Good service and good bagels. My hubby and his boys love the breakfast sandwiches! Veggie cream cheese is yummy!

Some of the most delicious sandwiches I have had. Their Lox and cream cheese bagel is to doe for. So good in fact I have to control myself not to get one everyday. Fresh bagels made daily, and great conversation with the staff. Always a smile and a cheerful anecdote to give.

THE GIRL WAS RUDE IT WAS 930 AND SHE WAS ON PHONE TALKING ABOUT WHAT SHE DID THE NIGHT BEFORE SHE SAID THEY WERE OUT OF EVERYTHING MINUS ONION BAGELS BUT SAID IT SO RUDE I WILL NEVER GO TO THAT ONE AGAIN ILL TAKE MY BUSNIESS ELSEWHERE THAT GIRL OUGHT BE A SHAME OF HOW SHE TREATED US AND OTHER CUSTOMERS I WASNT GONNA WRITE THIS BUT THIS ME SO LIVID AND DISGUSTED!!!!!! ILL BE GOING TO THE HIGHER HIGHER UPS!!It happened on rt 37 by Lindas Pizza and thank you I appreciate that joe.

We leave them with one star because we have to as they dont deserve it especially for the way they treated my wife yesterday. We were purchasing bagels and coffee from there when a worker bumped into me causing my hot coffee to spill on her back causing her to get burned. When my wife brought it to their attention they brushed it off as if she was trying to get something out of them. The owners comments were I have to look at the video and then wr dont play that. Then literally telling her to get out of the store in the condition she was in without any concerns to her incision scared back from previous back surgery. You go into that store at your own safety as they don’t have any for you. We will never go back there. A place like that does not deserve our business or for that matter yours. You have been warned. Stay safe and watch out for your back. 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻☹️This guy literally does not care for his customers or instead of kicking my wife out of the store and crying historically he would have gone out of his way to make sure she was okay and some type of medical help which he did none of. Just be careful of this place of business. Thank God that God is watching out for my wife. 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻

I drive 4 miles out of my way to get this place for breakfast. I’m there usually 3-4 times a week and I get the same welcoming reception from the girls upfront. They earn the tip I give them and the cooks in the back are on point.. The meats always cooked perfectly and the sandwich always holds up. I can’t get a pork roll egg cheese and hash brown anywhere else that holds a torch to this place. Keep up the smiling faces and great food.

Great place! Delicious breakfast sandwiches and phenomenal service!

Breakfast sandwiches are awesome perfect amount of meat cheese egg and bagel 👏

Great Bagels and excellent service. I am never disappointed!

Great bagels, a great assortment to choose from and many choices for cream cheese.

Devout bagel lover. This place is one of the best

First time ever going there but my sandwich was delicious

Fire food just to keep it short n sweet.

They have the best bagels ever and the people are always so friendly!

Really good bagels. Nice people work there.

Anything that you may put on an All-Star bagel, whether it be breakfast brunch lunch or dinner surpasses any other local bagel offering.

Excellent service, very pleasant experience,great product,quick service, reasonable pricing.

When I want great fresh bagels, Ill make the 20+minute drive to go there, even though other bagel places are closer.

The don’t toast and smear individual bagels!

Great little bagel shop on RT. 37

Good breakfast, but they need more cheese variety, they only have American cheddar and provolone.

Amazing bagels 👍👍

The breakfast sandwiches are delicious and the customer service is great. The girls are always very sweet and friendly. They always greet me with their beautiful smiles and their bubbly personalities which makes going there all the more enjoyable. You will not meet people who are nearly as friendly anywhere else. I enjoy the grand slam or the triple play breakfast sandwiches the most. The bagels are awesome too and they always hook you up with extra cream cheese!

They are always friendly and efficient. Its a pleasure to go there.

Best bagels in toms river. Employees are very nice .

Really about 3-1/2 stars. Honestly, its okay, but Im spoiled. I live in Bergen County and theres NO comparison to the bagels. Its a decent fix while were down here on the weekends. Im surprised that their breakfast sandwiches are the same price as up north...especially since theres really no taste comparison. Overall, for this area, theyre decent.

Great service for good bagels.

Amazing bagels, good variety, good sandwiches

Amazing bagels. So fresh

You will like it! They are great

I called and she said I cant hear you it sounds like youre 50 feet away from the phone. Ive been a customer for years now, idk if ill be coming back.

Nice place for a bagel

Great bagels, friendly staff and very clean.

Awesome Bagel!! Great staff!

Fantastic bagels! Good service, great selection of bagel types and beverages.

Best bagels!

So good love this place!

They make the best breakfast sandwiches around and Ive tried many. Even my picky eight yr old loves them

5/5 starsBest bagels I’ve ever had hands down for a good price! The counter staff are always friendly and helpful especially with the CBD products. Highly recommended.

OPEN EVERY DAY EXCEPT CHRISTMAS.Ordered a Turkey, Sausage, Egg and cheese on an everything bagel and it was great, especially for the price: $4.95 ! Had a host of other breakfast items and desserts on the menu as well.They serve self-serve coffee, so you can refill coffee. Tasted good as well. Overall, great place to grab a quick, great breakfast.

Great place and they open during this covid for take out. Recommend.

Best bagels around 👍

Great place for a quick eat

“Best bagel place in county hands down”I have tried just about every bagel place in ocean county and many more and this in number 1.Sandwiches are also very good.Short review because they are just the best bagels and there is nothing else to say.

The bagels were delicious, still warm when I got home! Super fast service and great prices!

Pretty quick for a busy tiny eatery. Made me my two eggs over easy with bacon hash brown, jelly and cream cheese on a cinnamon raisin bagel. I know, gross, but I eat strange. Was good!

Great. Has healthy options such as turkey bacon as well as regular breakfast meats. Also has lunch sandwiches.

Tomato basil bagel with vegetable cream cheese toast it so good places clean people are nice must make the visit if youre in the area

Great bagels. Delicious sandwiches. Worst part is when I get to the last bite and realize the deliciousness is almost over.

The best bagels I have found. Always fresh, soft. Just delish. Highly recommend this place..

Good bagel and cream cheese selection

Eh. Certainly better than Dunkin Donuts bagels but a far cry from the best bagels in the S. TOMS RIVER NJ area: NY Water Bagel Co. on Fischer Blvd. Best in the area. Place is also a deli and big on breakfast sandwiches.When I worked up the street from NY Water Bagels, stopped for a medium coffee and Onion Bagel w/Cream Cheese every day.

Service great. Bagels good and fresh

Bagels are good here. Service is a little slow. Pork roll egg and cheese is really good here. Large selection. The place inside could look a little nicer.

Bagels are delicious, ask for audrey.

Good bagel selection.

Like long wait times and bagels the quality of Dunkin Donuts? Then this is definitely the place for you! Between their lousy customer service, bagels the texture of gummy worms, and the cheapest spread of cream cheese I’ve ever seen... I would make it a point to drive a little further to get a decent breakfast. All Star Bagel is surely no MVP in the bagel game, you sir get a participation medal.

Every time I come here, I only get the French Toast bagel with cream cheese. Wonderful!Next time, Ill go diverse and try a different kind.

Love all star bagel. Very fast and friendly.

Great bagels... Very fresh.Not sure why but the West bound seems a bit fresher

Very nice people and great food! Best bagels. Even better than Manhattan in my opinion.

I am a repeatk customer, love the steak egg and cheese on an everything bagel

Very good bacon egg and cheese...

Very disappointed with the bagel and cream cheese. Bagel was basically the same as what you get at Dunkin Donuts which I refer to as a bread donut. Very spongy inside and the outside was not crispy. A premium quality bagel is crispy on the outside and airy on the inside. I could tell by looking at the bagels in the case and the fact that I didnt see a big kettle in the back that they order the bagels pre made and just bake them. Doing it the proper way takes more time where the bagels are hand rolled, fermented overnight for the yeast to grow, then boiled briefly then baked and voila, for the extra effort you get tremendous pride in having the best with hundreds of more customers everyday and more profits. The quick shortcut way is terrible in my opinion. I threw the bagel away after 1 bite.

Havent been here for lunch but love the breakfast sandwiches. Nice bagel selection. Plan on visiting often.

Each location has different varieties of bagels. Bagels are delicious. Taking my rating down to two stars as of today. The last several visits, the kitchen staff are cooking the life out of the eggs, which makes the sandwich very Dry and unappealing. We have said something about this when we go there but they get annoyed about it. This was todays sandwich that my spouse and I both tossed int the trash. Thats nearly ten bucks wasted. What a shame it used to be good there. Tell me those eggs are not overdone?

Always fresh bagels and friendly service. Breakfast sandwiches are very tasty too! Convenient location, and great prices.

Good food. Fast service.

Great bagels. Not too pricey

Bagels always fresh fast service and prices are reasonable. Love going her after work on the overnight shift to grab a quick sandwich

Love coming here. Great service. Perfect every time.

I ordered and paid for a buttered poppy to stay. Someone brings out and announcing poppy with cream cheese, putting it on someone else table. It wasnt theirs. They bring it back and try to give it to me. Left with nothing.

I get bagels here for my Bc Exress team every Friday. Friendly home town place with great bagels and service.

Service is excellent and bageis as well as rolls are great! The in place for sandwiches!

In my opinion they have the best bagels in Toms River. The staff is very friendly and they have very quick service.

Bagels are delicious as is the crumb coffee cake! Our guests raved about the fresh cream cheese and nova lox. Service is always pleasant.

Great crew .. friendly.. reasonable

Great bagel sandwich

One of my fav local bagel shops. They make an awesome turkey bacon, egg, cheese, and hash brown bagel sandwich!!

Best homemade bagels and fresh boar head deli breakfast sandwiches are great repeat customer

Our company gets its bagels here everyday and even make 2nd trips for when sales makes there orders with no problem. I got to work too early so I stopped by to get my own porkroll egg n cheese with hasbrown (highly recommend) and the worker must have about 10 bags ready to go for the morning delivery and still working on 1. Not easy doing morning bake alone so nice work all-star bagel.

Very friendly service and great breakfast sandwiches

Always a great breakfast, friendly staff. Its awesome!

Bagels as delicious and fresh as they can be. Highly recommend for fast breakfast

New bagel shop in town. Fresh bagels daily. Pork Roll egg and cheese, Boars head sandwiches for lunch! Great food and place to eat in or take out!

Great food, Great Staff N Nice place

Amazing quick service i go there all the time for breakfast and get a sandwich they are big servings decent prices amazing food

Its hard to find real bagels, but they do a nice job here. Good sandwiches.

Have finally found a bagel shop in Toms River that makes tasty bagels just like Northern NJ 😍 SO HAPPY...Bagel with cream cheese & Service was Excellent!!!

The breakfast sandwiches are absolutely amazing very good portions with eggs and bacon. Highly recommend!!

Mike the owner is great and the cooks always make great sandwiches and the girls are always smiling love bringing my grandson would highly recommend them❤👍

Love this place. Friendly staff, great bagels, always a smile when you walk in.

Bagels are the best in Toms River. Always Fresh.The staff is always extremely friendly and courteous

Breakfast in 6 minutes nice place you can eat in as well as take out

Great sandwiches but a little pricey

Delicious. The staff is always so lovely & bagel sandwiches are fat and scrumptious. The best shop out of all them

Best bagels ever!!!

Love there Breakfast Bagels!

I have tried them 5 times today, same location hoping for a better result. Today I had to go back in 3 times..wrong bagel..wrong cream cheese then so little cream cheese that it looked less than butter. I asked who I think was manager maybe owner after third time back in today if I could please have enough cream cheese so I can taste it!He fixed it and gave me 2 extra bagels but you know what I justed wanted what I ordered correctly..imagine if like the first few timed I didnt know until I got home! Today I would have brought it back.I will go out of my way..not to go back..Sorry All-star but 5 chances to get a everything with cream cheese and a plain or egg with veggie, correct is way too many chances..afterall its bagels not rocket science!

The Only plays better for Taylor ham and cheese on a bagel is the Gourmet Deli on route 9

If the sexy women do not keep coming;) the food will