Excellent experience from start to finish! Carly Kelly is sweet and does a great job.

Wonderful experience here at Maguire!! Helpful and friendly service. Will recommend to my family & friends. Couldn’t have asked for a better car buying experience! Thank you to Mike & Andy at Maguire Kia!!!

I was able to secure a 2021 Kia Telluride while it was still in transit to Maguire Kia with the help of Mike Kaufman. He took the time to help me find the vehicle I was searching for, talk after hours, provide updates, and have it ready moments after arriving. My experience with Mike far surpasses all previously encountered with other dealerships. If you are looking for honest, reliable help to get the vehicle you want be sure to send him a message or give him a call.

Mike Gommer was very helpful in getting everything set up for my new lease. I also enjoyed working with Christina Pesco to get insurance quotes. Great place. I will refer to my friends!!

Absolutely disheartening experience - arrived with a brand new Kia (purchased at another dealer located 4 hours away) due to an overheating engine. Was indifferently informed that the earliest they can look at the car would be 3 (three!!!) weeks later... I was provided the alternative of contacting the closest Kia service in hopes of an earlier appointment (the info provided was incorrect, as the one recommended was not the closest Kia service)... Extremely disappointing first (and likely last) experience - if you can take your car elsewhere (especially if it was purchased elsewhere), keep driving/towing away...

Bethany and Jesse were amazing! Would recommend

Great place, great people, great cars... highly recommend!!!

No pressure, very quick and accommodating. Leaving with my new car any minute!

Thank you Jesse Westfalls for making my first new car purchase buying experience a great one. You took such good CARE of every detail! I’m so happy in my new kia forte. Will most definitely be telling everyone were to go to have so much help with all the important details on getting a new vehicle.

GREAT GREAT GREAT SERVICE!!! Jessie Westfall did a amazing job communicating, getting the numbers and the right vehicle for me!!! GREAT JOB!!! All of my future vehicles will be purchased thru Maguire!!!

I just want to say a Special Thank You to Ashley Good sales consultant! Super job Ashley! You cared about us! You were patient! You made it easy to work out a deal! You are a Special person! We couldnt have done it without you! So many great things to say about you! Thank you! I sure hope we see you again! You made our day so Wonderful!

I had a great experience at Maguire. This is my second car buying experience with Beth. Beth answered all of our questions and made usfeel comfortable and apart of the family. We were able to get out of our lease 2 months early and get into a brand new car! We couldnt be happier! Thank you Maguire, and thank you Beth!

Its been years since the service dept flat out lied to my face about what was needed to fix my 2015 Kia Soul, but I am still disgusted. They advised I needed almost $5k worth of work including sensors and gaskets, etc, and said it wouldnt be warrantied. Charged $50 for a false diagnostic. I knew it was my catalytic converter and it should be covered. Took it back to my selling dealer 4hrs away. I was 100% correct and my car is still running well at 135K miles.

I used Maguire Kia for my new car and had a wonderful experience. The salesman, Adam, who we worked with was friendly and helpful every step of the way. Everyone else in the dealership was always asking if we needed anything and offering options for our five year old son who was with us and less than thrilled about being in a car dealership for any length of time. Overall a wonderful experience. I would go back again.

I drove 2 hours from Rochester, these guys are the best dealer around, I left there with 2 cars... Beth is the best

I drove to my appointment to get my heat fixed only to be told that it had been moved without my knowledge because the necessary parts had not come in yet, so i had to reschedule. When I called to ask for an update on the parts, I was met with attitude. When i finally did get my car in, I was charged over 900 dollars to still have no heat. I was told that the car could not be fixed for liability reasons, and what they could fix would cost me over 2800 dollars. I brought it to a mechanic, who was able to fix it by replacing a faulty wire connector for 10 dollars, and I had heat again. I dont have a lot of money, and i feel like all of it had been wasted on Maguire.

DO NOT DO IT - do not buy a vehicle from them let alone service it!!I paid $1,002.64 for a new water pump for my VW Jetta and put less than 4,000 miles on it before it started leaking again. I had it checked out and it requires another water pump.I called and spoke with Eric the service manager at Maguire of Ithaca and he informed me I am 2 weeks out of warranty regardless of only putting less than 4,000 miles on it. He then informed me he is my advocate and will contact VW customer care. When I called him back a week later he said that he is unable to get in touch with anyone at VW Care. Another week went by and I called VW Care and was able to speak with them in less than 10 minutes.At this point I am out $1,000 and do not have a vehicle I can drive.SO IF THE SERVICE IS THIS BAD - DO YOU REALLY WANT TO BUY A VEHICLE FROM THEM KNOWING SOME DAY YOU WILL NEED IT FIXED!!!

My wife and I had a very good experience buying our Kia Niro from here. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Our test drive was a joy. Everyone was very knowledgeable about the cars we were considering. We just wished that we knew that they had coffee available for customers before we got to the end!

Very good people, customer oriented. The showroom is great, and their waiting area is also comfortable. Im really happy with Maguire so far!

Perfect place. Im forever in love with this dealership. Will work with these guys for every purchase in the future and recommend them to all friends and family.

Have leased Kias with Maguire for over six years, and its been a very pleasant experience.

The service that was provided by Mike Duff was excellent. He answered all our questions. He made us feel important.

Ive been doing business with Maguire for several years. Recently they have put me into my third new car. When they say that you are family they mean it! Maguires does all they can in their power to get you into the vehicle of your choosing at the right price. Phil Maguire and his team go the extra mile to accommodate and ensure that you are satisfied walking out with a smile on your face. Im very happy with the work ethic Phil Maguire and his team continue to show each time I do business with them. This is why I will always return. They are the family of dealerships!

What a great dealership

We have done business with this dealership several times and every time is a pleasant experience! I have no complaints. The staff has always been pleasant and professional.On our most recent visit we were in the market for a new lease with a very limited budget, our salesman Bryan Planty was very patient with us while we were trying to decide between 2 vehicles. In the end he and the sales manager Ricky Russo were able to get us into a lease on a 2017 Sportage in the exact price range we were looking for!I really appreciate how the staff at Maguire Kia understand what a big decision buying/leasing a new vehicle is, unlike most dealerships they are not pushy. Thank you for you excellent customer service!

A little bit of a wait. Outside of that great service and a car wash with oil change....good deal!

I always do the maintenance and inspection here. Kind staff, friendly environment and helpful technicians. Like their services.

We received a recall letter from Kia regarding a seatbelt pretensioner. I called and set up an appointment with Maguire and when we got to the garage, we were told they had to order the part that day and it would be in, in about a week. We drive from Elmira to honor the appointments. Its a little frustrating.

The first new vehicle my wife and I ever bought ...they were upfront, casual, and professional, told them my budget and they came in under it, even with additional services..special thanks to Michele H.

Purchased a used 2018 Sorento from a dealer in Oswego. Driving home noticed a rubbing noise on the passenger side front tire. Scheduled an early appt to get checked out and waited for vehicle. Over 2 hours the tech investigated my complaint but could not find anything other than somewhat loose lug nuts. During the wait Ryan kept me up-to-date with my vehicle. Ryan is kind, professional, communicative and forthcoming - all traits I have come to appreciate from Maguire dealerships employees. I will definitely take my vehicles to Maguire and will recommend to friends and family. Cheers.

Purchased a 2011 Sonata in 2011. The car didnt have mats. I called and was told that it was to late there was nothing they can do. So the following month I purchased a second vehicle at drivers village. I decided to give this place another shot and purchased a new 2018 Sorrento. The bluetooth is not compatible with android. The manufacturer offered $500 for me to purchase a $800 iPhone. Again I went to the dealership and was not taken care of. So here I am with deja vu. Its time to replace my wife sportage in the next month or two and I will not be coming here to purchase it. Shouldve stuck with drivers village. Update: Maguire has reached out to me and cleared up a simple misunderstanding therefore I have changed my review to 5 stars. Definitely have to give credit to Maguire for doing all they can to turn me in to a happy customer. They have now gained a customer for life and I will be purchasing all future vehicles with Maguire!

Excellent customer service and sales.

The Maquire family is essentially a dealership monopoly in Ithaca and they act like it. I brought a car in to have a tire repaired. When I returned home I realized that the spare tire was left in the back of the minivan instead of being hoisted up underneath the car. When I went to put it back the hoist was zip tied underneath. It turns out that the crank to raise the tire was broken. Now, I took out the spare tire and cranked the support back up before I took the car in. In other words, it worked when I brought the car to Maquire. Clearly, they knew something was wrong and did not bother to say anything to me. The service person said nothing when I picked up the car and there was nothing written on the paper work. I left a message for a service manager and so far no return call.

A bad experience every time I have to deal with them... Their service has a lot to improve on.

Nice people, good service!

I bought my 2015 Kia Optima here. I didnt feel pressured to buy it either. Now that i bring it up for services, they never try to upsell. I just get whatever I need done.