This review is strictly for the cafe part of the store. I got an iced oat matcha latte and rooster sandwich. Matcha is fine, not bad but nothing special. The sandwich was very salty and biscuit was a bit gluey. Would not recommend, maybe try a dif sandwich. Service is a bit slow but the staff are very friendly. My friends got hot lattes and the barista drew some simple latte art, so cute! Im not a coffee drinker, but i think the coffee is quite nice.

Wow the smell in here is amazing! Made me hungry instantly. It’s a great shop with wonderful staff and has some areas featuring local art.

Stopped in for a quick drink. Ended up meeting some friends. Great time while watching some football.

We were in Ithaca for a long weekend in February 2021 and we stumbled upon Ithaca Coffee Company as our AirBnB had the coffee available for guests to have. After having a cup in the morning, we decided we needed to make a stop at the store. AMAZING store and even better coffee! We bought multiple cans to give as gifts to our dog sitters. We were able to find some snacks for our weekend, there are kitchen supplies, trinkets, a café, and even a small tavern! Such a cool place. The employees were super friendly and welcoming. This will always be a stop on our list when in the Ithaca area!

Really fun selection of so many things! Snacks and sweets, kitchen wares, bits and bobs with a cafe and a wee tavern in the back with packs and single beers for sale as well?! Not to mention the staff is always stellar and has great recommendations!!!!

Cool cafe with a top selection of coffees, beers and sandwiches. Definitely stop by and grab a quick lunch while you are searching for a few craft beers around Ithaca.

I get a mocha every time. My girl gets a hot cocoa. Both are stellar! Love the place!

Love, love and more love this place! When in Town, I always try and hit up Ithaca Coffee Co.; now, it’s permanently moved to a plaza on outskirts of Town, but worth the 2 minutes extra drive. Parking is ample. Product selection is select down to the minutest detail items, for example, was able to find orange bitters as well as Dutch licorice. The cheese selection is varied and is an astute selection. Beth, was very kind and outfitted me with a frequent shoppers card prior to my modest but noteworthy purchase of hard-to-find grocery items to take back with me to Buffalo, New York, in my car cooler... do it and just be happy you did it! Will return and also shop online, the coffee beans are to die for!!!

Cool little place, lots of local brews and coffee accessories.

Funky smell inside here. Quirky Shop thou has a little bit of everything.

Come here to buy coffee beans, but dont drink anything from the cafe. Espresso was far worse than anywhere else in Ithaca.EDIT: Ive only ordered from here once, so it may have been a one off thing.

One of the best coffee shop in Ithaca. Plus, they have lots of fancy cheese!

Food and coffe are excellent but services should improved. I asked for reward program, staff gave me the card without explaining that my order didnt added in the program, yet. When I checked my ORDER HISTORY and found out that it wrote..You havent placed any orders yet. That made me very upset.

Cannot wait to go back.

BEST COFFEE SHOP in Ithaca, PERIOD. I feel like I’m at home when I visit. The staff are fantastic, and the selection of drinks and pastries is fire.

We have come to depend on Ithaca Coffee for delicious coffee beans among other products and prepared foods, all of which we love! Today we ordered for curbside pickup and it worked out perfectly. Things we ordered today and recommend besides coffee include eggs, milk, ice cream, tea, oils, and cheeses! Thank you!

Excellent coffees and a nice deli. Good prices and broad selection of both coffees and teas.

Fantastic service, awesome selection and they even sell craft beers at their location! Cant wait to return!

Horrible experience! Tried bagel today and it was like a stone!!! Dunkin Donuts or even McDonalds would never do that. My teeth are still aching from eating that bagel. Coffee was good though but unfortunately was offset by a horrible bagel experience. I would recommend getting coffee here and go eating somewhere else if you’re hungry

Food and coffee here are awesome!

There was a time Ithaca had a German bakery, deli, and other yummy Euro luxuries. Here you can still buy great coffee, coffee related products, Austrian chocolates, marzipan pigs, as well as great local sweets, beers, olive oils and cheeses from here and all over. The gift baskets are sweet, the staff friendly, and I cant resist stopping weekly to see whats new. My personal favs: the cheeses, hot chocolate choices, and anything on the back wall.

I bought a bag of whole bean Ethiopia Yirgacheffe and it was the worst Yirgacheffe I have ever tried. Either the coffee was stored for too long before or the processing method couldnt make the flavor come out or the beans were just bad. Do not buy their Yirgacheffe because you always have a better choice elsewhere.

Nice place with interesting selection of cheeses and other items, definitely dropping a pin for next time through the area.

Absolutely loved this shop. The variety of items in there made me giddy. We were traveling and just wanted to pick up a cup of coffee. I was surprised to find not only coffee and sandwiches but the selection of meats/cheeses, chocolates, wine, and beer made me think I was at a Toy R Us for adults.

The woman working the front counter rudely barked orders at me like I was a dog- asking what I wanted, when she told my total, and when taking my card. The coffee was made incorrectly and the barista overcharged me; I ordered 2 20oz coffees and my total was $11.

Kind of hidden off Triphammer, but a lovely little coffee shop that has a simple menu of things to choose from along with some great things to buy. And if youre not feeling coffee and would prefer an adult beverage there is a little quiet bar area tucked in the back. Great place to catch up with someone and wanting to keep it casual and not surrounded by a ton of people.

Great local spot for coffee and lighter fare. The raspberry chocolate chip almond scones are incredible and the house blend is always a solid option! They also offer a respectable and well curated selection of craft beers in bottles and on tap. Highly recommend!

I recently moved to the area and was looking for gift ideas to send back to people. Aaron personally helped me find items and even emailed different ideas once he had more time. I really appreciate his kindness and helpfulness.

Excellent coffee and neat products to browse through.

Ive been buying my coffee there for years. The selection has dwindled a bit but there must be almost 20 choices. Good selections of cheese, beer and local products. Worth the trip.

Good place for bakery items, breakfast, and lunch. Also has a very good supply of craft beers in the back, along with a tavern that serves draft beer and wine. Havent tried their coffee yet😎.

Very overrated coffee store. It actually had very few coffee options, and it was a disappointment.

Some of, if not the best coffee in town! They have a splendid little coffee counter with some pretty great food offerings as one might expect of a coffee place, as well as a wide selection of bulk coffees for sale. Beyond that they have a selection of coffee and tea making devices for home, a nice selection of cured meats, cheeses and chocolates. As an extra special bonus they have a fantastic beer tasting room/bar with growler fills and a wide variety of beer on tap as well as a selection of bottles. Any trip to ithaca should include a stop here!

My most visited coffee shop. They have good espresso drinks, and a strong cold brew. If you like real green tea lattes, they make good ones (not from a mix like starbucks.) I also like to get chocolate covered pretzels from the back counter. They are my weakness and very delicious!

I used to go here daily and was always pleased with the great coffee! Ive had fresh brew, cafe lattes, steamed milk with honey, cafe mocha and the Kyoto iced coffee. The ice coffee feels like crack, it will have you wired for hours. The staff is great as well. Get a coffee card started and start earning free drinks!

An excellent mix of items for the foodie in you or just a nice place to grab a cappuccino or latte on a lazy Saturday morning. The scones are good but a little pricey. A nice selection of coffee beans, and a fantastic assortment of chocolate. Worth stopping by.

Coffee is okay, but the beer and wine selection are awesome. Some beers I love werent there but theres always something worth trying.

Best latte around! The girl working was super sweet. She knows how to make a smooth tasting latte!

I go here to buy ground coffee. They used to have great dark roast selections for espresso, but recently the dark roasts have gotten much lighter and selection has gotten smaller. Not sure why.... but can’t find good espresso roast now.

Great service with friendly staff members always knowledge about the stores offerings. Lots of in-store blends of coffee and tea with big windows at the front of the store and a small seating area to enjoy some pastries 🥐!

I didnt go there. I went to Ithaca Bakery and I didnt get what I asked for. I asked for everything bagel got that. I asked for toasted, it was not toasted. I asked chicken salad got that and that was good could have left out onions. I asked for provolone cheese didnt get that, got American cheese there is a difference. I guess I wont be coming back.

Great variety of food and beer! There are two menus (at least on Saturdays)....one for inside and one for outside in the patio area, where food items are cooked/prepared outside. During the summertime try their $4 pickled vegetables plate, with produce (beets, etc.) from their on-site garden! :9

Kyoto style cold brew coffee? I think they need to check their ratio/recipe. And cold brewed coffee doesnt mean the person wants ice. My wifes mocha drink was absolutely delicious but I have had instant coffee with better flavor than the cold brew.

I bought six scones to share at the staff meeting today. They were fresh and delicious! The café mocha was stellar.

Great selection of quality coffees, including local roasts. Artisan cheeses, meats, crackers, cookies, chocolates. Has a bar in the back that we didnt visit.

Amazing coffee & the cheese, coffee bean and tea selection is also very much worth the visit!

Wonderful coffee, unique gourmet foods, plentiful local foods, and diverse cheese choices. Always a favorite stop when were in the area.

Met friends in the tavern at the back of the store. Nice rotating selection of beer in n tap and wine by the glass. Plus a huge selection of beer and food stuff in store.

The main room has good espresso drinks, cheese, and chocolate. The tavern in the back is awesome. 12 taps and once a beer is kicked they switch it out to a new one. Every week you show up they have a new set of beers to choose from. You can buy the beer by the glass, or you can buy it by the 4oz sample which I like. They also have wine by the glass. It is kind of like a little slice of heaven.

Great place for beer, several rotating taps with selections from a large area. Large stock of beer in coolers and racks. Additionally, they offer wine pours and a limited but good food selection (cheese plate, pretzel, sandwiches, etc).The front area is a coffee shop and food store where you choose from a large selection of meats and cheeses as well as items like chocolates, crackers, and coffee beans, to name just a few.

Great place to buy beans. Enjoying the Red Rooster, and Kenya peaberry, and looking forward to trying more.

Excellent coffee, great atmosphere, awesome staff at the Triphammer location. Great selection of beer and coffee and other delicious foodie pleasing items.

Very nice coffee shop and sandwiches shop. The food is very good and the service is very good.

Amazing locial place with amazing coffee and tea!

Quintessential Ithaca joint. Grilled cheese sandwiches are dope and they got BEER! Just go!

I always like stopping in here for a coffee. dont get up in this part of town too often but its consistently a pleasant stop. the coffee is good, good fancy food to purchase( cheese and expensive snacks) and the beer bar in the back is really nice, but I am hardly ever up there at the end of the day for that.

Best avocado toast Ive ever had 🥑

Great coffee, great selection and great customer service. I only buy my coffee from here and have never been displeased with anything Ive ever bought. If youre into coffee, I highly recommend checking this place out.

Great place. Cozy, relaxed. Their tosted bread with gooda cheese is delicious, it really makes a difference. I love their coffee too.

The coffee is great choices of diffrenr snacks jams cheeses.friendly ppl.chocolates .the bar out back the bagels yo getting whats not to enjoy

Love the boutique vibe. Pricey but good.

Good coffee!! The very best latte.Great pastries too!

Lots of special and unique gift ideas. Good fresh roasted coffee too.

Triphammer Tavern & Coffee Staff are terrific! Welcoming, friendly, kind

This is my go-to gift shop in Ithaca! Wide variety of quality consumable gifts - gourmet cheeses, local whole bean coffee, European packaged snacks.

Great variety of cheeses, coffees, and other delicacies. The staff is fun and so knowledgeable and helpful.

Great coffee surprisingly good sandwiches.

Coffee is the best around. Better then gimmie good food and polite service.

One of my favorite places to hang out with friends. Fun gift items and every kind of beer you can imagine.

The assortment of coffee, beer and cheese is outstanding. It is definitely a little over priced but theres something for everyone here.

Fabulous selection of foods and beverages, from the finest cheeses in Ithaca to a surprisingly diverse draught beer stock. Oh, and coffee, desserts, wine, fine bottled beer galore, and lots of niche foods and kitchen supplies. May this place live eternal.

Great beer, sandwiches, cookies. I hear they also have coffee.

I find things here that inspire me to make new dishes!

Good hot Chocolate and blueberry coffee cake

The best place around. Be sure to check out the Pub in the back!

Super coffee. Scones are fabulous. Staff are great.

Amazing selection of beers in the back! Coffee and service is also A+

Wonderous selection exquisite taste and amazing ambiance.

Amazing selection of beer! And other assorted gifts, food and chocolate.

Love the latte and beer! Bartender was great

Very nice 👍 place 👌

Cold brew was good and bold. Nice beer selection. Staff was very friendly.

The best of both worlds, coffee and beer. Work and have a coffee during the day and then have a artisanal microbrewery beer at the tabern... The coffee is excellent and much more affordable than gimmes on a daily basis. Also, the staff is really nice.

Love this place! Great espresso drinks!!

Friendly service and great coffee.

Best local products and great beer selection.

Nice place for gourmands, with a cozy tavern in back featuring a continuous variety of finest craft brews and friendliest bartenders.

Great staff, products, and service!

Great selection of hard to find teas and coffee

Nice place. Good experience friendly staff.

Best coffee in the world! Get some Cornell blend to take home

Great coffee, good service, cute market with gifts and fine food stuffs.

They have a surprising amount of nice microbrews from all over the place tucked away in the back.

Always love the paninis and a cup of latte!

I have yet to find a better espresso..

Great tap room in back of stove. Coffee and tea selections are expectional.

Great selection of interesting Ales for sale

Great coffee and friendly staff.

Great selection of coffee, cheese, sweets and beers. The store has a little bit of everything!

Id live here if they let me. Coffee, cheese, and beer. All of lifes needs are met here.