Ive actually never had gelato from this place but their bakery options are to die for. For my birthday this year I just went and bought myself a box full of their treats instead of a cake. From savory to sweet, everything is authentic and delicious. I always expect my total to be super expensive but it never is, everything is very reasonably priced. I would sell a kidney for the Italian Butter Cookies with Strawberry Jam. Definitely try it out!

What a delicious treat! My husband is part Italian and fully approved of these desserts! We cant wait to bring family here!

Oh. My. Go. Here. Now.Do not pass go. Do not collect $200. Go here for real Italian Gelato.This is a great hole in the wall strip mall place serving up a serious serving of Italia. Va bene!If you are a foodie... go here.We did this as a Friday night treat after a day of shopping and eating and it was a perfect ending. I want to go back and try other things on the menu. But if I lived here, Id be there for the Gelato all the time.Dont let the location fool you... this is good stuff.

Absolutely amazing! We were looking for a place to buy cannoli and came across this. I was blown away by all the amazing authentic Italian food and desserts served up by Lucio and co. I love they offer Italian wines there as well. We cant wait to go back for lunch or dinner then enjoy a delicious treat afterwards. Oh and by the way the cannoli was incredible!

Worth every calorie! The new name (under same management) is Stacco House by Mamma Mia. DELICIOUS and AUTHENTIC desserts, individual meal portions, family meals, coffees, wine and homemade Gelato. SOOOO GOOD! Great service too.

They are really amazing. I was able to get an awesome gelato cake and chef was too kind to deliver it by herself in order to help me out. Highly recommended and overall best customer service! I will be ordering more from them in future :)

A little Italia in Indiana. Absolutely love this place! Ill be back soon!

This place definitely surprised me. Ill definitely be coming back as much as I can!

Wow!I went here for some gelato, but was met by a huge case of delicious looking desserts forcing a very difficult decision! I picked the gelato since it was a hot day, and I was not disappointed. It was very good and authentic. Ill definitely be back to try some more options!

We stopped in after being referred by the restaurant next door (Fat Dan’s) to get dessert here. We got a slice of cheesecake and it was the BEST cheesecake we’d ever tasted. It was so fresh and just delicious. We cannot recommend stopping in here enough. Yum!

A cute little gelato and desserts place, with some really good options. They have both fruity and non-fruity options, and available both in cones and cups. My favorite ones are Bacio and Hazelnut, as well as the Fig & Mascarpone. Great atmosphere to hang out and read a novel, or to play some board games with buddies. They have a give and take book collection inside the store, for those who are interested in exchanging books.

Straciatella was amazing. Cannolis are the best

Great costumer service. Fantastic food.Was definitely worth the drive from from cicéro. Totally worth it. Great food and please support local

Their tiramisu is the best! 😍

Just had some awesome dark chocolate gelato smothered in espresso!! It was delicious would definitely come back to try more on the menu!!!

My wife and I absolutely love this little gem.I highly suggest a gelato banana split (banana gelato topped with strawberry, pineapple, and dark chocolate gelato. Wife loves the Cornetto con gelato with the chocolate croissant and lemon gelato.

Friendly and professional. . .always great customer service

Wonderful place and absolutely delicious products. My favorite is cannoli!

Wonderful! Went for cannoli gelato and coffee after dinner. We wish we would have got dinner from there too.

Best chocolate gelato I have had in my entire life.

Yummy gelatos!!

Absolutely great food and customer service!!!

Great place, friendly staff!

Good cappuccino. Nice seating area. Good customer service. I love small local businesses.

Best Gelato in Hamilton County and probably Indiana. Friendly owners, looking forward to the new offerings after reopening ! Especially the gluten free ones.

My boyfriend and I have been going to mammamia’s every chance we get for the last 6 months and are in LOVE with the quality of their gelato and other desserts. Now that they’ve reopened with food, wine, coffee, etc. i I’ve been recommending this place to EVERYONE. The staff is personable and friendly and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. MUST TRY if you’re in the Carmel/Westfield area.

This is great gelato. It’s all homemade and the staff is very friendly and Italian!

Great atmosphere. Kind staff. Fun selections.

Amazing food and looks very nice inside. Very impressed!

Good service, good coffee, cant complain. Would like to see frappes there at some point but overall I would go back again if I didnt live far away

Lovely place. Dark chocolate is the best, definitely give it a try.

Great coffee still. Remodelled so no more seating but great counter service with pastries and also savory dishes to go

Loads of gelato flavor options, as well as other food and drinks. Vegan gelato is available and clearly labeled! Im not sure what base they use for those but they also have water-based flavors. My favorites right now are the dark chocolate and wild berry.

Cinnamon Toast Crunch gelato are boom!!!

The owner is Italian so expect amazing deserts that you will not eat anywhere except Italy.Deserts, cappuccino made to perfection. Worth trying it.

Amazing. Anyone with a dairy restriction will love this place. Half their flavor selections are dairy free. They also have Italian pastries and cake. I also had an affogato that was delicious. I have been here multiple times in the last week because it is so good. The customer service was great. I couldnt have the pastries and cake because of dietary restrictions but my kiddos and husband enjoyed them.Please hit thumbs up if this review is helpful.

Fresh and homemade it was really good

Excellent gelato! I will definitely be going back.

Best desserts and coffee in Carmel.. probably in Indy as well

Gelato is amazing. Great, super easy contactless pickup during the quarantine. Just call in order and pay over phone, they set your order out on the table out front. Tiramisu is also fantastic. Will be back.

Wonderful selection of gelato, coffee, and other confections. You can tell that everything is made with love! This place is especially worth checking out because of the unique, rotating gelato flavors (bacio and stracciatella are my favorites) and authentic Italian desserts you cant get anywhere else in town (affogato, cornetto con gelato, etc.)

Great treats

My husband stopped here recently and raved about it-- insisting we return on our honeymoon. Today we stopped and it was amazing! Great service and atmosphere. I only wish we lived close enough to visit regularly!

Delicious gelato (options for water [fruit] and cream based flavors), friendly staff, and good prices. I had an excellent affogato; the espresso was rich and dark. Highly recommend!

Absolutely delicious gelato! Being able to sample the authentic Italian flavors was really nice and the service in general was very lovely. I cant wait to come back!

The place had great gelato! It was also very clean and had comfy seats.

Thanks for the great gelato. Our new spot for a better desert. The people who helped us were friendly and very happy to help us find a good flavor. Will definitely be back.😃

Great gelato! My husband has allergies and they also had yummy flavors for him!

Absolutely delicious gelato! They have light, water based flavors and heavier, milk based flavors. The portions are smaller than other shops, but the flavor truly is outstanding. They also seem to have board games to play, which I thought was a nice touch. They have lots of types of coffee available that I didnt try.

From Gelato to the pastries, everything has been great! If you like cannolis, you have to try them. Can’t go wrong stopping here!

Fantastic tasting gelato with an assortment of flavors. Staff was very nice and inviting. I would highly recommend a visit. Help support your local business!

So many good flavors very down the kids and accurate not so sweet we will come back

Great place...great dice cream....and free book and table games....highly recommended

My family loves this place! It is always clean, has super tasty gelato, Affogatos (the drinking chocolate is awesome too), and the staff is super friendly. Reasonably priced for the quality and quantity, I hope this place sticks around!

Great gelato! And have vegan options

Absolutely my daughter’s favorite place. She’s 18 and often stops by after school. We’re there now. It’s a family addiction! It led me to start taking Italian!

Loved the flavors and texture - Im sure we will visit again.

Excellent gelato, sorbet, and cappuccino. Super reasonable prices to boot.

Taste just like the gelato we had in Italy. It was great. Highly recommend

Excellent place. Awesome ownership as well.

Fabulous Gelato. They have offered and pastries also. There are games and books to enjoy as well.

I had no idea gelato could be so tasty! The stracciatella is my favorite.

Had some today wow great ice cream(gelato) its great, I miss it already it reminds me of Las vegas Bellagio hotel the most delicious

Delicious Gelato and coffee! Customer service is always friendly! We love this establishment!

The best Italian gelato ice cream place in Indiana

Some of the best gelato I have ever had. Great people, and authentic gelato....5 stars!

A cute little dessert place! A lot more than just gelato, coffees, and cannolis, and a nice selection of desserts. You can have your gelato in a croissant too. Coffee shop atmosphere, cute selection of games.

Belissimo! By far! Keep up the great work, guys. Think how you can change the interior to make it cozier and mamma home style.

The shop was adorable, the staff was super friendly, and the coconut gelato was amazing!

Amazing... Simply amazing. You just have to TRY it!

Love this place. Friendly staff and delicious gelato and cannolis.

We loved it. Dark chocolate gelato is the best!

It was good gelato, just really expensive.

Great gelato. They have other deserts that are awesome too. My fiance loves their expresso.

Exactly what I needed on a beautiful day like today! They hit the spot.

One of the best. Very clean and chill atmosphere

Tiny scoop, equated to about 5 bites (or 3 if you like a brain freeze). More icy than smooth. No wonder no one was there.

Excellent gelato. A quick hop from the queues at the downtown Carmel eateries

Amazing gelato!! Better than all other ice creams around!

We drove from Castleton to try this place, arriving at 8:40pm, 20 minutes before closing, but they were closed anyway.

Great gelato. Family owned and run. Quaint.

Great gelato, classic flavors, nice seating environment! Coffees for adults and board games for kids.

Extremely impressed! Well be back!

True to Italian recipe! Plus pastries and coffees, mix and match. Worth the diversion from Monon.

Well....we went in to try the gelato, but we ended up with more! They have wonderful desserts like lemon tart, tiramisu, chocolate layer cake, and cannolis. My husband got the lemon tart and a scoop of lemon gelato, which I, of course, tasted -- for research. SO GOOD. I also very much enjoyed my chocolate cake and scoop of salted caramel gelato. The gelato is only $2/scoop -- a STEAL. With our desserts, our bill came to $17 and worth it. The lady who greeted us explained the options and was very friendly. Well go back. Again, and again, and again....

Best gelato and best prices. Go to Mammamia. Youll become a regular like we are.

Love it!! Great taste on any of their flavors.

Good service and great gelato reasonable price too

I didnt go here, didnt even notice it. Google Maps fails again! You can track my every movement and sell my info to the highest bidder but you wont find me at the gelato shop!

Wowwie!! Fresh made...soooo good!

Great tasting gelato.

Friendly and clean,but the gelato was nothing to write home about. Just regular olgelato.

The Gelato is delicious and the tiramisu is to die for!

Very good italian style gelato

Excellent gelato and friendly service and atmosphere

Yum!! Finally a gelato place in Carmel! Best treat in town!

The best gelato in town.

Very nice place, very good Gelato

Miss you guys.... 😘

I loved it here