I learned of this place from my daughter..She went here with her counselor and had the soft serve peanut butter and is obsessed with it! So we took her again to the drive thru to get more and it was delicious! Staff was friendly and was very clean and saw them all working even tho it wasnt busy. They were cleaning. Good job! Cleanliness is very important and will keep our family coming back God bless Thank you! 👍

Good ice cream. If you serve coffee drinks, teach your staff accordingly. Had a chocolate mocha that was 90% milk. Tasted like nothing.

I agree with the other reviewer who said, “Gingersnap ice cream changed my life.” I’ve tried many of their flavors (all delicious!), but I keep going back to the gingersnap. There is something magical about the crushed cookies mixed with candied ginger. PS: this is a small, for reference.

Smooth and creamy ice cream that beats out most other places around. The prices are great for the large portion sizes. Ive never ordered a large as the medium fills me up with an empty stomach. Drive through could be faster, but its worth the wait. Cash only is annoying.

I refer to it as Fielders Crack! Cant get enough!

Great selection, product quality, staff always have a smile & warm welcome. Looking forward to my next visit what with these lovely warm Fall days.

Blatant customer siphon from DQ across the street. Cash-only, and over-priced ATM on-prem is must give a kick-back to the owners. The ice cream is delicious, but I prefer the Sabattus St. location that isnt in such a blatant competition with Dairy Queen.

Delicious ice cream, I dont think the drive thru has worked all summer? And a little pricey but that chocolate sauce in the bottom of the cone is worth every penny

2nd Time there & Kids Are Always Happy 😊 Thanks for another Great Sunday on a Sunday

Just super ice cream more than enough in a servings price is great people are nice nothing bad to say just a nice place

The most incredible ice cream shop Ive ever been to! Icecream cones are huge.

Wanted to get ice cream for me and my kids so I popped on to google and this place came up. It is cash only but the drive threw was a bonus! Portions are huge and for the price can’t beat it. Friendly staff, fair pricing delicious soft serve! Would recommend to friends. 👍🏽

Love the chocolate almond joy ice cream and the service. Would like it better if staff made sure they got the right order in the bag.

Good ice cream, but the serving sizes are too large.

The ice cream is excellent! I find them a bit pricey but the serving sizes are extra generous so I dont mind. My place has a drive thru which was great last year during the pandemic.

Great prices and excellent quantity. Lots of different flavors of ice cream and great food.

Best ice cream ever!!! The flavors have such unbelievable goodness!!! Portions are amazing for the price.

Ice cream is so amazing. The staff so friendly and timely. The store is always kept up. Right now you can either drive up or order in inside.

Ice cream is great great service they come out and take your order if theres too many people its delicious

I went today to enjoy a nice sugar free ice cream seeing I am diabetic. Much to my disappointment, you have done away with all but French Vanilla and coffee in sugar free. Why are you ignoring diabetics?Will have to find another ice cream shop.MAJOR DISAPPOINTMENT!!!!

No other ice cream spot can compete. Everything is better here. Period

Best icecream!! The many locations in Maine make it so enjoyable!!

Im from Arizona here in main for a month the ice cream was the best

This place!! They have so many options, its almost overwhelming. The amount of ice cream you get is CRAZY. So order small! It was so good!!

Good ice cream very good prices great staff

Fast and friendly service. Large portions for reasonable prices.

Large portions. Always a favorite.

It was awesome, we had take out one day got home and the order was wrong called and the shop and they gave us a credit I will always support Fielders Choice a place that cares about there customers.

I love fielders the best around.

THE best ice cream. And the portions are amazing!

Very friendly! Big portions and large menu. Cash only!

Great ice cream you get a lot

Unless you are a big eater or really hungry only order the baby!!

I really dont know what to say other than its delicious! Doesnt offer some of the treats other dairy joys offer, but it doesnt matter because what they do make is phenomenal. Friendly staff, mostly high school students and clean inside.

Servings are Super sized and a dish or cone in Baby size is a medium most other places...

Nice size portions and a good selection of flavors.

Baby size is reg size small was a large. I like getting more than I thought. Icecream was worth it

Very pleasant, clean place. Good ice cream with a decent Gluten Free menu. Cash only is inconvenient, but the taste and AMT of what you pay for is worth it.

Fantastic homemade ice cream! Be warned the serving sizes are ridiculously large (medium is a half quart)

LOVE Fielders Choice and cant wait until theyre open for the season and not just weekends.

Was not expecting this level of ice cream sandwich. Huge portions here. This was peanut butter cup ice cream. I have large hands, its just gigantic.

My wife and I ordered two cups of ice cream hers had a Frozen hair inside of it. Told customer service message them on Facebook and send an email. never offered to make it right. I guess customer service is not a strong point with them

The Auburn Fielders Choice has done a great job during the pandemic. Weve made multiple visits during this tough time. They have someone in a mask out in the parking lot taking orders and directing traffic. They are busy and still able to keep everything moving along quickly and smoothly. Our full order is placed in a paper bag.And of course, it all tastes so good. Thats why we all go, right?Prices are typical and the staff has always been friendly.My one and only minor complaint is that it is cash only.

Incredible! Just dont get the large, the saddest part was not being able to finish it. The flavors are fantastic! Sitting outside watching the sunset in Maines beautiful summer weather was the cherry on top.

Dont believe they have a small cone, its HUGE! get it in dish...yummy

Always delicious and huge portions!

Quick drive through friendly service and amazing icecream!!!

Most excellent! Small was very large!

The Best an cheap

Cant beat the size for the price. Always a home run going here.

Great theme! Selection is great and they give you a lot of ice cream! New fav family spot.

Were new to the area,was looking for an ice cream place,we found it! Reasonable prices for the servings you get,friendly staff,very impressive! Thank you!! :) You now have several new customers!!!

Delicious so many flavors and the portions are huge

Awesome homemade ice cream

They have such great ice cream. A great variety of hard serve, I just wish they had a larger selection of soft serve. The prices seem a little steep, as they are a bit higher than the local competition, but its definitely worth it. They have a great quality homemade ice cream. And the size! Holy cow, I dont know how any could eat a large! 😂

The ice cream is amazing, we found fielders by accident trying to find an ice cream place for are kids as a treat. This place delivers everytime the cost is reasonable for how much you get. Just a heads up tho, they only take cash.

This isnt a knock, its the second best ice cream in the area. I know it sounds a little back handed but its not.The service is always friendly and the prices and portions are by far the best around.New flavor mint oreo was fantastic and vanilla chocolate chip is my favorite there.

Love this place a little too much. Best ice cream around.

Cant eat inside still. But icecream is delicious and generous sized portions.

One word... YUMMY!!

Fantastic ice cream!!!

Good food, fun and friendly atmosphere. However portion sizes are enormous! A baby size is what would be equal to something like a medium in my mind. I always end up having to throw away a lot of it as its just too much. But in these days its a great first world problem to have.

We visited Fielders Choice with my kids school. There were over 50 of us that showed up all at once! We were served quickly and accurately and everything tasted amazing! We will definitely visit again!

When you want ice cream, you want to get your moneys worth, right? Look no further than Fielders Choice. Chances are theres one not too far from you in Southern and Central Maine. Boasting hard and soft serve ice cream with a baseball theme, Fielders Choice is a great place for your taste buds to get their game on. But be careful, if you ask for a large serving, you are going to get a very large serving. If you want a regular large serving, get the medium. Trust me, I am still trying to digest the last large dish I ordered! I have been to the locations in Sabattus, Brunswick, and Auburn. I cant wait to get to the one in Old Orchard Beach.Enjoy and remember to tip the nice person behind the counter, they appreciate it!

Great ice cream.. just wish my gf baby size wasnt bigger than my small every time we go

The apple crisp Sundae was very tasty and right on.

Excellent staff and product.

Best ice cream! Great service!! Never long wait even in a long line, theyre very efficient!! Must try

Love it... very pleasant employees

Love this ice cream place! Great tasting ice cream, great portions and friendly staff. Only place the kids and I go!

Best ice cream around

Ice cream tastes great. Indoor seating is modern and clean. We go here in the winter time sometimes for a special treat. Standouts: Soft serve in more flavors than just chocolate and vanilla. Excellent pumpkin ice cream.

Favorite ice cream place ever. My family makes it a point to stop in at least once when we come back to visit. The portions, pricing, as well as the taste cannot be beat. Just met the owners last night actually and theyre extremely nice people, so thats another plus haha

Ginger snap ice cream changed my life.

Very yummy as usual!!

Have had a few different types of ice cream there and they are all great. The biggest difference between this ice cream shop and others is they have very very generous portions for the money. They definitely have the best value for price and quality ice cream.

Best place to get Ice Cream around. Great prices, friendly staff and a consistent experience. The portions are huge and we love it!

We absolutely love this place 😍 we dont live in Maine but whenever we visit family we have to go to Fielders Choice at least once no matter what time of year. Delicious ice cream, fun decor and massive portions.

It was pretty good for our first time. The baby size cones are huge! It be great if their menu had less options or pictures because its so hard to decide. Other than that it was a clean busy ice cream place the kids loved it

Delicious as always! Excellent price and service as well. Our family doesnt go anywhere else now that weve tried fielders choice.

Wow- such good ice cream! I had the peanut butter cup and Oreo ice cream with hot fudge. The combination was so good. Also good to know this is a local business. Staff was friendly and line moved fairly quickly.

We love Fielders Choice and will come up with excuses to go. Today, a moose visited the shop.

Get amount of Ive been for the price. Best value by far. Plus theyre open all year long, had a drive thru window and had great ice cream!!😄😄😄😄😄

This is an inside ice cream shoppe. There set up is cute. Ive always loved Fielders they provide great friendly service at a great price. I however will say its not the comfiest of seating because its not a restaurant its an ice cream shoppe.

This is the best ice cream place. Fast, friendly, service. Good portion sizes too. Highly recommend this to everyone who loves ice cream like I do. Reasonably priced as well.

Portions are huge, good pricing and very fast.

Very good ice cream & open all year. The highlight would probably be all the hard serve flavors they have & made from local farmers. I usually order a wind up, soft serve ice cream blended with candy. Just be sure to bring cash, no debit/credit cards accepted.

Love it here. The ice cream is consistently great! Cant wait for the Sabattus location to open since its closer to us. Try it and youll always be comparing others to them. The very BEST ice cream Ive ever tasted!

Always love coming here. Everyone that works here is always nice. The icecream is delicious.

Excellent ice cream! Quick service! Lots of ice cream for the money!

Fielders is always fantastic 2 of us went it cost under 5.00 and i couldnt finish my sundae. Next time Ill order the baby size!

You get what you pay for...and then some. Awesome ice cream, great big portions, and pretty faces. Whats not to like ?

This place is great .. you get a lot of ice cream .. everything is good here

Good ice cream, shop is absolutely spotless inside and out. Seems like the employees really care. Only 4 stars because the ice cream was only good, not great.

My usual hot fudge sundae was delicious as always! And way more than I could eat - even though it was a small ☺

The place to go when you need to have a real old fashioned Ice Cream. Love the baseball theme. Best of all open all year long.

Always a great treat!!

Fielders choice always has the best icecream

Holy Moly if you order a large you better get a dish .or two

Really good homemade ice cream and they give you a lot for the price.