I have been going here for a few years. Never disappointed. Fresh Bagels, moist & chewy. They make very good egg sandwiches as well. Staff is always friendly and accommodating. This is the best bagel place around! 😋

This place might actually have the best bagels at the shore. They have tofu cream cheese and I love to everything Bagels. The coffee here is pretty good too

We love Silver Bay Bagels! We are relatively new to the area and this is now our local bagel spot - we will not be going anywhere else! We order online and the bagels are always hot and ready for pick-up. They get you in and out fast, but are always friendly and welcoming. Its easy to get to the shop from Hooper ave and you can park in the front. But parking in the back is really easy once you find it! (make a right at the doggie daycare sign in the back). Their blueberry bagels are the best we have ever had and they make a great bacon & egg on toasted sesame. We have found our bagel place!! :-)

Awesome bagel place down the shore. Staff is great, food is phenomenal. Best bacon egg and cheese I’ve had so far. New, updated store space and motivated, friendly workers made it all the better (@ the cute girl at the cash register) ;)Highly recommend! 10/10.

So Ive ordered from here three or four times and every time it was fantastic. Great omoletes with premium quality bacon on the side and the home fries, well, I can honestly say they are the best Ive ever had in my life. Kudos to the staff and owners for being both good and consistent at a time when many restaurants arent due to the difficulty of finding reliable staff and other issues in a highly inflationary economy. Five stars highest rating!

Almost $3.00 for a small bagel with very little cream cheese. Used to have nice big bagels. Now you get less and pay more.

Excellent place for a quick meal 😋. For example.: breakfast, lunch, dinner as well.

The bagels here are so warm and fresh in the morning. This is my go to place for a quick bite to eat during breakfast!

Nice place. Nothing that is pushing it to a five star. Food was good, menu had a nice selection, pricing was fair, staff was ok and atmosphere is something you would expect from a standard bagel shop. Nothing here is really separating the experience from other locations.

Great Bagels. Any breakfast sandwich Ive had there has been great and every once in awhile Ill get chicken salad for lunch never been disappointed. They are normally busy but the crew is very quick.

Good food. Always busy. Nice people

Everything here is super delicious and fresh except the coffee do not drink the coffee.

Delicious food. Best bagels in the area. Plus, they dont skimp on the meat. They also have a bunch of different salad options to put on your bagel (chicken, tuna, etc...).

Great Bagles and sandwiches. Friendly service.

Absolutely love this place! Friendly service and staff. Always super helpful even when they are extremely busy. Bagels and other foods are always fresh! Highly recommend going here.

It was super nice to see Silver Bay Bagels team up with Toms River Police for Coffee With A Cop this morning!Great community relations with great community affairs police officers!!

Love everyone who works here. Amazing people and great atmosphere.

Bagels are delicious. Love the app and ordering ahead. Friendly and fast service. Its always busy because its good

Love this place. I have ordered through (DoorDash) from here and the food is amazing.The quality, effort and way they follow special instructions is amazing. Worth every penny, their competitors across the street can’t compare.Excellent food, and they value the (DoorDash) customers as well, packing the food with care.

Best bagel/breakfast stop in the area. We eat here multiple times a week. Great food, better service!

Phenomenal. Place and people are 5 stars. Highly recommend

Best bagels in the area. Great breakfast sandwich.

Professional kind and always fresh food! My go to is egg whites, onion, tomatoes, peppers with turkey bacon on an egg bagel simply delicious!

Silver Bay Bagels is top notch ... the food is impeccable and the staff is wonderful. The owner Brian is always happy and interacts personably with his customers. Being we moved from TR, this is a place I miss!

Great people, food is fantastic and the local ambiance is felt all over the store. Good to see the friendliness of the employees and personable. Thanks for the good food!

Place looks great, food is good

Bagels are great! THEY SERVED MY ICE COFFEE WITH ICE CUBES MADE OF COFFEE! This place is living in 3021!

Literally my favorite bagel place.

Awesome food. It was packed, but the staff moved through the orders quickly and pleasant.Rene best cook in NJ. Brie, Taylor,Jordan and the rest of the staff are the best.If I can give more then 5 stars I would. Thanks Brian.Stay safe!

Brian and the team have some of the best bagels in town. When I want breakfast SBB is where I go. Dont spread your hard earned cheese with anyone else

Great bagels and quick service.

Silver Bay Bagels is AMAZING!!!! Breakfast or lunch, they never miss the mark. Aside from the food, the team they have in place is customer service oriented and never lets us down...

Best bagels in the area. Always fresh and tasty! Staff is friendly and very efficient.

Fresh bagels...good coffee...the staff was friendly.

My favorite bagel place, hands down! Been coming here for years and nothing else matches theeir quality and freshness!! My personal fave is the whole wheat everything with egg white, turkey bacon, and cheese! Thanks, Brian and crew!!!

Best bagel shop/breakfast deli in Toms River as well as the surrounding area. Brian, the owner, is a great guy and the girls behind the counter are always so nice. Highly recommend their everything bagel or the breakfast burrito and the iced coffee with iced coffee cubes is the best!

Very friendly, delicious fresh hot bagels, and breakfast sandwiches

Best bagels around

I would have given 5 stars....but no seating.

Best bagel outside of NYC... might even be better than NYC!

Amazing good and staff! I can’t say enough about how nice everyone is here and how great the food and coffee is! The iced coffee is to die for especially with the homemade coffee ice cubes, so brilliant!❤️

Always delicious! Our go-to spot for a great bacon,egg, and cheese sandwich.

Clean inside and outside, staff is fast to serve and quick on the ordering, the bagel variety is vast and the breakfast sandwiches hold you over the entire day.. try the all.meat breakfast sandwiche.. amazing.. open early as well.. the staff behind the counter are down to earth town kind of people..

I’ve been living in Silverton for 3 years now. Finally I feel well enough versed to write an honest review. Silver Bay is the best bagel shop here. I say this because yes, their bagels are excellent, and I feel that types and quality of bagel is really a preference and can be debated but as far as a shop, they are the best. Everyone is as friendly as you could probably ask them to be. The food is great quality (Try the Porkroll Egg & Cheese on an Everything Bagel or the French Toast Platter - challah bread? - eggs your way - pick of meat and some good god incredible hash browns no idea why they are so good, cant figure it out) They slice their porkroll the right way, thin, perfectly crisp. The platter gives you so much food for the price. The pricing is perfectly balanced for the amount and quality you get here, hard to find now a days. Stop searching, you found your bagel spot.

The best as always I live in Florida now and you cant get bagels like you can in New York and New Jersey Silverton Bagels you rock

Better than Ohio bagels, close to NYC bagels but not there yet!

The staff worked tirelessly today to fulfill bagel orders for customers on Father’s Day! The staff were friendly and brought orders outside to waiting patrons on a very busy Sunday! Pork roll, egg and cheese on a bagel were super!!! Thank you Silverton! Cheers, Bob

Theres two reasons I come to New Jersey. 1. To see my best friend and 2. For the pork roll egg and cheese on an everything bagel from silver bay bagels. I love this place so much!!!!

Best place in town to get bagels Brian is a great person is the owner all his workers are as well nice and friendly and courteous. Do you want good bagels made on Site this is the place to go. They have tables you can sit down and order breakfast or get it to go.

They have the best bagels in Toms river Brian is the best his crew is right on the money east and friendly there great

It was ok I still cant believe there are bagel stores that still dont be things on the bottom part of the bagel..I got an everything bagel loaded on the top with nothing on the bottom alittle disappointed

The food is good but the service is too slow

Great bagels for a great price! Love the scallion cream cheese

I used to come on my way to work before COVID. Then I started going back to work and was sooooooo excited to grab a bagel from one of the 2 bagel places I like...but here’s where it went wrong. MY BAGEL WAS BURNT!!!!! I couldn’t believe it as first, and it kind of ruined my first day back to work after COVID. I don’t know if it was because they had around 4 orders at once but I mean come on. I said toasted not scorched.

Yummy. Great bagels. Nice staff.

Great local place. Owner always there and talking to people. Plan on the earlier side because the place gets sudden crowds and can run out before new batches come out. Best is if your lucky enough to get the bagels warm. Ive found everything fresh too. Support local.

Textures and taste of their bagels are fantastic!!! Im partial to their everything bagel and bialys. Thoroughly enjoy this mom-and-pop place with a coastal feel. As a matter of fact, I flew to TX with 2 dozen bagels from this place as a request from friends that used to live here. Love it!

Bagels are great here! Very clean place and a nice staff. Really good prices.

Best whole wheat everything bagels.....

Excellent

The best!!! Bacon egg and cheese on Salt Bagel. 👍

Best Bagels! Great owners.

Great bagels chocolate chip was my favorite

Literally the best bagels in the country.

This is one of the bagel shops in Toms River if not ocean county. There is a Manhattan Bagel across the street and yet it is always busy. Even on a weekend morning when they have every seat filled and a dozen or so people standing and waiting to receive their order, the wait is rarely more than 15 minutes.The bagels are continually baked fresh and repeatedly refreshed into bins for the front counter to pull from. The home fries are amazing and generously portioned. The staff is friendly and helpful. They make a great pork roll egg and cheese too.I have been referring people here for over 20 years and have never had a single complaint.

Fantastic boiled bagels they way bagels should be made. Always fresh!! Enjoyable breakfast & lunch place with local patron flair..

Love their bagels, whether a sandwich or with a spread!! Staff are great and get to know their customers! Great atmosphere!

Best bagel shop in South and Central Jersey

Probably the best bagel spot on the planet, and they have vegan cream cheese which is a game changer for lactose intolerant people. Service is great and iced coffee iced cubes are a great addition

Big bagels! Tasty. Had mine with cream cheese. Whipped cream cheese not available. Bummer. Plenty of tables. Coffees good. Tough parking.

Always good service and friendly staff! Love their fresh bagels too!

Theres no better way to start your day than with a pork roll and cheese from Silver Bay Bagels! The mini bagels and green St. Patricks Day ones are also amazing. Its a small business where everyone knows your name.

Hands down, the BEST bagels. The staff is super friendly!

Great bagels! We love the iced coffee with coffee ice cubes!

Good bagels however they need need a better coffee. Too weak. Good Coffee is important.

Great food - great prices - great atmosphere - nice energetic staff 👍

Best bagels I have found in our area since moving here!

Best bagels in town Im going there for years. Great service the owner gets to know everybodys name greet you when you come in. Not to mention the coffee is out of this world.

Bagels are delicious, I bought a mixed dozen, one cream cheese container and a breakstone butter, for 19 bucks. Definitely worth it.

Best bagles in the area! Great variety and people!

This place has the best bagels anywhere, always busy which means always freshest product..A+++

Clean, friendly, efficient staff, nice local bagel shop. Coffee was really good and I thought the bagel sandwich was on the spot.

The best coffee and the best bagels and amazing service.

Best bagels in Ocean County. Very clean and very friendly staff. Sandwiches are delicious.

Excellent omlette as always and for a great price!

Im local business in a local community is always great

Very nice place great food and the staff are friendly

Quick, friendly, good food, good prices.... My daily stop

Great selection of bagels and spreads the coffee is good and hot also reasonably priced

This is the best bagel place in the area. The best is a French toast bagel with cream cheese.

Breakfast was delicious and the service was extremely friendly!

Great food and service

Great staff always friendly food great

Great bagels! The only thing they need is, Mr. Roarke from Fantasy Island. Telling everybody to smile. A little happiness goes a long way.

The bagels there are warm n fresh, made on site. double dip eggs french toast bagel will rock your world 1of our favs. Very pleasant service.. You will go back for more. A-plus

Quick n hassle n the bagels are super moist n fresh

I’ve lived in Brick my entire life and still think this place has the best bagels in the area.

Great bagel place!! Workers are very friendly and the sandwiches are great. Highly recommend!!

Great ownership, great food and great staff. They never disappoint.

Best bagels in Ocean County. Great food, better people!