I can only rate on experience because I didn’t have a chance to taste the food. Went here last night with my bf looking for a quick bite. It was 15 mins to close, we figured a few slices of whatever was still left wouldn’t be a problem. The sign said open, and I walked in to see one of the staff sitting on the counter. We asked if they were open and another staff member said no and made a snarky comment to the person on the counter about us, like because he was on the counter, we should have known they were closed. Ok, but the sign is still on and the door is unlocked? Staff seemed young so maybe they’re just not particularly invested. But if you’re truly closed, turn the sign off and lock the door.Might try to come back again because we really wanted to try it.

I was debating on whether to write this because it is a fairly decent resturant and the owner that I have met is nice. However, for the past few times I have gone there they have messed up my friends and my food repeatedly. When they do get it right it is wonderful. This past time however was disgusting. I ordered a wrap and there was a rotten avocado and lettuce in the wrap. The avocado looked so bad no one could recognize what it was.

Ordered Chicken Parm family meal for 4 to go. Came with a nice salad (romaine, cukes, tomatoes,) pasta, and bread. Very reasonable price ($30.99.) Delicious!

I visited this pizzeria with my children and nephews and the truth is that the pizza was delicious, we ordered a cheese with pineapple and another cheese and mushroom pizza, the bad thing is the customer service, we had to wait too long for our order and in the end My daughter had to go directly to the cashier to order, I also had to stop to ask the waitress to please bring me the glasses since 20 minutes had passed after I had brought the 2 liter soda to the table, finally the service the customer was horrible.

Delivery took over an hour and their plain wings are REALLY plain. tastes like they just ran it over water and put in the oven... no seasoning or anything. Ive eaten plain wings at other restaurants before but they at least have flavor! Never ordering from this place again.

Was in here recently for a couple of slices and a root beer. Excellent thin crust pizza with wonderful staff.They also serve ice cream here which is great! They were a little busy and had a big table and were paying special attention to all the details on the ice cream sundaes!Ill be back in a couple of weeks when Im in town and its lunch time!

Hit or miss depending on what you get, menu seems to have a great variety, but you know it’s a red flag when a Pizza joint offers burgers, fries, etc. If I remember correctly, the grinders here were pretty bad. “Chaos Fries” were absolutely disgusting and just a jumbled pile of sauce and who knows what else. I could not even finish it. The garlic knots were great, and the wings were pretty good but overpriced for how wimpy they are, they’re not filling at all and you don’t get much. The pizza is a gamble. Pizza usually tastes good, but 9 times out of 10 the delivery either takes forever or you open the box to see cheese falling off. Overall this place is okay, but not my first choice and you gotta know what to order.

The pizza is decent and the ice cream is great. I love the fried dough and a couple scoops to share with boothang. The staff on my visits seem like they are in high school and arent always attentive. Only thing dropping stars.

I love that pizza very good.

Pizza. ✨AMAZING✨but I ordered over the phone wanting a SMALL Pizza, but NOOOOOO I gotta order something thats about 13 bucks or OVER. WHAT????? WHY????? so I decide to order medium and guess what? delivery was ONE HOUR!!!! well MORE than an hour AND I WAS STARVING!!!! I WANTED MY FOOD ASAP!!!! welp Im glad to get that off my sholders and btw NEVER. ORDERING. AGAIN.

Good food! Delivery just takes way longer than expected.Best bet is to just pick up

Good food selection. Quick and easy dining experience and pricing.

Wonderful owners who love food and family! My son was asking a million questions so they brought him back to help. Made our day!! Thank you for a heart warming experience & great food always!

Best pizza in town!!!! Great sandwiches and salads, too. Plus the owners are local and care about the community. All around 5-stars!

My boyfriend and I literally eat here at least twice a week. We moved to new Milford in December of last year and ever since we tried All Aboard for the first time we’ve been hooked!! Definitely our favorite restaurant in New Milford so far. Also, the service is always so warm and friendly. Not sure why their reviews are so low on here. We’ve never had a bad experience in the 20+ times we’ve ordered from them at this point!!

Decent food with good ownership who is happy to work with you if you run into any issues.

We really like the small quaint atmosphere, and the food has never disappointed. Wed go just for the bru-fetta salad and wings, if they served nothing else.

Friendly staff with great take in & take out service. Ordered a Pizza margarita that was made with very fresh ingredients, better than NYC! Mozzarella sticks were plump and not dripping in oil. Salad was average. Garlic Knots were a little underwhelming but not full of grease and garlic. The flavor was fine but a little weak, maybe thats good if you dont want epic garlic breath. I try to kill vampires with my face. A little expensive but the people and location make it well worth it. Great spot to meet with friends, have a date, or just get out of the house for a little bit to enjoy yourself.

Pizza arrived nice n hot

Food was ok. Greek omelet was bland and slightly disappointing. Seemed to be missing something. Portions were very nice and my waitress was friendly and efficient.

Boy do I love All Aboard Pizza! I come here on occasion, but I always expect good food and good service, and you can too! The pizza here is great and so is the rest of the food. Th ed service is just about what you would expect at an average restaurant, but its nice. You can come here for a birthday party, for dinner, for lunch, heck, I sometimes even come here to eat breakfast its that good! If you are looking for a new, good place to eat, I reccomend you try out All Aboard Pizza!

I made a delivery for Brescome & Barton

Best pizza I have had in a very long time 👌 👍 Nice atmosphere! Love their wings! They have excellent daily specials -- which is nice if youre on a budget $

Not the easiest parking at the location but pizza is always good

Love the pizza and the place is cute but you guys need to invest in nicer staff

Great place to relax and have some pizza! There menu has a lot more to offer than pizza too. The staff are always friendly and inviting. This place is a staple for us.

Hi I just ordered a large pizza and I normally order from them. I got my pizza upstairs and it was so over cooked the Crust was hard and cheese was also basically burned at the top. My kids ate some because they were really hungry. They gave me a 20 percent off for next time?? Umm ok thank you

We used to order from this place regularly. Living in town over 4 years no . Recently the service has been meh at best. Food delivered is always cold and things are often forgotten. Try eating a (sauceless) stuffed meat pizza without the giant container of marinara. They also refused to bring marinara back. Family in town and disappointed. sorry I hyped it up. :/

The pizza is so so, the crust has no flavor and is incredibly bland. It’s a nice enough place to go with the kids and the service is always friendly. I’ve had a few experiences where the pizza tasted somewhat better, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to eat there again.

Great place awesome food.. Its a must go to and you will love it...

All Aboard is good pizza. They are good prices. They are good service and they Deliver to your door.Sometimes things get messed up but MOST of the time they nail 100% perfect.I always recommend them when someone asks. They arent amazing, they arent perfect but they are farrrrr from bad.

They need to work on quantity of food. Got 4 bread slices for an 8 dollar bruschetta, 7 wings for 9 dollars, and a SMALL Buffalo wrap for 9. 30 dollars for about 15 worth of food. Quality is fine, quantity is lacking hard.

Staff used to be much better, after they left this business is coming down hill.. At many times we have heard some profanity come out of some of the guys... The females working are polite and mindful of what is playing on television, the food could be over price for some things, but is okay, and the other thing that bothers us is that deliveries take way too long, I shouldnt have to wait almost an hour for a chicken salad, and some times they forget what I ask for... The owners are rarely there maybe this place needs them to be present more often or hire people with more experience.

The perfect place for the kids and parents. Great pizza,good selection of beers and deserts to die for

Delivery charges quite steep and also must have minimum order amount. Too bad as food is tasty. Ordered last night food still good!

The small is actually a personal. Definitely a difference!. Not worth the $14 for a Hawaiian

Run by a hearty band of teens, everything about it was good to great to pizza or pasta... with a large cola.

Very disappointed. We used to go often but orders were being brought to us wrong.Poor-quality chicken on salad. Over-cooked pizza.Dirty bathrooms.Broken mens room faucet.

Good food, and good service!

Prime time on a Friday night I decided to order pizza, garlic knots and a salad. 6:30pm. I ordered delivery. I live about 10 minutes from this place but its cold so I didnt want to go out. I received my cold food at 8:00. 8!!!!! I called and they said they can only offer 10 percent off this purchase or the next purchase. WHAT A RIP OFF

I always order from allaboard New milford, but tonight was a problem. my pizza,was barely Luke warm and my hot fudge sundae had approximately 4 drops of hot fudge. a shame

Good food at a reasonable price. They offer pizza with a variety of toppings including the traditional and the more adventurous.

Great food, great service, great time

Best pizza in New Milford. Fast delivery. Friendly staff.

I’ve had so many problems from All Aboard. One being from their front people who don’t know what’s going on or they are rude. I order last week from them penne with broccoli and garlic and oil. THE most Italian simple dishes out there. I called 40 minutes before they closed seeing as I live 5 minutes up the road the minute she answers it’s we are not taking delivery. I said that is fine but still wondering if your open until 9 why you aren’t taking delivery as every other Italian places does! She told me rudely 15 minutes I got there in 10 so I wasn’t effecting closing and the door was locked. 15 mins to close I couldn’t believe it. Then I call tonight for the same order and they are telling me it’s not on the menu so they can not make it. You are an Italian restaurant how could you not make penne with broccoli and oil!?!? So your telling me you can’t make a simple Italian dish that you have ALL the ingredients for very simple and you get and attitude with me? Bravo got my call and had no problem in making it even IF it wasn’t on their ‘Italian menu’. How can I get it every other time I’ve called even if I’ve gotten rudeness just took you guys cause your right down the road and now you tell me you can’t make that? It’s the same as broccoli and penne with butter .......

Its consistently a great pizza. Im there with my family every Friday night.

Good food, but we ended up bringing our own plates back up to the counter for the check because we were ignored for 15 minutes while the waitress went back and forth between her phone and talking to the workers in the kitchen. We were the only customers there, so there was no excuse for any of the employees at the front to ignore us. We found out later is that she was texting the owner which is fine, but he should not be contacting employees on their personal phone during working hours and distracting them from their jobs. Also, one of the younger male workers had such attitude about being called out that he got loud with me and my boyfriend when neither of us had raised our voices, literally took my card from my hands, rang me up, and then threw my card across the counter at me afterwards. Any behavior such as that would have immediately gotten someone fired elsewhere. Disappointed with the actions of everyone involved.

All Aboard has the most authentic NY style pizza Ive had in New Milford, so no complaints there as weve tried most of the pizza joints!

Great place to get a slice. Good beer on tap. Friendly staff.

Cozy place and adorable staff! Good quality pizza!

This place is Train themed because it is a train wreck. At one point they were ok, but the owner has become a total b-face. She no longer cares about providing a good service, quality food, or her clients. There are much better places near by. DONT GO HERE

Very kid friendly, above average pizza and great dessert options.

Reliable place for good grub. Wings are some of the better ones in town.

Great service, milkshakes, and food. Definitely a local favorite

Possibly the best Pizza in New Milford. You can order by the pie or by the slice.

Food is pretty mediocre. It isnt bad but more so just bland. My biggest issue is that they seem to always forget something when getting delivery.

Love the fast friendly service, good grub for the price, cool hangout in the Summer for Beer and ice cream

Just great pizza. Simple, homey, staff very inviting.

I was very disappointed with my meal. pepperoni wasnt crispy at all. Looked like turkey pepperoni. each slice pizza ( medium) had only 1 maybe 2 of toppings. mushy. tastelessFried dough was just hunks of white dough maybe fried, not crunchy not at all like a fairs fried dough. 2 or 3 spots where there was large amounts of cinn just spooned on i guess. Didnt see or taste any type of sweetness (sugar) once again very bland. I seldom do reviews. never thought of taking pictures to show what im talking about. I added my own conf sugar . Ill try heating them up in my toaster oven. I wanted to give 1 star but this site will not allow itThe kicker is that order ( for 2) was not cheap $50 It was del in a timely manner. no I would recommend this place!!!!!!

Good place for a family to go

Great Pizza, garlic knots and Pasta Fagioli. Fast polite delivery.

After ordering a pie of pizza it came cold and the dou was very hard and it was very greasy ! I was very unpleased then after giving it another try I order a burger when I told him well done I got it burnt all I can taste was the burn on the burger and there fries were soggy so for me never again will I order from here ! Plus there price are pricy like are u kidding me

Food is good . service is horrible .everytime I go there at night theres teenagers running the place like a hang out and all Latinos in the kitchen. used to be our favorite place . not anymore . its a shame I live 2 mins down the road but will probably never go back. I will go to Italian mias instead or brickhouse.

Always great service, never a problem with delivery guys & pizza is good. Never had a negative experience here

Wow, so disappointed in quality of food. First time trying this place. Will not be returning ! Ordered chicken fingers and fries, mozzarella sticks, chicken parm grinder ( ALL HORRIBLE!! )

My favorite restaurant in town. Best pizza and welcoming to teenagers :)

Great pizza and service! Always!

Super nice staff, quick service and amazing food must try if youre in New Milford!! And the shakes are to die for 😍😍😍

Love the wings, pizza, and ice cream.

We ordered food from them sat there for about 20 minutes to half an hour for them to tell us they never even put our order in very rude unprofessional staff is probably of high school age dont waste your time or energy going there

Chef Joey is the best he deserves a raise!!!

Super friendly

Delicious icecream.

Food was average... Service mediocre

Good food

The soon to be famous root beer wings were extremely disappointing. They are basically plain wings.

Friendly staff and quick service

Over priced and they took an hour and then forgot our soda and when we opened the pizza its toppings were on one side when we called to speak with someone they did nothing

Great pizza all the time!

Nice employees & speedy delivery.

Great local place to dine

Over priced and rude staff! Not worth it!

Great place for pizza

Just ok pizza.

Food is hit or miss.

Food was decent, it was freezing cold in the back corner though.

Great stuffed pizza

Yummy

Surprisingly good

Yummy food

Good Pizza