheese was not worth the money. It was cooked perfect, bread was golden brown, but it was 1 piece of cheap American cheese and one layer of ham. Definitely would avoid the non breakfast items based off my experience. Spaghetti and omelettes were loved in my group. My group said fried steak was delicious from their prior visits.

jo
Review №27

This place was a bucket list for me. I enjoyed it. They was friendly and good service.

Br
Review №28

Food is really good. Service is great. Prices are very reasonable with large portions!!

Be
Review №29

Good atmosphere. Great food. The only reason it isnt 5 stars for me, is because the past two times Ive been, they were out of stock of chicken, and soup. I havent been in two months but have heard they are attempting and little by little succeeding on fixing this problem. Everyone is so very friendly and pleasent. Love!

Ve
Review №30

It is not gourmet or fancy but it is very good old fashioned home cooking. The place is not fancy but clean with old booths and tables. It has pictures and advertising reminiscent of the 50s. Sometimes they play music from the 50s - 60s. The staff friendly. Breakfast is always available and good. The prices are moderate, $5 - $9 for most meals.

Ch
Review №31

Highly recommended. First off, very fast service! My food was on my table not even 5 minutes after ordering! The food was hot & outstanding! Great portion as well very hardy serving! As well as good prices. The waitresses were very polite & checked in often! A nice peaceful environment & most importantly clean! I recommend this restaurant highly! A very good place for familys to gather & enjoy! :)

Be
Review №32

I had their veggie skillet tonight and it was so good! Ive always had really good service, but when the parking lot is full, I dont stop. This is one of my favorite places because of the friendly wait staff and good food with reasonable prices.Retros a place I can take my grandson. He gets to choose a coloring book or workbook and I get to relax! If youre looking for a fancy place, go somewhere else. This place is not pretentious. I noticed tonight that theyre starting to be open 24/7 on weekend, too.

Je
Review №33

The food is fantastic, the service is better than best, and the camaraderie, the clientele, the atmosphere of friendliness would and should make it even better than the five stars this establishment richly deserves! And the prices are extremely affordable!

Ma
Review №34

Great food...The fried potatoes were awesome! Definitely a hole in the wall place, but fantastic. Service was also chatty and nice!

Kr
Review №35

I love this diner! Every now and then something off of the menu is lacking a little taste but otherwise they have some great food. Great breakfast too that they serve all day

An
Review №36

Excellent service. Food is even better. Great!

Ji
Review №37

Sparse. The menu didnt have a lot of choises. The look was retro, but there wasnt much to it. The food portion was certainly plenty but the chilli didnt have much flavor and the Texas toast used for the grill cheese was too much for the amount of cheese. The hamburgers were fine.

An
Review №38

Great diner. Very friendly and helpful staff. Would recommend a visit. I will be a regular here.

Ma
Review №39

Thanks wonderful food and very nice and efficient waitresses. Love there prices and there 10 percent for seniors. My favorite place to eat.

Tr
Review №40

Restaurant Impossible FAIL! Gave it a shot & got a moldy roll & my friend had egg shell all throughout her beef & noodles. Manager had the gull to say well theyre homemade noodles, eggshells happen! Ummm no! Wont be back

La
Review №41

Good home style cooking, big variety of items. Great service. You can tell that the locals who are there feel at ease and comfortable.

Mi
Review №42

Not from there, just popped in on a drive by------excellent! The bacon eggs and biscuits & gravy as good as it gets. The waitress never let my coffee get less than half full.In and out in 20 minutes.Great job keep it up!

Do
Review №43

It is much better now. The food tasted great 👍👍

Ma
Review №44

Excellent service. Bent over backwards to fix sandwich order (free schnitzel)! Thank you

Ja
Review №45

Advertising says breakfast all day. Apparently they stopped at 1030, cause I arrived at 1035 and got a lunch menu. Ordered a sweet tea and they brought it with no ice and tea was warm. Sat there for like 5 minutes before someone even came to table. Took a few minutes to bring me my drink, then asked what I would like. I didnt even have a menu. Terrible service.

Br
Review №46

Btl club was excellent.. never disappointed.

Ra
Review №47

Amount of serving you get is worth the price, good home cooked meal.

pa
Review №48

Staff friendlyHometown AtmosphereFood Prices are greatBreakfast Western Omelet was delicious w/ large portionCame Away Smiling

En
Review №49

Way better after the tv show missoin impossible got on and fixed haha

Ti
Review №50

A work in progress....an hour and 15 mins to get our food. We were surrounded by family, if not we probably wouldve left. To many excuses and not enough action. Place looked better after restaurant impossible but organization and serving needs some attention. A smile and thank yous go a long way😊

Gr
Review №51

It was 9am on a wensday morning and there werent many people there. As soon as we sat down a waitress appeared with a friendly smile and went to get out drinks. Our food came out hot and quick. It was very good. Retro covers all the meals. Great home cooked meals with good prices.

Ni
Review №52

It was really good. Had the Veggie skillet was amazing!

De
Review №53

Good diner food for good and inexpensive prices. Home cooking youll love with very friendly service. Family friendly a piece of Muncie hospitality

Ma
Review №54

I used to like the quick service and daily specials. Today I waited for an hour to get my food ordered off the special board. My chicken was frozen in middle and my Mac and cheese was cold. I thought they cooked fresh, but obviously they reheated something frozen. After waiting that long, my granddaughter got over tired so I had to take her to the car instead if eating. My husband asked for a to go box and left as well. No one offered him silverware or drinks to go. I called to complain, but they were just so busy and my husband should have asked for to go cups. I was a regular meeting their with groups of 10 or more. We will no longer go there.

Te
Review №55

Great service, great food and great prices!

W.
Review №56

Good food prices could be better on some items

Ji
Review №57

First of all 3.24 for (1) glass of iced tea is ridiculous. Online menu says 1.49. Others got waited on that came in after we did. Restaurant was good before Hollywood came in and changed things. Breakfast all day doesnt exist. Menu stinks. Never going back. Got up and left.

Mi
Review №58

Service was great food is ok if you dont want to cook hashbrowns werent done got a couple of bites of raw potatoes they use 0 seasoning on any of the food biscuit was cold dry and overcooked

Je
Review №59

We were greeted with an intense smell of vomit when we walked in the door. You know that smell when back in elementary school when a kid puked and the janitor threw some sawdust on it but the scent lingered all day? Thats what this was like. We tried to stick it out, but the menu just wasnt compelling enough.

Au
Review №60

Nice little diner. Excellent diner food at real good prices. Waitresses were really nice.

Su
Review №61

Waitress was wonderful and very nice environment

LA
Review №62

Yummy Hamburgers! And really good customer service

Ch
Review №63

Get place for a real meal . And at a good price too. I will definitely going back there to eat again

Le
Review №64

Their food is great and so is the service! Great homemade meals!

Ri
Review №65

Friendly people and waitresses are awesome, nice atmosphere

ci
Review №66

Great food! Wonderful service! Feels like your are surrounded by friends! Love this place.

Aw
Review №67

Good food and good people! Best chicken and noodles 😋😍

Ba
Review №68

Waitress was polite . I got 1/2 order of biscuits and gravy. Was good but biscuit was to big and not enough gravy.

Co
Review №69

The food is always good. It is very quick. The service is good and the prices are great! I will have to visit this place a lot more often.

S
Review №70

It was great. The food was great. Very friendly servers. I would recommend it to anyone looking for good food and reasonable prices.

JO
Review №71

The waitress was very polite and helpful. The food was great. The prices are very reasonable.

Ma
Review №72

The food is good, the environment is really neat. The menu is a little small, but they do it well.

Je
Review №73

Very friendly staff and excellent food and good price

Ni
Review №74

Great food . Ppl . Atmosphere

Sa
Review №75

I got the BLT with fries. One of the best sandwiches Ive ever had

Ch
Review №76

Very friendly atmosphere and nice food for your dollar. I definitely recommend eating there

El
Review №77

Awesome ribs, awesome shakes, awesome staff. Found our new go-to.

Ma
Review №78

Good diner food. Fast, friendly service. Have tried much of menu and all very good.

Vi
Review №79

The food was good price decent and service was good.

Ja
Review №80

Took to long to order, to long to get food and then the chili and grilled cheese were barely warm, border line cold.

Ri
Review №81

Only my second time there and both times the food was good.A bit pricey for what it is tho.Service was decent.Place was clean and was obvious they have alot of regulars and repeat customers.I had worked for a nonprofit in tbe past and the owner was an avid Donator to the State Troopers and Veterans organizations that I worked with.Would go back.

Kr
Review №82

Breaded tenderloin sandwich wss yummy and service was excellent

Sh
Review №83

Food and service was very good!

Ch
Review №84

Its a mom and pop great dinner xant wait to see the remodel

Te
Review №85

Food taste different! I have good memories at Retro, with my Mommie nd sis, but other than that, please hire a new cook!

Jo
Review №86

Excellent environment and service. The food is reasonably priced and tastes wonderful.

he
Review №87

Great food, friendly atmosphere, decent prices!

Mi
Review №88

Solid food good service and decent prices

Bi
Review №89

Great local place. Mouth watering breaded tenderloin sandwiches.

Co
Review №90

Friendly, somewhat fast serving, and usually good crowd

Sa
Review №91

Never going back food is awful

Da
Review №92

I here this place was on Resturant impossible. The showa not realeased yet but its clear that the ownership needs to change there mental process. Positives... location and appearance. I like the bar seating and the clean look and feel of the tables. I ordered the mushroom and swiss which tasyed good but they had it on a cheep bun that crumbled when you handled the burger. Then they subbed fried pickles on the side but gave me only a few.... but the proble i think is that they didnt up charge for the pickles so to meet costs they shorted me on the quantity. No dipping sauce offered with the pickles. And they should improve the pickle batter... Yes its an economical place to eat but i think if their focus was more on quality they could charge just a bit more to make the experience better.

Rh
Review №93

Great food, great service. All the staff are great. My food is always perfect

wi
Review №94

Mom and pop dinner - decent variety on the menu.

Ci
Review №95

Great staff,good food,cost is very affordable. This is my favorite place in muncie.

Da
Review №96

Good food. Friendly service. Great prices.

Ro
Review №97

Always good food and good service. Mom and Pop done properly.

Vi
Review №98

Friendly atmosphere, great homestyle food, fun retro style...even has a juke box!

Ki
Review №99

The food and service you receive are tremendous.

Mo
Review №100

Really like the friendly service and the food is very good.

Information
100 Photos
100 Comments
4.2 Rating
  • Address:2421 S Madison St, Muncie, IN 47302, United States
  • Site:http://retrodinermuncie.com/
  • Phone:+1 765-216-7182
Categories
  • Diner
  • American restaurant
  • Family restaurant
Working hours
  • Monday:6AM–8PM
  • Tuesday:6AM–8PM
  • Wednesday:6AM–8PM
  • Thursday:6AM–8PM
  • Friday:6AM–8PM
  • Saturday:6AM–7PM
  • Sunday:6AM–8PM
Highlights
  • Fast service:Yes
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot:Yes
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom:Yes
  • Wheelchair accessible seating:Yes
Amenities
  • Good for kids:Yes
Similar organizations
  • To
    Tom John Food ShopBall State University, Thomas J. Kinghorn Hall, Tom John Food Shop @, Muncie, IN 47306, United States
  • No
    Noyer CentreBall State University, Noyer Complex, Noyer Centre @, Muncie, IN 47306, United States
  • Ch
    Christinas yummy foods1907 S Howell St, Muncie, IN 47302, United States
  • Ball State University Dining ServicesBall State University North Dining 201, 1525 N McKinley Ave, Muncie, IN 47306, United States
  • Micro CaféBall State University, Studebaker West Complex, Micro Café @, Muncie, IN 47306, United States