user
Whimsy Cookie Company
2410 N College Ave #2, Fayetteville, AR 72703, United States
Appearance
Whimsy Cookie Company
Comments
Ru
Review №1

I bought a box of several different types. Beautiful cookies and not one tasted good. High reviews must come from people who only but store bought packaged cookies. My family loves to bake, no one liked any of the cookies. I do not mind paying high dollar for good food. Do not waste your money or calorie intake on these :(

Ka
Review №2

This adorable little cookie boutique is exactly what I was looking for!!! I crave soft and sweet sugar cookies regularly and this place has done nothing but impress me each time I come through! I was honestly shocked at the selection of the sugar cookie designs. The last time I stopped by they had Hog cookies and AR Home cookies (shaped like Arkansas). I have sampled their gooey cookies and genuinely love the red velvet one. Their variety is great though. Definitely something for everyone. Might be great for a business meeting or a get together. Either way you gotta try these cookies!!!

Ra
Review №3

These ladies always have the best attitudes and willingness to answer any of my questions! Usually there’s a sample out to try. The cookies are so vibrant and there’s such a variety to choose from! You can’t go wrong with Whimsy. From parties or just an afternoon treat. It’s a must try!

Ka
Review №4

I absolutely love this place! I love when you walk in how friendly the staff is-they always greet me with a smile, always ask if I have any questions, help me with choosing what I want and just overall wonderful. And, the cookies are AMAZING! I definitely recommend this place!

lu
Review №5

It’s a nice place and everything but I would never pay $10 for 2 cookies that tasted like plastic and hard the worst cookies I’ve ever had 1st and last time I will ever buy cookies form there. Rick’s is just up the streets better lives and cookies are the best!

Ti
Review №6

This place is CLOSED FOR BUSINESS AS OF 3/17/20. Cookies are dry and hard. Gooeys are a cake mix cookie that you can find the recipe online. Owners do not care about the staff and their work is compensated poorly. Should they reopen, DO NOT SUPPORT THIS BUSINESS. Support your local home bakers who have a passion for cookies and long standing businesses in the area. They pulled a Hurts Donuts on their employees. NOT COOL.

Ma
Review №7

The sugar cookies were veeery hard but the cookie sandwhich was good.

Ka
Review №8

The environment at this place is incredible and always makes me want to come back! The cookies taste amazing and are always fresh! They never disappoint and make my day!

Ch
Review №9

Delicious cookies! Great selection and prices. Very cute decor. Get a punch card to earn a free gooey cookie

El
Review №10

I got cookies from here for my daughters birthday party and everyone loved them!! i can easily say these were the best sugar cookies i’ve ever had and i DEFINITELY will be coming back! the staff was very friendly and professional and i got exactly what i wanted.

Ka
Review №11

TERRIBLE BUSINESS. DO NOT EAT THESE COOKIES. DO NOT WORK HERE. AND DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY. the cookies are NOT worth it and the ownership is EMBARRASSING.

Am
Review №12

The shop is cute, the service was great, the cookies are unimpressive. If you want a pretty sugar cookie, you can get that here, but the sample of one that I had was dry and bland. Other than that, there are chocolate chip cookies that taste okay but look pretty sad, and there are different flavors of gooey cookies that Im pretty sure are just made out of cake mix. I could be wrong about that, but its how they taste. It just wasnt what I expected. I thought they would have other types of cookies (peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, white chip macadamia, something unique), not just Pinterest level cuteness. Ill just keep baking my own.

Ho
Review №13

Very cute shop and the cookies are amazing! Their employees are very friendly and knowledgeable. Wishing them the best of luck.

An
Review №14

Ordered a cookie cake for my sons birthday. My husband went to pick it up and they said they left me a voicemail that i had needed to pay for it in advance. I gave them my phone number and they repeated it back....but i had NO voicemails. My son was very disappointed.

Ly
Review №15

Stumbled upon them one day and have been back 3 times since. Love the gooey butter cookies! Huge hit in my office and for a play-date party for the kids

JU
Review №16

Owners do not take care of their staff the way they deserve. Wouldn’t want to support a company that doesn’t respect the people that work hard for them.

Er
Review №17

The cookies were not that great and the service is terrible, I would not want you to waste your time or money at this place!

op
Review №18

There is something to be said for presentation but a cookie should taste good, especially given the prices.

Ma
Review №19

Noticed that they treated the employees poorly and the cookies were kinda bleh

Sa
Review №20

Do not go to or work here. The owner is unbelievably rude and they treat their employees so bad.

Ca
Review №21

Expensive & bland cookies, rude staff, wont bother going again. For a delicious cookie I’ll just go to Bliss.

M
Review №22

Bad owners. Employees treated horribly.

Te
Review №23

Management does not seem to be making empowering decisions nor care about the welfare of their employees.

Ra
Review №24

Overpriced and awful.

St
Review №25

Owners are absolutely horrible.

Ke
Review №26

I like the gooey cookies.

Information
26 Photos
26 Comments
2.4 Rating
  • Address:2410 N College Ave #2, Fayetteville, AR 72703, United States
  • Site:http://whimsycookieco.com/
  • Phone:+1 479-249-8906
Categories
  • Cookie shop
  • Cafe
  • Bakery
Working hours
  • Monday:10AM–8PM
  • Tuesday:10AM–8PM
  • Wednesday:Closed
  • Thursday:10AM–6PM
  • Friday:10AM–6PM
  • Saturday:10AM–6PM
  • Sunday:10AM–8PM
Service options
  • Delivery:Yes
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance:Yes
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot:Yes
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Payments
  • Checks:Yes
  • Debit cards:Yes
  • Credit cards:Yes
Similar organizations