Called today and asked if they had a Strawberry Rhubarb. The lady who answered was so sweet and said she didnt but offered to make one. The customer service is over the top. I really appreciate it and will definitely be ordering from this place again. Absolutely delicious! Thank you very much!

Amazing! We tried the chocolate whoopie pie, pumpkin whoopie pie, and the jack Daniels chocolate pecan pie 🤤 oh my word, all of it was delicious!! Best pie Ive ever had!! The people were so nice and helpful and answered all our questions. Highly recommend.

The most amazing place ever! They should charge just for the aroma, thats how good their stuff is!! I havent had anything I didnt like yet and nothing that Id give less than 5 stars!!! The ladies there are patient and amazingly sweet. Thank yall so much for the love you put in your products!

Excellent pie and service. Jack Daniels chocolate pie!

Damn fine pie! We love this place, and will be picking up a pie to take back home to Portland, Oregon! Lovely service, nothing but friendly faces, and wonderful southern hospitality. There is an outdoor courtyard to sit and enjoy your pie if you wish. There is lots of indoor seating as well.

Peanut butter silk cookies as amazing ! 🤤

Just had one of the best coconut cakes I have ever had from a commercial bakery. This isnt just coconut thrown on a white cake and white icing. The Coconut Poke Cake from Pie Sensations is moist and tastes like coconut through and through.

Top notch people with top notch sweets

German chocolate Pie ..Thee BEST

Really cute place and the pies are amazing. I totally recommend! Pies are homemade and also a lot of options!

Great service and great pies. Swag

Coconut cream pie is fabulous! Generous helping of flakes... both on the topping and in the filling. Highly recommended for any occasion!

Best banana cream pie ive ever had! Super speedy!

All I can say is Pie Sensation is a great name....I have to avoid the place or I would turn into a pie...lol👩‍🍳🤭👩‍🍳

Oh my goodness.Just get the cheesecake with strawberries on it and sit outside.I’ve read wonderful reviews about this business so I took a chance and thank gosh I did!

It is neat and very clean. Friendly and knowledgeable service. Top quality pies and excellent coffee. I will be returning and I recommend Pie Sensations as “the” Pie Shop for the perfect Pie. My thanks for the rich and delicious pie. Thank you!

You will never put a better slice of pie in your mouth! This kind of deliciousness is unreal. I would give this a billion stars if I could. Do yourself a favor and buy a slice or a whole pie!

Best pie ever!

Great customer service!

What an adorable little pie shop!! The ladies who work there are so friendly. I bought a slice of chocolate cream and the caramel pie. OH MY-LANTA!!! Both of them were delicious. The caramel one is, in my opinion, very rich so its best shared with someone, unless youre in the mood to totally go overboard. :) The size of the slices are generous (more than the slices served at a particular place that offers free pie 1 day a week) and very tasty. The chocolate cream pie was oh so good!

Pie Sensations is just sensational! My favorite pie is the chocolate peanut butter one. I love it so much! We highly recommend stopping by here when you need a little sugar pick me up!

It a lovely place to be at, especially if you like the cokor PINK! The chocolate cream and the strawberry rhubarb are my favorite!It is a small, local business. Which means, its not fully stocked with every flavor every day. Be sure to call ahead and reserve what you want, otherwise it may be out of stock or already sold when your arrive.

Had Bourbon Chocolate Chess Pie and Jack Daniels Chocolate Pecan (I may have those mixed up). The JD was a little whiskey forward, but the bourbon was FAN-FREAKING-TASTIC. Mixed together? AMAZING. I want to go back and try everything else. Friendly service. Cute little place.

Ordered strawberry rhubarb pie for my Dads birthday......it was UNREAL!Thinks thats all i need to say. Was a little pricey but i got more than i paid for.

Delicious, wonderful friendly staff

The pies are sooooooo amazing....

Great as usual and the wife loved her Tennessee Birthday cakes

Excellent portion sizes. The flavor is incredible. The ladies that work in he shop are super friendly.

Pies made with love! Just like Mom use to make them.

I have been looking for the old fashion coconut cake and I found it. This was the first to go at my gathering. Then the pies( chess,chocolate chess. The key lime pie melting in your mouth. I found myself continuing giving out the name of your establishment name and number. Thanks for making our Pre Super Bowl 50 a success. S.Vaughn

Tried the overpriced caramel & key lime pies. Both had bland flavors that were not sweet at all. OCharleys caramel puts this to shame. The key lime had no punch of the tart flavor its known for, instead having almost a spiced pumpkin taste. Disappointed. Wont go back. : (

Pretty good selection of pies. They had a peanut butter and chocolate one I really liked!

Update 1 year later- as delicious as ever! I love that they have cupcakes, cookies, caramels and fudge- lots of little sweets to eat when you stop in to grab a pie or cake for your family gathering. Atmosphere is clean and cozy. Sweet employees and beautiful decor. They partner with lots of area artists, businesses and organizations as well. This place is definitely a community staple!Original Review: Loooove this cute little pie shop! Family owned and operated, they make a huuuge assortment of pies and sweets- all of them delicious. My personal favorite is the Dutch Apple pie, with Banana Cream Pie a close second. They also have homemade seasonal items- whoopie pies, toffee, caramels, and fried pies. Make it a point to visit this gem the next time youre in the area! You wont regret it!

Turtle pie? Whats not to love?? Great place to grab dessert. Seating inside and out in small patio area. Pies and desserts are delicious and some local Columbia restaurants are starting to carry there pies for their own desserts cuz they are deeelicious! Flavors change daily and tgey sell whole or by the slice. You can also order your favorite desserts for pick up on your special dinner or occcassion. Lots of varieties to choose from.

The best pies! Never disappointed!

Super cute pie shop & the pie was out of this world!

I’ve seriously never had better pie, EVER. I don’t know what they put in the crust, but it’s sweet and salty and MAGIC!

Best pie ever

The blueberry and raspberry pies are to die for!

I love the pie...yum!!

Purchased a Lemon Meringue pie for my dad for Fathers Day. Yum, just like my grandmother used to make!

Great pumpkin pie!

Pies! Pies! Pies! Pies! Great pies from great people!!!

Yummy

Scrumptious!