This place is a good spot for gamers who like board games, card games, RPGs, and TTRPGs.... but I bet it was awesome before the pandemic hit. I found the shelves a bit empty these days esp considering photos from a year or so ago. I also saw a lot of prior reviews say the community here was strong but the store was moreorless empty very quiet when I was there. Ill need to go back when life vaguely returns to normal and see what its like then. Overall tho worth a stop.

Great store that caters to all levels and types of gamers. They occasionally have people like Steve Jackson (creator of Munchkin) and others come to the store to do a event, and host D&D, Minateure gaming, and card tournaments.Visit them if you get a chance.

This is not a store it is the hub of a community. Not only does the staff play these games but they have great depth of knowledge about each system. Last time I went it was for a small item and the staff loaded me up with cool freebie items that sounded similar to what I came for. Cool people here! I remain a committed lifetime customer b/c they are on top of their game. The name is accurate.

Awesome store! Really appreciated the vibe, selection and help from the employees. They have options for any level and type of board or card gamer.

Mike was the employee that helped me with my purchase. He was very friendly and helpful. Was able to get me what i needed plus buy things I could use for my magic gaming experience. Is a great store and employee, will plan to continue to visit.

Place is awesome. Got a bit of everything and the inside is pretty cool overall.

A pretty nice selection of games. My friends and I will definitely be back!

Great game store, well stocked, friendly helpful staff.

Been going to TOGIT since it was located in Hillsborough. I wont shop anywhere else for my trading cards. They have friendly staff, great prices and are very knowledgeable about the games they sell.

Great customer service and super friendly.

Very nice store, huge selection of board games, card games and tabletop RPGs. I discovered this store via Free RPG Day. They have a great selection of RPGs, and not just D&D or Pathfinder. Youll find Star Trek Adventures, Star Wars (FFG), Starfinder and many other niche games. They have a game room in the back and the staff is super friendly and helpful. I felt welcome there. They are moving a few doors down soon and will have more space. I have a game shop 2 minutes from my house, UT Ill drive the 20 minutes it takes me to go to The Only Game in Town in Somerville since its much nicer.

Great staff and prices. Good selection of products as well.

Used to love coming here with all of our trades, so we can get different things/cards we need for certain games or decks. Staff was always nice and courteous, but I drive along way to make it to you guys from South Jersey. So im upset and thats the only reason I cant give you guys a 5 star rating. Website still says you do and Ive been patient all the way from March 2020 til now 😭. Please find a way to bring that back for everyone in the community even if its only on a few days during the week.Miss you guys!

Wanted to love this place, literally had a nice convo with the clerk about pokemon, and then he proceeded to sell me repackaged cards. Feels really bad.

They have a lot of different gaming stuff and a place to play too. Nice, helpful people

So this place really took a downturn starting covid times. They used to be punctual and good at ooening up on time. Half the times ive been there since covid theyve been closed for “vacations” with no notice anywhere other than their door, which happens to be a 45 minute drive from me. In other words, you really dont know when youre going to be wasting your time. They dont have a working phone line so theres no way to see if they are open, and the information about them on google is dated. Just lazy business running if you ask me. Take a trip to Boonton and go to huntington games. Much better place

Good layout, friendly employees, overall a good store. Unfortunately they where out of some of the more popular paints and minis which is unfortunate but expected.

While i have only came once, i found the staff to be nice. I came here to find vanguard singles but they didnt have much save for a few boosters and trial decks here and there. I would come back for sure if they had in stock more vanguard products but alas, it is not the case. I bought what they had and went on my way. (Apparently, one of the decks i got had a super rare card inside of it!! Picture included.)I would also like to add that, base on what i saw, is they specialize into MTG and pokemon based purely on what i saw in the glass case. I didnt see much in the way of Yugioh per say, as i was not looking for that, but i would say that they have that in stock as well. I did enjoy seeing all the warhammer stuff as well as all the paints and brushes for the models.The board games and other card games were a nice touch. I didnt really take noticed of their names but it made the shop a lot more lively just for having it in the store. It is rare to see stores, for me at least, to carry multiple types of games within the shop.In any event, parking at this location was easy and relatively easy to find. Since it is really close to route 287, getting to this location was a breeze.

Fantastic game store that keeps me coming back.The Only Game in Town has a HUGE selection of Trading Card Games, Board Games, etc. You name, they have it!The Only Game in Town buys a lot of your personal collections at FAIR prices. If you need cash, The Only Game in Town can help you.Clean. It is hard to find a game store these days that prides themselves on a clean and safe environment for you and your children. The Only Game in Town keeps their store very fresh smelling and pleasant.Overall, this place is a winner! And must visit.

They have amazing service and the people working there are really nice!

Awesome place cool people, a lot of Magic but a lot of Pokemon singles too which I came and keep coming back for!

A great place for table-top gamers to meet up and purchase what they need. The store has plenty of tables for both scheduled and unscheduled gaming events. Staff are friendly and try to keep the place family friendly. They also host a lot of MtG and Pokemon events. There is free parking beside/behind the building and there are food shops within walking distance.

The best place to sell Pokemon Bulk. Some cards are bought for much cheaper but on the cards they would maybe be worth 1-3 dollars so its not a big deal. I would not say they rip anyone off. People claiming they were ripped off could easily have shopped somewhere else or just done the research to know the value of whatever cards theyre complaining about I loved this place.T.O.G.I.T. is a top 3 shop in NJ if you ask me

Went in the store looking for a few specific cards and it was really easy to find them and the guys were very helpful. The only issue is that the phone number posted is disconnected so I don’t know how to contact the store

Not enough variety and cheaper online

Great place for new and old games. Friendly and helpful staff. You can buy and sell your old Nintendo, Sega Genesis and a whole lot more at fair prices. Its definitely a place you would want to visit if your in the area.

Prices are alright, staff is fun to talk with. Environment is cozy for the most part.

The best place for board games and card games. You like Dungeons and Dragons? They got it. Great community.

Great selection. Staff was friendly. Kind of wished i had stopped by on different day than a tournament. I just wanted to browse bit kept having to dodge the massive amount of tournament players. But i guess if you have that much turnout for a tournament that has to be a good thing.

Very friendly staff that know what theyre talking about. Walked in with no idea what I needed to start playing Magic The Gathering, and walked out with a deck and a hand-written slip of paper with recommendations for websites and live streams to watch to get better at the game. The store was also hosting an event when I walked in and although the players were enthusiastic, nobody was acting loud or obnoxious while customers were shopping. They have a wide assortment of stock from Magic Cards to D&D and Warhammer sets, figurines and paints. Will definitely be back for a game night!

Great selection of board games, tabletop rpg elements, and trading cards. They purchase bulk trading cards which is nice, though of course you could probably get more selling online. What is stopping me from rating five stars is my experiences in here as a woman. I visit the store once a month or so, and have brothers who visit it at least once a week. It has become painstakingly obvious that a few of the employees seem to think that I do not know what I am talking about simply because I am a woman. I have been a Pokemon fan for over a decade, and buying and selling cards for nearly as long, and accordingly know a great deal about it and the business of trading cards. Yet for some reason, when I went in to purchase a new storage box, I was told that they had none, and were a bit dismissive of my request. That alone is fine- people run out of things, and I could get one online, no big deal. However, the very next day, my brother went in and purchased two! I dont doubt that they could have gotten more in between our visits, but it would have been nice if one of the employees mentioned that they may get some in soon so I didnt have to wait for shipping. When selling bulk, there are traces of annoyance from the employees, which my brothers (who also occasionally sell bulk) have not experienced. Yes, it could be general spite for the job itself and not me- I work retail too, I get it. But this, combined with the customers makes me feel unwelcome in the store. (Yeah, they cant help the customers who look at me like I dont belong, I know thats not their fault.) Its a shame, really, because it is a very nice hobby shop, and I have many fond memories as a child of playing in the Pokemon card league in the back, but unfortunately I have to avoid going altogether.

My wife and I had a fantastic experience here! We are just getting into Magic: the Gathering and the staff here was able to help us and answer all our questions. They have hundreds of individual MTG cards for sale as well as booster packs and decks available. I would highly recommend for all your MTG needs!

Nice guys, wide selections of paints, and a good range of toys on offer. My main complaint would be that the smell leaves something to be desired.

Fantastic staff. I went and sold my collection of magic cards and they, John in particular, took their time to diligently work with me to price everything out fairly. 10/10 would recommend to everyone.

Best game store around by far. Huge selection and willing to order anything not already in stock. Knowledgeable, friendly staff. What more could you ask for?

Very helpful and friendly staff. They offer 20% extra store credit compared to cash when you sell MTG cards to them and have a good 3 for $10 deal on booster packs for current blocks. Definitely my new favorite game store.

Great store for Magic! Game nights and fair prices.Also offers a bunch of board games and Pokémon if you’re into that.Greatest game shop around

Your phone number does not work

Awesome atmosphere! The store is well stocked, clean and organized. The staff is friendly, welcoming and super helpful. Oh and great location too, many things to do in the area after you visit Togit.

Its okay, Its too small for big events. Very loud. The worst part is also the best part. The crowd. The people that go there. Some are nice and almost all of the magic the gathering games I played there were very competitive and well played. But I warn you. BE AWARE of the crowd. Enjoy

Don’t get me wrong about this review, the staff is great and helpful. even tho they might not show much interest it’s atleast helpful how knowledgeable they are and willing to help. Big problem is the community. You want try hard kids who are willing to spend there parents money and focus on winning rather than actually playing game that’s the place. Winning is the only thing. If you are new or looking for friends this is NOT the place.

Extremely disappointed. I went to sell some old boxes of magic and asked to be treated fairly, and they tried to Rob me. A box of 5th edition goes for 799 on eBay and would understand a decent chunk off but they tried 200 range. They lost a tremendous opportunity with my old stuff because they cant be fair. Do yourself a favor and avoid the same and sell your stuff elsewhere.

My son lives card games but I dont know how to play them. This place had tournaments and the workers and other players have helped my son a lot. They let him know which cards are better, talk about strategy and respect each other. My son goes here all the time and we will continue to do so. Thank you for your store.

Amazing game shop right on main street. Staff is amazing. The variety of games is excellent. They have singles of all the cards you could want. They also hold tournaments and different game nights.

Great local board game and trading card game store. They host lots of events. Check their calendar.

Consistently improving and growing. Owner is courteous. Once a hole-in-the-wall, this is now a destination in Somerville.

Before I make out this review I want to explain that it has taken me a while to put my thoughts into words about this place. And I will not be dropping names in this review I simply need to express a major concern with the staff, Im also not a difficult person to deal with at all.For years I have participated in many different TCGs with Magic being a major game for me. I have been to quite a few different shops over the years and have stopped by The Only Game in Town many, many times especially over the last year and a half. At my first visit ever, I had felt welcomed and encouraged to return with smiles and kind words from the guys behind the counter which felt great and had motivated me to make my return.However since my first time, I have felt more and more uncomfortable coming here primarily due to the different people behind the counter and their attitudes towards people and their questions. I have participated in prereleases here and have spent much money here and all the while felt criticized for either asking about singles or even walking into the shop. My initial intention was to never return here but I just would like to warn others if you come here.My last transaction here was midway through December in which i had purchased 2 boxes of Throne of Eldraine in addition to some dollar singles. The guy behind the counter was pleasant but at first seemed to not really care I was there. I had walked in about an hour after the store opened and no one else was in the shop other than me and the store associate.After faning through the singles on the counter, I had asked the guy about a few singles I had been looking for to which he did help me out however the whole time was eating a full meal right infront of me. Now normally I wouldnt care about that but you will see why I point this out soon. After looking through the singles he had behind the counter, The guy had asked me to hold on a second while grabbing his food and moving to the back room out of site. He was gone for about 20 min. Meanwhile another store associate had come in to start work and was super pleasant.She had been the person to help me complete my transaction at this point. As she was adding everything together at the counter and I was about to pay, the guy that had originally helped me came out from the back room, sat on the computer behind the desk and said oh good thank you for helping I completely forgot about this guy to the other store associate....The girl helping me and myself both chuckled nervously and I was pretty furious at this point. On the way out I had thanked the girl and shook her had and left never wanting to return. This was not the first time i have felt disrespected for doing buisness here. Let me explain another time prior to this.About a month prior to this I had gone in looking for singles for a deck I was building which I have done before at this shop. I was with a friend who tends to spend alot more money than I at this shop please keep this in mind. Upon entering the shop, the dude behind the counter said Oh no this guy again? Under his breath but still audible to people around us. I had ignored this initially and asked about a few singles I needed which was only about 15 cards most of which were in the glass case.The guy had a horrible attitude the whole time he was dealing with me and tried to make the transaction go as quick as possible. Once my transaction was done and payed for I had waited for my friend to buy what he wanted so we could leave. The same exact guy hepled my buddy and treated him with respect and spent time with him. Just a side note my buddy spent about 400 bucks this night. In my mind this tells me that after all the chances I gave this place, it really didnt matter in the end. But thats not all! I had returned recently to ask about a couple of cards that recently came out in the current Theros set and still received attitude when i asked. I walked right out. Word of advice to the owners, if you want return customers id recommend retraining your staff...

Fantastic local game shop. A mix of cards, minis, paints, and local games for everyone. The people who work here are incredibly helpful and will go out of their way to make sure you are helped. I see games going on in the front window all the time.All in all I gotta love a geek store who is inclusive, open to their local community, and caters to all of the different kinds of geeks (cards, rp, minis, artists)

Staff is very helpful, honest and treats customers kindly. Fair prices for products.

I love the atmosphere and the people behind the counter. Floored when I saw Blood Bowl banners. This is a good place.

Amazing store great selection! Definitely the best place and prices for pokemon cards

Its a great place with really good staff. I really love the game night on mondays. Theyre good at introducing new games and teaching them. The people who come here are great too. I love the atmosphere in there.

Ive been coming to this shop on and off for a little while not, and there are some pros and cons. I dont usually write reviews, but I felt very down after my last visit here and feel like people should be given a proper idea of how this shop operates.Pros:-Environment is great for play-Staff is very knowledgeable and polite-Massive amount of card inventoryCons:-Prices. This shop claims to use channel fireball as a reference point for their prices, which they do. What they dont do is take into account a cards condition. Ive on a number of occasions bought cards from them at near mint value, only to find scuffs, slight corner peeling, etc. In addition, this rule apparently does not apply to all cards, as no matter what, any non sought-after/ non-valuable commons/uncommons are always 50¢. This means every playset will cost you $2.00 minimum, which adds up quick.To put this into perspective, on my last visit I came in with a list of cards I wanted to purchase. I was originally going to buy the cards on tcgplayer, but didnt want to wait. Some of the cards were older, so they did not have about half the list in stock. Not a big deal. I was charged $20 for the cards they had available. On TCGPlayer, the cards came out to a total of $13 for the Entire list, and that was with $4 in shipping fees. Upon further searching, the value of the cards I bought, according to channel fireball, was $11.92. That means that I was charged pretty much double for HALF of my list and that they are not fully following the price reference they claim to be. Dont get me wrong, I expected to pay more, but not that much for so little.-Accessory and gear inventory could be better.In my opinion, unless you truly need the cards right away, and another LGS does not have what you need, you are better off buying the cards online. I dont say this lightly, as I am all about supporting LGSs, but this shop will likely rip you off.

If you a text not a super nerd, do not go into this store. This store is meant for people who love what they do. The customer service is immaculate. But there are a lot of needs in that store

Google said you were open sign on the door says closed mondays. Update your times please

Amazing store. Ive been coming here since I was young and have always had an enjoyable experience. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. Couldnt ask for a better place to play the games I enjoy.

Excellent customer service experience At the only game in town. Needed a gift for my niece, the team was able to educate me on the product, recommended which packs to buy and even hand delivered an item I was looking at on amazon.

One of the best LGSs Ive been to in a long time - I just wish I didnt live so far away. They have a good organized MTG scene, too

Great small game store. Lots of the normal popular mainstream tabletop games, and a good collection of the less mainstream. VERY kind and friendly staff. Very helpful.

Great store. Fantastic place to play and loving community. Employees are knowledgeable and courteous. If you like trading card games, war games, or other tabletop games, this is the place to go.

Shady store, they will try to steal from you any chance they get. Went to sell my large MTG collection here and the guy would ring the cards into the computer and then write down the dollar amount and clear the computer after a batch of cards. This didnt become a problem until the end when I had to remind him about 4 piles of cards he forgot about. Ya know if I wasnt paying attention TOGIT would have gotten about 250 in cards for free. The system is designed to take advantage of people not paying attention. They at the very least should get better employees if that is not their intentions, but who knows. Oh btw they buy stolen cards with ZERO questions.

Excellent place for cards. Board games and RPGs. They also carry some Games Workshop kits and paints. Very clean. Friendly staff and theres decent free parking nearby.

Been coming to the store for about 12+ years now and it is always a warm, welcoming place. I would consider it a home away from home. Great people and an awesome place to make life long friends.

I love this store. Especially because the people who work there are not rude or judgmental even if you have no idea what youre doing when it comes to Magic the Gathering or Warhammer 40k (me). I have never had a negative experience at this store. The only problem I have with this store is the parking, frankly it sucks. It is almost guaranteed a block away parking most days. Other than that, I would live here if I had the money. Their prices are fair and competitive. 10/10 will and do recommend to any new player for any kind of card game or war game. Thanks for your store and all you guys do.

The Only Game in Town is my favorite place to play magic the gathering and table top games. The staff is super friendly and helpful, the events are masterfully run, and the community consists of a fun group of individuals. With a large selection of table top games, and a variety of TCG singles (Pokemon, Magic the Gathering, etc.), The Only Game in town is a great place to spend time with friends.

Great selection of games. Helpful staff.

Great store. Found a lot different things there from magic cards to DnD miniatures

These are good folks. Ive shopped here plenty and theyre always above board. When I preordered a game and they were unable to get it, they could have just said sorry but they went the extra mile for service recovery. Ill keep coming back, thanks.

Cant wait for them to move to their new location!

Amazing place, by far one of the best card shops I’ve ever stepped foot in. Staff is always willing to help and always have what you need. I guarantee you won’t leave the store empty handed 👍🏽

Awesome place, has everything you can think of and great employees

Everyone was friendly and helpful. Atmosphere was pleasant and the staff was knowledgeable.

Nice store. Went for a gaming event and had a good time. Price were reasonable, staff was friendly.

Great gaming community. Welcomes new players. Having a great time.

We love gaming there with the whole family. A great time in Somerville.

The employees are very nice people, the owner seems like a cool guy, and tons of products to choose from. The clients ( who youll be interacting with most of the time there) are not really that friendly, especially to new players. Its not really the stores fault, but I cant give a place 5 or 4 stars if I feel uncomfortable and dont have a good time.

Overpriced on almost any MTG item. Came in to see if they had an item I was looking for. Guy busts out a few and gives me a price that was WAY over the average found through other vendors online. Before I could say anything, he then proceeded to say how they were in good condition so he couldnt do anything about the price. I wasnt going to argue the idea of competitive pricing with the guy.But really, about a 50% markup on an item I wanted two of?I politely said no thank you and left to get some lunch. Came back later to check for another item I had my eyes on. $380 average online - $500 at this store.I drove out instead of ordering online because I wanted to support local business.Sadly, my money will go to a fairly priced online vendor. Im sure they dont care about one guys business going elsewhere but I wouldve really enjoyed spending my time and money there in the future.Decent selection of tabletop board games, plushies, and other items though. Staff wasnt necessarily friendly but they werent rude at all - at least not to my face. Nice location and easy to find. Wish pricing were a little more in favor of the buyer (honestly I wouldnt even mind a slight markup, those were just way too steep).3/5Edit:@MikeThank you for responding to my review!First and foremost, I want to make it clear that I did in fact find your staff to be courteous and polite! Perhaps my initial wording made it seem I meant the opposite so I apologise for any misunderstanding.I disagree with your justification on pricing in that your store simply doesnt have the volume of business as Starcity, Channel Fireball, etc. Being a small store in Somerville, NJ doesnt compare to the volume of those giants. I believe every other store I found on TCGplayer adheres to the prices I expect and yours should do the same. Now, this is just my opinion - take it as you will.It is an expensive hobby, and markups from the local shops are to be expected, but I felt taken advantage of by the prices presented to me at your store. I did find what I was looking for at another local store at much more reasonable prices and purchased them there.I do appreciate your response and willingness to further discuss/inquire on this matter. I would love to come back to your store for some of the tabletops you have available and for gifts. In regards to MTG, however, I will continue to hunt for more competitive prices.

Great place to find game related merch that you cant find anywhere else. I was there for Pokemon cards but Ill note that it is the MUST stop place for those who like Magic and Dungeons and Dragons. I dont know much about those franchises, but The Only Game in Town seems to be fully stocked on everything you could need. They also host gameplay in shop for those looking to find other people with the same hobby.It is a store with board games, trading cards and other live role playing style games so dont go here looking for video games. They dont advertise as a video game shop, hence me giving the great review...but it could be confusing for those who are looking into the world of gaming for the first time so just note the style of gaming merch they carry! :-)

Good pricing offered based on other places I have brought my son to recently. Staff is willing to take the time to work with the customers.

I love bad ice cream 3 at hudgames, i could play on pc now yes!!!!!

Great shop. Has tons of demo games and events. They made huge renovations and a overhaul. Overall a lot brighter gunner and spacious.

Great store...huge selection of pokemon singles. A knowledgeable staff and nice atmosphere.

Friendly and helpful staff. Good pack deals too .its a little far from my house but definitely worth the trip when Im in the area.

A great place to stop in for Magic the Gathering singles! They had everything we needed and ideas for more! We will be back soon!

Great setting with good vibes. Im new this but it was a great learning experience. Everyone here is a part of this great community.

Very friendly, helpful and smart group of guys! Gets a great jump start to any new beginners and starters for any game! Am a casual player!

Great place to play Pokémon or Magic! Singles prices are reasonable. Staff is very friendly.

Excellent store, great selection of cards. Their prices are very competive with other hobby shops that sell MtG cards.The people there were very friendly and helpful to someone like me whos getting back into the game after 15 (!) years.My only reservation is that (the times I was there) is that you cant browse through the single yourself. I needed to give them a list of my needs, and they pull them out for you. This is a minor complaint, and doesnt really impact my review.

They have exotic stuffed animals and a wide collection of boardgames

Employees always helpful and take the time to support you

A poor environment and completely unenjoyable. The staff is rude, inconsiderate and condescending. Tonight was the last straw. We will definitely share our experiences with our son’s many classmates who play MTG and I will probably never allow our family to waste another penny in this miserable establishment. If you want to have fun with nice people go to Bernardsville.

It was awesome and they really help you. I wanted to get some Pokemon cards and they really showed you and explained the process and gave me the best cards for a good price.

Great store been going to it for a while. It has had a nice remodel that made the layout better. The staff is very friendly and awesome to talk with. If you are looking for a local place for collectable games form MtG to Warhammer check this place out.

Bruh, if youre into this kinda 90s nerdy dweller stuff this is kind of place for you. otherwise go to other comic book stores at the center of town.

Very solid location for card and board games. Good crowd, good stock of books, cards, figures, and accessories. Friendly staff, as well.

Great store, store with greater staff, never a bad experience. Keep up the good work.

Great selection of dice sets and other DnD items, among many other things

Good selection, helpful and friendly staff. I like the renovations, its a more open and nice aesthetic.

Great staff. Good prices. Fun tournaments !

Very freindly even when u dont know games